Previous Next Latest

Madonna, Mellencamp, Cohen Honored at Emotional Rock and Roll Hall of Fame Induction

3/11/08, 7:55 am EST

As Iggy Pop and the Stooges pounded through punked-up reinventions of inductee Madonna’s “Burning Up” and “Ray of Light” Monday night at the 23rd annual Rock and Roll Hall of Fame induction ceremony, it was only the most extreme example of what the show did all night long: find unexpected common ground between disparate genres and eras of music. The broad range of newly inducted artists included John Mellencamp, the Ventures, Leonard Cohen and the Dave Clark Five, the last of whom inspired the evening’s most impassioned speech: fan Tom Hanks vividly described hearing the British Invasion band’s hits coming out of a “speaker the size of a soda can” as a kid. “Joy is eternal,” Hanks said. “Joy was in the music of the Dave Clark Five. Their records still jump out of any speaker.”

(Click here for photos from last night’s ceremony.)

Justin Timberlake inducted Madonna with a light-hearted, flirtatious speech. “The world is full of Madonna wannabes. I might have even dated a couple. But there truly is only one Madonna,” he said, adding, “Though I’m pretty sure Little Richard would disagree, the truth is that nobody has ever gotten into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame while still looking this damn fine.” He also told a story about Madonna giving him a B-12 shot: “That’s what Madonna was and will continue to be for all of us: A shot in the ass when we need it most,” Timberlake said.

Madonna seemed moved by the occasion, appearing close to tears at a couple points as she gave a lengthy, heartfelt talk. She offered a brief history of her career, describing her first stabs at music: playing drums along with Elvis Costello records, and strumming four chords on a guitar. She thanked an old ballet teacher “who told me I was special,” and talked about songwriting in mystical terms: “Luckily, I have been miraculously and mysteriously possessed by some kind of magic.” And she introduced Iggy Pop as a kindred spirit, “another ass-kicker from Michigan.”

In his affectionate induction speech for Mellencamp, Billy Joel celebrated him as an American rebel at a time when the nation needs one. “This country has been hijacked,” Joel said. “People need to hear a voice like yours to echo the discontent in the heartland … Someone’s got to tell ‘em don’t take any shit, and John, you do that very well.”

Mellencamp traced his fighting spirit to his youth, beginning with surviving spinal bifida as an infant. “I’m lucky to be standing here for any number of reasons,” said Mellencamp, who choked up as he thanked his mom and dad, who both attended the ceremony. Before kicking into a fierce version of “Authority Song” (backed by a band that included his teenage son, Speck, on guitar), which he turned into an audience sing-along, Mellencamp said, “I still feel the same way today as I did when I wrote it twenty-five years ago.”

Lou Reed inducted Leonard Cohen, reading selections from his lyrics. “We are so lucky to be alive at the same time Leonard Cohen is,” he said. Of all the honorees, Cohen seemed most surprised to be there. “This is a very unlikely occasion for me. It is not a distinction that I coveted or even dared dream about,” he said, adding a joke that played off a famous quote about Bruce Springsteen: “So I’m reminded of the prophetic statement of Jon Landau in the early Seventies: I have seen the future of rock and roll and it is not Leonard Cohen.”

As John Fogerty inducted instrumental rockers the Ventures, he recalled that he and his Creedence bandmates spent time “picking apart these Ventures songs to see how they work and getting a great education along the way.” The Ventures then played note-perfect, reverb-swamped versions of two of their biggest hits, “Walk Don’t Run” and “Hawaii Five-O.” Early in the show, Ben Harper inducted the late blues harpist Little Walter, and Jerry Butler of the Impressions inducted the Philly soul production team of Kenny Gamble and Leon Huff.

The evening ended with Mellencamp, John Fogerty, Joan Jett and Billy Joel jamming on an explosive, garage-y version of the Dave Clark Five’s “Glad All Over” that recalled the all-star jams of the Hall of Fame’s early years. The Dave Clark Five’s singer, Mike Smith, died of pneumonia just two weeks before the ceremony. But drummer and bandleader Clark said that he was grateful that Smith was aware of the honor. “Mike tried desperately to be here with us tonight,” he said. “But at least he knew he was a hall of famer.”

Related Stories:

[Photo: Mazur/Wireimage]


Previous Next Latest

Comments

Spook78 | 3/11/2008, 9:01 am EST

All I can say about the Dave Clark 5 being inducted is, “It’s about freakin’ time!” Congratulations, guys. You deserve it. Now, with this exposure, and the soon-to-be-released deluxe hits package coming out, people not familiar with the band will grow to love them, and people who ARE familiar with the band will fall in love with them all over again.

Captain Duck | 3/11/2008, 9:12 am EST

Jesus Iggy, buy a shirt for fucks sake. Still, at least we know what Antony Keidis is gonna look like in a few years

Tommy G | 3/11/2008, 9:41 am EST

A great ceremony last night…I hope they induct the following soon: Joe Cocker, Chicago, Moody
Blues, Hollies, Jeff Lynne, Billy
Preston, Monkees, Styx. I think these guys were all innovators &
showed great success & longevity!
These ceremonies are so much fun!

Luke | 3/11/2008, 10:00 am EST

Madonna’s speech was so touching. She is a true musical legend.

Shaun | 3/11/2008, 10:04 am EST

Tommy, I agree with all of your choices except for Styx. Sorry, they just never did it for me. Lynne’s also a bit iffy, but between ELO, his work as a producer, and the Wilburys I’ll give him his due as well. If Lynne gets in other producers — Rick Rubin for one — should too.

Chicago’s later work probably drags down their chances, but that shouldn’t be a penalty against the original lineup with the amazing Terry Kath.

Plenty of deserving people still left out. Here’s a few more: Tom Waits, Jimmy Buffett, Neil Diamond (he deserves in for the number of people who have covered his songs alone, and give him props for his comeback), Alice Cooper (the original shock rocker, and his 70’s output is underrated).

Even though I’m not a KISS fan, I recognize they’re enormous popularity and influence. They should be in too. They, along with Cooper, brought theatricality to popular music long before Madonna.

Shaun | 3/11/2008, 10:08 am EST

John Hiatt (again, everyone’s done his songs) and Leon Russell are two more who deserve to be in. I’d also make a case for Little Feat.

Sorry for using the wrong form of “their” in my previous posting!

Hollybeth | 3/11/2008, 10:24 am EST

Madonna had a great speech…however, why didn’t she perform? Everyone else inducted, shows their appreciation and performs for the audience.

Lisa | 3/11/2008, 10:26 am EST

Come on Madonna, you are there and you don’t even perform? What a rip and totally tasteless.

40oz killa | 3/11/2008, 10:29 am EST

It would have been a better and more dynamic show if the Beastie Boys had got in. This is a band that had done it all, punk,hip-hop,indie rock, and instrumental jams. And Addrock inducted Madonna back in the day so it would bring it all full circle.

simon templer | 3/11/2008, 10:31 am EST

So, where was the dis on Timberlakes Ex girlfriends? Because he said he might have dated a couple Madonna wannabe’s? Geesh, how lame.

simon templer | 3/11/2008, 10:33 am EST

Hey killa, dynamic and a much better show doesn’t get you in the hall of fame. They were honoring people who created a whole culture of music. Beastie Boys arn’t even close yet.

simon templer | 3/11/2008, 10:35 am EST

Oh, and another thing…Spook 78 is right on the money. Hail to the 5!!!!

Julio Iglesias | 3/11/2008, 10:35 am EST

Where was Led Zeppelin

terri | 3/11/2008, 10:39 am EST

The Zombies deserve to be in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. Powers that be, please induct the Zombies.

GINMILL31 | 3/11/2008, 10:40 am EST

Could Madonna look more like a stepford Wife?

Mellon | 3/11/2008, 10:41 am EST

Madonna is a whore who only knew how to be controversial. We’re too liberal these days with the term, “artist.”

boogie | 3/11/2008, 10:42 am EST

Justin Timberlake is such a woman. I hate sissy men who act catty. Yes, you dated Britney and it didn’t work out. Man up, grow a pair and move on. Crazy or not, at least she hasn’t uttered your name in public.

Bob | 3/11/2008, 10:42 am EST

Leonard Cohen!

the king of music.
Go man

boogie | 3/11/2008, 10:42 am EST

Justin Timberlake is such a woman. I hate sissy men who act catty. Yes, you dated Britney and it didn’t work out. Man up, grow a pair and move on. Crazy or not, at least she hasn’t uttered your name in public.

Mike | 3/11/2008, 10:42 am EST

C’mon R+R Hall, Where’s Heart, and Three Dog Night

JACK | 3/11/2008, 10:46 am EST

IGGY AND THE STOOGES.
NEW YOUR DOLLS.
ENOUGH SAID.

firemyars | 3/11/2008, 10:46 am EST

So beyond lame.Mellonhead is a boring-pop-repub,Madonna never wrote a thing,and JT inducting her is a slap in the face to any real rock fan.Music has officially been killed.Congratulations.

Barbie Bradley | 3/11/2008, 10:50 am EST

Madonna is a fabulous artist and anyone who disagrees in anything she has and will ever do is just jealous of who and what she stands for.Gotta love that lady…

Barbie | 3/11/2008, 10:51 am EST

Madonna kicks butt and will always kick butt….

Mandela | 3/11/2008, 10:51 am EST

I think Madonna not playing was a smart choice. This is a room full of rock and roll legends, and you want a pop act like her to perform? You think John Mellencamp or Keith Richards enjoyed Like a Virgin? If she did perform she’d have to do Ray of Light and Beautiful stranger, they’re the main rock songs in her catolouge, but still it’s just the wrong venue. Again, smart choice.

Tim | 3/11/2008, 10:52 am EST

I still don’t understand how Madonna gets into the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame. That’s she didn’t perform. She knew her pop music wouldn’t sound right at a rock & roll event!!

Jim | 3/11/2008, 10:54 am EST

Where is Kiss….the hall of fame sucks balls

The wineguy | 3/11/2008, 10:54 am EST

What about J. Geils Band..back in the day they were so Awesome!!
The Eger Winter Group, Humble Pie, Leon Russell, Marshall Tucker Band…they all deserve it as well.

Fitzbath | 3/11/2008, 10:54 am EST

Iggy is always speaking out against fake rock and roll and there he is standing on stage with Madonna and Justin Timberlake.

Scott | 3/11/2008, 10:55 am EST

Boogie, you are a moron. Of course Britney dissed Justin when back when he broke up with her for fucking around. Just because you love Britney and think she can do no wrong, doesn’t mean she isn’t catty. You’re the one who needs to “grow a pair”…of eyes to see what the real deal is. Whose life is FUBAR right now and who has his shit together. The best thing that ever happened to JT was braeking up with that train wreck named Britney.

Lunch | 3/11/2008, 10:55 am EST

Motley Crue anyone? They’re eligible, but f’n Madonna gets in before them! WTF – this is supposed to be about ROCK AND ROLL, they need to create a POP hall of fame for acts like Madonna, because she is certainly NOT ROCK. Then again, neither was Grandmaster Flash last year, but the RRHOF doesn’t give a crap apparently.

matt | 3/11/2008, 10:55 am EST

I agree Madonna kicks…

Tory | 3/11/2008, 10:56 am EST

Yeah Kiss should be added next year. Its an injustice.

piano*nikki | 3/11/2008, 10:57 am EST

Justin, grow up! What a childish, lame comment . . . it’s NOT ABOUT YOU! Dave Clark 5 . . . it’s about damn time! Pretty sad it had to be the same year as Madonna and John Mellencamp, though.

sugar | 3/11/2008, 10:58 am EST

Madonna who doesn”t love her
We all have a little Madonna in us.

dianna | 3/11/2008, 10:59 am EST

Is that really Madonna or her wax image from Madam Tusseau’s Museum? (Sorry if I spelled Madam’s name wrong) I agree, why didn’t she “perform”? When I think of rock and roll, she does not come to mind. Perhaps it’s time for a pop music hall of fame, which is where Justin T. will end up.

Randy Huber | 3/11/2008, 11:02 am EST

It’s still Called The Rock-n-Roll Hall of Fame When Prince and Madonna are inducted and Alice Cooper, Kiss and The Moody Blues are not it should be called The Pop-n-Roll Hall of Fame or maybe The Rock-n-Roll Hall of Shame

jack | 3/11/2008, 11:05 am EST

Wax…you did not,hot hot hot!
she is almost 50…

Joe | 3/11/2008, 11:06 am EST

Mellencamp is a good inclusion, but the rest of this “class” was very weak.

The people at the Hall decide to include a tart like Madonna, after they made Black Sabbath wait almost 40 years to get in? What rubbish.

Brittanynyc | 3/11/2008, 11:08 am EST

I guess it was bound to happen. But…Madonna being inducted is kind of weird. It just doesn’t fit. She is pop music, nothing else. Having her honored alongside these trailblazing musicians is extremely odd. She was smart not to perform. That would have just been painfull. For both her and the entire room.

Frank11 | 3/11/2008, 11:10 am EST

What about RUSH?

Frank11 | 3/11/2008, 11:10 am EST

What about Rush and Triumph?

Rehan | 3/11/2008, 11:12 am EST

while pop music is different than the spirit of rock and roll, why are people mincing words when it comes to Madonna? People, she has a song catalog that has changed the face of music. anyone arguing over her place in a music hall of fame because she is a pop artist is clearly splitting hairs

gigs | 3/11/2008, 11:13 am EST

Madonna, Justin Timberlake.. Rock N Roll?????!!!! WTF, just when did they fit into that category. I can’t for the life of me compare them to Robert Plant, Neil Young or Mick Jaggar..now that was Rock!

Jogger | 3/11/2008, 11:16 am EST

I am a little surprised that Madonna was inducted. But I guess the Hall is really for any type of music. But, country has its own hall of fame.

Seek36 | 3/11/2008, 11:17 am EST

Madonna would have performed if she was getting paid or in another country. I hate that ungrateful bitch. She hates this country and she won’t play in a stadium if an american flag is flying. However…you’ll never see her turn down American Money from American People! America helped make her and she needs to recognize that! You notice that after living in London for awhile, she now is moving back to the states. Wonder why? Stay out if you don’t like your country! LOVE IT OR LEAVE IT!!!

Johnnya | 3/11/2008, 11:20 am EST

The hall of SHAME! Rush anyone?

Joe | 3/11/2008, 11:21 am EST

Rehan:
No one is splitting hairs. This isn’t a music hall of fame, it’s a rock and roll hall of fame. If they’re going to allow non-rockers to get in, why not start with Beethoven and Mozart? Both were influential, and both were a lot better than Madonna.

Besides, it’s a complete sham to induct her ahead of bands like Metallica or Judas Priest. Let her shake her ass somewhere else.

Rocker | 3/11/2008, 11:21 am EST

Rehan, it’s not the Music hall of Fame, it’s the Rock-n-Roll Hall of Fame, and no Madonna doesn’t belong in The Rock-n-Roll Hall of Fame, if you’re talking The Music Hall of Fame, I agree with you, do you think she belongs in the RRHOF before Alice Cooper, Kiss, The Moody Blues, or Rush?You’ve got to be kidding

Lemon | 3/11/2008, 11:22 am EST

She didn’t perform because she’s never been a good live performer. She always sound nervous and hits wrong notes. That’s why she always uses backing tracks onstage.

bigwilly | 3/11/2008, 11:22 am EST

Isn’t Rock and Roll sort of an abstract definition of music. I mean R & R has many faces and personalities. Let’s just let people embrace their own R & R!

Erik | 3/11/2008, 11:23 am EST

If you induct KISS then you gotta induct the Archies and the Monkees. The RRHOF is a joke.

Robert del Valle | 3/11/2008, 11:23 am EST

The induction of the Dave Clark Five was long overdue. Yo, Cleveland – make some room for The Merseybeats!

Bridgette Champagne | 3/11/2008, 11:23 am EST

HEY I FUCKING LOVE MADONNA. SHE HAS BEEN MY IDOL SINCE I WAS A KID. I LOVE ALL HER MUSIC. SHE IS A BEAUTIFUL NAD VERY TALENTED WOMAN. SHE HAS INSPIRED ME TO FOLLOW MANY OF MY TALENTS. THAT YOU MADONNA, FOR BEING SUCH AN INSPIRATION TO ME. THANK YOU

ingrid | 3/11/2008, 11:23 am EST

Madonna is an inspiring piece of art

Robert del Valle | 3/11/2008, 11:23 am EST

The induction of the Dave Clark Five was long overdue. Yo, Cleveland – make some room for The Merseybeats!

Chris | 3/11/2008, 11:23 am EST

Seek36 must work for FOX News.

dormant1 | 3/11/2008, 11:23 am EST

Madonna is a porn star!

Robert del Valle | 3/11/2008, 11:23 am EST

The induction of the Dave Clark Five was long overdue. Yo, Cleveland – make some room for The Merseybeats!

bellagatta | 3/11/2008, 11:24 am EST

What the hell? POP in a Rock N Roll Hall of Fame? Who votes? Give a female a break? Sorry they should open a ‘ POP” Hall of Fame perfect for Madonna!! Brittany and Madonna same level!!

ingrid Penilla | 3/11/2008, 11:24 am EST

Madonna is an inspiring piece of art

vetty | 3/11/2008, 11:24 am EST

I’m all for KISS, Madonna sucks, they must be desperate.

sachin | 3/11/2008, 11:24 am EST

lovely

gettagrip | 3/11/2008, 11:24 am EST

Seriously, the rock hall of fame is probably the dumbest tourist trap of all time. Who the hell cares if anyone gets in?

Mike | 3/11/2008, 11:25 am EST

Just another bunch of so-called stars patting themselves on the back. Talk about conceited

I thought Ms. M had A#$ Cancer. What ever happened to that?

Jamey | 3/11/2008, 11:25 am EST

About the only shred of credibility the RRHoF has left is that they’re not so taste-impaired as to induct RUSH.

Maybe RUSH can get in if the Hall has a More Notes Does Not Equal Better Music exhibition.

MCE | 3/11/2008, 11:25 am EST

To Seek 36: That love it or leave it crap when out in 1968…

BPfromME | 3/11/2008, 11:25 am EST

Did everyone fail to notice that John Mellencamp named his son SPECK?? Seriously? If it wasn’t for all their money that poor kid would have been hanging off a flagpole by his underware by now.

Lilly1969 | 3/11/2008, 11:25 am EST

Actually Madonna was/is an Icon and a trail blazer. She brought sex to the forefront. She was about the ME generation, and broke stereo types in the music industry.

Joejoe | 3/11/2008, 11:25 am EST

Justin Timber-FLAKE what a wuss.

Hera76 | 3/11/2008, 11:25 am EST

Why the hell was Justin there? And why throw in snarky comments about your exes or anything? Geez. Classless. He has such a big ego, I can’t stand it.
I am glad the Ventures and Dave Clark 5 got in there.

Mack | 3/11/2008, 11:25 am EST

The RRHOF became a joke several years ago, and the main fault for that lies with the panel that chooses the nominees and winners. You have the likes of bands like Yes, Rush, and so many others that have had success for over 30 years, have produced dozens of albums, can still fill 5000 seat venues, yet they aren’t in. On the other hand, you have bands and artists that put out maybe 2-3 albums that are. Go figure.

G.Lee | 3/11/2008, 11:26 am EST

Where’s Rush?? What a joke… But then the R-n-R hall has never been recognized by anyone but the establishment anyway… which in and of itself makes it a joke.

franklinsberry | 3/11/2008, 11:26 am EST

I think you are all idiots who don’t understand the wisdom of nothing and everything but maybe I do don’t so that is why I am writting here. Woot Woot Madonna. So I wonder what michelle Phifer looks like now.

