10 Best 'Saturday Night Live' Sketches, Season 42 - Rolling Stone
Home TV TV Lists

10 Best ‘SNL’ Sketches, Season 42: From Trump to David S. Pumpkins

From Alec Baldwin’s killer POTUS impersonation to a perfect ‘Black Jeopardy’ commentary – the highlights of the show’s historic year

10 Best 'Saturday Night Live' Sketches, Season 42: From TK to TK

From Alec Baldwin's killer Trump impersonation to 'David S. Pumpkins' – the 10 best 'Saturday Night Live' sketches from Season 42.

Kylie Billings/NBC (2), Will Heath/NBC/Getty

It was the show’s best of times, it was the world’s worst of times – going into its 42nd season, Saturday Night Live knew it had plenty of fertile comic ground to till. To throw a few more metaphors into the mix: The show also had a chip on its shoulder over the accusations that it had helped normalize a certain noxious, campaigning candidate when it let him host SNL back in 2015, which made folks wonder whether they writers’ room might have something to prove. And – let’s keep going with those metaphors, shall we? – they also had an ace up their sleeve, in that they had recruited a frequent guest host/bona fide movie star to play The Man Who Would Be(come) POTUS when it returned in October.

The rest is history: off-the-charts ratings, Op-Ed pieces, angry Trump tweets, viral clips galore, surprise special guests and the occasional genuinely devastating bullseye. Political humor with the volume turned up to 11 snuggled up to David S. Pumpkins. Blistering monologues bled into gentle love taps at some public figures and scorched-earth takes on others. Those 90 minutes happening right in the middle of the weekend had unprecedented cultural currency, Leonard Cohen sing-alongs and a podium that could attack press corps at will. And, right in the center of it all, there was a man with pursed lips and a bright orange glow. It was the season of the Smart Alec.

Looking back at the agony and the ecstasy that was Saturday Night Live in Trump Year Zero, three things became clear: Despite the fact that “live” remains a key element, this was the year that the post-Lonely Island era pretaped bit really came into its own. You didn’t have to be a cast member to have a recurring key spot in the show every week. And Kate McKinnon is God. Here are our picks for the 10 best sketches of SNL 42. Any questions?

(We’re not counting any “Weekend Update” segments or monologues here – though it should be noted that the incredible monologues by both Dave Chappelle and Aziz Ansari will be pored over and discussed long after their episodes have been forgotten, and long after the man whose presidency fueled their remarks has left the building.)

10 Best 'Saturday Night Live' Sketches, Season 42

‘Haunted Elevator’

We could have populated most of this list with the October 23rd, 2016 episode hosted by Tom Hanks – it’s easily one the strongest sketch-by-sketch shows in ages. (We’ll admit that we still watch this one’s “America’s Funniest Pets” skit at least once a week because, to quote Hanks’ Ron Howard, “it make me giggle!”) Still, if you’d told us that the season’s most viral non-political sketch, the one that people would be talking about for weeks, would involve the star of Philadelphia in a pumpkin-covered suit slapping B-boy skeletons on the ass … we’d have been skeptical. But a perfect storm of pre-Halloween timing, Hanks enthusiastically selling this frizzy-haired entertainer with great fashion sense and the sheer WTF-ness of it all made this a huge hit, as well one of the most inexplicably funny SNL oddities ever. We think Beck Bennett speaks for all of us when, upon hearing Pumpkins’ signature line (“Any questions?”), he replies “Yes! Several!!” His return appearance during the season finale was way, way too brief.

10 Best 'Saturday Night Live' Sketches, Season 42

‘Trump vs. Clinton: Third Debate’

Arguably the highlight of SNL 42’s great double act, this third debate has it all: Baldwin’s Trump impersonation, firing on all cylinders (the explanation on how he’ll defeat ISIS is a perfect sniffly-Donald riff); MacKinnon’s Hillary, who gives great reaction shots here; the “Trump Bingo Card”; a cutaway to the entire planet of Earth laughing as the republican candidate says that no has more respect for women than he does; Tom Hanks’ Chris Wallace saying “Oh no, not again” when Trump asks what Clinton has been doing for the last 30 years; the “Nasty Woman” mug; and a quick lesson on the art of pivoting. It has everything, in fact, except for any idea of what would happen a little less than a month later. But the show was not trying to be a Cassandra, just a well-oiled comic machine, and this debate sketch demonstrated how, when all of the right ingredients were in place, it could reflect Our Insane Toxic Campaign Season of Hate (Trademark!) and refract it back to us for laughs. How were we to known those laughs would eventually stick in our throat?

10 Best 'Saturday Night Live' Sketches, Season 42

‘Sean Spicer Press Conference’

Melissa McCarthy described the experience of being in this sketch in The Hollywood Reporter‘s SNL cover story: “There was this weird, great delay … first people figure out it’s
Spicer and then they figure out it’s me. You could just feel it in the
room.” The White House Press Secretary had just started to make his presence known as a bellicose, belligerent mouthpiece for the administration. And unlike Baldwin, who’d been publicized as a guest impersonator before the season began, McCarthy’s participation was not announced in advance; no one knew that she would be the one in the bald cap and boxy suit. Watch it again, and you can audibly hear people realizing that it’s the Bridesmaids star beneath the prosthetics right around the 22-second mark. The surprise has barely worn off before she starts nailing Spicer’s antagonistic attitude to the press (“Now let me wave something shiny in front of you monkeys!”) and his sheer aggressiveness – and that’s what turns this into one of the most jaw-dropping political caricatures since Tina Fey’s Sarah Palin. The shock may have subsided, but the sight of McCarthy pouring gum into her mouth and chewing it into a giant wad will still leave you gasping for air.

10 Best 'Saturday Night Live' Sketches, Season 42

‘Black Jeopardy’ (Featuring Tom Hanks)

This go-to game show premise had already been showing slight signs of wear by the time it was brought back for Tom Hanks’ ninth go-round as host. But what the creators of this sketch did here by switching the usual focus from how black America is different from white America to how the idea that there’s no class system in America is a fallacy is, frankly, a stroke of genius. Not that it gets rid of race at all – the bit still underlines the point that a cultural perspective on everyday life is not a one-skin-color-fits-all prospect, and watch what happens when Kenan Thompson goes to shake the hand of the guy in the red ballcap.

But the more it gives Tom Hanks’ rural Trump supporter and the African-American contestants and host common ground – scratch-off lottery tickets, distrust of the government and the voting process, a mutual love of Tyler Perry movies – the more you realize how this skit has been deployed to get at something deep in our national soil. We’re really not that different after all, it suggests … before deploying a killer final punchline that sadly returns us back to the country’s insurmountable reality.

We’d rank this among the top 10 best written sketches ever in the show’s history. There’s not a false moment. There’s not a bum joke. It’s both painfully funny and painful. There’s enough optimism to suggest that if we just talked to each other, we could actually bridge the gap. And there’s enough wisdom here in this smart bomb of a sketch to know that even that is still not enough.

Watch the best ‘Saturday Night Live’ political sketches.

Arrow Created with Sketch. Calendar Created with Sketch. Path Created with Sketch. Shape Created with Sketch. Plus Created with Sketch. minus Created with Sketch.