Song You Need to Know: Hayes Carll's Bluegrass-Plucky 'What It Is' - Rolling Stone
×
Home Music Music News

Song You Need to Know: Hayes Carll, ‘What It Is’

Texas troubadour looks toward a new morning on this highlight from his upcoming sixth album

Hayes Carll

David McClister

You hardly expect a guy who’s written songs with titles like “Bad Liver and a Broken Heart” and “Good While It Lasted” to go all giddy on you. But everybody has a moment when they realize something cherished is over, yet there’s no choice but to move on. For roustabout-looking Texas troubadour Hayes Carll, that flash arrives on the title track of his upcoming sixth record, What It Is.

Co-written with fellow singer-songwriter and fiancée Allison Moorer, “What It Is” finds Carll walking away from a situation that doesn’t sound terribly healthy — hearts broke, doors were slammed — and deciding to push on, even if another calamity could wait around the bend. “Every wave that crashes rearranges all the sand/And puts another path in front of me,” he sings in a voice that’s grown increasingly grainy with each new album.

On past records, Carll has operated in aggro-honky-tonk, stark-balladeer and droll-strummer modes. Anchored by a proudly springy banjo and a hardwood-floor drum, “What It Is” injects a hint of Sweetheart of the Rodeo pluck into the mix. Even though it’s been over 50 years after the Byrds’ milestone rock-meets-Nashville project, the result is still a record that sounds both retro and garden-fresh. Carll’s delivery never quite rises above a combination of wariness and weariness, but the vibrant arrangement stays the course and refuses to let him get more discouraged. A buoyant old-timer instrument and a dose of cautious optimism will do that to a person.

 

Popular on Rolling Stone

Newswire

Powered by
Arrow Created with Sketch. Calendar Created with Sketch. Path Created with Sketch. Shape Created with Sketch. Plus Created with Sketch. minus Created with Sketch.