Previous Next Latest

Evanescence Return to the Stage at “Secret” New York Gig

11/5/09, 9:29 am EST

Photo: Noam Galai
It was a chant that hadn’t been heard in Manhattan in more than two years, and it started a little after 9 p.m., as the anxious crowd who packed out the Manhattan Center Grand Ballroom started growing more and more impatient: “EVAN-ES-SCENTS, EVAN-ES-SCENTS.” And though the last time Amy Lee floated across a stage George W. Bush was in office, you wouldn’t have been able to tell from the band’s adept, hard-charging performance.

But as the Evanescence frontwoman explained to the audience at last night’s extremely intimate secret concert, the one-off performance was quite necessary. After all, on November 8th, Evanescence will be performing before 40,000 screaming fans at the Maquinaria Festival in Sao Paulo, Brazil, and the band needed a little limbering up before heading south. “Thanks for being our guinea pigs,” Lee joked to the mostly female crowd.

Check out our collection of Evanescence photos.

With Evanescence hard at work on the follow-up to 2006’s The Open Door, it’ll be another year before they’re back in New York, making last night’s concert a one-of-a-kind experience for the band’s rabid fans, who sold out the show in five minutes.

Lee, looking rested and donning bulky black boots and a multi-colored dress that looked like it was stolen from the Project Runway work room, commanded the stage, stretching her operatic pipes and stomping across the stage like a pixie on speed during the set’s opener, “Going Under,” her voice as crisp and smoky as ever. The band, featuring fill-in guitarist James Black from Finger Eleven, sounded tight, and ripped through cuts like “The Only One” and “Missing” for the mesmerized audience, who hoisted smart phones and Flip cams in the air, recording every minute.

After “Haunted,” the band pummeled the crowd through “Lithium,” with Lee swaying and bouncing around the stage, pumping her fists in the air. The anguish in Lee’s voice was palpable, and the band skillfully replicated live what they do on tape. Next came “Good Enough,” with Lee stroking the ivories and delivering her lyrics with an elegant sweetness reminiscent of Tori Amos and Sarah McLachlan.

After “Whisper,” Lee and the band launched into the anthemic “Call Me When You’re Sober,” which had everyone in the place headbanging along with Lee, whose hair whipped in circles wildly as she belted out the chorus. As the song ended, a fan tossed up a teddy bear that was intended for Lee, but ended up in the grip of a stage hand.

The audience sang every lyric back at Lee during “Bring Me to Life,” which was followed by “All That I’m Living For” and Taking Over Me.” Then came “Lacrymosa” with Lee going solo for “My Immortal,” a song that’s become something of an Alanis Morissette-like battle hymn for her Goth disciples over the last few years. Before leaving the stage, Lee thanked her fans for being so supportive for so long, and promised new material was on the way.

Related Stories:

The New Evanescence Open the Door
Q&A: Amy Lee
Ex-Evanescence Members Debut We Are the Fallen With Smithson


Previous Next Latest

Comments

Goth Emo Cutting Depressed Kid | 11/5/2009, 10:03 am EST

Ev are my fav band. Now excuse me while i cut some more.

Anonymous | 11/5/2009, 10:05 am EST

AMYYYY!!! wooooo

Ugo Capeto | 11/5/2009, 10:25 am EST

It’s a dream that Evanescence…that Amy is come back! No sign about Everybody’s fool? It’s my favourite…never mind! Ev is back…and that’s all that counts… Against all those chatting boxes telling it was a dead band…Wait and see…and a new evanescent era will reign over the world…!

Sean | 11/5/2009, 11:26 am EST

Goth Emo Cutting Depressed Kid – either you need help or if your trying to say everyone who listens to Evanescence are self-harmers its just really pathetic.

anyway good review, nice to see the song title errors were fixed lol :P

Qliaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa | 11/5/2009, 11:39 am EST

<3

Ben | 11/5/2009, 11:39 am EST

Awesome review! Saw a few videos and Amy’s voice seems better than before! Really looking forward to the new direction for the band, and the new album :)

neil | 11/5/2009, 11:42 am EST

i like to hear even baby singing whilst having great sex she makes me soooooo horny baby yeah

Equasia | 11/5/2009, 11:46 am EST

I was there and the performance was breathtaking. Amy’s voice is one of a kind and can’t be replicated. She’s sounds much better live and raw. I’ve been in love with this band since 2003.

Monica | 11/5/2009, 12:03 pm EST

Why were fans screaming: “EVAN-ES-SCENTS, EVAN-ES-SCENTS”, when the band’s name is Evanescence? :P What a bad news reporter. Love you, Ev. Can’t wait for the new material.

And -Goth Emo Cutting Depressed Kid-, please cut them until the end and die, ’cause you’re not funny at all.

Anonymous | 11/5/2009, 12:09 pm EST

ı love you amy ver very very beatıful very nıce

Evanescent | 11/5/2009, 12:16 pm EST

Amazing. I was actually tearing up reading this. Wish I could have been there. <33

Anonymous | 11/5/2009, 12:17 pm EST

but i thot she cut her haid..lol
EV. IS MY FAV BAND

TwitterAddict | 11/5/2009, 12:21 pm EST

Didn’t get to see EV in NYC even though I live in NYC. Tickets were sold out and even the contests online to win them were no go. Crap. Would have loved to hear Amy sing live. Messed up!

francisca | 11/5/2009, 12:23 pm EST

evanecence es una banda inpresionante emylytiene un avoz k pa ke po….***** la chi-k*******

Daiane | 11/5/2009, 12:24 pm EST

I can’t wait for sunday, i can’t believe that i’ll be able to see evanescence after 2 years,i’m so happy *-*

Ryuu | 11/5/2009, 12:29 pm EST

Damn I wish I was there!!!! That sounds like a fantastic show! Can’t wait to see how the concert in Brazil will turn out.

xD And I really like how the person wrote this article. Very descriptive. You described Amy’s movements to a T.

facebookaddict | 11/5/2009, 12:34 pm EST

hey i totally wish i could have been there. but i love evanescence and i love amy lee so i am just waiting for the next album

ryan mohammed | 11/5/2009, 12:38 pm EST

Hey I am from Trinidad way in the Caribbean. I love you and I totally wish you would visit for a concert sometime. I love your music, videos and Amy Lee i love you babe.Keep up the great work…

Will | 11/5/2009, 12:46 pm EST

Must’ve been awesome, even if this show was a ‘test’. They’ll rock in Brazil, that by the way is such an amazing country! Go Ev!

Jamie | 11/5/2009, 12:48 pm EST

Evanescence are the best band ever.

anna | 11/5/2009, 12:52 pm EST

evanescence too cool

Nay | 11/5/2009, 1:09 pm EST

AHHHHHHHH AND I WILL BE WAITING HERE IN BRAZIL! =D

MissingBra | 11/5/2009, 1:10 pm EST

Awesome ♥

QTinNYC | 11/5/2009, 1:10 pm EST

The show was AMAZING!!! Her voice is incredible live. I dont know how she can keep up at that level through a whole show. It was unreal!

Anonymous v.02 | 11/5/2009, 1:11 pm EST

Amy Lee is a hottie and needs to show more skin at shows x x x

Anonymous | 11/5/2009, 2:01 pm EST

I teared up while reading this.
Ev has had a huge impact in my life since Fallen came out in 2003, and the music has always been with me to calm me down when I was not feeling well.
I can’t wait for new music!

Montydon | 11/5/2009, 2:08 pm EST

I am soo happy that Evanescence is back specially Amyoo! I want her in the UK.

exodos_2 | 11/5/2009, 2:42 pm EST

I´m living for amy
amy is my life ^^

Ugo Capeto | 11/5/2009, 2:51 pm EST

Oh, I forgot…It could be an incredible dream for me a performance in my SICILY…but I know it’s something completely foolish…so I think it could be amazing the same a concert anywhere in Italy: AMY COME TO ITALY! WE LOVE YOU DON’T YOU? We wait for you celebrating the new album!

