CMT Music Awards 2015’s 13 Best and Worst Moments – Rolling Stone
Home Music Country Music Lists

CMT Music Awards 2015’s 13 Best and Worst Moments

From show-stopping performances to ill-advised dance moves, the water cooler bits from country’s wildest show

CMT Music Awards 2015

Keith Urban was a highlight of the 2015 CMT Music Awards.

Kevin Mazur/WireImage

There was the expected — Carrie Underwood reigns supreme; Florida Georgia Line set fire to things — but there were more unexpected moments at the CMT Music Awards this year than arguably ever before. Keith Urban plays a mean bass — who knew? Lady Antebellum have an EDM affinity? Rick Springfield plays for tips on the streets of downtown Nashville? Whether you loved or loathed Wednesday's show, it probably kept you on the edge of your seat, wondering what praiseworthy and cringeworthy moments were coming next. Here are the 13 moments from the 2015 CMT extravaganza that are still provoking smiles —and eye rolls — today.

Luke Bryan

FilmMagic/Getty

Best Unapologetic Performance: Luke Bryan

Before catching the award for Male Video of the Year, Luke Bryan revved his proverbial engine, ready to calibrate the crowd with a performance of his new single, "Kick the Dust Up." Wearing what looked like a shoulder holster and an eventually turned-backwards cap, the singer came galloping onstage like Davy Crockett storming the Alamo, bouncing to and fro between the boing-boings of a jaw harp and the Indian flavorings of the song's post-chorus. Its strutting tempo and funky gait rode the coattails of "I Love Rock 'N Roll" and a Backstreet Boys club banger — a thrill for the sea of swooning teenage girls whose cheers encouraged Mr. "Play It Again" to sensually gyrate his hips while rapping a few lines in the song. 

eric church

NASHVILLE, TN - JUNE 10: Eric Church performs at Ryman Auditorium on June 10, 2015 in Nashville, Tennessee. (Photo by Erika Goldring/Getty Images)

Erika Goldring/Getty

Best Back to Basics Moment: Eric Church

During a show that historically doubles down on huge productions, props and flash, Eric Church stood out with a strong performance that leaned heavily on the music, and not much else. His quiet delivery of "Like a Wrecking Ball" was in stark contrast to the rest of the night — raw, soulful and played on the arena floor, putting him on equal footing with the fans. There was no set to speak of, just a couple of musicians and a spotlight. Church played his own guitar parts, and although they weren't perfectly polished, they were real on a level that laid bare the ultimate goal of all country music — honesty.

lady antebellum

John Shearer/WireImage/Getty

Worst Pandering to Non-Country Fans: Lady Antebellum With Zedd

The CMT Music Awards kicked off with what seemed like a safe bet — Lady Antebellum performing their rousing new single, "Long Stretch of Love." But before the song was over they ended up proving country awards shows will do almost anything to prevent themselves from being country. In a mash-up attempt that didn't quite mash, the trio tossed to Zedd for an interlude of his pulsating EDM hit, "Beautiful Now." Beside the fact that the vast majority of the audience had no clue who the German DJ was, the segue felt forced and the active ingredients at work behind the two songs — and, for that matter, genres — could not have been more opposite. It's just the latest shameless attempt to bridge the gap between country and the broader pop culture of the moment, but this was a bridge to nowhere.

Charles Esten and Chris Carmack

Kevin Winter/WireImage/Getty

Best Chemistry: Charles Esten and Chris Carmack

In just one simple segment introducing Reba's commanding performance, Nashville co-stars Esten and Carmack exuded more warmth and playfulness than the awards' actual hosts, Dancing With the Stars' Erin Andrews and Pitch Perfect's Brittany Snow, whose opening comedy bit lacked spontaneity — and humor. Sure, Nashville's Deacon and Will have the luxury of sharing the screen together each week, but maybe that's the point: choosing hosts who have an inherent familiarity. Watching Carmack, who will soon release his own EP, rib Esten about his character possibly biting the big one in the show's season finale felt slightly off-script — and totally alive.

chris janson

NASHVILLE, TN - JUNE 10: Singer Chris Janson performs onstage during the 2015 CMT Music awards at the Bridgestone Arena on June 10, 2015 in Nashville, Tennessee. (Photo by John Shearer/WireImage)

John Shearer/WireImage/Getty

Best Use of the Least Time: Bumper Boys Chris Janson and Frankie Ballard

Newer artists relegated to playing the blink-and-you'll-miss-'em commercial bumpers are, in fact, usually missed. But in less than 60 seconds, both Janson's "Buy Me a Boat" and Ballard's "Sunshine & Whiskey" proved more buoyant and beaming than most of the songs by artists who were given full performance slots. Shrewdly, each singer-songwriter also managed to maximize their exposure and tell more of their stories by adding spice to their respective hits. Janson was all scarecrow charm and good cheer, pulling out his harmonica to show off skills the recorded version of the song doesn't even feature. Ballard followed suit, exuding Fifties greaser cool while revving up the brawn of his breezy hit with fiery guitar licks.

kenny chesney

C Flanigan/FilmMagic

Best Sing-Along: American Kids Sing ‘American Kids’

Way, way back in a time long ago (last November), Kenny Chesney opened the 2014 CMA Awards with "American Kids." He played the same damn song (actually, it's really good) at the CMT Music Awards, bucking the standard practice of using the show to plug a hot new single. The payoff: Chesney played the tune on a satellite stage outside the arena in downtown Nashville, surrounded by reveling fresh-faced fans who hollered along with the superstar and even drowned him out on call-and-response choruses. The outsized honky-tonk scene was clearly a transcendent moment for those who were there, as well as for a lot of people watching at home.

reba mcentire

NASHVILLE, TN - JUNE 10: Reba McEntire performs onstage during the 2015 CMT Music awards at the Bridgestone Arena on June 10, 2015 in Nashville, Tennessee. (Photo by John Shearer/WireImage)

John Shearer/WireImage/Getty

Best Royal Comeback: Reba McEntire

Coming off a resurgence that has surprised even the diva herself, Reba came out guns blazing on her defiant, no-tears-in-my-beers break-up jam "Going Out Like That," giving the early part of the show a welcome jolt of energy. She managed to be sassy yet age appropriate, and as usual, sang her red head off. The vibrancy of the performance had us immediately wishing the country queen wasn't confining her magical live powers to her upcoming Las Vegas residency with buddies Brooks and Dunn. 

CMT Awards

NASHVILLE, TN - JUNE 10: 2015 CMT Music awards at the Bridgestone Arena on June 10, 2015 in Nashville, Tennessee. (Photo by Larry Busacca/Getty Images for CMT)

Larry Busacca/Getty Images

Worst Song Choices: DJ Sinister

While viewers at home were watching Blake Shelton sell underwear during commercial breaks, fans inside the Bridgestone Arena were held captive by DJ Sinister, who spun seemingly anything but country. Sample mash-up: House of Pain's "Jump Around" and DJ Snake and Lil Jon's "Turn Down for What," played at Camp X-Ray decibels. It's true that many of today's country fans have broad tastes, but there appeared to be more blank stares in the arena seats than the intended dancing. (In fact, the only dancing going on during the breaks was by Nashville Predators cheerleaders.) Even an endless loop of Party Down South clips would have been more inspiring.

Arrow Created with Sketch. Calendar Created with Sketch. Path Created with Sketch. Shape Created with Sketch. Plus Created with Sketch. minus Created with Sketch.