G.Lee | 3/11/2008, 11:26 am EST

Where’s Rush?? What a joke… But then the R-n-R hall has never been recognized by anyone but the establishment anyway… which in and of itself makes it a joke.

Madonna???? | 3/11/2008, 11:26 am EST

Listen, I totally agree that Madonna changed the face of music…in the 80’s. However, Rock & Roll hall of fame? Give me a break. If it’s that important for all of you Madonna lovers, lobby for a “Pop Music Hall of Fame.” It’s a darn shame bands like Rush & Triumph just to name a few aren’t in it yet Madonna gets in.

MCE | 3/11/2008, 11:26 am EST

All these rock whiners here…rock has sucked for years…get a clue!

W00T | 3/11/2008, 11:26 am EST

Timberlake is a loser.

joshua | 3/11/2008, 11:26 am EST

why be hating on madonna…she musst have fit the criteria to be inducted. she is from the nineteen eighties…who can you think of that can last this long with such a fan base? she is the highest grossing concert every year she takes the show on the road and has been the most discussed female in music history!! and maybe i hears someone say she looked like a “wax” version of herself, but after all she is fifty this year and still doing it. my own mother is only a few years older and has nothing on looking like her. i love madonna and i believe she deserves every minute of her achievement and more. the good thing is that madonna doesn’t read her critics, good or bad, so she won’t have to hear a lot of this negativity. she has her true legion of fans like me to speak out for her….xoxo madonna and congrats!!!

taetum20 | 3/11/2008, 11:26 am EST

is that really true madonna wont play in a stadium/arena/other venue if there is an american flag hanging?!

amber | 3/11/2008, 11:26 am EST

what about stevie nicks and the rest of the artists that’s been around longer than madonna? it was nice to see her inducted but i was disappointed. why didn’t she perform?

Karen | 3/11/2008, 11:26 am EST

I agree with Terry, induct the
Zombies. Mellenamp and the DC5
were well deserving.

Chris | 3/11/2008, 11:26 am EST

Seek26,

I saw madonna at 3 seperate venues at her last tour and all had american flags hanging. Stop telling thing that are rumors. State facts.

amber | 3/11/2008, 11:26 am EST

what about stevie nicks and the rest of the artists that’s been around longer than madonna? it was nice to see her inducted but i was disappointed. why didn’t she perform?

socalval | 3/11/2008, 11:27 am EST

Madonna has NO right being in the AMERICAN hall of fame . She is nothing but a two bit terrorist that reads the friggin koran.

Steven | 3/11/2008, 11:27 am EST

The rock and roll hall of fame is a complete joke. Went there a few years back. It was totally rock and roll to see costumes worn by britney spears, chrsitina agiulera, and n’sync on display.

Veronica | 3/11/2008, 11:27 am EST

Madonna belongs in the rock n roll hall of fame. She is truly a legend. You’re nuts if you don’t think so.

choptastic | 3/11/2008, 11:27 am EST

Rush sucks. No one wants them in any category which is why they havent been nominated. They arent metal, hardrock, or Christian (which they surprisingly claim)///

nicholas | 3/11/2008, 11:27 am EST

fsj eda ghhg g dagh gh dagh hg ashggdahg gh dagh gh dagh gh dagh gh dsgh dasgh dagh gh dsh sdhg dasgh schg hg sdcgh dasgcghgh dagh gh asxgh dgh dashghg dsghgh sghg

nicholas | 3/11/2008, 11:27 am EST

fsj eda ghhg g dagh gh dagh hg ashggdahg gh dagh gh dagh gh dagh gh dsgh dasgh dagh gh dsh sdhg dasgh schg hg sdcgh dasgcghgh dagh gh asxgh dgh dashghg dsghgh sghg

lane | 3/11/2008, 11:27 am EST

most of the people in the rock and roll hall of are pop, so why single out madonna?

socalval | 3/11/2008, 11:27 am EST

Madonna has NO right being in the AMERICAN hall of fame . She is nothing but a two bit terrorist that reads the friggin koran.

Mike | 3/11/2008, 11:27 am EST

Chris must work for MSNBC

Bridgette Champagne | 3/11/2008, 11:27 am EST

AMEN TO THAT SUGAR!!!! THAT IS THE TRUTH. WE DO ALL HAVE A LITTLE MADONNA IN US. SHE HAS INSPIRED ME TO FOLLOW MY DREAMS, AND TO COME OUT OF MY SHELL. I USED TO BE REALLY SHY,THEN AFTER LISTENING TO HER MUSIC, SHE OPENED MY EYES, AND I AM NO LONGER A SHY PERSON. I THANK HER SO MUCH.

Ray Ray | 3/11/2008, 11:27 am EST

Madonna is a great influence to millions around the world. Her music defines alot about who she was.

spookaroni | 3/11/2008, 11:27 am EST

Kiss, Heart…not Madonna

Chdots | 3/11/2008, 11:28 am EST

Peter Gabriel. His work with Genesis, his solo career and advancement of World Music plus movie soundtracks makes him a very honorable inductee.

jansporit | 3/11/2008, 11:28 am EST

What about the butthole surfers or GG Allen

holdengirl | 3/11/2008, 11:28 am EST

After I saw Truth or Dare, I completely despised Madonna and still do. The way she treated people as well as her hard as nails looks and attitude are disgusting. But bravo to a long-overdue recognition of Leonard Cohen, one who brought poetry to song in the very best sense.

CC | 3/11/2008, 11:28 am EST

Madonna is NOT Rock And Roll. If there was a Pop, Disco, Dance, or Electronic Music Hall of fame, sure–she’s in. But her only undeniable contribution to the world of music is image. Her actual music is very far from ROCK. Is she really that great as a singer? Does she really play an instrument? ALSO–Please don’t expect me to believe she actually even wrote most of that crap she released…

Gage Kristofer | 3/11/2008, 11:28 am EST

Madonna HAS had some pretty good memorable tracks in her past…but with her newest cd dropping in April, Im becoming less of a fan. She had to go to Timbaland & Justin to get on the radio. So much for being yourself.

girlmusician | 3/11/2008, 11:28 am EST

Where is

The Electric Light Orchestra or the Moody Blues? They have been around a lot longer than Madonna and they have played all their own instruments without layers upon layers of sample music.

Rush, Kiss, ELO, Moody Blues is real rock with real instruments.

Supernaturalfan1 | 3/11/2008, 11:29 am EST

This is supposed to bethe Rock & Roll hall of fame – what’s with all the pop??? I love John Mellencamp and he belongs there, but not Madonna (sorry fans). Kiss totally should be in, as all distinctive rock bands who made their own contribution to the genre.

Mark | 3/11/2008, 11:29 am EST

The Rock n Roll Hall of Shame….
it’s all bullshit.

january | 3/11/2008, 11:29 am EST

I have no idea why Grand Funk Railroad isn’t in the R&RHOF. Please get serious about the inductees.

Santana?? | 3/11/2008, 11:29 am EST

Santana before Madonna any day.

armando | 3/11/2008, 11:29 am EST

rush, rush, rush! mother f’ers!!!!!!!!!!

john | 3/11/2008, 11:29 am EST

how about judas priest..they changed the look and sound of metal

Jeff | 3/11/2008, 11:29 am EST

I’m sorry Madonna gets in only because she was basically the evolution of MTV with Duran Duran, Hall and Oates, and of course Michael Jackson. I like Madonna don’t get me wrong, but her ability to take music off the radio was WAY more influential than her music itself. How about putting more bands in that actually changed the landscape – Rush, Joy Division, and one could even argue Depeche Mode, after all they are the most successful synth pop band, and they proved that synths could be used outside of disco and new wave.

Veronica | 3/11/2008, 11:29 am EST

and WHY is everybody bitching about Rush? Rush sucks.

Clevelander | 3/11/2008, 11:29 am EST

The Rock and Roll Hall of Fame was never set up to only honor Rock music. For those of you who have been to the museum in Cleveland you would know this. There are legends from all types of music (even country) at the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame Museum.

Rocksinger | 3/11/2008, 11:29 am EST

Sad, they lost there lead singer and sax player.
The Dave Clark 3

another old rocker | 3/11/2008, 11:29 am EST

I not only ask what was Timberlake or Madonna doing there, but I also ask what was Billy Joel doing there! He is another hall of fame member who belongs there a bit less so than Paul Anka. And I certainly agree it was about time for the DC5, and also agree that Rush, KISS, and Alice Cooper should have been inducted long before Madonna.

J Bond | 3/11/2008, 11:29 am EST

Madonna is indeed a music icon, but I wouldn’t describe Justin Timberlake’s introduction of Madonna as flirtatious. Rather, it’s more appropriate to describe JT as “egoistic.”

john | 3/11/2008, 11:29 am EST

how about judas priest..they changed the look and sound of metal

john | 3/11/2008, 11:29 am EST

how about judas priest..they changed the look and sound of metal

TOMMY D | 3/11/2008, 11:29 am EST

WHAT ABOUT AC/DC OR BAD COMPANY OR LYNYRD SKYNYRD OR Z Z TOP DAMN WHERE HAVE ALL OF YOU BEEN.IN AN ELEVATOR ????????

Chris G | 3/11/2008, 11:29 am EST

Rock and Roll Hall of Fame is a crock – JT Is not a ‘rocker’. And no Rush in the hall? They are one of the most influential bands of all time, consistantly putting out hit album every few years.

bigdaddy | 3/11/2008, 11:29 am EST

What about Gary US Bonds? The guy invented party rock and roll. Everyone from the Beatles to Springsteen list him as an influence…RNR Hall of Shame indeed!

armando | 3/11/2008, 11:29 am EST

rush, rush, rush! mother f’ers!!!!!!!!!!

Howard | 3/11/2008, 11:29 am EST

When are groups like Yes, King Crimson and especially Genesis getting in? Genesis has gone though its “progressive” period and its “pop” period and has sold millions of records and filled stadiums thoughout the world, including last year. I know Rolling Stone thinks little of Genesis, but they are well deserving.

Rocksinger | 3/11/2008, 11:29 am EST

Sad, they lost there lead singer and sax player.
The Dave Clark 3

J Bond | 3/11/2008, 11:29 am EST

Madonna is indeed a music icon, but I wouldn’t describe Justin Timberlake’s introduction of Madonna as flirtatious. Rather, it’s more appropriate to describe JT as “egoistic.”

Barkley | 3/11/2008, 11:29 am EST

Madonna is dance-pop and didn’t write any of her hits. She’s more a performer than an artist. Cher & Linda Ronstadt should be in before her. Madonna tries to be rock but her thin voice doesn’t suit it.

J Bond | 3/11/2008, 11:29 am EST

Madonna is indeed a music icon, but I wouldn’t describe Justin Timberlake’s introduction of Madonna as flirtatious. Rather, it’s more appropriate to describe JT as “egoistic.”

anne howells | 3/11/2008, 11:30 am EST

Maddona get a life

HAL TRIPP | 3/11/2008, 11:30 am EST

leonard, we all love you in montreal,

amazedbystupidity | 3/11/2008, 11:30 am EST

Did Seek36 really just say, “America: Love It or Leave It”??? I didn’t think anyone was that backwards and ignorant anymore. Americans have the right and the RESPONSIBILITY to criticize their own government, society and culture; it sounds like Seek36 would be happier living in a totalitarian dictatorship or perhaps in communist China where citizens really DO have to love their country or leave it (via firing squad). At any rate, yes, Madonna DOES suck and would have embarrassed the entire audience if she had performed any of her so-called “music” at the show.

PopSux | 3/11/2008, 11:30 am EST

WTF. The Rock-n-Roll Hall of Shit can kiss my ass. It’s what it’s name implies. It’s a joke of itself. Fuck’em. I feel sorry for the real rockers that are in it.

anne howells | 3/11/2008, 11:30 am EST

Maddona get a life

MissDiva | 3/11/2008, 11:30 am EST

Madonna is a legend and her music goes beyond a specific title or genre….that’s for all the haters out there!! Do your thang, Madonna WE LOVE U!

anne howells | 3/11/2008, 11:30 am EST

Maddona get a life

CK | 3/11/2008, 11:30 am EST

And why is the ceremony always in NYC? The Rock Hall is in Cleveland! Are these rockers too good to step foot in the Midwest. Shameful, especially b/c Madonna and Iggy are from Michigan. Faced with a failing economy, miserable weather, etc., Cle. need something to get excited about. Have the ceremony here. Then we’ll find out who the real rockers are.

wrecksracer | 3/11/2008, 11:30 am EST

Link Wray is the most glaring ommission from the….well, I guess it’s the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. He invented the Power Chord, used by all rock acts after him. Oh, and the Ventures were the only deserving act to get in this year……

Anonymous | 3/11/2008, 11:30 am EST

Sorry she got so choked up…..was Dennis Rodman around???

jes18 | 3/11/2008, 11:30 am EST

It’s called the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame because they didn’t have all these diffrent genres of music before. Madonna was a trend setter for her time that’s why she made it. Prince made it because of his musical talent to write produce and play many diffrent instraments and make good music. Kiss should be in the Hall of Fame but let’s not discredit others because they are not considered “Rock and Roll”. They don’t have a rap hallof fame or a pop hall of fame. And the only reason country has their own is because Country music has been around forever and it was one of the first!

SULLY | 3/11/2008, 11:31 am EST

I HAD TO WORK WILL IT BE BROADCAST ANYTIME SOON AGAIN?

Insidious | 3/11/2008, 11:31 am EST

Madonna did not perform because her vocal tracks that she lip synchs to while doing arobics were not available.For all those griping about the inductees-the Hall is a joke that lets any and everybody in regardless of talent or stylistic relevance.This is nothing new.I’m sure they will eventually induct the Partridge Family and Sonny & Cher as well as the Osmonds.

REAL Rock Fan | 3/11/2008, 11:31 am EST

So Madonna is in the Rock n Roll Hall of Fame. Yeah she’s been around in the music scene for a long time, but she is NOT rock n roll. Makes me sick that real rockers such as Alice Cooper are still not in there but that tramp of pop is!

REAL Rock Fan | 3/11/2008, 11:31 am EST

So Madonna is in the Rock n Roll Hall of Fame. Yeah she’s been around in the music scene for a long time, but she is NOT rock n roll. Makes me sick that real rockers such as Alice Cooper are still not in there but that tramp of pop is!

Donna | 3/11/2008, 11:31 am EST

Madonna being in the Hall reduces it to a popularity contest. Yes she is popular and an “icon” of sorts, but her talent is mediocre and she is a glorified slut. It is an insult to everyone else who is in the Hall, and they are there because they have talent! Madonna is all about herself – she doesn’t come close to the others. She may be a nice mother and wife but she doesn’t belong in the Hall!

JB | 3/11/2008, 11:31 am EST

RRHOF is a lame joke. Madonna? What is RnR about her? I’d like to see her dragged through the streets of Baghdad for being a self-righteous liberal.

Rob | 3/11/2008, 11:31 am EST

Madonna before Heart? That’s a shame. Ann & Nancy Wilson have been an inspiration to many noted women including Celine Dion, Deana Carter, and even Christy Romano. Madonna never sings live. She lip syncs. She’s flat in the studio requiring all sorts of tricks to make her sound good. She defined women sleeping their way to the top. What she didn’t define is what it is to be a true musician.

aurora | 3/11/2008, 11:31 am EST

Madonna & Justin in the Rock n Roll Hall of Fame….. since when did POP become Rock N Roll… wtf??? someone had their head up their butt on this one for sure! and for the love of all things holy it should at least be manditory that the inductees were shirts! Iggy put on some cloths man, noone needs to see that!!!!!

j.p. | 3/11/2008, 11:31 am EST

Timberlake also inducted the O’Jays in the Rock N Roll Hall of Fame a few years ago as well. Also, you do not have to be a rock n roller to get inducted. Funk, R&B, and rap stars can also be inducted. I’m not that big of a Madonna fan, but people who have been to her shows can attest she can do anything. Some have said Madonna put on the best show they have ever seen. It’s interesting they always have the great white hope Timberlake doing things at the Super Bowl and this event, but not someone like Usher.

Anonymous | 3/11/2008, 11:32 am EST

Madonna is the perfect excample of a sick, degenerate society.

vflow1 | 3/11/2008, 11:32 am EST

I’m not a big Madonna fan but even I have to admit that she deseres it. She changed a whole genre of music and should be recognized beside Prince,MJ,Mellencamp, and others that changed music

EE | 3/11/2008, 11:32 am EST

What about YES? Some of the best musicians ever.

AMORETTO | 3/11/2008, 11:32 am EST

I HAD THE PLEASURE OF MEETING MADONNA SEVERAL TIMES IN MY LIFE BACK IN THE DAY AT THE ROXY’S WHICH THEN TURNED INTO 1018′S AND AT THE FUNHOUSE AND AT BONDS INTERNATIONAL CASINO. WE SPOKE AT TIMES ABOUT HER DREAMS AND ASPERATIONS TO BECOME THE BEST AT WHAT SHE DOES. SHE GAVE ME TIPS AND I PAID ATTENTION. SHE WAS YOUNG AND FULL OF LIFE. WE BOTH HAD HIT DANCE RECORDS OUT ON THE RADIO. THE ONLY SAD PART IS THAT I WAS TIED TO TWO OTHER GIRLS IN MY GROUP AMORETTO. TWO OTHER GIRLS THAT DISAPPEARED. IF I HAD DONE WHAT MADONNA TOLD ME TO DO …….I COULD OF BEEN AS BIG AS HER. I NEEDED TO GO SOLO AND I DIDN’T. I GOT STUCK IN THE LATIN HIP HOP / FREESTYLE 80′S ERA. SHE MOVED ON TO BECOME MADONNA….AN INDUCTEE TO BE HONORED INTO THE ROCK AND ROLL HALL OF FAME!

ONE DAY SHE TOLD ME TO LOOK HER UP ABOUT A YEAR AGO …….WHILE JOGGING IN CENTRAL PARK..CAUSE I LIVE NEAR HER! YOU KNOW WHAT…….I JUST MIGHT. SO AS FAR AS I AM CONCERNED………GIRL YOU DESERVE IT….AI MAMI!!!! I LOVE YOU MADONNA….THANK YOU..FOR SHOWING HOW ITS DONE!

LOVE AMORETTO’s (Clave Rock)
Jessica Lopez
Original 1 of 3

Bill | 3/11/2008, 11:32 am EST

The Ventures got me to start playing guitar 47 years ago. Their sound is still great and they were WAY overdue …

Kai Dewey | 3/11/2008, 11:32 am EST

What is happening with all of the Madonna haters out here, damn! Let’s get something straight, 22 years ago I was rocking to Madonna, just like everybody else. Damn her personal life, that’s her biz, you know? That’s what’s wrong with you Anglo Saxon Americans, too busy trying to run everything, you forget how to enjoy yourself. Madonna, thanks a lot, man. I fell in love with my wife listening to your music, which brought me my two sons. You’re a rocker, only a fool believes otherwise….

Beautiful Loser | 3/11/2008, 11:32 am EST

I can’t possibly think of an alternate reality in which Madonna deserves to stand on the same stage as Leonard Cohen.

“We are ugly but we have the music.”

gary | 3/11/2008, 11:32 am EST

40 years later and no Jethro Tull induction into “the hall”.

Rock & Roll Hall of Fame is simply a travesty and a joke. Who does the voting? Why don’t the true Hall of Famers vote? Isn’t that what they do in baseball?

Time will show that this institution is just a farce.

Cassie | 3/11/2008, 11:32 am EST

Madonnna looks like a wax figure after all those botx shots to keep her face from falling down. What a pathetic selection. None of these individuals deserve the honor. All they know how to do is market themselves, they are not artists in any real sense at all.

Long Time Rock Fan | 3/11/2008, 11:32 am EST

No, not everyone loves Madonna. Her cover of “American Pie” was one of the worst songs in the history of music. I’ve never felt her music was significant; her songs attempted to be controversial and shocking without having any real depth or backed up by a true voice.

