Home Culture Culture Lists

The Best Record Stores in the USA

The top spots for unique vinyl and CDs, from San Francisco to Boston

The Best Record Stores in the USA: The top 25 spots for unique vinyl and CDs, from San Francisco to Boston

Photograph by Jules Ameel for RollingStone.com

Hollywood – San Francisco – Berkeley, CA

Even in the days when record-store chains ruled the music world, nothing compared to Amoeba. It was, and is, simply the most thorough and welcoming place a record lover could hope to shop. Each of its three stores features more than 100,000 items — much of it surprisingly high-grade, and with loads of surprises and rarities around seemingly every corner. Which, as anyone who's been to any of them can tell you, is a lot of corners.

By Michaelangelo Matos and Stacey Anderson

RELATED:

Photos: The 20 Best Record Store Day Exclusives

Jerry's Records

Photograph by Doug Payne

Jerry’s Records

Pittsburgh, PA

Sure, there are CDs, videos, old rock magazines and books, even 8-track tapes at this massive Pittsburgh store. But it's vinyl that really matters here: Close to a million pieces of 12-inch vinyl (and nearly as many 45s) are housed in Jerry's enormous space, running the gamut of genres: jazz, R&B, psychedelic rock, as well as more recent stuff. Bonus: Jerry's repairs record players, and sells used turntables as well. Double bonus: Whistlin' Willie's 78s, which opened earlier this year, is located right next door.

Photos: The 20 Best Record Store Day Exclusives

Laurie's Planet of Sound

Photograph by Anthony Auston

Laurie’s Planet of Sound

Chicago, IL

Chicago has no shortage of excellent record stores (as this list demonstrates). But ask knowledgeable locals for their favorite, and chances are they'll name this Lincoln Square classic. Laurie's is known for a stellar new and used inventory, which has breadth and bulk; when other places run out of titles, you can probably find them here. Laurie's is also fun: they recently gave away Pavement tickets for the best macaroni drawing inspired by the band. "The fact that they sell dead-stock Pee-Wee Herman fun packs makes me love them," says the Chicago Reader's Miles Raymer.

Photos: The 20 Best Record Store Day Exclusives

Newbury Comics

Photograph by Jason Bergman for RollingStone.com

Newbury Comics

Boston, MA

There's no denying this New England powerhouse, which still maintains numerous locations throughout New England — 21 of them in Massachusetts alone. The Newbury St. shop in Boston, though, remains Mecca for serious music lovers. There's plenty of new and used selection, of course — but the many toys, T-shirts, and (especially) one of the most thorough collections of contemporary designer concert posters you'll find this side of a Flatstock exhibit are just as much of a draw.

Photos: The 20 Best Record Store Day Exclusives

Other Music

Photograph by Alex Reside for RollingStone.com

Other Music

New York, NY

This adventurous-listener's wonderland was named "Other" because Tower Records was across the street. Now, Other is just about the only game left in New York. (Tower, of course, closed.) Yet it does better than merely hang on, thanks to its unobtrusively friendly staff and a strong stock of hipster sounds — from free-jazz icons to cool new indie bands, plus a fine selection of techno 12-inches and a robust African section. A smart selection of used CDs and deeply discounted major-label catalog items help pick up some of Tower's slack, as well.

Photos: The 20 Best Record Store Day Exclusives

Princeton Record Exchange

Photograph by Jon Lambert

Princeton Record Exchange

Princeton, NJ

PREX sells new items, but it's the used CDs (which sell for under $9) and vinyl (which is generally under $5) that makes it worth the trip. (That's saying something, especially at a time when dollar-bin items are often listed elsewhere for more than their actual worth, thanks to the sudden trend for vinyl.) There are collector finds and obscurities, of course — as well as a hefty number of DVDs — but PREX earns its rep by being accessible and affordable.

