4 - Rolling Stone
Home Music Album Reviews


Girls run the world. But who runs the girls? For most of the past 10 years, the answer has been Beyoncé Knowles. In the Estrogen Era – a period in which women seized pop music’s center stage – Beyoncé has been the prima donna, the diva of divas: the girl with the funkiest songs, the flashiest Bob Fosse-meets-hip-hop dance moves and, as Kanye West memorably declared, the Greatest Video of All Time.

Beyoncé is such a force of nature that it’s easy to overlook her trump card: She’s a bit of a weirdo. Not a weirdo like her stiffest competition, Lady Gaga. (Wearing sirloin to an awards show isn’t B’s style.) Her weirdness is musical – it’s in the idiosyncratic way she syncopates her vocals, the odd melodies she floats over rugged beats, her sui generis mix of rap bravado, gospel sanctimony and old-fashioned showbiz razzle-dazzle. It’s in songs like “1+1,” the ballad that opens her fourth album. The track begins like the lowest-fi indie rock: a few raggedy guitar arpeggios, a discreetly piping organ. It stays there, more or less, while Beyoncé sings a meandering melody, crooning, groaning and whooping about the comfort of love – and sex. “When my days look low/Pull me in close and don’t let me go/Make love to me,” she sings.  

4 might be her strangest rec­ord. It’s a big-budget megapop album with an A list of guest stars (Kanye West, André 3000) and songwriter-producers (Tricky Stewart, the-Dream, Diplo, Ryan Tedder, Diane Warren). Yet it’s as eccentric – as unmistakably personal and quirky – as anything that Sufjan Stevens ever cooked up in his bedroom.

Beyoncé has made a career of setting trends, and on 4, she leaves fashionable production styles behind. There’s no Eurodisco thump; live instruments take the place of digital beats on many tracks. Half the songs are ballads, but all kinds of sounds filter through the mix – vintage soul, hard rock, reggae, adult contemporary. Beyoncé calls Nigerian Afrobeat legend Fela Kuti a big inspiration (Jay-Z is co-producing the Fela! musical), which may explain the bristling brass arrangements in “Countdown,” a dancehall-style corker, and in “End of Time,” whose martial beat drives home a command: “Say you’ll never let me go!”

That song, like many on 4, is a steamily sensual ode to monogamous romance. Beyoncé has been a star for more than a decade, but now she’s a 29-year-old married woman, and she sounds like one, singing love songs that are no less sexy for being unblinkingly true to life. “There’s ups and downs in this love/Got a lot to learn in this love/Through the good and the bad, still got love,” she growls in “Countdown.”

The low point comes in “I Was Here,” a blowsy Diane Warren ballad swamped in “My Way”-style self-mythologizing: “I was here/I lived, I loved/I was here/I did, I’ve done/Everything that I wanted.” Beyoncé sings with authority, but sounds off; she’s a diva, Lord knows, but she’s never been a preener, a navel-gazer. She’s too busy with other stuff: singing, dancing, following her muse, loving her man, running the world.

Listen to “The Best I Never Had”:

Related: Photos: Beyoncé and Jay-Z, Hip Hop Royalty
Beyoncé’s ‘4’: A Track-by-Track Breakdown
Photos: Pop Divas on the Cover of Rolling Stone

In This Article: Beyonce


Powered by
Arrow Created with Sketch. Calendar Created with Sketch. Path Created with Sketch. Shape Created with Sketch. Plus Created with Sketch. minus Created with Sketch.