Previous Next Latest

“American Idol” Finds One Diamond in a Lot of Rough Florida Auditions

1/28/09, 11:07 am EST

Photo:Becker/FOX

If hosting American Idol auditions in Jacksonville, Florida, is enough of an excuse for the show to run vintage footage of be-fro’d Randy Jackson slapping his bass with Journey while “Don’t Stop Believin’ ” plays, we’re fine with that. There was so little talent in the Sunshine State, Paula Abdul and Kara DioGuardi stooped to fake-kissing during an audition to drum up a little drama. If they wanted real fireworks they could have played Vampire Weekend’s “Cape Cod Kwassa Kwassa” a little longer (it popped up as segue music) and asked indie rockers whether that meant the New York band has sold out. Well, have they?

The judges handed out a scant 16 yellow passes to Hollywood Week. Here’s a quick rundown:

Ones to Watch:

• The judges send away DioGuardi fan Ann Marie Boskovitch and tell her to come back “as a different person.” Somehow makeup and new shoes make her version of Colbie Caillat’s dry “Bubbly” awesome. (Hint: she was also awesome before the bogus makeover.)

• Repeat auditioner T.K. Hash riffs all over (and botches the lyrics on) “Imagine,” but it’s soulful enough to sell. The judges say it’s okay to let a great melody be — hey, how come nobody told David Archuleta he was over-riffing on John Lennon’s masterpiece?

Meh:

• Julissa Veloz wants to rep for the Latinas. The show undermines her efforts by blasting “Hot Hot Hot” when she gets her golden ticket. That helps.

• Joshua Ulloa likes it when people compare him to Justin Guarini.

• Sharon Wilbur’s shitzu, Sasha (Fierce?) sat on Simon’s lap while she gulped Karen Carpenter’s “Superstar.”

• Jasmine Murray is “cute,” “commercial” and willing to nasally sing Fergie’s “Big Girls Don’t Cry.”

Ones to Wipe From Your Memory With Bleach:

Beardo physics student George Ramirez could be a member of Fleet Foxes. Or a bobblehead.

• Naomi Sykes’ first mistake: comparing herself to Mariah Carey (”So you’re a talented loony,” Simon says. Zing!). Second mistake: Having her friend sit on Randy’s lap (which leads to an awkward lap-a-thon that puts Ryan Seacrest on Kara DioGuardi). Third mistake: singing Minnie Riperton’s “Loving You,” a song that shouldn’t be sung, ever.

Thanks for the Memories:

• Michael Perrelli never leaves the house without his guitar or Bret Michaels’ bandanna. He sings Third Eye Blind’s “Jumper” sans six-string and gets the boot, then brushes off his consoling mom with a snotty “Don’t touch me.” That’s the part of this that embarrasses you?

Related Stories:

American Idol Finds a Major-Labe Burnout, Kentucky Derby Hats at Louisville Auditions
American Idol Finds Little Talent in San Fran
American Idol Finds Soulful Singers in David Cook’s Hometown
American Idol Returns With New Judge DioGuardi, Zen Mantra, Cavalcade of Meh Singers


Previous Next Latest

Comments

Shereen | 1/28/2009, 11:25 am EST

But the thing is, David Archuleta sang Imagine in his own way. The problem with that one auditioner was that he was trying to sing it like David Archuleta…and if you’re gonna do that, you better do it right, lol.

Vagabond | 1/28/2009, 12:10 pm EST

David Archuleta stayed on the show because he was so cute…his singing was only dressed-up screaming…always going for the ratings…American Idol is fiction

TJ | 1/28/2009, 12:59 pm EST

The contestants on American Idol can’t win. Either the judges are telling them to “Make it their own” and stop trying to imulate the original recording artist, or their blasting them for changing a perfect arrangement! Go figure!!!!

lb | 1/28/2009, 1:02 pm EST

Michael Perrelli’s mother should beat him with his guitar. What a brat.
Go cry, emo-Bret.

808080 | 1/28/2009, 1:25 pm EST

Just a reminder to people that American Idol is evil and soulless and creating a generation of people with no taste. You would be more stimulated just staring at the sky.

Forget American Idol!

DJ | 1/28/2009, 4:14 pm EST

I agree with TJ, they want to contestants to make the song their own, but when do they od they shit all over them like they did with TK Hash.

I also agree with the writer of this article, no one said anything to David Archeluta oversinging a song, but of course they never gave any constructive criticism at all during his entire time on the show. Why do watch this show again?

Post A Comment

Caution: Off-topic comments will be deleted

Name:

Comments:



Advertisement

Advertisement