Ugo Capeto | 11/5/2009, 2:53 pm EST

It could be an incredible dream…but i know it’s completely foolish…a performance in my SICILY… So it could be amazing the same a concert anywhere in Italy: AMY COME TO ITALY WE LOVE YOU!

Anonymous | 11/5/2009, 2:53 pm EST

Amazing

Adame | 11/5/2009, 2:58 pm EST

yeah amy lee i love u !
I wish u are here in morocco :)

Skye | 11/5/2009, 3:31 pm EST

“the band pummeled the crowd through “Lithium,” with Lee swaying and bouncing around the stage, pumping her fists in the air.”

…That’d be a really accurate description of just about any song _except_ Lithium. You know, what with her playing piano and all…

Also left out the last song of the night (”Your Star”).

Josselin.. =P | 11/5/2009, 3:34 pm EST

WOW!! EV is back!!!! that’ great!! it’s my favorite band…

cathy | 11/5/2009, 3:40 pm EST

evanescence for the win!
can’t believe I couldn’t be there…
and so looking forward to new music next year….
amy, u rock!!!

deviks | 11/5/2009, 4:31 pm EST

was there for most of the concert, FANTASTIC perfomance! unfortunately i had to leave at 10:30 to catch the train home, so i missed my immortal and your star. i was so jealous of the people around me with real cameras =P i had to take pictures with my phone.

Dean | 11/5/2009, 4:36 pm EST

hmmm…. “Lee joked to the mostly !female! crowd.” pfffff xD i wish i was there =O can’t wait for new album!

evfan93 | 11/5/2009, 5:17 pm EST

alright!! nice 2 hear evanescence is baq! they my fav band and i hope this new album will be even bttr and more epic than the last two! With terry writting like in the open door album we can expect great work! =]

jamie | 11/5/2009, 5:29 pm EST

Wasn’t there but I saw some performances on YouTube captured by the fans, and I must say she looked and sounded great! She does indeed look well-rested and she lost some weight. Although I must say, she kinda looked like Bjork!

ÇriszEv | 11/5/2009, 5:36 pm EST

Evanescence had to go back, I can not die without them! I love Evanescence

Çristina.Lima.Peru | 11/5/2009, 5:39 pm EST

I have great hopes that come to my Country, here we go crazy for Amy, Evanescence grande.Disfruto much listen to them, Let them come to Lima – Peru World Tour hahaha:) dream costs nothing

Liv | 11/5/2009, 5:44 pm EST

Argh! Evanescence! It’s been too long! I wasn’t even at the concert last night and yet I was super excited just knowing that it was taking place at that moment. 2010, come on already! I will die before they release their new album!

liloli | 11/5/2009, 5:49 pm EST

everyone is like, omg there back there back.. they never LEFT!

CheshireTheCat | 11/5/2009, 6:06 pm EST

YAAAAY!
Evanescence is back!

candy | 11/5/2009, 6:32 pm EST

wooow amy is woo my life YEHA!!!

LCjustonce | 11/5/2009, 6:39 pm EST

5 minute sell out? I love you guys! I’m glad all who went got to go! I can’t wait til 2010!

MCT | 11/5/2009, 6:58 pm EST

WHOOT,HOOT !!!
I’m so glad to hear Amy Lee and the band coming on strong.I’ve missed my Evanesence fix.I need to replace my other CD’s and add the NEW one to My library Next year…
I can hardly wait !

Fallen Angel | 11/5/2009, 7:28 pm EST

WOW! I love Evanescence and I love her!! I hope they come to Spain u.u

mizzael | 11/5/2009, 8:33 pm EST

my amy is awesomee like ever!!

Chynna | 11/5/2009, 10:50 pm EST

I almost cried while reading thiss. <3

TacoBoy | 11/5/2009, 11:21 pm EST

awful awful awful

tacos are better than “ev”

shaun | 11/6/2009, 12:58 am EST

I can appreciate their melodies. Evanescence has some tunes I really like, particularly from the first popular album

puggy | 11/6/2009, 4:41 am EST

Goth Emo Kid. We know who you are and your not cool by getting attention………….

But it sounded great. Gotta love living overseas =)

foxy9284 | 11/6/2009, 10:18 am EST

I was there and it was great and I got to meet amy and she is a very nice person

Daniel | 11/6/2009, 3:31 pm EST

So happy that they’re finally back! I’ve watced the videos and the band rocked that night!! I just hope the new music to be more rock than electronic.

Sumaira | 11/6/2009, 3:45 pm EST

It’s definitely a dream come true, I’m so happy that they’re back, i wish i could be there but sadly i live nowhere near N.Y. :( But cant wait for their new album!

Anonymous | 11/6/2009, 4:34 pm EST

jjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjj

Anonymous | 11/6/2009, 4:35 pm EST

süper kadın ya

heathen2002 | 11/6/2009, 5:43 pm EST

wow. can hardly wait..no, really..
Amy needs to get naked, but that is the only good thing about that band. Overproduced shit…

The Open Door | 11/6/2009, 6:44 pm EST

Can’t believe people are saying Evanescence is coming back! They were never gone! Can’t wait to hear their new album!

sasha | 11/6/2009, 8:09 pm EST

i gonna die i could’nt see u amy lee i love u i didnt know that u gonna be there when just was in ny im a big fan of u please come 2 my country dominican repubublic we love u there evanescence the best

brklyn rock | 11/6/2009, 10:28 pm EST

I was lucky enough to be at this show & it was truly incredible. The band was tight, and Amy’s voice was amazing! Can’t wait for their new record next year.

Sid | 11/6/2009, 11:08 pm EST

Just love your voice AMY…will go to the US once only to listen to your song……Love you and waiting for your album

Sid | 11/6/2009, 11:24 pm EST

Will the concert i n brazil be released in a DVD which we can BUY???

Guillaume | 11/7/2009, 4:26 am EST

Great ! Can’t wait for the new album ! :-)

regina | 11/7/2009, 7:27 am EST

it’s very nice job from Eva! the new album will be the best!

Zaid | 11/7/2009, 8:13 am EST

My favourite band is Evanescence and my favourite singer is Amy lee
please I can’t wait alot for the new album

aja | 11/7/2009, 1:42 pm EST

omg evanescence is back im only 11 but i love them. i hav herad all the songs. i soooooooo hav to go to their next concert.

Anna | 11/7/2009, 8:55 pm EST

The music of Evanesense changed the way I look at the world…all I have to say is Welcome Back and keep being incredible!!!!

Anna | 11/7/2009, 8:57 pm EST

wait i changed my mind….they were never gone!

estrella | 11/8/2009, 12:12 pm EST

soy fanàtica de evanescence desde era muy chica ahora ya tengo 20 y he crecido con todas sus canciones dulces y me han inspirado sus temas.. los amo..besos desde venezuela

Aziza | 11/8/2009, 12:39 pm EST

I Love Amy

PB | 11/9/2009, 12:12 am EST

I wanna see some video… please
EV ROCK !!!

Ayabe | 11/9/2009, 3:48 pm EST

“omg evanescence is back im only 11″

Yeah pretty much.

I guess they’re better than Paramore or whatever marginally talented, but female fronted group you wish to substitute. I can’t really tell them apart anymore.

Vic De Zen | 11/9/2009, 4:55 pm EST

It’s good to see them back on stage. I’m looking forward to new material.

t | 11/9/2009, 4:56 pm EST

@Ayabe:

Paramore is miles ahead of Evanescence, you may wanna check them out live before you pass judgment on them and mislabel them as “marginally talented”, idiot. I’m not a huge fan of Evanescence, but can you name any modern female singer that can sing like Amy Lee? Stop being an idiotic snob, and open up your eyes and ears, dumbass.

