Previous Next Latest

“American Idol” Returns With New Judge DioGuardi, Zen Mantra, Cavalcade of Meh Singers

1/14/09, 10:05 am EST

Photo: Becker/FOX

In case your AT&T phone didn’t remind you, last night marked the premiere of American Idol’s eighth season. Simon, Randy and Paula, plus new judge Kara DioGuardi, hit up Phoenix, Arizona, for the first auditions, but the episode opened with a cheesy montage that aimed to convey the majesty of the show by sprinkling in shots of the American landscape (the upshot: footage of David Hasselhoff and Elliott Yamin’s adorable mom) as Ryan Seacrest intoned the show’s zen new mantra: “The beauty of Idol is the journey itself.” Is that a trip to product-placement heaven? But we won’t squabble with producers’ decision to run this awesome clip of tweens blowing out at David Archuleta’s defeat last season, or to include more substantive auditions and fewer wackos.

Of the 10,000 people who tried out in Phoenix, 27 received passes to Hollywood Week. Here’s a quick rundown:

Ones to Watch:

• Deanna Brown, the subtle blonde with a country drawl who killed on “(Sittin’ on) The Dock of the Bay.”

• Horror-movie-maker Cody Shelton — because he’s the Danny Noriega of Season Eight and even comes with his own Ashley Ferl.

• Emily Hughes, the pink-haired “Barracuda”-snarling frontwoman who’s about to pull a Constantine Maroulis and ditch her bandmates for the show.

• Stevie Wright, who’s named for Stevie Nicks, and swung a sultry version of Etta James’ “At Last.”

• Blind Scott MacIntyre who nailed Billy Joel’s “And So It Goes” and then had this awkward exchange with Seacrest: “We’ll see how it goes.” … “We’ll see you in Hollywood.”

Meh:

• Bikini-clad Katrina Darrell is obviously taking her wardrobe cues from Rock of Love’s Megan, and the male panelists likey. She so enraged DioGuardi, the judge exclaimed, “Hold on a minute, bitch.” (As Tina Fey would say, “cat sound!”) Golden ticket in hand, Darrell kissed Seacrest to the strains of “I Kissed a Girl.” Okay, we get it, Ryan is a lesbian.

• Nice guy J.B. Ahfua and do-gooder Arianna Afsar, who both scored trips to Hollywood but didn’t have the wow factor.

• Michael Sarver, the oil-rig roughneck who can croon.

Ones to Wipe From Your Memory With Bleach:

• Cubicle worker (and self-proclaimed “rock star in a box”) Randy Madden, who wept pre-audition, during his audition and, yes, post-audition. Simon called his off-key “Livin’ on a Prayer” “wimpy.”

• Michael Gurr, who was super-nervous for good reason: his constipated murmur was so bad he required medical attention after he sang.

Thanks for the Memories:

• Lea Marie Golde described herself as Kara DioGuardi’s biggest fan and her music as a cross between Hilary Duff and Madonna. Her nasal rendition of Cascada’s “Every Time We Touch” was a campy delight.

• Brianna Quijada let her inner monologue out (”Oh my God, I’m hugging Paula Abdul, y’all!”) after scoring a yes for singing “Let’s Hear it for the Boy.”

• Alex Wagner-Trugman taught himself to sing whilst in a closet. Which led Simon to the season’s inaugural uncomfortable gay comment: “You just came out of the closet?” Okay, we get it, Ryan Seacrest is a lesbian!

• “I’m 22 years old, I’m from Phoenix, Arizona, and I’m 22 years old.” Thus spoke low-voiced Elijah Scarlett.


Previous Next Latest

Comments

Lynn | 5/22/2009, 4:19 am EST

You idol junkies need to give it a rest.
Bitch and moan how you hate the new judge. She won’t get canned bc of it. You’re not one of the producers. So what she’s made up like Simon. All female judges can’t always be happy and drugged up a la paula.
Plus who cares if she bitches at bikini girl? Who the he’ll auditions in a friggen bikini?! Obviously someone in dire need of attention. The season is done now. Now go cry in your room and over your ai posters.

