Review: Katy Perry's 'Witness' - Rolling Stone
Home Music Album Reviews

Review: Katy Perry Navigates a Less Bombastic Pop Universe on ‘Witness’

Our take on the latest from the chart-topping pop star

Review: Katy Perry, 'Witness'

Katy Perry's latest album is the less bombastic 'Witness.'

AJ Numan

After steadily charting nine Number One hits since 2008, anthem-roarer Katy Perry is stumbling through the fog and strobes of a less bombastic pop universe. Fourth album Witness surfs on gentler throbs of house music and lets ballads smush into art-pop soup. It’s all a perfect fit for a Hot 100 dominated by the subtle, nuanced, EDM-informed music of artists like Halsey, Camila Cabello and Troye Sivan. But subtle and nuanced was never the calling card of the artist behind songs like “I Kissed a Girl.” Perry has replaced the eye of the tiger with the heart of a contemporary night owl, making an album of mostly moody, dreamy, reserved music – and one double-entendre-filled, AC/DC-ready food fight in “Bon Appetit.” In turn, a pop icon blends into the rest of the radio.

Working with super-producer Max Martin and a list of modern cool kids (Duke Dumont, Jack Garratt, Corin Roddick of synth-pop band Purity Ring), Witness is a mish-mash of electronic-leaning pop: the currently trendy revival of British 2-step (“Witness”), a dancehall/disco smash-up (“Chained to the Rhythm”), fake Sam Smith (“Save as Draft”) and a look back on vintage early-Nineties house music (“Swish”) that jacks the same Roland Clark sample that Fatboy Slim did in 2000. Throughout, Perry is less like the so-unusual, candy-coated Cyndi Lauper of “Teenage Dream,” and is more an anonymous disco crooner, a breathy moderator leading us through passionate but muted songs of longing and empowerment.

A brassy voice that once held long notes and sang lines like “I am a champion” is now devoured in effects and reverb, rarely reaching the excited joy of punkier electronic-poppers like Robyn, Charli XCX or even recent singles from Lorde. The exceptions are “Roulette,” an explosive EDM Eurythmics update (produced by Martin and Shellback), and the gospel-choir-assisted “Pendulum,” which brings a vintage Perry vocal performance to some late-Eighties filigrees by Kanye producer Jeff Bhasker. But her advice in that song doubles as a criticism: “Don’t try and reinvent your wheel/’Cause you’re too original.”

Popular on Rolling Stone


Powered by
Arrow Created with Sketch. Calendar Created with Sketch. Path Created with Sketch. Shape Created with Sketch. Plus Created with Sketch. minus Created with Sketch.