Previous Next Latest

Seether Get Their Wham! On, Plus The Worst Heavy ’80s Covers

6/15/09, 5:47 pm EST

Today Seether unleashed the Commodore 64-inspired video for their cover of Wham!’s 1984 ballad “Careless Whisper” (watch it, above). While the video is a strange but somwhat entertaining mix of ’80s nostalgia (dig the California Raisins) and current world crises (the recession and Kim Jong Il), the tune unfortunately puts the band amongst the ranks of countless heavy rockers who have tried to beef up ’80s pop songs and failed — often miserably.

Rock Daily has collected the worst, the songs that completely deviate from everything that made their predecessors noteworthy, like Good Charlotte OD-ing on guitars while playing OMD, System of the Down destroying Berlin and Chris Cornell’s depressing “Billie Jean” (why, David Cook, why?). Click the jump for the all the highlights, including the track that previously held the title of Most Ear-Stabbing Cover of a George Michael Song. Plus, let us know your favorite — or in this case, least favorite — ’80s covers in the comments.

Limp Bizkit – “Faith” (originally by George Michael)

Good Charlotte – “If You Leave” (originally by OMD)

Chris Cornell – “Billie Jean” (originally by Michael Jackson)

System of a Down – “The Metro” (originally by Berlin)

Alien Ant Farm – “Smooth Criminal” (originally by Michael Jackson)

Marilyn Manson – “Sweet Dreams” (originally by the Eurythmics) [Ed. Note: We kind of like this one]

Kelly Osbourne – “Papa Don’t Preach” (originally by Madonna) [Ed. Note: not heavy, but still ...]


Previous Next Latest

Comments

Edge | 6/15/2009, 6:01 pm EST

I think the Manson version of Sweet Dreams is excellent. However the worst would go to Chris Cornell.

Patrick Chewing | 6/15/2009, 6:08 pm EST

Yeah, Greatest American Hero!….forgot all about that cheeseball classic!

Listen To Penny Racer | 6/15/2009, 6:13 pm EST

Proof that you can’t fix what isn’t broken.

However, I do have a soft spot for Thrice’s cover of Real Life’s “Send Me An Angel.” Killer stuff.

the dead rat | 6/15/2009, 6:14 pm EST

man, i love some cornell usually, but that cover truly is ass.

Steel Dragon | 6/15/2009, 6:25 pm EST

I like the Seether cover, and AAF cover is pretty good as well. Better than the crazy man’s original in my opinion, but I can’t stand MJ so I’m probably not the best to ask.

Manson covering Tainted Love and Sweet Dreams were both excellent. Nonpoint’s cover of In the Air Tonight is the best 80’s cover I’ve heard so far

al bundy | 6/15/2009, 7:05 pm EST

I like seether but that cover is absolutely horrible.

The Hater | 6/15/2009, 7:14 pm EST

Worst 80s cover of all time:

Fall Out Boy – ‘Love Will Tear Us Apart’.

Nauseating!

Aaron D. | 6/15/2009, 7:43 pm EST

The worst 80’s cover is Coal Chamber’s version of “Shock the Monkey.” I dig the Seether song, by the way.

Schultz | 6/15/2009, 8:33 pm EST

Manson’s version of DM’s Personal Jesus is pretty sick too, although I like his Tainted Love cover better. Cornell’s version of Billie Jean is pretty sick in my book. I don’t care what the popular vote sez…

thezero | 6/15/2009, 8:38 pm EST

seether has taken the cake on this one… retarded… although the killers doing shadowplay by joy division made me nearly vomit…

Ed | 6/15/2009, 9:00 pm EST

ummm yeah…rolling stone missed the mark on this one. the billie jean, smooth criminal, Manson and SOAD covers were all actually pretty good to very good. sheesh…

Jane | 6/15/2009, 10:57 pm EST

I wanna hear Metallica do a cover of Cyndi Lauper’s “Girls Just Wanna Have Fun”. That would be so awesome…

jaad | 6/15/2009, 11:03 pm EST

Seether is amazing shaun morgan is god…fuck rolling stone

DeVoN | 6/15/2009, 11:20 pm EST

wow all of these SUCK. im sorry but they do. the AAF’s cover of Smoothe Criminal is kind of terrifying, so is Billie Jean. Poor Micheal Jackson. These are all pretty sad. I’m glas RS captured these poorly done covers.

devon, 13

thezero | 6/16/2009, 4:13 am EST

system of a down’s version of the metro was very well done…

ROLLING STONE DREAMS | 6/16/2009, 7:16 am EST

Man, you got to love it!
Join the Rolling Stone Dreams International social Netwok!
Just Google “ROLLING STONE DREAMS” See lots of 8’s fun!
-Kidkel69-
ALL~MOST FAMOUS VIDEO REVIEW MAGAZINE
Yes, I’m still campaigning for the cover!

