Emmy Awards 2015: Who Should Win, Who Will Win

Predicting the winners — and who should be collecting the gold — for this year's awards broadcast

Load Previous
Best Drama
10
AMC10/10

Best Drama

The Nominees:
Better Call Saul (AMC)
Downton Abbey (PBS)
Game of Thrones (HBO)
Homeland (Showtime)
House of Cards (Netflix)
Mad Men (AMC)
Orange Is the New Black (Showtime)

WILL WIN: A failure to award Matt Weiner's masterpiece Mad Men one more time before it heads off to the big Coke commercial in the sky would be almost willfully perverse. If its most direct points of comparison — Weiner's alma mater show The Sopranos and its AMC brother-in-arms Breaking Bad — could pull off the final-season win, the house that Don Draper built can do it t0o.

SHOULD WIN: Never mind the naysayers: Mad Men is an all-time top-five television show and deserves the trophy for its melancholy, valedictory suite of final episodes. That said, no series on TV thinks bigger or strikes harder than Game of Thrones, though it will take the departure of both its Bad/ Mad rivals for it to finally take home the gold.

ROBBED: The biggest drama here may well be the shows that didn't make the cut. Showtime's uncompromising psychodrama The Affair took home the Golden Globe but didn't even manage a nomination. FX's political thriller The Americans gets better and better seemingly with every episode but has yet to garner a nod, even as its weaker counterparts Homeland and House of Cards keep racking them up. Fox's ratings behemoth Empire was a way more entertaining soap than Downton Abbey's sagging fourth season, while Boardwalk Empire's morally merciless final episodes trumped it in the period-piece department. The Marvel/Netflix joint Daredevil was the best live-action superhero-comic adaptation since Tim Burton's Batman in 1989 (eat it, Chris Nolan). And NBC's violent visual fantasia Hannibal made almost everything else on TV look like a public-access show.