Coachella Day Three: Roger Waters, My Morning Jacket and Justice Send Revelers Home Happy

4/28/08, 11:40 am EST

There was no moon in the Coachella sky as Roger Waters stepped onstage for the final headline set of the festival on Sunday, bringing his own airborne props, exploding fireballs and the elegant, mind-expanding music of Pink Floyd. Embedded in Waters’ set was Floyd’s entire 1973 album Dark Side of the Moon, still one the best-selling albums ever, with songs of madness, hope and outrage.

At 64, Waters may have been an unexpected choice to headline a festival with roots in the alternative nation, but Floyd’s soaring waves of forward-looking sounds have been echoed in different ways by the likes of Radiohead and Massive Attack, both Coachella alums. And as huge clouds of stage-fog drifted across a field packed with festival-goers, Waters strummed an acoustic guitar for “Set the Controls for the Heart of the Sun,” a song from Floyd’s earliest days, accompanied by old black and white footage of the band wandering an English beach. The tune marked the beginning of a major theme of the evening: the genius and tragic breakdown of founding Floyd leader Syd Barrett, who died in 2006 after spending three decades fading into drug-damage and madness.

During “Shine On You Crazy Diamond,” blurry psychedelic images of Barrett appeared behind Waters as he wailed, “You were caught in the crossfire of childhood and stardom . . . come on you stranger, you legend, you martyr, and shine.” Waters turned “Wish You Were Here” into a British folk ballad, sitting with a guitar, his vocals clenched and deeply felt. The dreamy “Brain Damage” had Waters singing softly “the lunatic is on the grass . . . There’s someone in my head and it’s not me” as the image of multicolored pills tumbled across the big screen.

Waters’ other main obsession had a geopolitical bent, emerging on “Mother” (from 1979’s The Wall), asking “Mother do you think they’ll drop the bomb? . . . Mother should I trust the president?” to a roar from the crowd before stepping back and mouthing the words “No fucking way!” He spoke of a Lebanese family that once took him in as a young traveler, leading into “Leaving Beirut,” an Internet-only solo release in response to the invasion of Iraq. And he did two songs from his final album with Pink Floyd, 1983’s underrated The Final Cut, on which he railed against the foreign policies of that moment: Reagan, Thatcher, a war in the Falkland Islands, nukes everywhere.

Perfected after a week of rehearsals at the Forum arena in Los Angeles, all of it was matched with the sort of special effects and spectacular images Waters and Pink Floyd are known, like the giant inflatable pig covered in graffiti (”Don’t be led to slaughter”) that floated above the crowd during “Sheep” to explosive sparks of electric guitar by Dave Kilminster before being allowed to break free as spotlights crisscrossed the sky. Waters’ night ended with songs from The Wall, with fiery virtuosic soloing by violinist Lili Haydn taking over Gilmour’s original leads on “Comfortably Numb.” During “Run Like Hell,” a pair of dudes in baggy shorts responded on the grass with a lengthy interpretative dance — falling to one knee, finger pointed in the air, stepping forward and back, bowing and swinging their hips — a routine no doubt practiced back home between multiple bongloads.

Earlier, My Morning Jacket arrived just in time for sunset and were ready to rock, erupting with “One Big Holiday” as singer Jim James traded thundering electric guitar riffs with Carl Broemel. MMJ is known for wild improvisation during its live shows, but this was about musical fire and brimstone, not jam-band noodling. The Louisville, Kentucky act mixed fan favorites with songs from the upcoming Evil Urges album, balancing modern rock with a southern accent, like a post-grunge version of the Band.

New songs dabbled in new forms and beats, stepping out of the country-rock groove, even when setting Broemel’s pedal steel against a spare 4/4 beat, before exploding again with loud slabs of guitar. James was still ready to slow things down at times, falling to his knees during the vulnerable “Wordless Chorus,” wailing to a soulful southern rhythm, “We forgot about love, but weren’t brokenhearted.” The reggae-flavored “Off the Record” had James sounding a little bit Joe Strummer at the microphone, with guitars swelling into a big rock groove around the bright green drum-kit of Patrick Hallahan. Just as impressive was the quintet’s ability to slide into complex instrumental jam-outs without getting lost there.

For die-hard Coachella-goers, the final moments of the festival took place in the Sahara tent, as dance act Justice fired off rapid beats, electronic riffs and vocal samples to an overflow crowd well after midnight. In fact, they went a half hour over curfew, which means that for last night alone, Goldenvoice owes the city of Indio $300,000 (it’s $10,000 per minute you go over, according to sources). Three days in the desert were just about over, but the hardiest fans weren’t ready to leave, still bouncing to the beats and twirling their glow gear, as if the party was just getting started.