Hope7887 | 6/16/2009, 8:00 am EST

Come on Rolling Stone! Marilyn Manson Sweet Dreams is bad? What are you talking about. Manson did a great cover of that song. Take that off the list.

yeahh | 6/16/2009, 10:14 am EST

This doesn’t really make any sense. You’re judging covers of songs that started out as shite, with the exception of smooth criminal. Yes I’m serious. Child molester or not, Michael Jackson is a funky motherfucker.

John | 6/16/2009, 11:32 am EST

Ahh, Sheryl Crowes cover of Guns N’ Roses – Sweet Child O’ Mine should of been on this list.

matt from farmers branch | 6/16/2009, 11:44 am EST

Cool System of a Down song. Never heard it before.

That new Seether song is growing on me. Why am i the only one of my friends that cares for Seether?? Are they that bad and i just can’t see it??

WTF? | 6/16/2009, 12:52 pm EST

Erm, what the fuck is Marilyn Manson’s version of Sweet Dreams doing on this list? Are you guys insane? Most people i know, from around the world, recognize first the MM cover and then they remember it was cover – hint, hint, they ALL love the MM version and its a classic

Bob | 6/16/2009, 2:35 pm EST

Save Ferris’s version of Come on Eileen deserves metion. As does Nonpoint’s In The Air Tonight. Awful.

And even though it’s not 80’s, A Perfect Circle’s Imagine by John Lennon is blasphemy.

amber | 6/16/2009, 2:45 pm EST

i thought mansons cover was great and i love it

JP | 6/16/2009, 3:05 pm EST

Is it just me, or do people like Marilyn Manson’s covers more for the concept of making a pop song with dark lyrics heavier than the original, than they like the actual performance of his covers. I like the concept, but I realize that Marilyn Manson isn’t talented enough to pull it off!

I think you are too hard on Seether. It’s not best cover song of all time. It’s not that bad either. Of course, “Careless Whisper” is a pretty cheesy song to begin with. The only version of it I heard that was actually listenable was by Gossip last year on their live album.

Couple of favorite 80’s cover I can think of right now that I like are: Alien Ant Farm “Smooth Criminal”, Foo Fighters “Darling Nikki”, and Keane “With Or Without You”.

Ann | 6/16/2009, 3:46 pm EST

Seether’s cover is interesting…

StrummerJones | 6/16/2009, 6:03 pm EST

Hey, look! A Marilyn Manson fan who undervalues Eurythmics!

rick | 6/16/2009, 9:26 pm EST

what the hell? mansons sweet dreams is awesome, gets loads of air play and is often on tv so id image im not the only one who thinks so. didnt care much for his Personal Jesus though

Anonymous | 6/17/2009, 12:43 am EST

Oh come on the Billie Jean cover was awesome as was Seether’s version of Careless Whisper.

Anonymous | 6/17/2009, 4:19 am EST

system of a down’s versions sucks. i couldn’t even get thru past 15 secs. geez what a way to murder an 80s anthem

STARkGAZING | 6/17/2009, 11:05 am EST

Okay, i’m not on uber Marilyn Manson fan, because he kind of freaks me out, however, he does great covers in my opinion. I love the Sweet Dreams one, its one of my favorites of his!

And I’ve heard people like Alien Ant Farm’s Smooth Criminal. I like the original better, but its not so bad.

Most 80’s music is bad anyways. hah.

Fail | 6/17/2009, 12:27 pm EST

This list is crap. The MM cover of Sweet Dreams is awesome

SimonCowbell | 6/17/2009, 10:21 pm EST

Disturbed’s version of “Land of Confusion” by Genesis rocks mighty!

doink | 6/18/2009, 11:29 am EST

The Manson cover is one of the worst covers ever.

Anonymous | 7/9/2009, 6:45 am EST

i can think of two worst covers ive hread latey this moment covering im borken by pantera and fall out boy doing walk

Anonymous | 7/9/2009, 6:45 am EST

i can think of two worst covers ive hread latey this moment covering im borken by pantera and fall out boy doing walk

Iycbuqwi | 7/13/2009, 11:17 pm EST

zJ38cK

Post A Comment

Caution: Off-topic comments will be deleted

Name:

Comments:



Advertisement

Advertisement