Kara hater | 4/15/2009, 11:10 pm EST

I agree 100% the new judge hasn’t done anything 4the show but ruin it. There were funnyer moments last year

Man I get annoyed with her she better go by next season

alli | 3/31/2009, 8:44 pm EST

The new just is horrible. I’ve been watching the show since the beginning but I have to say this may be my last if this judge sticks around. She goes on and on with the negative crap and acts like she has something to prove. Paula looks so sad. Well I am too….

joypri | 3/26/2009, 8:56 pm EST

Get rid of this new JUDGE.She is an idot..ruins the show.Please do not bring her back another season.She does not know when to shut up.Has no idea what she is doing.What a disaster!!!!I am thrilled to see the mojority agrees with me and hope the producer reads this

Idol Chatter | 3/17/2009, 8:14 pm EST

The new judge is like Paula, but without the over medication spontaneity, so totally boring, and probably brought in to replace PA when she falls off the Kodak stage dancing…get rid of them both and get Carole King or Aretha…someone with chops, dawg

Lisa in CA | 3/10/2009, 11:16 pm EST

Can’t stand the new judge DiG-who? She is annoying and drags her words out. When its her turn to talk I change the channel. She really needs to go. There’s no need to change from the original 3.

Anonymous | 3/10/2009, 8:36 pm EST

The new judge needs to go!!!!! I think three was enough, if they need three——get someone else. This one just does not fit the spot. NMB viewer

Ano | 3/6/2009, 7:41 am EST

The new judge needs to go go go and fast. Idols will lose its once worldwide audience. She really blows especially when it comes to hotchicks.

SA-Durbs

Rose | 3/6/2009, 7:37 am EST

Honestly, she really sucks. Shes a mean bitch who thinks shes the world. Especially when she tried to sing off with bikini girl.I would prefer the old clan back…

J Youngblood | 3/5/2009, 4:10 pm EST

The new judge is horrible. Everything about her is cringeworthy. Simon can’t stand her and she’s adds nothing of value to the show.
Idol, please get rid of her by next season. She blows.

rockme | 3/3/2009, 2:13 pm EST

The new judge is a pop songwriter.
Certainly not the kind of music I like. But others apparently do and
have paid for her music. You can
read her bio on Wikipedia.

Nomy | 2/25/2009, 9:33 pm EST

The bitchy new judge doesn’t know a thing about ’singing’. i wonder what she did to secure a place on the show.

Melissa | 2/25/2009, 5:48 pm EST

I have watched the show all 8 seasons, and I can not stand to watch the show now because of the new judge. She drives me crazy and I think it was a HUGE mistake to bring on another person. It changed the chemistry of the original 3, who were great by the way, without Kara. Please go back to Paula, Simon and Randy next season.

rockme | 2/12/2009, 10:50 pm EST

I watched AI the past 3 three years. I’m fed up. I am not watching this year, and am especially glad because of this new
judge. I read her background,
and I don’t get a good feeling.
I never really liked Paula. They
should have replaced her instead
of adding another.

Anonymous | 2/11/2009, 4:00 am EST

The new judge is great. Give her a chance. At least she has the guts to be honest.

kiki | 1/28/2009, 5:43 pm EST

i cannot stand the new idol judge. what is she there for but to ruin the chemistry that simon,paula & randy have. she is so unecessary for the show and her personality sucks.

idol | 1/23/2009, 2:13 am EST

i can’t believe the way new judge tried to be cool by making a dull, cruel joke and made the girl cry… she thought that she was funny but it turned out that it was a stupid comment. I really feel sorry for the girl. Poor girl! American Idol, how could you let such person being a judge when her credibility and personality not qualified for the job? what are you guys thinking bringing her in the show… She totally ruined the show…………

idol | 1/23/2009, 2:12 am EST

i can’t believe the way new judge tried to be cool by making a dull, cruel joke and made the girl cry… she thought that she was funny but it turned out that it was a stupid comment. I really feel sorry for the girl. Poor girl! American Idol, how could you let such person being a judge when her credibility and personality not qualified for the job? what are you guys thinking bringing her in the show… She totally ruined the show…………

Voice4idol | 1/23/2009, 2:01 am EST

I am a big fan of American Idol since day one, as a loyal fan, let me honestly suggest that if you want to attract more audiences, please fire the new judge, her being there does not make a bit difference. On the contrary, it shows jealousy, showing-off her singing and being a be-atch. ALl my friends hated her and they kinda boycott the show until the new judge gone. She has not made any remarkable comments since day 1 of this season, all she did was copying what other judges commented on. Big mistake to hire this judge. I am so worried that there will be a huge number of fans will be rejecting the show because of her so please act A.S.A.P

idol fan | 1/19/2009, 11:43 pm EST

The new judge is such a mistake. Even Paula looks like she doesn’t want to get too close to her. The girls have to act like they’re friends or this will never work..no chemistry at all. What’s the point anyway and who wants to sit thru 4 opinions? Why, Why? And she is so plain, scraggly hair and all.

muse | 1/19/2009, 1:40 am EST

Could someone please tell me what the country-rock song in the middle was that the large studio audience sang along to part of? Thanks!

TaTas | 1/16/2009, 6:11 pm EST

I hope someone spikes Paula’s drink otherwise it will be one long boring a$$ season.

TaTas | 1/16/2009, 6:11 pm EST

I hope someone spikes Paula’s drink otherwise it will be one long boring a$$ season.

Anonymous | 1/16/2009, 5:59 pm EST

I hate the new no personality douchey judge. She actually makes Paula likeable. Im no fan of Paula but you realize that she is the wacky compassionate component of the show and it needs it.

pAulAizzaJunkie | 1/16/2009, 2:41 pm EST

I LOVE to HATE idol, BUT i gotta say that I’m (Mc)Lovin the yet unexplored (on tv anyway) tension between simon and this new broad. He HATES when she opens her mouth. ITS SOO OBVIOUS! And I cant wait to see he Xplode and call ‘er a c*nt! Out singing a Bikini “chick”?? Rookie mistake. She took the bait and ACTUALLY tried to “outshine” an ASU sperm recepticle. I am, however, glad that the show has someone that WANTS TO BE VICIOUS! I mean, WHOs that old grey haired guy that “won” a few yrs ago??? BAD idol! Bad!!! No! You poop on the newspaper! BAD IDOL!!!

Me | 1/15/2009, 10:23 pm EST

I totally agree with Angie about Andrew!! What’s his last name, anyone know?

Darcy | 1/15/2009, 3:28 pm EST

As a point of education, using the word “see” in a conversation with a blind person is not awkward. I’m blind as well, and use “see” and “watch TV” etc. all the time. Just part of the language. “See you later” really means “meet up with you later’ more than “I’ll cast my gaze upon you later.” i didn’t see this episode and rarely watch idol, but wanted to clear that one up.

Angie | 1/15/2009, 3:09 pm EST

I think the guy Andrew that came with his cheerleaders should have went through last night 1/14 from Kansas, however; he doesn’t need the cheerleaders. He deserves another chance.

lisa | 1/14/2009, 10:05 pm EST

I hate the new judge. She makes things super boring and I love the original 3 judges when it is just them. They have their bantering and jokes but with the new judge sitting smack in between Randy and Paula…dullsville AND she called one of the contestants a BITCH!! Paula would never do that. What a jealous hag.

Angie | 1/14/2009, 7:50 pm EST

Oh Poo! When I got this in my google hits email I thought it was going to be about the best AI Contestant ever - CONSTANTINE MAROULIS.
I love Constantine and have followed his career ever since day 1.
There will never be another Constantine.

katiedee | 1/14/2009, 4:52 pm EST

Let me start off by saying that the blind guy doing big eyes kind of freaks me out, a lot. I know he is blind but the fact that he sang a song about what he had seen was really quite hilarious. Yes this is mean, but kind of ironically funny.

The new judge hasn’t gotten a feel for things yet so give her a break. I know she isn’t one of the three original musketeers BUT apparantly she knows what shes doing or they wouldn’t have hired her. I know she was a total jerk to the bikini girl but what do you expect? Bikini girl just wanted attention and they gave it to her.

Besides all the drama the rocker girl with pink hair is AMAZING and I think she will be a different voice that does really well. And The roughneck seems like such a genuinely nice guy so I hope he goes far also.

Marc | 1/14/2009, 3:06 pm EST

I’m not a big fan of the show, but watched with my girlfriend last night. The chick in the bikini was good, not great, but Paula & the new judge just came off as two catty bitches.

new judge | 1/14/2009, 2:49 pm EST

what the hell was the new judge doing with the bikini girl? she came off as a total beotch.

yeah, we know you can sing, you’re a professional… sit down and judge like you are paid to do.

Anonymous | 1/14/2009, 2:17 pm EST

New judge ruins everything. There was chemistry and teasing with 3 judges but new judge looks like misfit.

Anonymous | 1/14/2009, 1:11 pm EST

anybody else see Seacrest go for the high-five with the blind guy after he got his ticket? awesome.

Idolchick | 1/14/2009, 1:08 pm EST

I hate the new judge. Especially when it came to her “sing-off” with bikini girl. That judge belongs on the Flavor of Love or something. None of the other judges would have done that. She is totally not right for Idol. Just some jealous, not-hot, not-famous, bitter, middle-aged woman.

Anonymous | 1/14/2009, 11:37 am EST

VoteForTheWorst (dot com) is the first, and still the best Idol mocking site…

alexis-sunshine | 1/14/2009, 10:47 am EST

This was the most boring season opener EVER. No water cooler moments and nothing to talk about. I just found a site called WE HATE IDOL (dot com) and it sums it all up nicely. I’d recommend it for a laugh!
-Alexis in PA

Post A Comment

Caution: Off-topic comments will be deleted

Name:

Comments:



Advertisement

Advertisement