Anonymous | 11/9/2009, 6:26 pm EST

I love Evanescence to pieces and I’m so excited that Amy is writing again and I can’t wait for the new album!! I have been a huge fan since I was 10. However, I really wish they would admit that the band that they have right now is not Evanescence. It’s simply Amy writing songs then having some dudes play them… But don’t missunderstand me- I LOVE Evanescence and Amy. I love her voice, her music and she’s been my idol since I first heard her, I just wish she hadn’t been such a bitch to the rest of the band…

AJ | 11/9/2009, 9:14 pm EST

i was at the nyc gig. amy and the guys sounded great. i just hope they can get along and coexist to make new tunes for years to come. they’re a young band and have a lot to offer the fans. with all the whispers and whatnot, it always appears as though they were on the verge of implosion. i really hope that’s not the case since they’re amazing at what they do. loved fallen even though it was quite commercial sounding. open door was goos but not as good as fallen as it was way to slow and somber. songs like snow white quenn and like you pretty much always make me hit skip on the cd. aside from that, they’re a kick ass band and i can’t for more in 2010.

Jessica | 11/9/2009, 9:16 pm EST

hmmm I thought I saw more male than female fans. Anyway great review! I can’t wait til they start touring next year.

hattie | 11/10/2009, 8:16 am EST

come UK ! (: <3

Andrei | 11/10/2009, 11:37 am EST

You are the BEST!!!

Amylee | 11/10/2009, 11:38 am EST

Hey lol I am one of Amy lees oldest fans and I saw her in consert in 2004 and trust me I can not wait to see her again!!I mean after all the consert I have ever been to I would have to say she puts on the best!!!!

Danielle | 11/10/2009, 9:01 pm EST

Amy ROCKS! Can’t wait for the return of Evanescence

jacob | 11/11/2009, 1:17 am EST

they should tour with creed. they could call it the “mediocrity tour.”

evelyn (chile) | 11/11/2009, 7:25 pm EST

me encanta este grupo me ayuda cuando estoy triste todos sus temas son con muxo sentimiento los felicito

Me! | 11/11/2009, 9:27 pm EST

so then is evanescence coming back?

nydi | 11/11/2009, 11:24 pm EST

i love this band amy lee your encreadible

nydi | 11/11/2009, 11:25 pm EST

you sing so good i would like to meet you someday

dandelion | 11/12/2009, 4:04 pm EST

@nydi:
It’s incredible, not “encreadible”. Good Lord, where do you people learn to speak English?

Coo Coo for evanescence!!! | 11/12/2009, 6:16 pm EST

I am mad that i missed the secret show but im happy i got to hear that it turned out great, im trying to see if there is a video of the show somewhere though…

Débora | 11/12/2009, 9:26 pm EST

Amy, return to Brazil!!!

brea | 11/13/2009, 5:12 pm EST

goth emo whatever the hell your name is stop ridiculing ev, not everyone who listens to her cuts themself, and her music doesn’t inspire them too, get a life.
on a side note ev is awesome, can’t wait for the new album

TheOnlyOne2103 | 11/14/2009, 8:36 am EST

Amy love ya !!!
Evanescence love ya !!!
We will see us 2010 in Berlin !!!
I hope !!!
Kisses to you and the Boys

The open door | 11/15/2009, 11:20 am EST

Love you evanescence, we want your new CD now!!!

Catherine Hanorah | 11/17/2009, 8:02 pm EST

I love Evanescence, Amy Lee, you are my musical hero!!! Looking forward to the next album, hope you come to Oregon sometime. Good luck with your concert in the south, have fun!!! ♥/katie.r

666 | 11/19/2009, 12:19 am EST

EVANESCENCE METAL ALTERNATIVO

JAAJ GOTICO EMO? JAJA

EMO PARAMORE

METAL ALTERNATIVO
KORN
EVANESCENCE
LINKIN PARK
ETC
SYSTEN OF A DOWM
UNSUN

Where's Ben | 11/19/2009, 4:30 pm EST

How can you say favorite band???
It has not been a band since Ben Moody Left.
It is Amy Lee and whoever.
What a shame.
Love Amy’s voice
Kiss and Make up Amy / Ben

Post A Comment

Caution: Off-topic comments will be deleted

Name:

Comments:



Advertisement

Advertisement