Natalie Maines, 'Mother' - Rolling Stone
×
Home Music Album Reviews

Mother

It’s been a decade since Natalie Maines said a few choice words about George W. Bush and set off the biggest flame war in country-music history. Overnight, the Dixie Chicks became pariahs, and the role suited them: They broke with Nashville, hooked up with Rick Rubin and recorded their tautest, most tough-minded album, 2006’s Taking the Long Way. Now, Maines returns with a solo LP – and she wants no part of country whatsoever. Mother, co-produced by Maines and Ben Harper, is a rock album, with nary a fiddle or pedal steel in earshot. It’s serious and at times grim, full of midtempo songs in brooding minor keys. The straight-forwardness is in Maines’ choice of repertoire: songs by Harper, Eddie Vedder, Jeff Buckley and the Jayhawks, most of them tastefully rootsy. Too often, the music feels a bit limp, and the buttery harmony backups of her fellow Dixie Chicks are sorely missed. But there are some surprises: The title track is the famous Pink Floyd ballad, which in Maines’ stately reading comes off as a lament, not as a rant. The album hits its stride with the more spunky material, like Patty Griffin’s “Silver Bell.” It’s a breakup song – but it sounds a whole heck of a lot like a kiss-off from Maines to her old Bush-era foes: “How you been?/I’m doing well/I hear you’re digging a hole to hell.”

Popular on Rolling Stone

Newswire

Powered by
Arrow Created with Sketch. Calendar Created with Sketch. Path Created with Sketch. Shape Created with Sketch. Plus Created with Sketch. minus Created with Sketch.