The insanity Conley is referring to began in 2003, when Saves the Day released In Reverie, their major-label debut, on DreamWorks Records. This was supposed to be the New Jersey punks' big break -- but fate had other plans....

"We never even discussed what was going to happen," says Weinstock of the demise of Glassjaw -- guitarists Weinstock and Justin Beck, singer Daryl Palumbo, bassist Manuel Carrero and drummer Larry Gorman. "It was, like, 'Finally, we're off tour -- who cares what's going on?' And the Web site didn't get updated, and then months and months and months started going by. And then Dary...