Mellencamp brings his unique genre of rebellious songs to many–rock, country, pop….and his songs always have a meaningful message. His voice is full of passion and grit. There’s no comparison between the two. Many may have liked Madonna, but they were probably adolescents like those who buy Britney’s records, at least in large part.

I can rattle off dozens of Mellencamp songs, but can only think of a couple of Madonna’s… she’s made that little of an impact on this rock lover.

BIG AL | 3/11/2008, 11:33 am EST

BARBIE,I JUST WANT TO RIP YOUR LITTLE PLASTIC HEAD OFF!!!!!!

Rob | 3/11/2008, 11:33 am EST

Why i the hell didn’t she perform. Last year they all performed, this year, only 2. I guess they wouldn’t let Madonna lip sync.

Miamiguy | 3/11/2008, 11:33 am EST

What a Joke! It’s R-N-R Hall of Fame, not the POP hall of fame.. This really hit an all time low for the old school rockers… No respect!

Wyatt | 3/11/2008, 11:33 am EST

Madonna before Neil Diamond?!!!

Pahleeese!!!

BeBopkiller | 3/11/2008, 11:33 am EST

franklinsberry is the idiot and a TURD.

Hall of flamers | 3/11/2008, 11:33 am EST

Madonna uses backing tracks on stage and lip syncs??? You all allow that type in the hall of fame??? This whole thing is a joke, big joke, and cannot be taken seriously.

TK | 3/11/2008, 11:33 am EST

HMMM… Madonna now, earlier the Bee Gees and yet one of the foundations of Rock N Roll The Big Bopper is no where to be found!
Amazing considering he created the very first music video in 1958. I guess as one commenter said at the start its more like the music hall of fame instead of the Rock N Roll Hall of Fame. Not much respect for the real rock n rollers!

Jim Bob | 3/11/2008, 11:33 am EST

Justin Timberlake is a big sissy girl ..

Anonymous | 3/11/2008, 11:33 am EST

Madonna is no ROLE MODEL..and no rock n roller.

steve | 3/11/2008, 11:33 am EST

Madonna is to rock n roll what Twinkies are to pastry. Just another reason to avoid going to Cleveland….

milan | 3/11/2008, 11:33 am EST

madonna is more than rock and roll,she is phenomenom and she deserved to be in hall of fame.

Anonymous | 3/11/2008, 11:34 am EST

I grew up with the Ventures during the surf era type music of Jan & Dean and the Beach Boys and am damn glad they’re in the Rock n Roll Hall of Fame.

TNTTYREE | 3/11/2008, 11:34 am EST

Welcome in John Mellencamp!
What Rock & Roll is all about,Or was… Fighting the corrupt scum bu$h & whoever else does “We the people” wrong…
More rockers should be standing up and fighting the corruption ala Neil Young!
Madonna, while popular with women, isn’t nor ever was a Rocker…

real rock `fan | 3/11/2008, 11:34 am EST

what about great and innovative progressive rock groups like yes, jethro tull, rush

Lawa | 3/11/2008, 11:34 am EST

I understand those of you who are crying foul about the differentiation between pop and rock music but I dont think it really applies here. I think the Rock-n-Roll Hall of Fame is about rock music as a larger whole. That means its about metal, hard rock, pop rock, rock-a-billy, motown, and more. Yes we tend to specialize rock music even more but this award is about those who contributed to any of those genres. And while I hate Madonna and think 95% of her stuff is garbage, you cannot deny that she had tremendous influence on the music world. Besides, every year there is some big name person/group who is inducted who seems less deserving than others but is a bigger name. The Hall of Fame seems to always pick a group/artist who is still receiving alot of attention specifically so that they can get a headline in all the news outlets. What teenager recognizes the name Leonard Cohen or even Mellancamp? But they all know Madonna. ugh

schnazzybo | 3/11/2008, 11:34 am EST

Madonna is NOT a Rock-n-Roller and NEVER was, the hall of fame sold out on this one

Anonymous | 3/11/2008, 11:34 am EST

Wow what a bunch of pathetic losers crying about who got inducted.
Heres one for you dickheads Rush sucks Black Sabbath isn’t even music and niether group compares to true rock and roll.
meaning Chuck Berry Fats Domino Little Richard and the original 5 from Sun records.

BRUNO | 3/11/2008, 11:34 am EST

HOW COME FRANKIE GOES TO HOLLYWOOD NEVER GETS IN???
THEIR THE GREATEST………

who | 3/11/2008, 11:34 am EST

i love madonna but i have to agree she has no business in the rock n roll hall of fame. the right thing for her to do is to give it back and say why. JT is the man but catty comments may have been written in the script you know how they do. its television they so what they can to keep stuff going. kind of sad. esp since britt is so messed up. blame the tv producers, we all know they write that stuff

unison | 3/11/2008, 11:34 am EST

why is everyone bitchin so much about Madonna? Have you even checked the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame? Do names such as Elton John, for example, sound rock to you? Yet he is in there, and to the guy who made the Led Zeppelin comment open your eyes man, they ARE in there as well. Most people are acting as if Madonna is Fergy or Mariah or something…she HAS revolutionized the pop industry and back in she has more rock attitude than 80% of new so called rock bands today. Everyone is moaning as to how she looks like a wax statue and stupid things like that as if a woman with Madonna’s history just matters as a sex symbol. Back at her days her shows, videos and music where a lot more shocking than Marilyn Manson and a number of other bands. Why? Cause her music was labeled “pop” and was supposed to be mainstream and it takes real balls to do that when you are a pop singer than a heavy metal singer and look at her, she has survived, evolved and still sells like crazy even if in the US the “Christian” societies have made sure she doesn’t get much airplay and people think she is a loser. Blah…and this my friends come from a guy who mainly listens to rock

Leo Burnett | 3/11/2008, 11:34 am EST

When will the hall take music pioneer RUSH into their family?

Not made in china | 3/11/2008, 11:34 am EST

I agree with the wine guy and others. Did Madonna pay her way in? Rock and Roll has an never will be her venue. Justin Timberlake? He shouldn’t even have been allowed in the building. A sad moment for Cleveland. Who’s next Jessica Simpson? Rock and Rollers should have a say in these picks.

tjon84 | 3/11/2008, 11:35 am EST

what a cynical piece of trash and a horrible representation of what rock is supposed to be. The Hall of fame is completely lost all credability when it comes to deciding who is worthy and who should never be allowed to utter the words “thank you…..” crap crap crap…… RRHOF ur mother would be very upset, Maddona what a skeez, and an absolute Bennedict Arnold

Bernadine | 3/11/2008, 11:35 am EST

congrats to Leonard… and yes we are SO lucky to be alive the same time as him. His works will go down in history as some of the most important pieces of art, long may he continue and cannot wait to see him on his tour this year.

josh | 3/11/2008, 11:35 am EST

Timberlake comes across as such a pretentious asshole who laughs at his own jokes…

The Divine Grace | 3/11/2008, 11:35 am EST

Madonna isn’t a legend, she’s a lubricant!

Anubis8 | 3/11/2008, 11:35 am EST

Styx, Rush, KISS all come to mind before Madonna!

Tammy Elaine | 3/11/2008, 11:35 am EST

Madonna? Give me a break. REAL Rock legends such as Jimmie Hendrix are rolling over in their graves right now. The Rock and Roll Hall of Fame has become a watered down joke! They should be ashamed for inducting these pop artists while ignoring so many true rock artists like Sabbath, Rush and KISS. I am a long time member of the “classic rock generation” and find this years’ class laughable. They should be ashamed. Madonna in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame…now that’s funny! Seriously.

Daddyoh | 3/11/2008, 11:35 am EST

I bet Seek36 doesn’t have abrother or sister in Iraq or Afghanastan, let alone one that died there. Probably believes all of Bush’s lies, too.

Anonymous | 3/11/2008, 11:36 am EST

Madonna getting inducted before Rush, ELO, The Moody Blues, Cheap Trick, The Cars, Todd Rundgren, and many other more deserving artists is an example of how corrupt this Bruce Springsteen worshipping bunch are. Madonna and Bruce Springsteen are the most contrived performers that I know, Springsteen is just a poor man’s, poor man’s Bob Dylan and Madonna is about as talented and original as fake dog shit. It’s a sad time for music appreciation, obviously.

barrelchick | 3/11/2008, 11:36 am EST

As a 40 year old I remember listening to my 1st KISS record and seeing my first Madonna video……… we shouldn’t be so closed minded to “catagories.” KISS rocks hard and Madonna changed generations of women. There enough room for all in RRHOF! Don’t Hate.

Joe | 3/11/2008, 11:36 am EST

Clevelander:

I think you’re missing the point. There are people in the RRHOF from other genres, like blues or even country, but only because they has a great influence on rock music.

Madonna has had a huge influence on pop music, but absolutely ZERO influence on rock music. So she has no place here.

CalJ | 3/11/2008, 11:36 am EST

that Hall lineup again proves it’s a JOKE. where is Rush and Kiss? two true rockers??

beachbabe | 3/11/2008, 11:36 am EST

Where do they get off saying that she is R & R ?? She is definately POP.

Lisa | 3/11/2008, 11:36 am EST

I agree with Bob 100%. Let’s give some love to Leonard Cohen. Now THAT is one genius musician who has changed many lives with his music for many decades. Congratulations Leonard! A Thousand Kisses to you!

Anonymous | 3/11/2008, 11:36 am EST

Madonna getting inducted before Rush, ELO, The Moody Blues, Cheap Trick, The Cars, Todd Rundgren, and many other more deserving artists is an example of how corrupt this Bruce Springsteen worshipping bunch are. Madonna and Bruce Springsteen are the most contrived performers that I know, Springsteen is just a poor man’s, poor man’s Bob Dylan and Madonna is about as talented and original as fake dog shit. It’s a sad time for music appreciation, obviously.

Bo | 3/11/2008, 11:36 am EST

Justin Timberlake?!

HAHAHAHAHAHAHA HAHHAHA!!!!!!!!!

Joe | 3/11/2008, 11:36 am EST

Clevelander:

I think you’re missing the point. There are people in the RRHOF from other genres, like blues or even country, but only because they had a great influence on rock music.

Madonna has had a huge influence on pop music, but absolutely ZERO influence on rock music. So she has no place here.

Truth | 3/11/2008, 11:36 am EST

So Madonna played drums to Elvis Costello songs and learned guitar chords? What, is that an attempt to make it seem like she has rock credibility? Yeah, right. Chrissie Hynde said it best – Madonna was never rock and roll, she was disco.

loar33071 | 3/11/2008, 11:36 am EST

We live in the age of “American Idol”…just be thankful that there are still SOME artists left, who can remember what the dirty,empty clubs,poor sound systems,smelly buses, nasty vans,larcenous promoters,pea brained A&R weenies,backstabbing bandmates and pompous, self agrandizing critics are all about. Because, THAT is what gives Rock music it’s heart.

Granted, success changes everything and that a minor talent such as Madonna was able to transend her limitations and become more than a performer needs to be taken for what it is…but THAT is really the downside of the DREAM.

barrelchick | 3/11/2008, 11:36 am EST

As a 40 year old I remember listening to my 1st KISS record and seeing my first Madonna video……… we shouldn’t be so closed minded to “catagories.” KISS rocks hard and Madonna changed generations of women. There enough room for all in RRHOF! Don’t Hate.

beachbabe | 3/11/2008, 11:36 am EST

Where do they get off saying that she is R & R ?? She is definately POP.

Joe | 3/11/2008, 11:36 am EST

Clevelander:

I think you’re missing the point. There are people in the RRHOF from other genres, like blues or even country, but only because they had a great influence on rock music.

Madonna has had a huge influence on pop music, but absolutely ZERO influence on rock music. So she has no place here.

Lisa | 3/11/2008, 11:36 am EST

I agree with Bob 100%. Let’s give some love to Leonard Cohen. Now THAT is one genius musician who has changed many lives with his music for many decades. Congratulations Leonard! A Thousand Kisses to you!

Mark | 3/11/2008, 11:36 am EST

Dave Clark Five rules, but i would of covered “bits & peices” and then kick Billy Joel off the fnnnnnnnnn stage!

sfd691 | 3/11/2008, 11:36 am EST

rock and roll hall of fame? more like a hard rock cafe without a bar.

beachbabe | 3/11/2008, 11:36 am EST

Where do they get off saying that she is R & R ?? She is definately POP.

Robert | 3/11/2008, 11:36 am EST

1. Why did not Madonna sing?????

2. It’s a crying shame that the RRHOF waited so long to induct the DC5. It’d have been great to see them play together if they had been inducted earlier.

3. Why were the Ventures not part of the end of the ceremony jam.

4. It’s too bad that they could not get more the musicians involved with Gamble and Huff to play at the ceremony, eg O’Jays, Billy Paul, etc.

EC | 3/11/2008, 11:36 am EST

Mellencamp named his son Speck after his grandfather. Just an FYI.

Reyad | 3/11/2008, 11:36 am EST

What a waste, if only they knew. What was J Timb doing there anyway. Madonna aint a rocker, wasn’t a rocker and will never be one. Whatever………

cherwin2121 | 3/11/2008, 11:36 am EST

Congratulations to the Dave Clark 5! They should have been in LONG AGO!Their music is timeless and never seem to get the recognition they deserve. It’s sad that two of them didn’t get to realize the experience. Love you guys!!!

Anonymous | 3/11/2008, 11:36 am EST

How about Jethro Tull? Still touring and selling out venues 40 years later.

TOMMY D | 3/11/2008, 11:36 am EST

ANYONE WHO THIKS MADONNA OR JUSTIN T IS ROCK & ROLL HAS BEEN LIVING UNDER A ROCK.WHAT ABOUT BLACK LABEL SOCEITY/RUSH/38 SPECIAL PAT TRAVERS/ OZZY I COULD NAME A MILLION MORE.

Really Madonna????? | 3/11/2008, 11:36 am EST

Madonna inducted in the ROCK AND ROLL HALL OF FAME….GET REAL. That’s like well, I can’t think of a worse example except for maybe Rap stars.She is one of the most talent less peolpe on the plantet, just a great marketing person, she can sell anything.

Bo | 3/11/2008, 11:36 am EST

Justin Timberlake?!

HAHAHAHAHAHAHA HAHHAHA!!!!!!!!!

Lisa | 3/11/2008, 11:36 am EST

I agree with Bob 100%. Let’s give some love to Leonard Cohen. Now THAT is one genius musician who has changed many lives with his music for many decades. Congratulations Leonard! A Thousand Kisses to you!

Lisa | 3/11/2008, 11:36 am EST

I agree with Bob 100%. Let’s give some love to Leonard Cohen. Now THAT is one genius musician who has changed many lives with his music for many decades. Congratulations Leonard! A Thousand Kisses to you!

Bo | 3/11/2008, 11:36 am EST

Justin Timberlake?!

HAHAHAHAHAHAHA HAHHAHA!!!!!!!!!

Lisa | 3/11/2008, 11:36 am EST

I agree with Bob 100%. Let’s give some love to Leonard Cohen. Now THAT is one genius musician who has changed many lives with his music for many decades. Congratulations Leonard! A Thousand Kisses to you!

Lisa | 3/11/2008, 11:36 am EST

I agree with Bob 100%. Let’s give some love to Leonard Cohen. Now THAT is one genius musician who has changed many lives with his music for many decades. Congratulations Leonard! A Thousand Kisses to you!

Lisa | 3/11/2008, 11:36 am EST

I agree with Bob 100%. Let’s give some love to Leonard Cohen. Now THAT is one genius musician who has changed many lives with his music for many decades. Congratulations Leonard! A Thousand Kisses to you!

Tull Fan | 3/11/2008, 11:37 am EST

Your so right Gary. Tull should have been inducted years ago. Ian Anderson has more talent in his pinkie toe then Madonna.

Robert B | 3/11/2008, 11:37 am EST

What about The Allman Brothers Band and Kansas?? If Duane Allman hadn’t died so young he would have changed rock and roll.

And if they’re going to induct pop artists then they should induct Gino Vannelli. 15 albums of the greatest music on the planet, not to mention the best live voice ever.

Johnnya | 3/11/2008, 11:37 am EST

I’m glad to see there’s so many Rush fans out there. It’s time to stop the nonsense and put these three gentlemen in the hall!

EC | 3/11/2008, 11:37 am EST

Mellencamp named his son Speck after his grandfather. Just an FYI.

JOSH | 3/11/2008, 11:37 am EST

Can someone please get IGGY off the stage and put a shirt on him.

Mike | 3/11/2008, 11:37 am EST

The Mummy 4!!!??? Oh, it’s just Iggy Pop and Madonna.

Mick | 3/11/2008, 11:37 am EST

About time the Ventures get in there! Any self-respecting classic rocker from back in the day listened to their share of Ventures and other surf tunes from the 60s. What group hasn’t played Wipeout! We still play Ventures stuff and other surf tunes in our classic gigs and the teenagers just love it. Rock On Ventures!

schnazzybo | 3/11/2008, 11:37 am EST

I hope Im in that good a condition when im 60, Go IGGY

Patriot | 3/11/2008, 11:37 am EST

“This country has been hijacked,” Joel said.

It seems Joel, Johnny Cougar, and their ilk have done alright in this “hijacked” country. Why do these a**wipes always have to introduce their divisive politics into entertainment award festivites?

loar33071 | 3/11/2008, 11:37 am EST

We live in the age of “American Idol”…just be thankful that there are still SOME artists left, who can remember what the dirty,empty clubs,poor sound systems,smelly buses, nasty vans,larcenous promoters,pea brained A&R weenies,backstabbing bandmates and pompous, self agrandizing critics are all about. Because, THAT is what gives Rock music it’s heart.

Granted, success changes everything and that a minor talent such as Madonna was able to transend her limitations and become more than a performer needs to be taken for what it is…but THAT is really the downside of the DREAM.

Jenn | 3/11/2008, 11:37 am EST

Pop is NOT Rock-and-Roll!

Sure Madonna’s music is the earmark of that genre of music, and I even like some of her stuff, but it still doesn’t pass for Rock!

And Timberlake doing the induction?! EEK!

Iggy is the only one who deserves to be there!

Dennis | 3/11/2008, 11:37 am EST

I love Iggy Pop, because for God’s sake, hy would anyone want to perform those rotten Maddona songs! R & R HOF is a joke anyway. If it was up to me, the Stooges, NY Dolls, The Jam, Mott he Hoople, & T. Rex would have been in there already, and idiots like Maddona out. Also, keep that freak Timberlake away….he has nothing to do with Rock and Roll.

Sara Lee | 3/11/2008, 11:37 am EST

Rush fans – boycott the Rock and Roll hall of fame!

daveyboy | 3/11/2008, 11:38 am EST

jethro tull!

roman | 3/11/2008, 11:38 am EST

Madonna? She doesn’t play an intrument. She doesn’t sing well–needs backing tracks. Her “composed” songs are derivative. Hall of fame?

Patriot | 3/11/2008, 11:38 am EST

“This country has been hijacked,” Joel said.

It seems Joel, Johnny Cougar, and their ilk have done alright in this “hijacked” country. Why do these a**wipes always have to introduce their divisive politics into entertainment award festivites?

LOOP281 | 3/11/2008, 11:38 am EST

ALL THIS DOESN’T MATTER ANYWAY,WHEN YOU DIE YOU EITHER GO TO HEAVEN OR HELL EITHER WAY ITS NOT UP TO YOU ANYMORE WHAT HAPPENS THEN. SO RELAX ENJOY LIFE.

