Will Ferrell and Billy Eichner unloaded a lot of holiday cheer on unsuspecting New Yorkers, screaming Christmas trivia and dishing out bizarre gifts in a new clip from Billy on the Street.

Dressed in Christmas onesies — a hilarious, but ostensibly unseasonable choice compared to the sun dresses and T-shirts of their contestants — the pair scurried around town in search of answers to the tough questions: Who starred in Scrooged? Who’s the one American actress in Love Actually? And which is better: gold, frankincense or myrrh?

Eichner and Ferrell doled out $1 prizes to the lucky winners, though the man who said Scrooged was a better Christmas movie than Elf got his buck snatched back by the incensed Elf himself. Elsewhere, Eichner and Ferrell attempted to gift one man a replica of a bale of hay used in the manger, while another replied to Eichner’s boisterous season’s greeting with a nervous, “Happy Easter!”