Judge Slashes $1.92 Million RIAA Ruling Against Minnesota Mom - Rolling Stone
Home Music Music News

Judge Slashes $1.92 Million RIAA Ruling Against Minnesota Mom

A Minnesota District Court judge has significantly slashed the $1.92 million fine against Minnesota mom Jammie Thomas-Rasset, who was sued by the RIAA after illegally downloading 24 songs through peer-to-peer networks. In a decision announced today, Judge Michael Davis found that the decision to fine Thomas-Rasset’s $80,000 per song was “simply shocking” and downright unconstitutional. Davis then sliced the penalty to $2,250 per song for a grand total of $54,000 — a 97 percent drop from the previous sentence, Copyrights & Campaigns reports. The major labels named as plaintiffs in the case now have seven days to decide whether to accept this fine or let Thomas-Rasset go to trial for a third time.

It’s been a long, hard-fought legal battle for Thomas-Rasset. The initial trial in 2007 resulted in a $212,000 fine, and after her legal team uncovered an error in jury instruction in the first trial, Thomas-Rasset’s case went to trial once again last year, only this time the jury levied the immense $1.92 million decision against her. That ruling went straight to the Justice Department, who defended the $1.92 million fine, arguing that “the defendant’s suggestion that the actual harm can be measured to the ‘tune of $1.29 for each of the 24 songs’ … ignores the potential multiplying effect of peer-to-peer file-sharing.”

The RIAA argued that Thomas-Rasset’s massive penalty would serve as a cautionary tale for would-be illegal downloaders, but maintained a willingness to negotiate. Richard Marx, who was one of the artists Thomas-Rasset downloaded on the peer-to-peer network, said he was “ashamed” that he was involved in the excessive punishment and called the $1.92 million fine against the Minnesota mom “misguided and at worst, farcical.”

Related Stories:

Justice Dept. Defends $1.92 Million RIAA Fine Against Minnesota Mom
Minnesota Mom Asks for Reduction of $1.92 Million Downloading Fine
Richard Marx “Ashamed” He’s Linked To $1.92 Million RIAA Fine Against Minnesota Mom


Powered by
Arrow Created with Sketch. Calendar Created with Sketch. Path Created with Sketch. Shape Created with Sketch. Plus Created with Sketch. minus Created with Sketch.