LOOP281 | 3/11/2008, 11:38 am EST

ALL THIS DOESN’T MATTER ANYWAY,WHEN YOU DIE YOU EITHER GO TO HEAVEN OR HELL EITHER WAY ITS NOT UP TO YOU ANYMORE WHAT HAPPENS THEN. SO RELAX ENJOY LIFE.

Dot Com | 3/11/2008, 11:38 am EST

Madonna is a “Sultry Milf”

Monica69 | 3/11/2008, 11:38 am EST

Seriously where is LED ZEPPELIN or THE DOORS? Why Madonna? She is pop not rock and why is Justin Pussylake the one inducting her? Hes good for his type of music (POP) Why is either one of them in ROCK N ROLL hall of fame ceremony anyway?!

LOOP281 | 3/11/2008, 11:38 am EST

ALL THIS DOESN’T MATTER ANYWAY,WHEN YOU DIE YOU EITHER GO TO HEAVEN OR HELL EITHER WAY ITS NOT UP TO YOU ANYMORE WHAT HAPPENS THEN. SO RELAX ENJOY LIFE.

shell | 3/11/2008, 11:38 am EST

Leave it to Justin to kick Britney while she is down. Just what she needs-if that is the kind of person he is then he would be good to be an EX

LOOP281 | 3/11/2008, 11:38 am EST

ALL THIS DOESN’T MATTER ANYWAY,WHEN YOU DIE YOU EITHER GO TO HEAVEN OR HELL EITHER WAY ITS NOT UP TO YOU ANYMORE WHAT HAPPENS THEN. SO RELAX ENJOY LIFE.

LOOP281 | 3/11/2008, 11:38 am EST

ALL THIS DOESN’T MATTER ANYWAY,WHEN YOU DIE YOU EITHER GO TO HEAVEN OR HELL EITHER WAY ITS NOT UP TO YOU ANYMORE WHAT HAPPENS THEN. SO RELAX ENJOY LIFE.

susieQ | 3/11/2008, 11:38 am EST

Madonna in my opinion is NOT a role model. When my kids were young she had her books with explicit sex scenes and she cussed all the time. now 20 years later she doesn’t even let her daughter watch TV. She writes childrens books PLEEEASE. She is talented yes but NOT someone I would want my kids to look up too.

Laurie | 3/11/2008, 11:39 am EST

spingirl12 | 3/11/2008, 11:39 am EST

boogie wtfbomb are you talking about. That guy Justin has a couple and not a girl at all. It’s not about who he dated and he has moved on and he is a better man because of it.

TFan | 3/11/2008, 11:39 am EST

What about Jethro Tull? Still touring and selling out venues 40 years later

rebekah | 3/11/2008, 11:39 am EST

meh it was boring for the most part, and i missed the leonard cohen induction. that would have been nice. how come no pictures of him in the slide show? who wants to see madonna? and justin whateverhisnameis … not me … blah.

roman | 3/11/2008, 11:39 am EST

Madonna? She doesn’t play an instrument. She doesn’t sing well–needs backing tracks. Her “composed” songs are derivative. Hall of fame?

Ozzy Daltrey | 3/11/2008, 11:40 am EST

Iggy, now I know where the Pop came from in Iggy Pop. If I could find out what they did with real R n’ R.

Spotty | 3/11/2008, 11:40 am EST

Rush Blows!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Scurvydog | 3/11/2008, 11:40 am EST

Up the Irons !

Britti | 3/11/2008, 11:40 am EST

I agree with Anubis8!

If you don't love America | 3/11/2008, 11:40 am EST

For Madonna fans especially, look she was born her, but decided to turn her back on her country that has given her the freedom to choose what she want ed to do in life, let alone made it possible for her to become famous and rich. My sentiments on this is that is should not even be allowed to return to the country where we have men and women dying every day to protect us from terrorism and others that want only destroy what our country represents. Shame on Madonna and shame on the Rock-n- Roll Hall of Fame for even considering her as a candidate of an award and then giving her one. I have no respect for her what-so-ever and feel she should be stripped of her title. If they can take Johnny Bench’s Baseball hallof fame from himm for gambling which is a far worse offende than turning your back on your country than she needs to be completely booted the hell out of here and never allowed to return nor be inducted into any time of Hall of Fame. Now that is how I feel about it, Bruce Carter

bigbalddave | 3/11/2008, 11:40 am EST

Madonna is in the Rock and Roll HOF and KISS isn’t? A true sign of the apocalypse!

lionbard | 3/11/2008, 11:40 am EST

To all the Rush haters, get over it.

Fact remains is that Rush deserves the recognition of the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame for it’s contribution to Rock and Roll. It does NOT however define them. Rush has the best fans in the world. If you don’t believe it, watch the DVD Rush in Rio and look at the crowd during YYZ. The crowd is singing along with an instrumental song. A sea of 40,000 screaming fans and most of them under the age of 30. If that doesn’t prove they belong, I just don’t know what else can.

MAINNIX | 3/11/2008, 11:40 am EST

HOW ABOUT THE MONKEES!!!

Jimmy James | 3/11/2008, 11:40 am EST

I’d rather watch VH1 Rock Honors. At least then you’ve got real ROCK icons.

rjcundiff1 | 3/11/2008, 11:41 am EST

What about Neil Diamond? He’s been around for 40 years, has written songs that are remade by current artists on a regular basis, worked with Rick Rubin, and sold out more shows than Elvis…where’s the justice?

MAINNIX | 3/11/2008, 11:41 am EST

HOW ABOUT THE MONKEES!!!

Bridgette Champagne | 3/11/2008, 11:41 am EST

UNISON, AMEN TO THAT. I AGREE WITH YOU 100% ON THAT. THESE PEOPLE JSUT UNDERSTAND WHAT REAL MUSIC IS. THEY’RE JUST LOSERS. WAY TO GO!! I GIVE YOU MAD PROPS FOR SAYING ALL OF THAT. BECAUSE IT WAS TRUE!!!!!

Rolan | 3/11/2008, 11:41 am EST

Wow! untill now it’s still Madonna that’s why shes the living legend.

M Frederick | 3/11/2008, 11:41 am EST

How the hell is it that Madonna got in before any of the artists that have been listed previously? Rush, Kiss, Neil Diamond, Chicago! All these bands have had incredible success during their hayday and have continued to be relevant or have had a second coming at some point. What’s up G.Lee!

Inigo | 3/11/2008, 11:41 am EST

Why the f..k has madonna been inducted into the Rock and Roll hall of fame. She didn’t sing rock and roll.

BC | 3/11/2008, 11:41 am EST

I think madonna is awesome, but she doesnt belong in the rock and roll hall of fame. There SHOULD be a hall of fame for her kind of music though, and all kinds of music for that matter.

Matt X | 3/11/2008, 11:42 am EST

hey G. Lee & Mack, the reason why yes and rush aren’t in there is because they both suck – well, maybe rush, but definitely Yes. oh yeah, and Genesis and the Doobie Brothers too (wait, are they already in?)

what? | 3/11/2008, 11:42 am EST

Alice cooper? what the hell are you talking about? ALICE COOPER? HE’S A STUPID LAME ASS SHIT! GROW UP!

WHAT A JOKE! | 3/11/2008, 11:42 am EST

Madonna should be in pop of fame not rock n roll hall of fame. I used to be a big fan of hers until she finally made a concert appearance back in Michigan (her hometown) after numerous years of waiting to charge hundreds of dollars just to see her and then the concert was aired on HBO for FREE a week later. She can just GO AWAY and STAY AWAY as far as I’m concerned!!

PadeLee | 3/11/2008, 11:42 am EST

I will never go to “The Rock and Roll” Hall of fame. They have ignored The Moody Blues for years and induct nthe likes of The jackson 5 and master P. Give me a Break. What a Joke this place is.

margaret o ' sullivan | 3/11/2008, 11:42 am EST

madonna is more rock and role than anyone. She was one of the few female musicians singer/songwriters out there and in front. She opened a lot of doors for females in music and its about time they started acknowledging a lot more female musicians.

Bill | 3/11/2008, 11:42 am EST

Bill Maher left out the Dick Head-in-Chief: Himself

Here’s a Dick Head whose only talent is the degradation of those he doesn’t like. Someone needs to advise this Dick Head that that’s no talent.

Hope this isn’t deleted as it is one of the Most Popular headliners above.

Laurie | 3/11/2008, 11:42 am EST

The Progressive Rock Hall of Fame does better:
The 2008 Inductees are:

Yes

Kansas

Gentle Giant

UK

King Crimson

jason | 3/11/2008, 11:42 am EST

while some of 2008;s r and r hall richly deserve induction,how can TEN YEARS AFTER not be desreving of the honor.WOODSTOCK icons top ten hits and one of the greatest live acts in music history,and are still touring the world.

jason | 3/11/2008, 11:42 am EST

while some of 2008;s r and r hall richly deserve induction,how can TEN YEARS AFTER not be desreving of the honor.WOODSTOCK icons top ten hits and one of the greatest live acts in music history,and are still touring the world.

DeathWish | 3/11/2008, 11:42 am EST

Its just music… there is much more important stuff goin on in the world…

Shug | 3/11/2008, 11:43 am EST

I agree to this point; it is called the rock and roll hall of fame. It i not he hip hop, pop, or rap hall of fame. As he origins of rock stem from folk, jazz, and blues, I could see famous artists from those specific genres (branching to country) being added… in otherwords ACTUAL musicians/songwriters… not just performes. Otherwise, just throw John Travolta in there while your at it

jason | 3/11/2008, 11:43 am EST

while some of 2008;s r and r hall richly deserve induction,how can TEN YEARS AFTER not be desreving of the honor.WOODSTOCK icons top ten hits and one of the greatest live acts in music history,and are still touring the world.

Gene in FL | 3/11/2008, 11:43 am EST

How is it that with some of the has beens & never weres “inducted” into the Hall of Fame, that one of the pioneers of early pop/rock NEIL SEDAKA isn’t there? It’s a travesty & a joke!

justafan | 3/11/2008, 11:43 am EST

I like all kinds of music. People are getting inducted into all kinds of Hall of Fames because of popularity only. Madonna is awesome no question about it. They just need a Hall of Fame appropriate for her genre of music.

estatic | 3/11/2008, 11:43 am EST

the fact that people are actually discussing names like madonna and timberlake in a forum related to the rock n roll fame is hilarious! both are very successful in their own rights, but c’mon this is rock n roll!!! rush, black crowes, kiss, etc.

Andy | 3/11/2008, 11:43 am EST

Let’s see,Madonna inducted into a hall of fame alongside Little Walter.Has anybody worse ever been enshrined with anybody greater in the history of Blatant Nonsense? Let us know. Thank you for the bad news.

mortgage man | 3/11/2008, 11:43 am EST

what about the most talented metal band of all time-iron maiden!!!!!

Justin | 3/11/2008, 11:43 am EST

I have read through some of the comments that you people have made. Some of you need to grow up. When you wake up each day and the only thing you have to do in your life is go on the net and bash people you do not even know..you’re life needs reworking.

KMack | 3/11/2008, 11:43 am EST

Enough Madonna talk…let’s talk about Mellencamp. Love his music now and loved it when he was ‘John Cougar.’ No matter what his name…his lyrics were/are great and to the point.

astral_stardust | 3/11/2008, 11:43 am EST

I agree with Alex Lifeson; this is all a joke. I feel sad for anyone stupid enough to actually be proud of being inducted.

Doesn't matter | 3/11/2008, 11:44 am EST

Who cares – rock n roll hall of fame. Same thing as a museum. Museum = mausoleum. To be inducted you might as well be dead. Thank thank thank goodnes for NEW INDIE rock. Put Madonna in there, Bruce Sprinsteen too (isn’t EVERYONE sick of him yet!), if it ain’t new it’s … OLD!

pontymania | 3/11/2008, 11:44 am EST

Too many awards and some non deserving..Why do we dishonor the Legends who left us..This is no talent, sorry..

Shera | 3/11/2008, 11:44 am EST

I love Madonna! She deserves the WORLD!

Stooge | 3/11/2008, 11:44 am EST

When do The Stooges go in?

Jen | 3/11/2008, 11:44 am EST

FYI Justin: YOU are a Michael Jackson wannabe.

what? | 3/11/2008, 11:45 am EST

Hall of fame was to recognised those who make an impact to the world of music and beyond..Alice cooper did jack shit except banging himself in the ass! At least Madonna make an impact to all music with her experimentation of different genre and fuse it together!

Boptop | 3/11/2008, 11:45 am EST

Captain Duck…Your comment at 9:12am about Iggy made me LMAO!!! Dude…do you do a stand up act anywhere? Too funny. Madonna does not in any way, shape, or form belong in the rock hall and in my opinion..Mellen head sucks but…I guess these lofty decisions come from the board of directors of the hall of shame..

UYA | 3/11/2008, 11:45 am EST

ALL POSTERS ARE STUIPED EXCEPT ME OF COURSE

Mikey0219 | 3/11/2008, 11:45 am EST

How can anybody look back at Madonna’s career and even dare to say she doesnt deserve this honor…..Back then there was no one like her, and till this day there has been no one like her…She was and still is a pioneer, she set the music world on fire…….and if it werent for her……I dont think there would have been stars like Missy Elliot or the Fergies…….Till this day she has always entertained me, and I have always enjoyed her performances…..She is my Elvis…and I love her and always will…..Please Madonna, never stop….NEVER!

Ted Wills | 3/11/2008, 11:45 am EST

Kai Dewey, if you have to use the Anglo-Saxon card, it must mean you don’t have a reason to argue. And thanks to anyone who reminded us that “Heart” still hasn’t been inducted. Hard to believe! madonna????? God help us all. Great entertainer maybe. Rock-n-roller… Never. Pointeeee breastesses. What was that? Marilyn Manson imitation?

little walter!!!! | 3/11/2008, 11:45 am EST

One of the greatest harmonica players of the last century was inducted as a sideman, should have been inducted a long time ago and not just a side man!!

Ryan | 3/11/2008, 11:45 am EST

Oh and by the way. . .I thought off topic remarks were supposed to be deleted. Someone please to tell Daddyo to shut the Hell up. I have a cousin who was killed in Iraq and a friend who is on his 3rd tour, you’re not special.

me | 3/11/2008, 11:46 am EST

so..madonna is cool and all. she was an integral part of growing up in the 80s, but her music is def. pop.

This is the ROCK & ROLL hall of fame…right?

i mean what is JT and patti labelle doing there? i’m not saying they are bad artists, but they are in a totally different genre of music.

they should change the name of the organization…

L. Barnett | 3/11/2008, 11:46 am EST

It’s a well known fact that Justin Timberlake is not a nice person for any woman to be around!

Anonymous | 3/11/2008, 11:46 am EST

Freakin Madonna what a joke this musta been some kinda insider politics she is NOT worthy! And don’t even get me started about Timberlake, all he is is a pretti boy why he’s involved is just to up the ratings

style | 3/11/2008, 11:46 am EST

WTF!!! rock and roll hall of fame… there could never be a pop hall of fame because of transition of pop music,,but rock is rock..why is madonna?and timberlake there..wtf.. hollee sh*t.. how could pop be rock? theres a lot of rock bands deserve to be there..shame!!!! a fan is disappointed here…how can they be AC/CD, Queen or Aerosmith? madonna didn’t perform because her music doesn’t fit in that genre… what a shame….

ecardoza | 3/11/2008, 11:46 am EST

MADONNA YOU ROCK!!!!!!!!!!!

what | 3/11/2008, 11:46 am EST

rock and roll hall of fame??

Liz | 3/11/2008, 11:47 am EST

CK I agree with you. It should be in the midwest. I think that it would have been a good PR move. Because I get that Madonna changed music, blah, blah, and she’s spiritual blah, blah. Her music is great because she had great producers. She’s not like the real artists who write, compose, produce, play, and can actually sing! If you took away all the help, what would you have?

Micki | 3/11/2008, 11:47 am EST

Hey come on!! Quit bashing Madonna! The woman changed the type of music we were listening to back in the ’80’s. If those of you who are too young to remember this, quit talking about her! Yes, Rush should be in there too, but that’s not Madonna’s fault. Rush’s 2112 album is one of the best albums ever released-I know! I was at the concert for that album!! But Madonna deserves to be there too!! She helped alot of us women realize that our sexuality was just as important as any man’s!!

Anonymous | 3/11/2008, 11:47 am EST

40oz – Beasties are not eligible yet AFAIK – it has to have been 25 years since the artist’s first commercial release. License to Ill was 22 years ago. I’m sure they had indie releases before that, but I doubt those are recognized by RRHF geezers.

They’ll make it when the time comes, that is, if anyone still cares.

Stephanie | 3/11/2008, 11:47 am EST

Why is Timberlake giving speeches in the Rock ‘N Roll Hall of Fame? What? Backstreet Boys weren’t available? Does he think he’s going to be inducted one day?

Josh | 3/11/2008, 11:47 am EST

Give me a break. Who the hell cares if Madonna got in and RUSH didn’t. The hall of fame itself is relatively new and still trying to build a name for itself will all people, not just metal/rock heads. Dont be surprised to see it turn into the Music Hall Of Fame or something. Since its inception it hasnt had a ton to do with ROCK (proper) but just random forms of music. The only reason Led Zeppelin was put in was to keep everone from rioting if they hadnt been. Thats just the way I see it.

Volkov | 3/11/2008, 11:48 am EST

The rock and roll Hall of Fame is in Cleveland. why don’t they have the ceremony in Ohio anymore? I’m a loyal Ohioan It pisses me off that they don’t hold the ceremony there.

ecardoza | 3/11/2008, 11:48 am EST

MADONNA CONGRATULATIONS YOU ROCK!!!!

Monica69 | 3/11/2008, 11:48 am EST

There are MANY MANY more bands that deserve it before Madonna she is ungrateful and highmaintance she’ll charge as much as she can for just one concert. But i dont know i dont think KISS should really be in there THE DOORS should be or Johnney Cash or is he already in there?

BRUNO | 3/11/2008, 11:48 am EST

HEY, I AM SERIOUS!!!
FRANKIE GOES TO HOLLYWOOD IS PLAYED EVERYDAY 7/24 BECAUSE THEY ARE GREAT. ALSO RSF (RIGHT SAID FRED) IS ONE OF THE BEST OUT THERE BUT THEY GET NO MENTION IN THE STATES.

cindy | 3/11/2008, 11:48 am EST

Madonna has never been Rock ‘n Roll, at least not the Rock ‘n Roll I grew up with; she’s a Pop Artist and so is Timberlake. Rock ‘n Roll goes back to the 50’s and 60’s – like Bill Haley & the Comets, Elvis, Rick Nelson, Frankie Avalon, Fabian – whatsamatter with you guys !!

BobbyA | 3/11/2008, 11:48 am EST

SO many others deserve to get in before Madonna. Rush, certainly. Heart for a truly groundbreaking female act. John Hiatt, Warren Zevon (wait, is he in?), Zombies…

Stinky Britches | 3/11/2008, 11:48 am EST

40oz – Beasties are not eligible yet AFAIK – it has to have been 25 years since the artist’s first commercial release. License to Ill was 22 years ago. I’m sure they had indie releases before that, but I doubt those are recognized by RRHF geezers.

They’ll make it when the time comes, that is, if anyone still cares.

what | 3/11/2008, 11:49 am EST

what about barney or julie andrews or hank williams

seeing blind | 3/11/2008, 11:49 am EST

I have the great privilege of saying i went to school with Getty Lee (founder of RUSH for the uneducated) in Canada. He is and will continue to be a shining star in the world of ROCK & ROLL. I also once was dragged to a Maddonna concert – please, this woman is talented, no doubt, but she is no rocker!

chaz | 3/11/2008, 11:49 am EST

Anyone who thinks Madonna hasn’t done enough to be in The Hall of Fame is an idiot. She, without a doubt, deserves to be inducted.

LOPEZ | 3/11/2008, 11:49 am EST

Why so much hate on Madonna? I know it was a Rock n Roll event but she still looks good compare to other women???

vadbhoi | 3/11/2008, 11:49 am EST

The Rolling stone encyclo of rock has it that mike smith of the DC5
was one of the Great unrecognized
Soul Shouters.AMEN! those guys were the first of the pop british invasion to “kick it!”

mikeman | 3/11/2008, 11:49 am EST

Get real,I downed Madonna early in her day. Then my ex g-friend made me listen to her. After a while she did not have to force me anymore. There are a lot of artists who belong there before her. But it is also very immature to say she doesn’t. Open upyour ears and broaden your scope of music. Then you will learn to appreciate what she has done in the music world. Thanks

Anonymous | 3/11/2008, 11:50 am EST

Rock & Roll has never been, and never will be, about positive role models for kids. If you are looking there for your kids’ role models then you are misled if not outright stupid. R&R is about energy, persistence, rebellion, and the cult of personality. All of these inductees earned their status.

Firegoddess | 3/11/2008, 11:50 am EST

Just a note – In case I missed it
Santana was inducged back in 98

: )

Telecaster | 3/11/2008, 11:50 am EST

They inducted Nat King Cole years ago.
He was great but had NOTHING to do with anything resembling rock and roll.
It doesn’t matter if it’s rock or not.

Shame.

Pre Madonna | 3/11/2008, 11:50 am EST

Madonna is the greatest female artist and will always be. Every female artist I see for the last 15 years get a little something from her, face it. Don’t hate

What's the deal? | 3/11/2008, 11:51 am EST

With all of the poor spelling, people? Take your time, man! spell it right.

--- | 3/11/2008, 11:51 am EST

Are you shitting me? Why the hell is Justin Timberlake part of all this and Madonna in the Rock N Roll Hall of Fame? Does not make sense. These people do not have anything to do with rock n roll. Plus, Justin is so obnoxious!

whatnot | 3/11/2008, 11:51 am EST

Madonna’s speech was long, attention starved and narcissistic and in the end, she said nothing at all. Sounds like her musical career. Iggy was great and his performance was the payoff to sitting through such a self-involved waste of time and space. On the complete other end of the spectrum Mel encamp is my hero now. His acceptance speech said so much about his country and the character of its people. To be able to convey his personal feeling about the direction this country is heading without beating you over the head with them, to thank the right people and have the balls to tell the rest of them to suck-it in the nicest way. He makes me so proud of the Midwest.

Kou | 3/11/2008, 11:51 am EST

…Really? Madonna..? Since When Was She Considered A Rock ‘n Roll Artist?
Eh…’Tis A Sad Day Indeed When People Think Madonna “Rocks”.
Rock ‘n Roll Is Truly Dead.

Jan | 3/11/2008, 11:51 am EST

Some of you guys are uneducated idiots. Everyone who actually does their research knows that there are not just Rock n’ Roll acts in the RRHOF. It’s been that way for a long time. And I’m sorry, like her or hate her, there’s not questioning her influence on music and pop culture. It’s incredible and very few artists, male or female have done more.

Kozziewozzie | 3/11/2008, 11:51 am EST

Madonna should be in a Hall of Fame of her own, together with the Justin Timberlake’s and Elton’s of this world. Brittney Spears these days though I getting really ‘rock ‘n roll’! bwahahahaha time for an induction!

bucket123 | 3/11/2008, 11:52 am EST

u can not define Rock & Roll music by the way it sounds. rock and roll is an attitude. all these bands rocked in different ways. i agree sum are left out, but to say someone is not worthy because YOU dont like the way they sound is against everything R & R is about!

LeviS. | 3/11/2008, 11:52 am EST

Madonna, Justin Whimperlake? Ok. It’s official! Just been re-named the ELEVATOR MUSIC HALL OF BORING! Why would Motley Crue, Alice Cooper or any other true rocker wanna’ be inducted after this lame party??

The real mccoy | 3/11/2008, 11:52 am EST

So all you haters out there don’t think madonna should be inducted? So, where are your top selling platinum records? Oh thats right you all don’t have any records that people enjoy and will continue to enjoy for years to come. Im not even a madonna fan, but give her a bit of respect. She does deserve to be inducted, and her musical legacy will surely outlast most others. *$#! genres, its all about good music in the end.
I listen to all types of music, and that being said I think that maybe a few of you posters should open your horizons, and find a few songs from 2008 to listen to.

Rich | 3/11/2008, 11:52 am EST

The R & R Hall of Fame is a joke for the most part. When you get so many nameless, barely able to make music people in it and you leave the greats of all time (Grand Funk, Rush, KISS) what a bunch of jerks (or should I say jerk) on the voting committee!

HBB | 3/11/2008, 11:52 am EST

When will the show be broadcasted again on the West Coast?

Bridgette Champagne | 3/11/2008, 11:52 am EST

SUSIEQ, YOUR A DUMB BITCH. MADONNA HAS BEEN AROUND FOR AGES.THE WAY SHE DOES THINGS JUST MEANS THAT SHE S HER OWN PERSON. NO ONE SAID THAT YOUR KIDS HAD TO LOOK UP TO HER. I LOVE HER, SHE AND HER MUSIC ARE GREAT. GET A GRIP ON REALTY.

Franklovesong | 3/11/2008, 11:53 am EST

There are a lot of ignorant comments going on here. Madonna, whether you like her or not, along with iggy pop and Bruce Springsteen have proven themselves to be relevant, entertaining artists. Criticize them and offer juvenile criticism all you want, they’re in the Rock and Roll hall of fame, you are posting on a wall on the internet on a site about them.

iggy | 3/11/2008, 11:53 am EST

madonna sucks so bad you have to be a damn fool to defend her induction. she does not rock and she never has. you can take timberlake and jam him too. Who is next , that freak Bjork? What about keeping the rrhof for those who rock, not idiot pipsqueak performers who dont even play instruments. Fuck Off!

macq1 | 3/11/2008, 11:53 am EST

the name should not be rock n roll hall of fame. Should be music hall…. most rock bands sound diff from one another and many musical styles are represented in the hall of fame that went against the rockers

Micken Keef | 3/11/2008, 11:54 am EST

By the way, the phrase “Rock and Roll” originally was a euphemism for sexual intercourse, and expanded to include, basically, anything that made old people nervous.

Madonna’s always had that in spades. Rush has never had that in any quantity. So get over it.

unappreciatedtruth | 3/11/2008, 11:54 am EST

Empty accolades from an empty world to empty celebrities. On the flipside, payday someday for the true heroes in life throughout the ages…the unsung heroes whose rewards are everlasting and untarnished, to those who trusted God and did their best to do His will. That is the ONLY Hall of Fame worth achieving. Hate the message if you want, the truth is the truth.

magz | 3/11/2008, 11:54 am EST

“According to The Guinness Book of World Records, Madonna is the Most Successful Female Recording Artist of All Time. She claims the second-longest string of consecutive Top Five hits – and the most by a female artist – with a run of 16 that extended from 1984’s “Lucky Star” to 1989’s “Cherish.” Furthermore, Madonna is the only recording artist for whom every album (except those from which no single was released) has yielded a Top Ten hit. Those are just a few of her more noteworthy feats.”
—Enough Said

come on | 3/11/2008, 11:54 am EST

barrney the purple dinosour is just as hard rocking as madonna
get him in too

drmike5451 | 3/11/2008, 11:55 am EST

Of course Madonna doesn’t deserve to be in the Hall ahead of classic Rock and Rollers but remember the only thing that matters in this country is the almighty dollar. It would be naive to expect that the RRHOF is to induct classic bands like Rush or KISS ahead of Madonna just to uphold the sanctity of pure Rock and Roll. Plain and simple, the RRHOF is going to induct performers that will help to attract more visitors. The Rock and Roll Hall of Fame has nothing to do with Rock and Roll, it has to do with making money.

RobG | 3/11/2008, 11:55 am EST

Let’s face it folks. Rock is dead. Turn on your radio and what do you hear? Bottie shaking top forty garbage with no message other than I’m the baddest mother out there, and F**k the world!

There was a time when rock meant something. A time when rockers were still the baddest mothers out there, but used their power to send a message to the establishment (fat old men in limos) that we weren’t going to sit on our hands and let them screw up the world. Now it’s all just BS lyrics based on self gratification and self promotion.

Now more than ever before, we need someone to step up and tell young people it’s time to take back our world and make it all it can be. All it should be. Rockers can’t do that. But they can help open the eyes of those who cannot see.
Rock On!

If you Love america&Its MUSIC! | 3/11/2008, 11:56 am EST

I ‘m amazed in the stretch it takes one to somehow relate the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame & Terrorism! Because a star decides to move to England. Now she’s unpatriotic, Unamarican & deserves to never be let in again!!!? This proves to me that people will create what they need to see in order to justify their own beliefs. If these are the things in which we choose to judge people- you better call Tina Turner also, and the many other rockers who no longer actually live in the states & tell them that they’re now considered traitors as well. With that easy statement we’ve just lost many many other talented artists who created rock & roll & helped make this country as great as it is. With MUSIC!! THATS called FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION! K bruce!? Freaks!

Jimi | 3/11/2008, 11:56 am EST

Madonna and especially her sheep fans make me puke a little in my mouth…they might as well add Fergie , Brittney Spears, Jessica Simpson, Macy Gray, and Hannah Montana to the Hall of Fame now…99.99998787656% of female musicians are horrid thats why they do pop so they can have somebody else write their music for them and not know how to play an instrument or if they do not be original with it….did you guys here about that new girl who just shreds the guitar and who’s band kicks a**…oh ya thats never happened

denmanjum | 3/11/2008, 11:56 am EST

It was a bit difficult for me to sit there and listen to Madonna go on and on and on…My god who cares? Who’s next, Paris Hilton?
When I think of Rock and Roll I think of people like,Muddy Waters,Chuck Berry,Rolling Stones,Lowell George,SRV etc. You know guys who actually play, who made you want to get up and scream!Who’s going to be there next year, Liberace?
The Ventures were way cool!

Madonna yo | 3/11/2008, 11:56 am EST

Madonna is da bomb! she wanted justin on stage but he kept whimpering and she just beeeeeeyotch slapped his ass!

Bearer of Knowledge | 3/11/2008, 11:57 am EST

Did Elvis create Rock & Roll? No. But he was inducted. Not hating or taking anything away from Elvis but was he nearly as innovative as Madonna? No, he was copying some moves and riffs that he heard black musicians playing in blues bands. Rock and Roll was born from different types of music and you shouldn’t expect the HOF to respect only rock music. Madonna changed the face of music not just for women but across the board. So…to those who have so much to say…until you are as awesome as either of these two or any of the people who YOU think should be inducted for that matter, keep your lame thoughts to yourself because you’re wrong. PERIOD.

Cdog | 3/11/2008, 11:57 am EST

My God…Madonna and Timberlake?
Rock my arse. Just look at the posts of all the rockers who aren’t in but should be. GFR also should be in. I don’t know who the morons are that elect these folks are or what the crierion is but true ROCKERS are shagrinned!

Old Rocker | 3/11/2008, 11:57 am EST

Beats the heck out of me how Leonard Cohen gets into the Hall of Fame and SRV is isn’t…Does anyone have a clue what Leonard Cohen’s contribution has been to Rock???? Anyone????? (Cue the crickets….)

jupitergod76 | 3/11/2008, 11:57 am EST

madonna is a icon,she has made her way through the decades,those who think she is not worthy or bad mouth her past and then judge her for her books,life etc and dont think shes a role model for their kids puuhleeez,let your kids look in your nightstands and your online fav’s and then judge her,so dont be a hater cause she has made it and her lil dirty secrets are not private like yours.your just jealous

Pug | 3/11/2008, 11:57 am EST

The only ones, in my opinion, that truly deserved the nomination was the “Dave Clark Five”. These guys were a big part of the music I grew up with. This induction was way over due.

katrin | 3/11/2008, 11:58 am EST

I love you justin … you are very handsome and good singer … i kiss you …

fruitato | 3/11/2008, 11:58 am EST

NO ONE in the history of music has gone as far, with such little actual TALENT than Madonna… with the possible exception of U2.

Tim M. | 3/11/2008, 11:58 am EST

After reading all the comments,there are so many bands and individuals that deserve to be in the so called”Rock&Roll Hall of Fame”,before(or at all)other acts that have made it.Remember the Jackson Five getting in!!PLEASE!!If they called it the “POP Music Hall of Fame”,it would make more sense.When I went to Cleveland,I was more than a little disappointed.Somebody should start a real R&R H.O.F. !!

little t | 3/11/2008, 11:58 am EST

Rock draws from a seductive melting pot of influences – it is impossible not to dive into the myriad pop, blues, dance, jazz, funk, rap, country, hip-hop, folk, reggae, gospel, world, soul and R&B aritsts that dance alongside their rockier counterparts in telling the story of ROCK music. Some artists don’t use the four letter term to identify themselves. If your offended that Eminem could be inducted right next to Pink Floyd then sell all your music cause you couldn’t hear talent if it bit you in the ass! If Madonna played the drums along to Elvis Costello’s music where do you think her genius came from? So while you all sit there and poll eachother on whether KISS or Chicago should be inducted next, I think I’ll will go listen to “The Immaculate Collection”

rock | 3/11/2008, 11:58 am EST

led zeppelin
pink floyd ac dc and madonna rock and roll royalty
oh thats right madonnas not rock and roll oh well

Ray1bigdaddy | 3/11/2008, 11:58 am EST

Madonna is a genius. She did it her way and she did it big. Congratulations Material Girl.

Ari | 3/11/2008, 11:59 am EST

RRHOF is a COMMERCIAL enterprise. Those that choose the inductees have sold their souls to the almighty dollar. Madonna is/was a PERFORMER not an MUSICIAN and her induction brought lots of attention to the soulless bastards that nominated her. If that were just a ceremony for The Ventures, Dave Clark 5 and Leonard Cohen, no one would be talking today.

VicyCat | 3/11/2008, 11:59 am EST

Madonna- puh lease she’s pop, they have completely twisted what the very element of Rock once was by calling this- stay-in-the-trends- princess de pop. My god what about KISS!!! One of the most influential rock bands in histrory! What about Heart ! Why the hell is a legend like Iggy redoing Madonna crap… The rock n roll hall of fame has truly lost it’s founders’ vision.

LOOP281 | 3/11/2008, 11:59 am EST

QUIT WHINNING PEOPLE.

VicyCat | 3/11/2008, 11:59 am EST

Madonna- puh lease she’s pop, they have completely twisted what the very element of Rock once was by calling this- stay-in-the-trends- princess de pop. My god what about KISS!!! One of the most influential rock bands in histrory! What about Heart ! Why the hell is a legend like Iggy redoing Madonna crap… The rock n roll hall of fame has truly lost it’s founders’ vision.

SMITH | 3/11/2008, 12:00 pm EST

RUSHRUSHRUSHRUSHRUSHRUSHRUSHRU SHRUSHRUSHRUSHRUSHRUSHRUSHRUSH RUSHRUSHRUSHRUSHRUSHRUSHRUSHRU SHRUSHRUSHRUSHRUSHRUSHRUSHRUSH RUSHRUSHRUSHRUSHRUSHRUSHRUSHRU SHRUSHRUSHRUSHRUSHRUSHRUSHRUSH RUSHRUSHRUSHRUSHRUSHRUSHRUSHRU SHRUSHRUSHRUSHRUSHRUSHRUSHRUSH RUSHRUSHRUSHRUSHRUSHRUSHRUSHRU SHRUSHRUSHRUSHRUSHRUSHRUSHRUSH RUSHRUSHRUSHRUSHRUSHRUSHRUSHRU SHRUSHRUSHRUSHRUSHRUSHRUSHRUSH RUSHRUSHRUSHRUSHRUSHRUSHRUSHRU SHRUSHRUSH

skullbonz | 3/11/2008, 12:00 pm EST

Madonna is the queen of music,attitude and style. No one will ever compare to her and she deserves any award that comes her way. For those that don’t like her,stick to your polkas. I Love You Madonna,you ROCK.

katrin listen up | 3/11/2008, 12:00 pm EST

yo kiss me baby justin smokes pickles not ur kisses! give me sum suga babbbbyyyy

Rokker Chick | 3/11/2008, 12:00 pm EST

Madonna does not deserve to be
in the Rock and Roll hall of Fame.
That is so unfair that there are
many other great “rock” bands
out there and she gets chosen..She’s not even rock she’s pop! WHAT A JOKE!

REAL Rock Fan | 3/11/2008, 12:00 pm EST

I had to post one more time. I don’t think we “Madonna Haters” are saying she didn’t sell millions of albums or establish herself as a star. She did. What we are saying is that there is a difference between true Rock n Roll and the kind of music she has been a part of. If you like Madonna…hey that’s fine…to each their own. Just don’t sit there and tell real rock fans that she is rock and roll…we know better.

Slopoke71 | 3/11/2008, 12:01 pm EST

Daddyoh, maybe you could go live in Madonnas place. Just leave the country and shutup!

Debbie | 3/11/2008, 12:01 pm EST

What about Meatloaf? Now he rocks!

Slopoke71 | 3/11/2008, 12:01 pm EST

Daddyoh, maybe you could go live in Madonnas place. Just leave the country and shutup!

Anonymous | 3/11/2008, 12:01 pm EST

I think Madonna is an example how somebody with very average musical talent to say a least got everything out of nothing. I think she is a talented person but not a talented musician. I have not watched the show but as you say she did not perform, which I think is another smart move of hers. In her latest photos she looks very different. She looks as somebody else. I tried in vein to figure out what part of her face she altered. Being 50 must be hard for the material girl.

mag | 3/11/2008, 12:01 pm EST

I think Madonna is an example how somebody with very average musical talent to say a least got everything out of nothing. I think she is a talented person but not a talented musician. I have not watched the show but as you say she did not perform, which I think is another smart move of hers. In her latest photos she looks very different. She looks as somebody else. I tried in vein to figure out what part of her face she altered. Being 50 must be hard for the material girl.

Ray1bigdaddy gag me! | 3/11/2008, 12:02 pm EST

wtf! turn off ur computer and get a life.

rebe | 3/11/2008, 12:02 pm EST

The reason Madonna got the award and not yet some of these other past RnR artists is because no one hears about them anymore. Madonna has been popular since the 80’s, into the 90’s and up until now. she does have alot of talent and is always reinventing herself. We should be happy for her. As for the christian bashing comments, that isnt necessary. Im a christian and love madonna. There are so many christians that feel the same way i do. Just because you have a few ignorant few that claim to be christian who are bashing Madonna, are not true christians. Stop judging christians like we are all hateful hipocrits.

easteurope | 3/11/2008, 12:03 pm EST

I think Madonna is an example how somebody with very average musical talent to say a least got everything out of nothing. I think she is a talented person but not a talented musician. I have not watched the show but as you say she did not perform, which I think is another smart move of hers. In her latest photos she looks very different. She looks as somebody else. I tried in vein to figure out what part of her face she altered. Being 50 must be hard for the material girl.

Rock 4 Ever | 3/11/2008, 12:03 pm EST

Whoever the idiots are that run the Rock Hall of Fame, someone needs to tell them Madonna is not a rocker. The artists they induct are LAME. I think someone needs to start a new Rock Hall of Fame, a REAL one.

marykary | 3/11/2008, 12:04 pm EST

I heard madonna wasnt a virgin when she wrote material girl? anyone know?

Kay | 3/11/2008, 12:04 pm EST

Madonna is a legend.. She is a singer, Business women, mother.. she has paid her dues..as far as this white trash rockers.. get over it.. no metal will EVER be in the hall of fame.. PLEASE!!! She is awesome…and deserves her award.. so rockers like the guy who went to school with getty lee.. didnt they die in the 80s.. anyway.. GET OVER IT.. Madonna is awesome!

Melaniekg | 3/11/2008, 12:05 pm EST

Just wondering what 7th grade, pre-pubescent boy wrote Justin Timberlake’s speech regarding Madonna?

tvas | 3/11/2008, 12:05 pm EST

Elvis invented rockabilly. That’s an entire genre of music. Hello.

gtw | 3/11/2008, 12:05 pm EST

madonna is famous for her fashion looks, daring video’s and sticking it out so long in the industry and thats maybe a reason why she deserves to get heralded. However an occasion is missed to point out more obscure artists who make inventive and staying music women like anette peacock, a true original

blah | 3/11/2008, 12:05 pm EST

Monica69 should keep quiet. do you even know what your talking about the whole top floor although not that big is dedicated to THE DOORS

JudyLou | 3/11/2008, 12:05 pm EST

Good for them for getting in the R&RHOF. But I think it’s a political and money deal. Why hasn’t Wanda Jackson, THE first rockabilly woman singer, been inducted? She is the roots of rock & roll, along with Elvis. She dated Elvis, for God’s sake!

sam | 3/11/2008, 12:05 pm EST

what is this about

WILDCAT66 | 3/11/2008, 12:05 pm EST

Give me a break! Madonna inducted into the hall of fame? Mellancamp,The Ventures and Dave Clark are the only ones that should have got in. I can think of alot of true R&R artist that deserve to be in there alot more than Madonna. And Iggy Pop needs to realize he is not 20 anymore. What an asshole!

sam | 3/11/2008, 12:05 pm EST

what is this about

the WHO? | 3/11/2008, 12:05 pm EST

MADONNA SHOULD NOT AND NEVER SHOULD BE INDUCTED,SHE CAN’T SING,THE ONLY REASON WHY PEOPLE BUY HER MUSIC WAS BECAUSE SHE DRESSES UP RAUNCHY COSTUMES AND AND SHE CAN’T SING GOOD.SHE’S NOT A ROCK N ROLL SINGER MY GOSH…THE WHO NOW THAT WAS A ROCK GROUP.HEY MADONNA…WHO ARE YOU?

sam | 3/11/2008, 12:05 pm EST

what is this about

I emailed | 3/11/2008, 12:05 pm EST

the R&R HOF when I heard about Madonna being nominated. Their response was that she was nominated because she was popular and an influence. I agreed, but said she wasn’t an influence on R&R. Always hated Madonna, talentless and overhyped/marketed. Shock does not talent make. HOF is a joke.

reason | 3/11/2008, 12:06 pm EST

Message: for the people above..get a life!!! WHO cares!!!!!!!!

MetalMaiden | 3/11/2008, 12:06 pm EST

OK, I really don’t have a problem per say. I agree that there are other bands that have ROCKED for 25 years or more that deserve it more than Madonna! Bands like DEF LEPPARD, that still go on tours every year! When was the last time she had one? What can you say coming from people that give Tull the first HEAVY METAL AWARD?

Rick Vannoy | 3/11/2008, 12:06 pm EST

I am a rock and roll fan. I’d REALLY like to know WHAT Madonna and several others inductees contribution to Rock and Roll are? This is a joke. If this were a performers hall of fame then I could agree on the selection of Madonna. But for Rock and Roll? Give me a break!!

reason | 3/11/2008, 12:06 pm EST

Message: for the people above..get a life!!! WHO cares!!!!!!!!

steveie | 3/11/2008, 12:06 pm EST

Madonna should wait another 25 yrs ! at least to be inducted!
This rock ‘n roll hall of fame is way out line.
Ten years after, chicago ….
What about them?

The chic in the cube next to.. | 3/11/2008, 12:06 pm EST

me just sharted. It really stinks, like really really bad.

Xandra_96 | 3/11/2008, 12:06 pm EST

hey-hey! madonna is great! i love her! i want to sing…….aaaaammmm……rock ….perhaps…….or……..aa aaaaaammmmmmmmmm…………ra p……….=))=)) hahaha….that is very funy….see ya

Jimi | 3/11/2008, 12:06 pm EST

Saying Madonna rocks is like saying Dave Matthews is the greatest gangster rapper of all time…

Miti | 3/11/2008, 12:07 pm EST

Congratulations Madonna

barney | 3/11/2008, 12:08 pm EST

madonna should also be in the country music hall of fame
and the polka hall of fame
she is a rock country polka legend!!
oh thats right shes a pop singer
anyway maybe the tejano hall of fame

Monica69 | 3/11/2008, 12:08 pm EST

HOW ABOUT MEGADETH!

MaryKary asks the... | 3/11/2008, 12:09 pm EST

STUPIDEST question of the day. Congratulations for your irrelevance, ya dopey turnip!!

EricH | 3/11/2008, 12:09 pm EST

Madonna in the rrhof.???? Isn’t Pat Benatar one of the few that truly rocked and opened the door for all these girls. She would be more deserving… and overdue IMO.

John | 3/11/2008, 12:10 pm EST

Madonna is terrible, her music is worse. She is not a good person.

John | 3/11/2008, 12:10 pm EST

Madonna is terrible, her music is worse. She is not a good person.

John | 3/11/2008, 12:10 pm EST

Madonna is terrible, her music is worse. She is not a good person.

beet | 3/11/2008, 12:11 pm EST

Hey Timberlake,nobody gives a rats dick about the washed up whores that you dated!

Mr.Madonna | 3/11/2008, 12:12 pm EST

HELLO BRAINWASHED SOCIETY ,,, !!!!!! ROCK AND ROLL IS NOT AN IMAGE BUT A MUSIC AND IT CAN BE EXPRESSED IN MANY DIFFERENT WAY,LIGHT OR TOTALLY METAL,,,,,,,, DO YOUR HOMEWORK ,,,MADONNA IS A ROCKS MORE THAN ANY ROCKER

Blue | 3/11/2008, 12:12 pm EST

Madonna is ugly too.

Dawn M | 3/11/2008, 12:12 pm EST

wait a minute… did Madonna play her own instruments? I mean after all, isn’t THAT the big stink that’s keeping the MONKEES out? At least you can actually classify Stepping Stone as Rock N Roll!

Hey sam | 3/11/2008, 12:12 pm EST

idk as far as i can see this is about a bunch of idiots talking about madonna and other losers?

Dino | 3/11/2008, 12:13 pm EST

If Madonna was inducted why Donna Summer wasn’t? Donna Summer has all kind of genres in her catelog from R&B, Pop Rock, Soft Rock, Dance & more. Those voters are just a bunch of idiots!!!!

CHICAGO | 3/11/2008, 12:13 pm EST

Congrats to all musicians who achieve their dreams, regardless of the genre.

And to all postings on this page, learn how to appreciate the diversity in the world.

brenny | 3/11/2008, 12:13 pm EST

In regards to all the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame remarks…What is with you people? Sounds like envy of everything and everyone. Why can’t you just be happy or be miserable in private. You want to see something happen then stop complaining and do something constructive about it. People make it in this world by shear tenacity and usually working for it. Very few in any industry especially the music industry get anything handed to them. So I say if you love it Rock On otherwise shut up. Be happy, make a joyful noise and change the attitude.

pro madonna | 3/11/2008, 12:13 pm EST

Keep doing what you are doin, you are the greatest, I love about you that you dont take yourself seriously Mdonna, you are wonderful.

Randy | 3/11/2008, 12:14 pm EST

The original Grand Funk Railroad with Mark Farner …. the most influential band EVER with the exception of the Beatles…. and they are not in ????

Music makes my world go round! | 3/11/2008, 12:15 pm EST

No laurie, madonna is still a virgin!

mikeyla | 3/11/2008, 12:15 pm EST

Madonna influenced a lot of girls to wear lace on their heads.
She has no influence on rock and roll.
Joan Jett had influenced many girls to play guitar.

Madonna Sucks | 3/11/2008, 12:15 pm EST

Is she even a musician? She didn’t write those songs, or play an instrument. Most of her music is in fact electronic, right?
I’ve been to the RRHOF anyway,…it sucks.

Hey Beet | 3/11/2008, 12:15 pm EST

You are waaay off base. Half of the US LOVES Brittney Spears. Wake up dude.

1stResponder | 3/11/2008, 12:16 pm EST

No talent idiots running for President,no talent idiots who support them being inducted into the Rock -n- Roll Hall Of Shame. Kind of makes since, in a creepy leftist idiot sort of way.

cbjr | 3/11/2008, 12:16 pm EST

cheap trick, the replacements, the jam, husker du; all important to the music of the 90’s (and 70’s-80’s)and should be in the HOF

steinway | 3/11/2008, 12:16 pm EST

madonna is LAME AND OVERRATED and the only thing she ever rocked was the casting couch.

and, she must’ve gone to the same plastic surgeon that hacked up jocelyn wildenstein or the mom in terry gilliam’s brazil.

i was hoping iggy would club timberlake like a baby seal with her statuette.

steinway | 3/11/2008, 12:16 pm EST

madonna is LAME AND OVERRATED and the only thing she ever rocked was the casting couch.

and, she must’ve gone to the same plastic surgeon that hacked up jocelyn wildenstein or the mom in terry gilliam’s brazil.

i was hoping iggy would club timberlake like a baby seal with her statuette.

John | 3/11/2008, 12:16 pm EST

What’s Timberlake doing there anyway? Who does he think he is? Just some kid from some school boy band.

Simon Cowell | 3/11/2008, 12:17 pm EST

No Randy, those groups are sooo yesterday. Come sit next to me a Paula and listen to some more singers! WTF!

Whatever Maddona | 3/11/2008, 12:17 pm EST

Chick is a traiter. Like said before, stay in Jolly Old England if you dont like it here. It amazes me that people such as her are tolerated because if it were not for the US, that tramp would not exist. Typical celebrity thinking that they make a difference other than making music.

mada | 3/11/2008, 12:18 pm EST

I’m not saying i’m the biggest fan of madonna, but when you describe the best peeps of rock’n roll.. i mean really make a list, she’s done it all whether its in a song or performance, or wore it… her versatility, and style will keep inducting her into any and every genre… its a fact that this planet has to accept.

shaker | 3/11/2008, 12:18 pm EST

Madonna and Timberlake ! What a fuckin insult to those that deserved to be inducted!

Rock On | 3/11/2008, 12:18 pm EST

If you are not going to induct real ROCKERS…KISS,ELO,CHICAGO,STY X,MOODY BLUES, STOP saying Rock Hall of Fame. Call it the MUSIC HALL of FAME

Dianna | 3/11/2008, 12:18 pm EST

I find it hysterical that everyone here defines Rock n’ Roll by whatever they personally like. Get a grip people. You are not important enough to define a state of mind.

The words “rock n’ roll” started out as another way of saying “sexual intercourse.” Madonna did that in spades, whether I like her or not, that’s the facts.

I think I’ll die when Hip Hop hits the RNRHOF, but that’s a whole other issue.

Rock On | 3/11/2008, 12:18 pm EST

If you are not going to induct real ROCKERS…KISS,ELO,CHICAG O,STY X,MOODY BLUES, STOP saying Rock Hall of Fame. Call it the MUSIC HALL of FAME

amspecial | 3/11/2008, 12:18 pm EST

Plain and simple they don’t have a clue of what Rock-n-Roll is. The hall should be renamed.

The real mccoy | 3/11/2008, 12:18 pm EST

So all you haters out there don’t think madonna should be inducted? So, where are your top selling platinum records? Oh thats right you all don’t have any records that people enjoy and will continue to enjoy for years to come. Im not even a madonna fan, but give her a bit of respect. She does deserve to be inducted, and her musical legacy will surely outlast most others. *$#! genres, its all about good music in the end.
I listen to all types of music, and that being said I think that maybe a few of you posters should open your horizons, and find a few songs from 2008 to listen to.

() | 3/11/2008, 12:19 pm EST

Why was Justin even in this induction ceremony for Rock n Roll? I think he has the most annoying voice ever! AND he is so full of himself!

nek | 3/11/2008, 12:19 pm EST

madonna has payed her way in pop music, the key words are rock n roll she was not rocker or role model i don’t care if she payed her way she is not rocker she is pop, she is not someone kids should look up too she sayed it herself she likes sex that’s want you she on stage and in her videos she should have received a award for been a slut

AnalogKid | 3/11/2008, 12:19 pm EST

A band who has continued to produce music and tour extensively for over 35 years: RUSH.

It is way past time to bring these veterans into the fold.

Godandthedevil | 3/11/2008, 12:19 pm EST

I just want to state that for all of you that claim rock n roll is dead…get off your butts and revive it then. If you’re sick of the music you hear make your own and change things. That’s what rock n roll is about. Change. Whether it’s a demand for world or political change or a bunch of people that are just sick of the music they hear rock n roll is about change. So..in the spirit of rock n roll stop dwelling on what was and focus on what could be.

Jim | 3/11/2008, 12:19 pm EST

A performer has to pay to be inducted into the hall. The Canadian hall has better acts in it than this joke does and they only induct Canadians. I think a lot of true rockers want no part of this thing. Personally, I wouldn’t pay five cents to be in the same room with a lot of the people who have bought their way into this thing

Anonymous | 3/11/2008, 12:20 pm EST

since everyone is just hating on madonna and throwing out all kinds of bullshit value judgments:
Fuck KISS, fuck Motley Kkrewe, fuck styx.
sure, you may like them, but I don’t.

That about sums up your arguments.

nobody | 3/11/2008, 12:20 pm EST

Justin is so stupid and cocky, I can’t stand the way he acts. He likes to diss people to make himself look better, he wants to look tough, he is NOT TOUGH!!!!!! I still think britney will come back, and she’s definitely a madonna wannabe. Madonna is really pretty and one of a kind.

D.W.I.A. | 3/11/2008, 12:20 pm EST

MADONNA IS MY QUEEN IN AND OUT OF THE MIND.

barney | 3/11/2008, 12:20 pm EST

i think mr. rogers should be in too
remember that great rock song
its a beutiful day in the meighborhood?

Mike | 3/11/2008, 12:20 pm EST

Madonna over Heart, What a joke, Madonna doesn’t have 1/100th of the vocal talent that The Wilson Sisters do. This is why I will never visit The Rock and Roll Hall of Shame. Madonna has to be the most over rated no talent there is, Oh yeah, she has been a fine rool model!!!

kevin reno nv | 3/11/2008, 12:20 pm EST

people should be shamed of thereselves for bashing anyone that got an award. all of these great music artists have touched our hearts at one time or another. and some will never be forgotten. who are we to judge. thanks kevin.

k.j. white | 3/11/2008, 12:20 pm EST

if it was just about “rock” as defined by most, the temptatons, ray charles, james brown, sly stone, earth wind and fire, marvin gaye, the jackson 5, aretha franklin, dusty springfield, parliament/funkadelic, and alot of others would never have been inducted.

Rick Vannoy | 3/11/2008, 12:20 pm EST

I think the RR HOF selection committee needs a good swift kick in the head. They must be drinking the kool-aid if they think Madonna or her ilk every belonged in the HOF. It’s like putting Babe Ruth in the Pro-Football HOF no one can argue Babe Ruth’s contribution to sports but his HOF classification is baseball. RR HOF is a joke. Get some REAL ROCKERS to decide who gets in!!

nana ke kumu | 3/11/2008, 12:20 pm EST

Music Hall of Fame not Rock n Roll Hall of Fame!!!!!!! Grow Up!!!!!!!!!!

nana ke kumu | 3/11/2008, 12:21 pm EST

Music Hall of Fame not Rock n Roll Hall of Fame!!!!!!! Grow Up!!!!!!!!!!

bucket123 | 3/11/2008, 12:21 pm EST

i m ok with the inductees, and will always be, unless U2 is ever inducted. now there are sum no talent pricks.

raul | 3/11/2008, 12:21 pm EST

madonna reminds me of beetlejuice

Dennis | 3/11/2008, 12:21 pm EST

Sad and very DISTURBING!!!Should Be Inducted Into the ROCK-N-ROLL HALL OF WANNABES.(THIS SOUNDS LIKE A HOSTILE TAKEOVER FOR US ROCK-N-ROLLERS)WHAT DO YOU THINK??!!!!!!!!!!! BACK TO THE ROCK,FORGET THE POP!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

nana ke kumu | 3/11/2008, 12:21 pm EST

Music Hall of Fame not Rock n Roll Hall of Fame!!!!!!! Grow Up!!!!!!!!!!

nobody | 3/11/2008, 12:21 pm EST

SORRY, BRITNEY IS NOT A MADONNA WANNABE, THAT’S WHAT I MEAN’T TO SAY!!!!!!

nana ke kumu | 3/11/2008, 12:21 pm EST

Music Hall of Fame not Rock n Roll Hall of Fame!!!!!!! Grow Up!!!!!!!!!!

nana ke kumu | 3/11/2008, 12:21 pm EST

Music Hall of Fame not Rock n Roll Hall of Fame!!!!!!! Grow Up!!!!!!!!!!

nobody | 3/11/2008, 12:21 pm EST

SORRY, BRITNEY IS NOT A MADONNA WANNABE, THAT’S WHAT I MEAN’T TO SAY!!!!!!

nobody | 3/11/2008, 12:21 pm EST

SORRY, BRITNEY IS NOT A MADONNA WANNABE, THAT’S WHAT I MEAN’T TO SAY!!!!!!

MusicIndustryProfessional | 3/11/2008, 12:21 pm EST

You people that are dissing Madonna have obviously no inkling of her career past 1990. Madonna has had 3 world tours in the last 6 years, one of which is the highest grossing female concert of all time. If you actually knew her music of the last decade, you would know that she has played electric guitar, acoustic guitar and rocked out with Lenny Kravitz, Iggy Popp and other ROCK and ROLL icons on her tours. She actually is a true female pop and rock star – she doesn’t have to be a hair band that had 2 or 3 successful albums and then lost her edge b/c she wasn’t willing to adapt with times and stay on the cutting edge of music, she has pushed forward not afraid to take risks in production and working with vocal arrangements and song structure, not unlike Radio Head, but you would have to actually listen to albums like Ray of Light and American Life to understand that, not the singles. Regardless of your thoughts on her music, she has a talent for producing music albums that are completely independent of one another, as opposed to being stuck to one genre like so many which ultimately leads to their downfall, and a record lable’s worst nightmare, she creates an independent body of work (or work of art) with each album, which very few artists have managed to do. She is one of the few artists that has consistently stayed on top of the music industry for 25 years – unlike Elvis and Michael Jackson who fell into obscurity later in their later years. So think what you will, but she’s more deserving than you think. Lets see “white snake” accomplish what she has and influence as many people as she has through her music, the Beatles and Elvis also wowed people in the beginning with flashy costumes, choreography and girating hips, lest you all forget.

nobody | 3/11/2008, 12:21 pm EST

SORRY, BRITNEY IS NOT A MADONNA WANNABE, THAT’S WHAT I MEAN’T TO SAY!!!!!!

A-Yo! | 3/11/2008, 12:21 pm EST

Hey 1stResponder I have a question. I guess you have loved the last 7 years under another “idiot” eh? Leftist? Dude, do me a favor, look up and I mean look up the word Fasism and see if it doesn’t seem eerily similar to the past 7 years.

Then take a good stiff wiff of coffee and wake up!

Hey John!!!!!!!!!!! | 3/11/2008, 12:21 pm EST

who does timeberlake think he is? DUDE!!!!!!!! He did Britney!!!!!!!! Britney man!!!!!!!!!!!! Wait, so did KFED! Never mind, everyone has done her now. too bad I haven’t! Have You?

Tfan | 3/11/2008, 12:21 pm EST

Someone needs to define Rock and Roll. Madonna is pop music. You know…dance music which caught on in the early 80’s. Ironically, putting some of the great Rock Bands of the 60’s and 70’s to an early demise as they were forced to change their sound to a more dance/disco format. Pop music needs they’re own hall.

barney | 3/11/2008, 12:22 pm EST

at least she was cool about it she only gave a SIXTEEN minute speech thanking everyone except her family
what a doll

frozzenn6970 | 3/11/2008, 12:23 pm EST

Madonna is the the queen of pop!!! now the queen of rock and roll!!! Madonna is very talented… all you people are just envious.. She has no talent?? you cannot stay in the music industry for 25 long years if you don’t have the talent.. 12 # hits and counting.. She’s awesome.. Give her a break.. she truly deserves the honor…

Andy Dreamy Day | 3/11/2008, 12:23 pm EST

Madonna didn’t sing or produce one note of rock music in her life. This is a shame. http://www.addsite.eu.tt

D.W.I.A. | 3/11/2008, 12:23 pm EST

MADONNA IS MY QUEEN IN AND OUT OF MY MIND. LOVE YOU HUNNY.

Duncan | 3/11/2008, 12:23 pm EST

I am really happy Leonard Cohen got inducted, he may not be the future of rock, but he certainly has left a legacy behind him. My respects to Mellencamp who choose not to be a John Cougar and has always been true to himself. Now, Madonna left us “La isla bonita”…isn’t that something? With Justin Timberlake and Madonna it should be renamed the MTV Hall of Fame…

flogamocker | 3/11/2008, 12:23 pm EST

ATTENTION MADONNA SYMPATHIZERS!!!!

Just listen once again to her insipid rendition of America Pie and maybe you’ll understand why she does not deserve to be in The Hall.

cristina | 3/11/2008, 12:23 pm EST

….it’s about time we all realized that our music is being held hostage and is not allowing it to evolve as it could…..

Steve King | 3/11/2008, 12:23 pm EST

Leonard Cohen is so far above all this hoo-ha that he is correctly embarrassed about the ‘honor’ …listen to ‘dress rehearsal rag’ and dare to say that madonna is anywhere equal in talent. Making money is not the same, i have some respect for what she has done, but a metric ton more for LC

lisa | 3/11/2008, 12:24 pm EST

the reason madonna is in the rock and roll hall of fame and alot of other singers and groups are not is because she is still rocking and kicking ass and they are not thay all are to old and washed up and madonna is still going You just keep rocking madonna

skiff | 3/11/2008, 12:25 pm EST

Who the hell wants to hear about Wacko bitch Brittany? That bitch needs to be locked up in a rubber room . Timberlake is a poor excuse for a pop singer.And all the fucking brits that dont like the way shit in the USA get your asses back on the plane and go back to merry ole england !

gigs | 3/11/2008, 12:25 pm EST

The R&R Hall of Fame Induction is not the same as it was…It used to be a huge venue, now look it’s at the Waldorf (lame). Next year it’ll be at Bobbyjoe’s pig pickin BBQ.. LMAO!!

Jeanie | 3/11/2008, 12:26 pm EST

Okay..Madonna, I can see, especially since she has had her share for experience…meaning time line. But Justin Timberlake?! The Jonas Brothers would be way better suited than him on the list!

Stevie Rachelle | 3/11/2008, 12:26 pm EST

All of these artists SUCK! I was in the band Tuff and we deserved success much more than these greedy lunatics. Justin Timberlake? He’s not even close to rock! If he ever came to Metal Sludge, I would tear him apart.

barney | 3/11/2008, 12:26 pm EST

does she still use the fake english accent????

TO CHICAGO | 3/11/2008, 12:26 pm EST

THANK U CHICAGO! RIGHT ON!!

Hmmm | 3/11/2008, 12:27 pm EST

Justin is definitely annoying. Why does he have to keep dissing Britney. She obviously has moved on–why don’t he do the same? I’ve never liked his attitude…

S2.Sohaib | 3/11/2008, 12:27 pm EST

congratulation Madonna you are the best.no one deserve this award more than you.

your music inspired me I LOVE YOU.

Rick | 3/11/2008, 12:27 pm EST

Rock and role by the way has been around since the mis to late 1800’s and it was a term originaly for fast moving gospil music. It was not a term for sexuality at all. Rock and role makes you move and tells a story. Some of you say rap will never belong in the RRHOF I disagree look at songs like riding dirty mamma many many rap songs tell a great story if you would give them a chance.

MUSIC MINDED | 3/11/2008, 12:27 pm EST

MUSIC MUSIC MUSIC…ALL OF MY LOVE ALL OF MY LOVE ALL OF MY LOVE TO YOU…HEY RRHOF…CAN I GET IN NOW…HAHAHAHAHA

S2.Sohaib | 3/11/2008, 12:27 pm EST

congratulation Madonna you are the best.no one deserve this award more than you.

your music inspired me I LOVE YOU.

URDogSpot | 3/11/2008, 12:27 pm EST

I love these post! It shows just how uneducated American people are. You post comments about things you know nothing about. Do you know the history of “Rock” music? Rock was never defined as most Americans think it is defined. Ask Mick Jagger what Rock and Soul, oh I mean Roll music is. I cant wait to see America is 20 years! Your arrogants is going to kill you! Keep posting and showing your ignorance. Madonna is Rock, Roll, Pop and Soul! Justin – just another boy toy who sold (stole) his/the soul. Grow up -and recognize! They lied, the revolution is being evangelized, right b4 u-r eyes! Can you say MTV!!!!!

MADONENA | 3/11/2008, 12:27 pm EST

FUCK THEM ALL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

cliff tagaban | 3/11/2008, 12:28 pm EST

Can a person get a video of the entire Rock and Roll Hall of Fame ceremony done last night?

Belmont Rocker | 3/11/2008, 12:28 pm EST

I’m amazed how many people out here cut Madonna when they have guaranteed listened to many of her songs and sung alongside her voice on the radio. Any moron who undercuts her presence on the music scene and her contributions to charity needs to look at him/herself in the mirror and see what he/she had done to help the world.

Zenabi D | 3/11/2008, 12:28 pm EST

Hey, has everybody forgotten
Frank Zappa. You talk about
an innovated rocker.

cliff tagaban | 3/11/2008, 12:28 pm EST

Can a person get a video of the entire Rock and Roll Hall of Fame ceremony done last night?

Local Celeb~ | 3/11/2008, 12:28 pm EST

the only reason madonna is even metioned is because she’s so old, she’s gets a pity prize for telling america she’s a “virgin”. P.S. jt, you may have dated madonna wanna be’s but then again, they dated a Michael Jackson wanna be…..whaddya gotta say to that. the only thing i liked about jt is his music, and even that “omg britney dumped me im gunna diss every girl out there since i oobviously cant find one” music is tired……grow up, retire and leave the biz with a shred of dignity b4 you end up in rehab like the rest of the has-beens. Maybe your old boy band mate will make you happy!! give lance a call! Because just like your boy band’s name, your carrer is N the Sync.PeAcE!

dgr1963 | 3/11/2008, 12:28 pm EST

is randy rhoads in the rrhof/if not he should b /cause he influenced alot of guitar players

Anonymous | 3/11/2008, 12:28 pm EST

To those ignorant (stupid) enough to complain about Madonna making the Hall you should check the official list of inductees from the official site here:
http://www.rockhall.com/ inductees/inductee-list/

If you are too bored let me tell you a few names who made the list over the decades:

2007 – Grandmaster Flash and the furious five

2006 – Blondie

2004 – Prince

2003 – Righteous Brothers

2001 – Michael Jackson

2000 – Earth, Wind & Fire

1997 – Bee Gees
– The Jackson Five

1994 – Elton John

1993 – Etta James

1988 – The Supremes

Now either some people are just bitchin for no fuckin reason or most of you don’t even have a clue about the Hall

Luna | 3/11/2008, 12:29 pm EST

Madonna – not R&RHOF material. And FYI, she pre-dated Marilyn Manson – pointed breasts and all. (She probably warped him.)

As for Elvis? He was a thief; just like Pat Boone was a thief – taking music that was not his in any way shape or form and repackaging it for commercial sale. The only difference between him and Boone is that he was allowed to bring some attitude and body movement along with the words.

Rock & Roll was a euphanism for sex, but the music that was being played downstairs by the band while people were getting some upstairs was deep, backwater blues by the likes of Big Momma Thornton, Muddy Waters, Howling Wolf, etc.

Before you start bumping your gums about “Elvis”, know where he stole the jewels for his fool’s gold crown.

And Jerry Lee Lewis’ incestuous drunkard carcass saw Litte Richard Live, prior to his career taking off. That is why Little Richard’s claim to be the “True King and Creator of Rock & Roll” is actually correct.

A-YO! Yah! | 3/11/2008, 12:29 pm EST

Yes! Thank you very much!!!!!!!!

jross | 3/11/2008, 12:29 pm EST

madonna DID look like a stepford wife–and looked nothing like the rebellious image that made her–sold herself out, i guess. i’d be honored NOT to make it in the hall, to be excluded,etc—that shows u who the true rock icons are– the ones denied induction!!

Rick Vannoy | 3/11/2008, 12:29 pm EST

Nice try MusicIndustryProfessional. As a Rock and Roll fan, I wouldn’t be seeing Madonna in the Rock and Roll section of my local music store now would I? She has her place in the industry but NOT in Rock and Roll. IMO.

jross | 3/11/2008, 12:29 pm EST

madonna DID look like a stepford wife–and looked nothing like the rebellious image that made her–sold herself out, i guess. i’d be honored NOT to make it in the hall, to be excluded,etc—that shows u who the true rock icons are– the ones denied induction!!

jross | 3/11/2008, 12:29 pm EST

madonna DID look like a stepford wife–and looked nothing like the rebellious image that made her–sold herself out, i guess. i’d be honored NOT to make it in the hall, to be excluded,etc—that shows u who the true rock icons are– the ones denied induction!!

JP | 3/11/2008, 12:29 pm EST

How does Madonna get in the hall when classic rock bands like KISS and RUSH are still waiting around.
Whats next….. Guns N Roses will get bumped by MC Hammer.

matrona | 3/11/2008, 12:30 pm EST

madonna is not into rock, she’s into fuck…..sleeping with boys, girls, lesbians ….for that alone, i can say she rolls !

Sophy | 3/11/2008, 12:30 pm EST

Madona is a genius, She is a singer since many of you are using diapers,
La isla bonita, material girls, many of her songs until now are listening by many other peoples that likes her songs, She deserves all that she have… She is a stronger women…for many many years..Congratulations MADONNA Your music is excellent..good job

Sophy | 3/11/2008, 12:30 pm EST

Madona is a genius, She is a singer since many of you are using diapers,
La isla bonita, material girls, many of her songs until now are listening by many other peoples that likes her songs, She deserves all that she have… She is a stronger women…for many many years..Congratulations MADONNA Your music is excellent..good job

What a joke! | 3/11/2008, 12:30 pm EST

Madonna doesn’t know how to write music, she doesn’t play any instrument and most importan,she doesn’t sing well so please get somebody get Tod Rundgren in the hall of fame before Madonna.

gusy | 3/11/2008, 12:30 pm EST

who’s madonna?

Joe Mama | 3/11/2008, 12:30 pm EST

I don’t know who is scarier looking….Madonna or Iggy Pop……

I guess Iggy Pop has had less facial surgery, so he retains the ugly award. LOL!!!

djmcginty | 3/11/2008, 12:30 pm EST

I cannot believe all the negative comments on posted on this website. No. 1, all this has nothing to do with you, so get over it. No. 2, everyone keeps calling her “pop”, which by definition means popular, or high-selling. No. 3, just get a life and admit that the only reason you keep bashing her is because you’re jealous of her fame and fortune or you’re stuck in a time warp and can’t appreciate newer music. I listen to ALL types of music, and in the end that’s what it all is, music. Madonna deserves a lifetime achievement award for being on the forefront of cutting edge music her entire career, no matter HOW it is labeled. Congratulations Madonna, although I am not a huge fan like some, I have been appreciating and enjoying your contributions for years.

joy | 3/11/2008, 12:30 pm EST

I really hate Timberlake,he;s an arrogant bastard!

juanita | 3/11/2008, 12:30 pm EST

face it or not to face it.MAD-DONNA will always be Miss Thing.People like her,MJ,and Tina Turner took the world by storm in the 80s and till to date you’d still boogie down to their musik.most are inspired by ‘em.true that

www.iamsavoirfaire.blogspot.co | 3/11/2008, 12:30 pm EST

I hink that was an excellent event…and maddona is a diva and a star…a superstar to be exact…and so is Justin and Leonard Cohen …people need to wake up and have some respect for success… a win is a win..

gigs | 3/11/2008, 12:30 pm EST

Hey musicindustrypro…FYI, Madonna just learned how to play guitar a few years ago..so I wouldn’t say she rocks out with any instrument!

KRISSY | 3/11/2008, 12:30 pm EST

Alice Cooper, The Moody Blues, and one of the best F@CKIN ROCK & ROLL BANDS IN THE WORLD, KISS HAVE NOT???? WHAT IN THE HELL IS MUSIC COMING TO!!!! IT’S POP & ROLL HALL OF FAME FOR SURE!!!! BULLSH!T MUSIC!!!!!

www.iamsavoirfaire.blogspot.co | 3/11/2008, 12:31 pm EST

I hink that was an excellent event…and maddona is a diva and a star…a superstar to be exact…and so is Justin and Leonard Cohen …people need to wake up and have some respect for success… a win is a win..

http://www.iamsavoirfaire.bl ogspot.com

big willie | 3/11/2008, 12:32 pm EST

wrong hall of fame she is a dico queen why rock . judas priest iron maiden where are they ?????

Bridget English | 3/11/2008, 12:32 pm EST

Madonna’s singing is strange that what’s make her unique. she should be rewarded for her work. You go girl.

Bridget English | 3/11/2008, 12:32 pm EST

Madonna’s singing is strange that what’s make her unique. she should be rewarded for her work. You go girl.

Bridget English | 3/11/2008, 12:32 pm EST

Madonna’s singing is strange that what’s make her unique. she should be rewarded for her work. You go girl.

Bridget English | 3/11/2008, 12:32 pm EST

Madonna’s singing is strange that what’s make her unique. she should be rewarded for her work. You go girl.

Bridget English | 3/11/2008, 12:32 pm EST

Madonna’s singing is strange that what’s make her unique. she should be rewarded for her work. You go girl.

Bridget English | 3/11/2008, 12:32 pm EST

Madonna’s singing is strange that what’s make her unique. she should be rewarded for her work. You go girl.

WHY-NOT-TOD | 3/11/2008, 12:32 pm EST

Madonna doesn’t know how to write music, she doesn’t play any instrument and most importan,she doesn’t sing well so please get somebody to get Tod Rundgren in the hall of fame before Madonna!!

Bridget English | 3/11/2008, 12:32 pm EST

Madonna’s singing is strange that what’s make her unique. she should be rewarded for her work. You go girl.

Bummer | 3/11/2008, 12:33 pm EST

pretty sad that so many people can’t be happy for someone else’s success.

Why is everyone so angry?…. it’s music
music=good.

Simon | 3/11/2008, 12:33 pm EST

Now see you gone pissed everyone off, you should of brought it to A. Idol and we would of shown how great everyone is. Besides they all suck! Madonna was only good at that time because there was really no other crazy horse to sing the crap she sang.

MUSIC MINDED | 3/11/2008, 12:33 pm EST

MELLENCAMP DA MAN…MADONNA DA WO-MAN…HAHAHAHA

Rusty | 3/11/2008, 12:33 pm EST

I have lost 100 percent respect for the Hall of Shame.
Madonna please. what a disgrace.
Get this thing out of Ohio now!

CygnusX-1 | 3/11/2008, 12:33 pm EST

Until Rush is inducted, no inductions are valid. Especially Madonna, who isn’t Rock and Roll.

Who is the bigger idiot? The person who votes for change, or the person who votes for the same old crap that keeps sending the country further down the toilet after 8 years of proof that it doesn’t work?

Mick | 3/11/2008, 12:34 pm EST

MusicIndustryProfessional,

You can go on and on about Madonna but she ain’t no rocker. Sticking here in here is like making Johnny or Edgar Winter a member of the NAACP

wopboptorledo | 3/11/2008, 12:34 pm EST

Everyones a critic nowadays….I think we should ALL spend less time blogging and more time reaching our goals……………

barney | 3/11/2008, 12:34 pm EST

im from texas but i saw england on a map once, so i too have a fake english accent

Divine Miss M | 3/11/2008, 12:34 pm EST

**Leonard Cohen is so far above all this hoo-ha that he is correctly embarrassed about the ‘honor’ …listen to ‘dress rehearsal rag’ and dare to say that madonna is anywhere equal in talent. Making money is not the same, i have some respect for what she has done, but a metric ton more for LC**

I couldn’t have said it better myself. He is the most talented writer of our lifetime. Kudos. And, Jon Landau… BITE ME lol

barney | 3/11/2008, 12:34 pm EST

im from texas but i saw england on a map once, so i too have a fake english accent

Bob H | 3/11/2008, 12:34 pm EST

I like Leonard Cohen OK, but I think he deserves the honor less than Madonna. Maybe the poetry HOF but the R&R HOF for Cohen?

don't forget! | 3/11/2008, 12:35 pm EST

how about the brady kids! now they rock on! gotta love Marcia back then- slammin. Now, not so much. Just plain weird. But back then! TASTY BITS!!!!!!!!!!

dgr1963 | 3/11/2008, 12:35 pm EST

they should put everybody in the rrhof next year then they won’t have 2 have a lameass awards show on tv anymore

Judgy Judgersons.... | 3/11/2008, 12:35 pm EST

It’s so funny to see people bashing other people for their feelings on this matter. Who calls someone a loser & tells em to get a life when they’re not even contributing anything related to the subject. Just a stop to trash other human beings today!!?

Carolyn | 3/11/2008, 12:35 pm EST

What about George Michael? He’s a true artist, writes his own lyrics, plays several instruments, has one of the clearest, most beautiful voices in the industry, and seems to be a genuinely kind spirit.

Surf Punk | 3/11/2008, 12:35 pm EST

Madonna eh? What the hell? I cannot classify her music as rock n roll! This is bogus!

Cheap Trick definitely does belong in the Rock-n-Roll Hall of Fame!

Gonna Raise HellWords and music by rick nielsen

Gonna raise hell, gonna raise hell.
Gonna raise hell, gonna raise hell.
Ambition? ha!
If all I’ve heard is true,
There’s nothin’ much I can do
To change the world, it’s irreversible.
But in what it lacks,
It’s got a taste that smacks of somethin’ irresistable.

Gonna raise hell, gonna raise hell, gonna raise hell.
Gonna raise hell, gonna raise hell, gonna raise hell.

Submission? yes!
Now I won’t name names, and a secret’s a secret,
But a hint’s a hint or a clue.
You really wanna know, you really wanna go,
There’s only two things you got to do.

Gonna raise hell, gonna raise hell, gonna raise hell.
Gonna raise hell, gonna raise hell, gonna raise hell.

Mother, mother.
Mother, mother.
Mother, mother.

My mission? ah, yes!
Everybody hear? everybody here,
It’s a fate I all agree.
Sometimes you win, I never lose,
To me it’s no mystery.

Gonna raise hell, gonna raise hell, gonna raise hell.
Gonna raise hell, gonna raise hell, gonna raise hell.

