Previous Next Latest

Academy Awards Change Best Original Song Rules

6/29/09, 3:29 pm EST


The Academy Awards recently upped the amount of Best Picture nominees from five films to 10 (Rolling Stone movie critic Peter Travers is still wondering “Why?”), and now the Oscar rule changes have seeped into the Best Original Song category. After this year saw only three songs nominated, including two from Slumdog Millionaire, the Music Branch Executive Committee will now require that only songs that average an 8.25 score — songs are rated from 6 to 10 by Academy members — can be nominated in the category, Billboard.biz reports. If no songs average 8.25, then that Oscar year will not feature a Best Original Song category.

If only one song clears the 8.25 barrier, then the next highest-ranked track will join that song as a nominee, regardless of its score, just so there’s a little suspense on Oscar night. The old Best Original Song category only called for an 8.5 required aggregated score, with a maximum of five and a minimum of three songs in the category each year. However, as the Best Picture category has doubled, that requires more screen time, and the Best Original Song was one of the casualties of the clock. Under the new rules, fewer nominees also means less performances, however the category will still have a five-song maximum if the votes warrant it.

As it stands now, Academy voters will still be shown clips of the song being used in a movie when voting on the category, a practice that has affected songs like Prince’s Happy Feet contribution “Song of the Heart,” Bruce Springsteen’s “The Wrestler” and Eddie Vedder’s Into the Wild track “Guaranteed” — tunes that soundtrack the end credits but lose a lot their meaning when isolated from the rest of the film. All three songs won the Golden Globes’ Best Original Song category, yet none earned even an Oscar nod.

Related Stories:

Travers Take: Oscar Doubles Best Picture Nominees from 5 to 10 — the Question is WHY?
Oscars Snub Springsteen, Celebrate “Slumdog” As Nominations Are Announced
Oscars: Depp and Blanchett Nominated, Vedder and Greenwood Shut Out


Previous Next Latest

Comments

Grippity Groppity Groo | 6/29/2009, 4:43 pm EST

Your blood will be my stew!

In or out of the movie, the song “The Wrestler” blew. But the movie was crackin’.

Black Hole Sun | 6/30/2009, 2:02 pm EST

I agree there aren’t that many film songs worthy of even listening to, let alone being nominated for an Oscar. Back in the 90s, Disney actually pumped out some quality stuff (yeah, I’m not afraid to say it) with Elton John writing a song for The Lion King and Phil Collins for Tarzan, but now they’re all about it Miley Cyrus and the Jonas Brothers. I’ve yet to see which song this year could ever deserve to make the cut.

twitter.com/divalentino | 6/30/2009, 10:56 pm EST

I’m surprised they didn’t just axe the category outright. It just takes valuable time away from the important stuff, like Pilobolus’ pantomimes.

Winnie khumalo | 7/4/2009, 4:04 am EST

Live my life

calmobserver | 10/17/2009, 2:46 pm EST

In Response to Grippity Groppity Groo’s comment: You make a good point…sometimes the two can and should be mutually exclusive or at least analyzed separately…I think the opposite is true for that “2012″ movie…the movie itself is nothing that innovative imho (we have seen countless movies with the same theme played out in different ways)
but the song “Time for Miracles” sung by Adam Lambert deserves a nomination…his vocals are unbelievably good. Check out the song on youtube. TFM FTW. I hope it gets the recognition it deserves. I also agree as to the Disney songs from the 90’s.

Post A Comment

Caution: Off-topic comments will be deleted

Name:

Comments:



Advertisement

Advertisement