Season 4: Bette Tattler / Dot Tattler
Season 3: Cordelia Foxx
Season 2: Lana Winters
Season 1: Billie Dean Howard
The always wonderful character actress Sarah Paulson has been twice Emmy-nominated for AHS roles: once for playing the undercover journalist Lana Winters on "Asylum"; and once for her role as psychic medium Cordelia Foxx on "Coven." But this will hopefully be the year that Paulson finally takes home the gold, given that she has twice as much work to do as her cast mates: she's playing both of the murderous conjoined twins Bette and Dot Tattler.