Team Alicia singers Stephanie Rice and Vanessa Ferguson each sat at the piano and switched off lines from the Carole King-penned classic, with fellow team member Chris Blue joining the trio following the first chorus.
The rendition was bittersweet for Team Alicia, however, as Rice was eliminated from The Voice at episode’s end.
This wasn’t Keys’ first time performing the 1967 smash. In January 2014, she sang “(You Make Me Feel Like) A Natural Woman” solo at the MusiCares tribute to Carole King.
The Voice also showcased Gwen Stefani and her team performing a rousing cover of Coldplay’s “Fix You.” Watch the full clip below: