Previous Next Latest

Book Review: The Untold Stories Of John Lennon’s Epic Life

10/22/08, 2:43 pm EST

Photo: Daniau/AFP/Getty

According to Philip Norman’s new biography, John Lennon: The Life, the teenage Lennon occasionally napped with his mother, Julia, and the accidental touch of her breast one time triggered longings in him to have sex with her — longings, Lennon believed, that Julia might have been willing to satisfy. The “truth” of the story may be more psychological than literal — who knows what Julia would have done? — but it deepens our understanding of a complex artist and man.

That’s true of The Life in general. Norman is the author of the 1981 Beatles biography Shout!, and knows their world well. So much has been written about the Beatles, however, that this book, at 851 pages, treads some well-worn paths. But if the book lacks blockbuster revelations, it sharpens what we know about Lennon at just about every turn.

Reporting is Norman’s strength, and Yoko Ono gave the author unprecedented access — discussing, among other things, the ups and downs of their own sex life. His rendering of Lennon’s years in Liverpool is similarly nuanced. Extensive interviews with Lennon’s friends and relatives cause him to view Lennon’s father, typically seen as a ne’er-do-well who abandoned his son, in a softer light. He reveals Julia’s sister, Mimi, who raised John from boyhood, to have been a virgin throughout her marriage to John’s uncle — a suggestive idea, given her lifelong devotion to John.

Norman is no critic, so Lennon’s music isn’t discussed in great detail. The book is, after all, subtitled The Life, and Norman sticks to the task he set for himself. But he pushes beyond the clichés in exploring how the books and poems Lennon loved as a child re-emerged in both his songs and his prose. And he cracks the mystery of the affair Lennon admitted writing about in “Norwegian Wood” — turns out it was likely the wife of one of his friends. How important is all that? Devotees will relish the new information, while casual readers will find a familiar story told more truly than ever before.

Lennon Lives Forever

The Immortals: John Lennon

Photos: John Lennon Through the Years


Previous Next Latest

Comments

johnnyb | 10/22/2008, 3:17 pm EST

lennon is still the greatest songwriter ever!

fp | 10/22/2008, 4:58 pm EST

these vultures feeding on the bones of a dead artist…shameful. Lennon, for me anyway, spoke to me with love and I am not going to let this bloodsucker change the way I feel …..shame.

=] | 10/22/2008, 8:14 pm EST

This sounds dumb. I could of wrote this book and no one could of said im wronge cus hes dead. its one of those book where if someone is dead everyone can argue but he cant becuas hes dead. R.I.P John even if this is true your still my favorite No one beats you or the beatles

=] | 10/22/2008, 8:14 pm EST

This sounds dumb. I could of wrote this book and no one could of said im wrong cus hes dead. its one of those book where if someone is dead everyone can argue but he cant becuas hes dead. R.I.P John even if this is true your still my favorite No one beats you or the beatles

auramac | 10/23/2008, 1:05 am EST

I’m wondering if Yoko and Sean approve of this book since cooperating with the author.

David Shaw | 10/23/2008, 4:19 pm EST

I was disappointed to see that three quarters of the book is up to 1970, whereas the period that’s not been well covered (the solo career) is rushed through. I don’t know why any music fan would consider anything Philip Norman writes to be serious after “Shout” – vastly inferior to Hunter Davies definitive book. Even Paul McCartney calls Norman’s effort “Shite”….

v- | 10/24/2008, 10:11 am EST

Lennon – my favorite Beatle.

Anonymous | 10/24/2008, 11:54 am EST

Now that I’m much older and spent many more years dwelling on Miles,Coltrane,Joni,Fagen, Metheney etc., It amazes me how the three songwriting Beatles came up with such original, shocking and sometimes beautiful music, when you consider their lack of formal education and training.
Lennon’s #9 Dream, A Day In A Life, One Day At A Time and Imagine; McCartney’s Waterfalls, Maybe I’m Amazed, The Long and Winding Road; Harrison’s Learning How To Love You, Something and You’re Love is Forever. Pure Genius! They’re ability as musicians is pretty ordinary by today’s standards, but together, they played like minimalist masters. Lennon was a charismatic beautiful adult child.

getthedoggie | 10/24/2008, 3:43 pm EST

I agree .. some Beatle ‘biographers’ make their living solely on picking at the carcass. What they don’t rehash, they fabricate. Give it up already…. from a lifelong Beatles/Lennon fan

Philippines | 10/25/2008, 12:33 pm EST

Philip Norman might be fabricating story of the great John to make money out of it, He’s a big shit. Lennon still the greatest musician ever.

Joe | 10/25/2008, 2:19 pm EST

If Lennon wanted his mommy I dont see a problem with that. Dysfunction=beautiful songs.

Kliff | 10/26/2008, 4:33 pm EST

My favorite book about Lennon was written by Mae Pang.

KellyR | 10/26/2008, 6:10 pm EST

Just listened to Lennons definitive (best of) CD the other day. Wow…a reminder of his beauty and genius.

former roller | 10/28/2008, 2:09 pm EST

Creepy review for what promises to be a creepy book. Of course Yoko plays up her and Lennon’s sex life. That’s the only real connection she had to the Beatles teat. Yuck.

NAMELESS!!! | 11/1/2008, 10:50 am EST

I don’t know weather or not John wanted to make love to his mother, but I am surly positive that he had many things to hide. Someone that brilliant is definitely not made of all peaches and cream. I bet, sexually, he was a really kinky guy. I mean, he was getting it on with Yoko.

ziggysawdust | 11/4/2008, 8:30 pm EST

The basic fact is that ‘Norman’ is saying nothing new, infact if Goldman was still alive he could probably sue ‘Norman’ for plagiarism! I see nothing here that every muck raking anti-Lennon critic has been saying since Lennon died. If Lennon was alive they would be too afraid to say it because Lennon’s pen was mightier than anything a two-bit sensationalist could muster. If I read this book and find even one new piece of information, I’ll retract everything I said. Goldman said that Lennon was a heroin addled, reclusive Brian Wilson style wreck before his death, and went so far to say that if Lennon was in better shape physically, he would have survived the bullets! Come on people. This man was human, and humans make mistakes. Lennon would be the first to acknowledge that, and think for a moment, what the world would be like if John Lennon had not given us twenty years of poignant, tuneful, soulful and beautiful songs. Do not listen to imbeciles that just want to make a buck re-hashing old, old misinformation and speculation. Read Cynthia Lennon’s book or May pang’s book ‘Loving John’, even Fred Seaman’s very anti Lennon books, at least Seaman was a trusted member of John’s inner circle for three years up until his death. These are books written by people who were there, not people who, in 2008, want to buy a mansion, Porsche and litter of poodles by trashing the greatest songwriter of the 20th Century.

Bennett | 11/7/2008, 10:45 am EST

I agree with Kliff (above). I’ve read most of the Lennon bios, and I just bought this one, and
May Pang’s was the best.

GT | 11/8/2008, 12:38 pm EST

Lennon F*cked more broads than all his biographers could wish for. I have a feeling that some of them never laid down with a women and thats the obsession of trying to paint him as a bi-sexual bohemian. They are in love with the idea of having him in there club and lets not forget, it SELLS Books!

Edith | 12/11/2008, 3:33 pm EST

He never denied that he was weird. Yet what he is is what had made him brilliant. I love his carefree and peaceful style. He is truly eccentric.

Post A Comment

Caution: Off-topic comments will be deleted

Name:

Comments:



Advertisement

Advertisement