9. James Durbin, "You Got Another Thing Comin'"
Durbin made it to the Top Four on Season 10 but had already established himself as the resident metalhead. Over the course of the show, Durbin covered hard rock classics but none as soaringly as his take on Judas Priest's "You Got Another Thing Comin.'" Steven Tyler admired how over-the-top he was, and he called the performance "fucking crazy good."