40 Greatest Sketch-Comedy TV Shows of All Time - Rolling Stone
Home TV TV Lists

40 Greatest Sketch-Comedy TV Shows of All Time

From Caesar to Schumer, 65 years of the Land Shark, the Chicken Lady and a bunch of Muppets

Waynes World; Key and Peele

Everett; Ian White

Television sketch comedy is having a bit of a moment. Key & Peele just scored their first movie deal, the Mr. Show team is collaborating for a much-ballyhooed non-reunion, the unlikely hit Portlandia just wrapped a fifth season, Kids in the Hall will be touring America this May and more than 23 million people watched the Saturday Night Live 40th anniversary special. 

Here’s our list of the 40 greatest sketch comedy shows of all time, dating back to the 1950 premiere of Your Show of Shows to four shows that still have new episodes ahead. 

placeholder
3

‘Mr. Show’ (1995-1998)

"I'd done sketch shows," Bob Odenkirk would say later about the origins of Mr. Show. "But I'd never done them right, the way I'd wanted to." An outgrowth of L.A.'s D.I.Y. alt-comedy scene percolating at places like UnCabaret, David Cross and Odenkirk's HBO series was to Nineties humor what the original SNL was to Seventies counterculture: a blast of cutting-edge irreverence that captured a moment. Which isn't to say the skits feel dated (though a familiarity with the era's shock rockers, Gen-X nostalgia and reality TV doesn't hurt). It's more about the way the duo took the same rip-it-up sensibility of the movement's stand-up and ad hoc stage performances to TV. "The network wanted to know what would be the same each week," Odenkirk recalls. "'Well, [we'll] come out and say 'Hi.' And that's it."

Once the guy in the suit and the dude in the slacker uniform came out for their introduction, all bets were off: An extended skit about cults might flow into a commercial for a cock-ring warehouse or a documentary on old-timey megaphone singers. It was comedy as college rock that got signed to a major label; and, for four seasons, a generation felt like it had a Monty Python to call its own. "A lot of people who listen to this show," Marc Maron told Odenkirk on his WTF podcast, "and a lot of what has become this 'comedy nerd' audience really sees Mr. Show as the starting place of modern comedy. I talk about it on this show, that I know there's a lot of people listening whose sense of comedy history starts at Mr. Show and beyond that, there's nothing. I mean, the impact that thing had was incredible."

placeholder
2

‘Saturday Night Live’ (1975- )

How can you really measure the full impact of the longest running, most iconic sketch show in American history? Sure, it launched Chevy Chase, John Belushi, Eddie Murphy, Mike Myers, Adam Sandler, and Kristen Wiig — but, by sensing their early comedic talents, SNL also provided formative learning experiences for Gilbert Gottfried, Julia Louis Dreyfus, Joan Cusack, Robert Downey Jr., Damon Wayans, Chris Rock, Ben Stiller, Sarah Silverman and Jim Henson's Muppets. Three American presidents felt the need to appear on the show and one American senator used to be a featured player. We would not exactly be shocked if SNL was the first place "douchebag" was said on network TV.

James Signorelli, the show's longtime commercial parody director, said that in the Seventies, ad agencies were even impacted by the "the archness or the surrealist approach" of SNL's spoofs. "During the first five years, the show changed a lot of stuff you don't think about," Signorelli said in the Live From New York oral history. "It changed this business of dinner at eight into dinner at ten or dinner at midnight. The way Franne Lee, our costume designer, dressed Lorne for the show suddenly became the way everybody in New York was dressing….Before you knew it, everybody was sitting around in Levi's and a jacket."

placeholder
1

‘Monty Python’s Flying Circus’ (1969-1974)

"I was frustrated by the tyranny of the punchline," John Cleese recalled in the book Monty Python Speaks. "Surreal things would be suggested, writers would laugh, and then [a producer] would say, 'Yes, but they won't understand that in Bradford.'" It's impossible to underestimate the impact that Monty Python's Flying Circus would have on a generation of comedians: Sketches might stream into each other or suddenly give way to a cartoon. Huge arguments over dead parrots, a cheese shop's inventory or whether two people were having an argument could escalate into dizzying wordplay. Silliness reigned supreme. As veterans of earlier sketch shows, each of the Pythons knew the form well enough to shatter and reconfigure the format. As phrases such as "nudge, nudge" became a nerd lingua franca, Flying Circus proved that something completely different could, in fact, translate worldwide. "There's not one minute of it that seems dated," novelist Dave Eggers said about the show in 2004. "Their stuff is a lot more sweeping and lasting than almost anything else, because they weren't taking on current events — they were addressing history itself. History and sheep."

Arrow Created with Sketch. Calendar Created with Sketch. Path Created with Sketch. Shape Created with Sketch. Plus Created with Sketch. minus Created with Sketch.