…or MTV could go back to showing real musicians playing real instruments.

They TRIED that, remember?

The most recent show with real musicians playing real instruments was a songwriting competition hosted by the highlight-happy Ryan Cabrera!

Real musicians playing real guitars
and playing original music? Now thats a concept.

Well, ultimately, the advertising dollars determine the best concepts!

Yeah, lets let corporations like Lehman Brothers, Freddie Mae, AIG,Morgan Stanley,determine what the best concept is. They know the scoop of real rock n roll.Kind of like cheering on someone who lip synchs.

Haha, I wonder what the “Ultimate Rock Band Experience” is.

I was there it was great!!!!!! JERK RAGS WON!!!!!! It was the coolest show I’ve ever seen!!!!!! Any one now when it airs? GO JERK RAGS!!!!!!!! I totally voted for them!!!!!

I was there it was great!!!!!! JERK RAGS WON!!!!!! It was the coolest show I’ve ever seen!!!!!! Any one now when it airs? GO JERK RAGS!!!!!!!! I totally voted for them!!!!!

JERK RAGS WON!!!! I was in the Audience it was soooo cool!
PEACE OUT!!!!!!!!!!!!

Obviously you weren’t there Joe Schmoe. Jerk Rags were one of the first to get voted off. Poor Mans Process won, and Scared Puppy got second. In my opinion, Scared Puppy should have won, but Poormans Process had people in the paid audience voting for them. That drummer from Scared Puppy completely rocked it.

Well it was a joke competition anyway, the band that won it had the level set at easy, and the band that came in second was on expert…. should at least take that into consideration, did you see the lead guitars screen!!! those buttons were flying down the screen… wrong band won….as usual for these types of shows…. doesnt matter how you play, just how many fans you bring along with you…

Scared Puppy should have won. The lead singer was soooooo cute!

Were any of you REALLY there? Scared Puppy AND Poor Man’s Process BOTH played on HARD. I know guys from both of the bands and had you been there to see the full performance (not just the edited version) you would have gotten to see the awesome choreography that put Poor Man’s Process over the top and heard the crowd’s REAL reaction, not the one that they PRE RECORDED so that you could actually hear PMP (thats how loud the crowd got). Get your facts straight before you start posting things you OBVIOUSLY weren’t even there for. And for your information the bands were only allowed 5 guests per person who were NOT allowed to vote for ANY band.

A Rockband competition is quite possibly the worst thing I’ve ever heard. Doesn’t MTV stand for music television? News Flash: Pushing buttons on a plastic guitar and having your eyes dilate at the colors on the screen isn’t musical talent. Rockband is a GAME. How about, oh, I don’t know, a REAL music competition. Y’know, with actual instruments? No?

Rockband as a game is cool and a fun way to past time. A competition for it broadcasted on television? Not so much.

“Rockband” as far as a video game is ok, I guess as long as people don’t confuse it with the real fuckin’ deal!! MTV should be renamed GTV or VGTV. Better yet, JTV for “joke television!”

scared puppies were the best

scared puppies were the best