Live Report: Garbage - Rolling Stone
Home Music Music News

Live Report: Garbage

9:30 Club, Washington, D.C., May 27, 1998

(Full disclosure: If at any point during last night’s Garbage show
firebomb redhead Shirley Manson would have leaned into the sold-out
crowd, pointed at yours truly and ordered me to rob the nearest
Nationsbank with just a banana and my good looks, I would have not
only said yes, but brayed like a jackass while sprinting for the
Yellow Pages. There, just thought I’d get that off my chest before
continuing with this unbiased review…)

Producer/drummer Butch Vig, the Sara Lee of modern rock &
roll, may be the chief reason for Garbage’s confectious pop thump,
but the Scottish Manson, with her smeared lipstick, dizzying eyes
and salacious vocals, is the sole reason for the band’s
mega-selling success. Her come-ons are irresistible, her put-downs
seething, and when rumors spread that she often performs sans
underpants, well, that just showed what a fine promoter she was,

Packed into a blood-red (mini) mini-skirt and a snug, sleeveless
white blouse, Manson bounded onto the 9:30 Club stage almost a
minute after her band had revved up the intro to first-single “Push
It.” For the ninety-plus exhausting minutes that followed her
entrance, you couldn’t take your eyes off her; she was all parts
randy, angry, vindictive, hurt. Yeah, you try looking away.

As if Manson’s presence wasn’t distracting enough — she’s never
still: always jumping, bumping, grinding, posing — the band was
backlit with myriad multicolor lights, from glaring spots to
blinding strobes. And with a state-of-the-art sound system that was
both heart-attack loud and crystal clear (thank the perfectionist
Vig for that blessing), Garbage, as an experience, was a
full-throttle sensual attack, a technofied sexual nightmare with a
blissfully happy ending.

For as wild and unhinged as Manson seems in our overworked
imaginations (OK, my overworked imagination), the band as a whole
— both in the studio and on the stage — is efficient and
well-packaged, almost to a fault. Without taking much of a
breather, Garbage packed nineteen songs into the set, mixing most
of their 1995 self-titled debut with a good portion of superglossy
sophomore effort Version 2.0. “Push It” was followed by
the new “Dumb,” a hard, unnerving tune about long nights and bad
sex, and the band’s first big hit, “Queer.”

“Special,” one of the evening’s many highlights, is an ode to
hero Chrissie Hynde (although despite the compliment, the Queen
Pretender was reportedly none too pleased about the use of some of
her lyrics); the beat was breakneck and mean, but Manson smeared
dreamy la-la-las over the frenzy. For Version 2.0‘s
industrialized “Hammering in My Head,” a furious song about, well,
long nights but good sex, the frontwoman prowled the stage pleading
with her listeners to “Sweat it all out! Sweat it all out!” (Jesus,
doesn’t she ever let up?)

Garbage closed the set with a string of hits (and those
soon-to-be), including “Stupid Girl,” “#1 Crush,” the new “I Think
I’m Paranoid” and signature song “Only Happy When It Rains.” Manson
& Co. encored with two obscure B-sides, a cover of Big Star’s
“Thirteen” and “Girl Don’t Come,” then closed the night with
Version 2.0‘s final track, the hallucinatory “You Look So
Fine.” As the band stretched the song out to its thick, blurry
borders, mixing samples, loops, Steve Markes’ and Duke Erikson’s
guitars, and Manson’s lush voice, it was hard to decipher what was
real and what was programmed. But then again, isn’t that the whole
point of Garbage, anyway?

Popular on Rolling Stone


Powered by
Arrow Created with Sketch. Calendar Created with Sketch. Path Created with Sketch. Shape Created with Sketch. Plus Created with Sketch. minus Created with Sketch.