CMA Awards 2014: Who Will (and Should) Win on Country's Big Night

We predict the victors in the largely unpredictable categories, plus make our case for who really deserves the high country honors

Load Previous
Single of the Year
Blake Shelton NBC Universal11/12

Single of the Year

In what may be the closest category of the night, five smash hits are duking it out: Blake Shelton's "Mine Would Be You," Tim McGraw and Faith Hill's "Meanwhile Back at Mama's," Dierks Bentley's "Drunk on a Plane," Eric Church's "Give Me Back My Hometown" and Miranda Lambert's "Automatic."

Who Will Win: This one is a toss-up. "Drunk On a Plane" elevated bro-country tropes into something surprisingly winsome. "Automatic" appeals to simpler times. "Give Me Back My Hometown" reflected on a break-up with a fresh song structure. "Meanwhile Back at Mama's" felt as cozy as a slice of apple pie. "Mine Would Be You" was the finest song on Shelton's CMA-winning Based on a True Story… album, and although it wasn't his biggest hit, there's a good chance that votes will be split so evenly between the nominees, that Shelton's consistent popularity with CMA voters will give his song the victory.

Who Should Win: Tim McGraw sputtered at the start of this year with the overly auto-tuned "Lookin' for That Girl," which never took off. So his duet with wife Faith Hill felt like a refreshing reprieve from trend-chasing. "Meanwhile Back at Mama's" connected with critics and listeners alike, and its popularity was rooted in real emotion, not just flash.

Back to Top