Comments

Bill Weir | 5/15/2008, 12:15 am EST

Roger Waters’ set was hands down the best concert I’ve ever been to in my life. I’m a sound engineer and I’m a big music fan so I’ve seen a lot of them- this takes takes the cake! I’m not talking about all the “flash and trash” either- the heartfelt performances made me cry! I came away feeling clean- and i was working as a sound engineer at Coachella so I wasn’t on anything either!

Greg | 5/7/2008, 3:35 pm EST

Best Coachella yet. Well . . . 04 was pretty solid, but 2008 was an amazing year. GoldenVoice will have a hard time topping it.

Debbie | 5/6/2008, 7:40 pm EST

The Concert was everything I knew it was gonna be….And Roger did THE MOST EXCELENT JOB!!!!!! And you didn’t even have to be high to enjoy it….Cuz it was the Ultimate

debbie | 5/6/2008, 7:39 pm EST

The Concert was everything I knew it was gonna be….And Roger did THE MOST EXCELENT JOB!!!!!! And you didn’t even have to be high to enjoy it….Cuz it was the Ultimate

Matt | 5/5/2008, 4:38 pm EST

wow i never thought i would see Roger headlining a festival, especially in the states.

ruud | 5/2/2008, 5:48 pm EST

roger is god.

ruud | 5/2/2008, 5:48 pm EST

roger is god.

n8 | 5/2/2008, 1:11 am EST

seriosly 40 years? He was still in pink floyd 30 years ago, and has done solo stuff ever since leaving.

FOSO | 5/1/2008, 4:40 pm EST

Also my third time on Waters Dark Side of the Moon Show since 2007, front row this time and it was the best i’ve ever seen. The pig is always set free at the end of sheep. Sincerely The best concert i’ve been in My life.

Jenna | 4/30/2008, 12:46 am EST

It’s also worthy to note that he had an airplane drop small pamphlets urging people to vote for Obama. Unfortunately, the pamphlets missed the audience and landed thousands in the surrounding neighborhoods.

Joe P | 4/29/2008, 7:22 pm EST

I was there for the entire Roger Waters show right in the middle of the mass of fans and it was incredible. An amazing show from beginning to end.

John | 4/29/2008, 8:37 am EST

Damn, sounds like I missed an awesome show. Pink brings back a lot of great and slighty smokey memories, LOL

tooth | 4/29/2008, 2:38 am EST

“Run like hell” was not played. Pay attention.
The pig was accidentally let go. There is now a $10,000 reward for its return along with 4 tickets for life to Coachella.

DeezNuttzz | 4/28/2008, 11:40 pm EST

Hey RS; how hard would it be to just go ahead an post set lists when you do the reviews of shows, whether they be festivals or individual band shows? It’s cool to hear the report, but knowing the exact setlist is always nice to see as well. Whaddya say?

michelle | 4/28/2008, 8:35 pm EST

i am pretty sure that it is NOT $10,000 per minute after curfew… it is $1,000 per minute.

Ron | 4/28/2008, 4:52 pm EST

Had super low expectations because he seemed like such a bad fit… instead it was probably the greatest show I have ever seen… and I’ve been to all Coachellas except the first… way above expectations… Really amazed by Roger Waters… Forgot how influential and good he was… No wonder there were lots of 50 year olds there with their 10 year olds.. they knew … too bad this guy didn’t do anything good for forty years… we have all missed out on the genius he could have been making for these past 40 (?) years ..why doesn’t he quit whining about world fighting we he can’t even solve problems with his own band? …

Steve | 4/28/2008, 4:47 pm EST

That arrogant bastard needs to mind politics in his own country which is going down the tubes. I love Pink but his floating pig was too much.

T-Bone | 4/28/2008, 4:22 pm EST

First off, Waters was the BEST concert the desert has EVER seen!
Sorry Jhon but Floyd music doesn’t need hype, it speaks for itself. Secondly, Steve Appleford was wrong when he reported Roger did “Run Like Hell” off “The Wall”.
Maybe he got a contact high from those bong tokin’ baggy short dudes he mentioned and THOUGHT he heard that song. I have seen Roger and this show three times in the last two years, and trust me, I would know if he played it. It’s probably my favorite Floyd song next to “Comfortably Numb” and “Time”! I hope the kids appreciated what they saw last night, cause it doesn’t get much better than that!

Pink | 4/28/2008, 2:19 pm EST

“Isn’t this - Where we came in?”

Jhon | 4/28/2008, 1:31 pm EST

After Prince the Dark Side set din’t live the hype.

Post A Comment

Caution: Off-topic comments will be deleted

Name:

Comments:



Advertisement

Advertisement