Photos: The 20 Best Record Store Day Exclusives

Shake It Records

Photograph by Alison Hillard

Shake It Records

Cincinnati, OH

This Cincinnati stalwart is impressive enough for its musical selection — nearly 40,000 titles on CD (about three-quarters of the stock) and vinyl — but it's the extras that make it a favorite. Shake It features loads of music books, DVDs, and magazines, not to mention a killer selection of Japanese toys and vinyl figurines.

Photos: The 20 Best Record Store Day Exclusives

Sonic Boom

Photograph by Chona Kasinger for RollingStone.com

Sonic Boom

NW Market St., Seattle, WA; Melrose Ave., Seattle, WA

Ballard is the Brooklyn of Seattle, so it stands to reason that one of the best record shops in the city has the bigger of its two locations there, near the earthy live venue Sunset Tavern. Sonic Boom has enough space for in-store performances and an array of new titles, indie and major, and while the vibe skews toward the former, there's little snobbery to be found either there or in the recently relocated Capitol Hill location. A wide selection of vinyl and books rounds things out — as do homemade mixtapes from K Records' Calvin Johnson.

Photos: The 20 Best Record Store Day Exclusives

The True Vine

Photograph by Jeremiah Evans

The True Vine

Baltimore, MD

A small shop, run by the knowledgeable Jason Willett and Stewart Mostofsky, with big inventory — and the most constant turnover in town. Onetime Baltimore City Paper music editor Jess Harvell refers to True Vine's "ginormous, catholic vinyl selection — they buy whole collections," containing everything from rare ethnographic 78s to Baltimore club 12-inches, and sell them just as fast to a discerning clientele. Expertly chosen indie and experimental titles with special emphasis on local labels make True Vine a Baltimore institution.

Photos: The 20 Best Record Store Day Exclusives

Waterloo Records

Photograph by Peyton McGee

Waterloo Records

Austin, TX

Savvier out-of-town attendees of the South by Southwest festival like to stick around an extra day so they can shop at Waterloo in relative peace. But only relative — this robust store has earned a loyal base in a town notable for its music-friendliness even when biz tourists aren't invading it. There's good reason: Waterloo has everything you could ask for, new or used, and its abundant size means it gets plenty of in-store performances by everyone from Hot Hot Heat to Ozomatli to the Black Angels.

Photos: The 20 Best Record Store Day Exclusives

Wuxtry Records

Photograph by Bryan Stewart

Wuxtry Records

Decatur, GA; Athens, GA

Famous as much for its former employees — Peter Buck of R.E.M. and Danger Mouse have both manned the counters of the Athens shop — Wuxtry is a Georgia stalwart that continues to win new fans that don't even care about its history. (Well, maybe a little.) Nevertheless, the store's deep commitment to rock new and old — listening to and debating it alike — has sparked a deep bond with the place shared by regulars and visitors alike. As a bonus, the Athens location features a terrific comics shop upstairs. Pictured: Owner Dan Wall

Photos: The 20 Best Record Store Day Exclusives

Jive Time Records

Photograph by Chona Kasinger for RollingStone.com

Jive Time Records

Seattle, WA

Located in Seattle's charming Fremont district, Jive Time is a modest-seeming local store whose holdings belie its size. There are bigger vinyl specialists in town, but few offer the kinds of bargains you'll find here — the $3 bins (four records for $10) are full of good stuff, and the more collector-oriented sections feature lots of terrific vintage R&B, including an enviable selection of P-Funk titles. (There's also a nice selection of used CDs, but the vinyl is the attraction here.) On good days there are vintage rock magazines (including early issues of Rolling Stone) for sale in the corner, to further enhance the old-school vibe.

Photos: The 20 Best Record Store Day Exclusives

Academy Records

Photograph by Alex Reside for RollingStone.com

Academy Records

Brooklyn, NY

The snug, heavily stocked Academy in Manhattan is a reliable go-to for city folk looking for good used-CD bargains, particularly in jazz and classical. But the more expansive Brooklyn outlet specializes in carefully selected vinyl in all kinds of popular genres. It's made for leisurely browsing — and how many places in antic Williamsburg can that honestly be said of?

Photos: The 20 Best Record Store Day Exclusives

Bananas Music

Photograph courtesy of Bananas Music

Bananas Music

St. Petersburg, FL (Vinyl-Only)

A two-story warehouse housing nearly 3 million pieces of vinyl, this St. Petersburg monster is well named. (There's also a CD/DVD shop across the street.) Stories abound of fanatical collectors who plan vacations around all-day (or longer) excursions into its LP and 45 catacombs. And they find good stuff there consistently, in all kinds of categories, from classical to blues, and rock to comedy. One shopper tells us how he found so many rare Brazilian records from the '70s that they alone overwhelmed his budget.

Photos: The 20 Best Record Store Day Exclusives

Dave's Records

Photograph by Rob Lambert/ Wax.fm

Dave’s Records

Chicago, IL (Vinyl-Only)

"Records" means records — Dave doesn't even carry a few token CDs, and according to all the store's promotional material, never will. More power to him — this is one of Chicago's most beloved music emporiums, filled with everything from disco 12-inches to rock rarities, and Dave himself, a 25-year veteran, knows his wares as well as anyone in the city.

Photos: The 20 Best Record Store Day Exclusives

Hymie's Vintage Records

Photograph by Jules Ameel for RollingStone.com

Hymie’s Vintage Records

Minneapolis, MN (Vinyl-Only)

A classic, overstuffed mom-and-pop used-vinyl haven, Hymie's has been around since the '80s, and it's still an ideal stop for serious digging. But rather than the usual stereotype of haphazard you-find-it stacks, the shop is tidily organized and full of superb finds — a spiffy copy of Love's 1970 album False Start over here, who knows what else over there. And when you get tired, you can slip over to the cafe next door for a caffeine fix.

– Michaelangelo Matos

Photos: The 20 Best Record Store Day Exclusives

Courtesy of Twist & Shout

Twist & Shout

Denver, CO

Situated on Denver's trendiest drag, Colfax Avenue, this 12,000-sq. foot emporium abounds with a quarter of a million new and used titles. The store has featured hundreds of in-store performances since its mid-Eighties launch, including memorable gigs by Ween, Elvis Costello and John Cale. The used vinyl racks are legendary, and collectors can be seen fighting over sifting spots every day. A vast collection of reign film, Japanese plastic toys and band apparel rounds out the vast offerings.

Stacey Anderson

Photos: The 20 Best Record Store Day Exclusives

Courtesy of A.K.A. Music

A.K.A. Music

Philadelphia, PA

Philly's artsy Old City neighborhood is the perfect home to this lovingly kept shop, whose motto is succinct: "Rock is our life." That means no toys or memorabilia, a knowledgeable staff and a very deep catalogue of new and used rock, prog, avant-garde and jazz. Regulars boast endlessly about the rarities they unearth here – recently, A.K.A. sold a Bob Dylan mono LP and a Syd Barrett-era Pink Floyd album, each worth its weight in gold to collectors. Owner Michael Hoffman curates in-store performances shrewdly, insisting that the artists must match the sincere ethos of the store and staff – musicians like Kurt Vile, Bill Callahan and Kimya Dawson have all made the cut.

S.A.

Photos: The 20 Best Record Store Day Exclusives

Photograph by Shawn Thorpe

Boo Boo Records

San Luis Obispo, CA

This is the venerable little-shop-that-could of Southern California, and revered justly by fans across the Golden State. Located in an idyllic beachside college town, Boo Boo's nuanced collection of CDs and vinyl dwarfs those of shops three times its size and the scholarly but friendly staff keeps even the most eccentric bands accessible to neophytes. The extensive jazz and classical wing closed recently, turning the U shape of the store into more of an overstuffed J – a problem Boo Boo's has happily compounded with its newfound expansion into books and memorabilia. Singer/songwriter M. Ward once presided over the cash register, about two decades after the store opened in 1974 – but neither he nor anyone else has been able to pry the meaning of the store's name from founders Ed Taylor and Glenn Forbes.

S.A.

Photos: The 20 Best Record Store Day Exclusives