(repeat to coda)
Gonna Raise Hell

______________________ ____________

We need to do this:

Tell it to the Rock-n-Roll authorities and stick it to them for even thinking of Madonna! Totally bogus!

rock on | 3/11/2008, 12:35 pm EST

Indeed, most people don’t even get where Rock and Roll comes from or what they mean by “Rock”. If some of you have issues because some bands you like are not in there firstly do some freakin research cause they might not wanted to be given the award and second don’t cry like bitches cause of it, it ain’t Madonna’s fault. Like someone already posted since the Hall was created in the 80’s (i think)it was ALWAYS open to non “rock” bands unless u think The Supremes or Earth, Water & Fire (It’s raining men??) or even Elton John are what you stereotypically call “rock”. Wake up and smell the air, Madonna is more rock in spirit than most

Kevin X | 3/11/2008, 12:36 pm EST

Surprised but delighted that Leonard Cohen got in. IMHO, he’s by far the most talented inductee this year. Now if they’ll just put Brian Eno in I’ll be happy, either with Roxy Music, his pioneering solo career or as a producer. It’s just shameful Eno’s not in.

Rman | 3/11/2008, 12:37 pm EST

Madonna in the hall, never thought I’d see the day some blond bimbo skank pop singer would be inducted. She may rank in the top of contraversy and the queen of tackyness but not in the R&R hall of fame. Mellancamp deserves it, congrads to john for being john !

Rman | 3/11/2008, 12:37 pm EST

Madonna in the hall, never thought I’d see the day some blond bimbo skank pop singer would be inducted. She may rank in the top of contraversy and the queen of tackyness but not in the R&R hall of fame. Mellancamp deserves it, congrads to john for being john !

Adrian | 3/11/2008, 12:37 pm EST

All The Real Rock and Roll Stras are alread added

they need to stop this hall of fame

Little Richard, Elvis, The Beatles, The Rolling Stones, Jerry Lee Lewis, The Doors, Jimmy Hendrix, Ray Charles, Chuck Berry, Bob Dylan, and all the other greats. THATS REAL ROCK AND ROLL.

Today it is bogus

Modonna, GrandMaster Flash,Blondie, The Ramones

Come on people whos next

Nsync, Justin Timberlake, Britney Spears.

I mean where do we draw the line.

Russ | 3/11/2008, 12:37 pm EST

This is a prime example of what happens when elitist NY music journalists put together a “rock n roll” event. Madonna and Leonard Cohen? I’ll try to stop laughing. Oh sorry, I just can’t. Next year they might as well induct some street musicians that play drums on buckets.

City Girl | 3/11/2008, 12:37 pm EST

At least her face lift almost looks natural – compare her pics from the 80’s and early 90’s til now.

who cares | 3/11/2008, 12:38 pm EST

you all sound like idiots. i like this person i hate that person. you all need to grow up. there is more to life, go find it because it obvously hasn’t found you!

pats | 3/11/2008, 12:38 pm EST

Wow! you guys are pretty small minded. Grow up. Do some research on Rock and Roll. And try not to make a fool of yourselves by insulting people who have worked hard to express themselves through music. These guys are all important to Rock and Roll. Maybe your favorite will be inducted next time around.

Vern | 3/11/2008, 12:39 pm EST

Can we all agree that it’s time for Iggy to start wearing a shirt?

Marcia Brady | 3/11/2008, 12:40 pm EST

thanks for remembering me on the brady kids and yes! we did rock! Are you single? I still rock if you know what I mean! slammin back then…hehe…..I’ll slam u now!

NoElleNo- not worthy | 3/11/2008, 12:40 pm EST

Bearer of Knowledge- THIS IS A PUBLIC MESSAGE BOARD and unless YOU are the ADMINISTRATOR screw you! How are YOU telling people to keep their comments to them selves…WTF are you? Madonna can’t sing that’s a FACT. Madonna is a POP artist not R&R that’s a FACT. Wheather or not she deserved the honor was decided by a committee not the general public because if it was she wouldn’t get eithin 10 feet iof the RRHOF. When YOU become awesome YOUR 1.5 cents STILL won’t matter to us. WHO YOU think should or should not be inducted is LAME to us…but we aren’t telling you you’re WRONG. Everybody has an opinion…and WE ALL have so much to say so where do you get off acting like you own the board?

big willie | 3/11/2008, 12:40 pm EST

MADONNA MUST HAVE PAID ALOT TO GET HER NAME ON THE ROCK AND ROLL HALL OF FAME . SHE IS AA DISCO QUEEN. NOTHING TO DO WITH ROCK

Wow! | 3/11/2008, 12:40 pm EST

Who cares about any of this?

me | 3/11/2008, 12:41 pm EST

I’d have watched just to hear billy joel’s induction. Billy had the most talent in the building anyway.

Divine Miss M | 3/11/2008, 12:42 pm EST

Oh…and if they had a RnR BUSINESS Hall of Fame, then Madonna shoulda definitely been inducted..that woman marketed and sold herself better than any woman before or since…can you imagine Janis with those kinds of marketing people or marketing skills? Crazy.

go away | 3/11/2008, 12:42 pm EST

oh shut the hell up, green day has nothing to do with this!

YO-------NoElleNo- not worthy | 3/11/2008, 12:42 pm EST

you got that right! nicely stated! Check Mate MF!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Haris Pilton | 3/11/2008, 12:42 pm EST

Whoever wrote this article of coverage did a piss-poor job of describing and relating to Ben Harper’s induction speech for the late bluesman Little Walter & Jerry butler’s induction speech for Gamble & Huff. Shame on you for bad journalism.

jupitergod76 | 3/11/2008, 12:42 pm EST

ok,madonna does play a instrument watch her concerts,she plays the guitar so um duh and she can sing how many albums does she have and EVITA a musical so brush up on your madonna facts then post a comment so quit hating cuz your not her like i said jelalous ass people

Haris Pilton | 3/11/2008, 12:42 pm EST

Whoever wrote this article of coverage did a piss-poor job of describing and relating to Ben Harper’s induction speech for the late bluesman Little Walter & Jerry butler’s induction speech for Gamble & Huff. Shame on you for bad journalism.

Haris Pilton | 3/11/2008, 12:42 pm EST

Whoever wrote this article of coverage did a piss-poor job of describing and relating to Ben Harper’s induction speech for the late bluesman Little Walter & Jerry butler’s induction speech for Gamble & Huff. Shame on you for bad journalism.

Geoff1 | 3/11/2008, 12:42 pm EST

Maybe next year the Hall can go the other way and induct Ted Nugent. Chances anyone???

Haris Pilton | 3/11/2008, 12:42 pm EST

Whoever wrote this article of coverage did a piss-poor job of describing and relating to Ben Harper’s induction speech for the late bluesman Little Walter & Jerry butler’s induction speech for Gamble & Huff. Shame on you for bad journalism.

Haris Pilton | 3/11/2008, 12:42 pm EST

Whoever wrote this article of coverage did a piss-poor job of describing and relating to Ben Harper’s induction speech for the late bluesman Little Walter & Jerry butler’s induction speech for Gamble & Huff. Shame on you for bad journalism.

Haris Pilton | 3/11/2008, 12:42 pm EST

Whoever wrote this article of coverage did a piss-poor job of describing and relating to Ben Harper’s induction speech for the late bluesman Little Walter & Jerry butler’s induction speech for Gamble & Huff. Shame on you for bad journalism.

Haris Pilton | 3/11/2008, 12:42 pm EST

Whoever wrote this article of coverage did a piss-poor job of describing and relating to Ben Harper’s induction speech for the late bluesman Little Walter & Jerry butler’s induction speech for Gamble & Huff. Shame on you for bad journalism.

Haris Pilton | 3/11/2008, 12:42 pm EST

Whoever wrote this article of coverage did a piss-poor job of describing and relating to Ben Harper’s induction speech for the late bluesman Little Walter & Jerry butler’s induction speech for Gamble & Huff. Shame on you for bad journalism.

Haris Pilton | 3/11/2008, 12:42 pm EST

Whoever wrote this article of coverage did a piss-poor job of describing and relating to Ben Harper’s induction speech for the late bluesman Little Walter & Jerry butler’s induction speech for Gamble & Huff. Shame on you for bad journalism.

Oh Hell | 3/11/2008, 12:43 pm EST

ELO, Styx, Kiss, Rush should all be next in. And if RRHOF considers Madonna a rocker, Jimmy Buffet should be getting his induction soon.

celebhater | 3/11/2008, 12:43 pm EST

just goes to show if ytou give someone enough money even white trash like madonna can be someone!

sarie j | 3/11/2008, 12:43 pm EST

I have read alot of comments from alot people today. I bet most of you don’t remember madonna when she came out!The rock-n-roll hall of fame was meant to allow rebells in and if you look at the roots of rock-n-roll it was all about making the stuffy sqirm and making parents nuts and calling rock-n-roll the devils music and if I am not mistaken madonna made alot of people sqirm and alot of parents say she is the devil.Back in mr parents day when rock-n-roll was ceated it didn’t sound like the metal today so for some of you you do not know what rock is (IT IS AN ATTITUDE)

Cook | 3/11/2008, 12:43 pm EST

Nat king cole has every right to be in the rrhof. Rock and roll was created from the blues. Rock and roll has become what it is today by people like madonna. Her sound may not be like some of the other artists inducted, but it’s for that reason that she desrves it more. She has managed to continue to grow and change in her style of music much like rock and roll changes due to the contibution of new sounds, ideas, and styles from many musical artists over the years. Congratulations to all musicians inducted…Rock on!

nifty white girl | 3/11/2008, 12:43 pm EST

welp that is funny you should mention all these people need lives, as you were on the same site they were leaving a comment.. i love the total lack of common sense that people unleash.

nifty white girl | 3/11/2008, 12:43 pm EST

welp that is funny you should mention all these people need lives, as you were on the same site they were leaving a comment.. i love the total lack of common sense that people unleash.

bud woods | 3/11/2008, 12:44 pm EST

rock and roll died when the british invasion began. they need to change it to anybody get’s in to this hall of fame.

rock hall revolution | 3/11/2008, 12:44 pm EST

The Rock Hall board should be fired. Leave it to the fans to decide what should be in or out of the Rock Hall.

Oh and Madonna might have sold lots of records and tours. But big deal. So has Garth Brooks. Should he be inducted?

Just like in the early 80s when Madonna ruled the charts, she has killed rock music all over again.

HA! | 3/11/2008, 12:45 pm EST

Hahaha!

Rick Vannoy | 3/11/2008, 12:45 pm EST

RockOn. If that’s YOUR definition and classification of Rock and Roll, then stop calling it Rock and Roll! Call it entertainment! I like EW&F but don’t believe they should be in the RR HOF either.

Kathy Jean | 3/11/2008, 12:46 pm EST

Jethro Tull fan

Funknbluezer | 3/11/2008, 12:46 pm EST

Kudo’s and Huzzah’s for inducting The Dave Clark Five and The Ventures! Long, long overdue for both. John Mellencamp??? Madonna?! What in the world qualifies her for the ROCK Hall of Fame? I daresay that she will be a minor footnote once she departs for good.

nek | 3/11/2008, 12:46 pm EST

madonna has payed her way in pop music, the key words are rock n roll she was not rocker or role model i don’t care if she payed her way she is not rocker she is pop, she is not someone kids should look up too she sayed it herself she likes sex that’s what you she on stage and in her videos she should have received a award for been a slut. we are not a shame of having a opinion, whom ever doesn’t like opinions about and award shouldn’t be on this site, you have your opinion right

long live rock | 3/11/2008, 12:46 pm EST

A shame that real rockers are out there and not in the hall of fame. People who think Madonna SHOULD be in there, you don’t know what rock is. Rock n Roll is a lifestyle to many, something you Madonna fans would never, could never understand. You don’t know the power of an amazing guitar solo, the way the masters make their instruments sing, to breath their own life. If you like Madonna, that’s fine, it really is. I’m not gonna put you down for your taste in music. Although to say Madonna is rock n roll shows how truely ignorant and uninformed you are. You are the same people who would ask me to turn down (or off) my KISS, Led Zep, Alice Cooper (list goes on and on) albums.

HA! | 3/11/2008, 12:47 pm EST

Madonna Is not fucking rock n’ roll. wtf

Local Celeb~ | 3/11/2008, 12:47 pm EST

THANK YOU NOELLENO!!!

ames | 3/11/2008, 12:48 pm EST

Although I would love to see Stevie Nicks, Chicago, Linda Rondstadt, Styx, Joan Jett or numerous others I grew up listening to honored, I also really feel Madonna has been around as an entertainer and proved herself worthy of the honor. I have appreciated her art since the age of 12 when I first remember hearing “Borderline.” She knew what she wanted and she went for it. I have to admire her talent and I envy her courage and her willingness to experiment. As with most memorable entertainers in history she put herself up there for criticism and out of that criticism started some of the trends of our times. Theres that saying,”Well Behaved Women Rarely Make History” – well she did make history and I think she came out on top with class.

Adam | 3/11/2008, 12:48 pm EST

It’s amazing how many untruths about Madonna are posted here.

in Michigan | 3/11/2008, 12:49 pm EST

Until Rush is inducted into the R-n-R Hall of Fame, it will be a total joke.

MaryKay | 3/11/2008, 12:49 pm EST

call me a turnnip? that hurt me. stupidist question of the day? yup. Waiting to see what idiot thought it was a real question and you won! who is the idiot now! lol! stupid MF!!! lol!!! GO Marcia Brady!!!!!!!!

Rusty | 3/11/2008, 12:50 pm EST

BOYCOTT this insult to Rock n Roll!

What? | 3/11/2008, 12:50 pm EST

Madonna in the Rock Hall? How did this happen? There is nothing, I repeat, NOTHING rock about Madonna. Not her music, not her voice, nothing about her persona. She has no business in the Rock Hall and should never have been considered. To me, this is simply a move by the Rock Hall to solicit more visitors. Well, this is one visitor that will probably not visit again. And don’t get me started on the voiceless, no talent, pop queen that inducted Madonna. Justin Timberlake has no business even stepping foot in the Rock Hall, let alone inducting a nominee. I am actually surprised he was able to do something without Timbaland’s help.

Mike | 3/11/2008, 12:51 pm EST

A lot of those mentioned are worthy. ELO is another, and if not the band, then Jeff Lynne has got to be in there at some point.

Local Celeb~ | 3/11/2008, 12:52 pm EST

THANK YOU NOELLENO! IF THEY DIDNT WANT COMMENTS THEY WOULDN;T PUT A COMMENT BOX HERE! aRE YOU GOING TO DEFEND EVERY CELEBRITY OUT THERE???? HAVE FUN!stop trying to act like peacemaker when you probably aalk more shit than anyone. your just trying to get some sort of limelight. grow up. I VOTE FOR GUNS N ROSES, QUEEN, ROLLINGSTONES, BEATLES, AND LOL…..BEACH BOYS….LOL TO BE IN THE RRHOF~ NOT MADONNA. THE WOMAN WORE TRAFFIC CONES FOR 5 YEARS FOR CHRISAKES! NEXT PARIS HILTON IS GOING TO GET AN EMMY FOR ACTING~

Hey Haris Pilton!!!!!!!! | 3/11/2008, 12:52 pm EST

shut up u dumb broad and turn off the lites and get back to it baabbbbyyyy!! My camcorder battery is running low!!!!!!!!!

I am with you Rusty!!!!!!!! | 3/11/2008, 12:55 pm EST

Boycott this? Yes!!!! Now you are talking!!! everyone get out your crayons and start making poster! We march tomorrow!!!! You geek

Buck Dharma | 3/11/2008, 12:56 pm EST

Three words: Blue Oyster Cult!

(And word to Billy Joel and Johnny Cougar: no one wants to hear President Bush sing rock & roll @ the state of the union, no one wants your lame-o politics at an entertainment awards ceremony.)

80s Rocker | 3/11/2008, 12:56 pm EST

Madonna is definitely not Rock n Roll! May as well induct her in to the Country Music Hall of Fame too.

Come on people, Please!

big willie | 3/11/2008, 12:57 pm EST

IRON MAIDEN
JUDAS PRIEST
LED ZEPPELIN
AC DC
BLACK SABBATH
METALLICA
GUNS & ROSES

MADONNA HA HA HA JA JA JA DUM DUM

HA! | 3/11/2008, 12:57 pm EST

Its called The ROCK N” Roll Hall of FAme for a reason.

rock hall revolution | 3/11/2008, 12:57 pm EST

My favorite Madonna rock songs.

Well… let’s see… uh… well… um…

OK… how about just a list of Madonna Rock Songs. This should be easy for someone in the Rock Hall right? Here we go.

Ok… there was… hmmm… well… uh…

Oh! I got it. She did the worst ever rendition of the Beatles’ “Revolution” with the Thompson Twins at Live Aid.

So… that’s it I guess.

Czr | 3/11/2008, 12:57 pm EST

Haha Rock N Roll Madonna NEVER , The Whole Thing Was A Ritual . Some Of The Things That Were said Dint Make Sense .Its nothing But,Ritual And Crap!!!!! Waste Of Nightight That We Dint Ask For

Javs | 3/11/2008, 12:58 pm EST

Hey, Long Live Rock– I beg to differ. I am a fan of Madonna, and also of Kiss, Led Zep, and probably of nearly any other band of “your genre” that you’d care to hurl at me. Just because one likes Madonna doesn’t mean that they can’t scream every word of “…And Justice For All”!

idk | 3/11/2008, 12:59 pm EST

someone please help me. I can not figure out which one is Madonna above in the picture. Is she on the left or in the middle. I think the left since she is not wearing a shirt. Oh so Madonna!

Ravens_Eden | 3/11/2008, 12:59 pm EST

Ok Ok So you all don’t think Madonna Belongs in the RRHOF. But If you are going to complain about people being “left out” make sure they really are. I have seen Listed The Doors(1993), Led Zeppelin(1995),Allman Brothers (1995) Santana (1998) and Black Sabbath (2006) as Being “left out” Yet they are all there. DO some research before you complain

les cherubains | 3/11/2008, 1:00 pm EST

madonna deserve that honor. she’s the queen of pop. you can’t define rock and roll. it has many roots and many influences. jazz is the original rock. by the way, she’s my favorite female artist in the world, and a-ha is my number one band.

The Big Bopper | 3/11/2008, 1:00 pm EST

I am turning over in my grave.

Me | 3/11/2008, 1:00 pm EST

Madonna in the rock and roll hall of fame……what a friggin’ joke. The only rock she has is what she’s smoked and the only roll she has is from the bags under her eyes. Who’s next? Britney?

Coop | 3/11/2008, 1:01 pm EST

The man, the myth, the legend.
Alice Cooper.
It is implausible that he has not been inducted yet.

Czr | 3/11/2008, 1:01 pm EST

People Now You Know How Fake Rock And Rock His/Story Is All Made Up !!!!!!!!!!!! Its Their Story Not Ours!

Coop | 3/11/2008, 1:01 pm EST

The man, the myth, the legend.
Alice Cooper.
It is implausible that he has not been inducted yet.

HA! | 3/11/2008, 1:02 pm EST

I agree with ‘What?’.

Anonymous | 3/11/2008, 1:04 pm EST

they might as well induct Britney Spears, The Spice Girls, Christina Agulera, The Backstreet Boys, New Kids on the Block, Milli Vanilli, Vanilla Ice, any other takers? Yeah Snoop Dogg sold a lot of cds, but he’s not rock n roll either. I used to want to go check out the RNRHOF but now I think they should just burn it to the ground. Oh, to the person who said Alice Cooper did nothing for rock, you know nothing. Cooper has put out more albums than Madonna has, influenced many other famous rock bands and is still out on the road touring every year. He has yet another album due out this year, this will be his 26th studio album. Not including live albums and box sets. He puts on the greatest stage show around today in rock. He hosts his own nightly radio show that is aired around the country. I could go on and on, but it is wasted on you. Real rockers unite, we know who we are.

Anonymous | 3/11/2008, 1:06 pm EST

To all you morons defending madonna, you need to understand that one credential for being inducted, it influencing other rock artists. Madonna in no way, shape or form, influenced and rock n roll artists. This is just a ploy by the Rock hall, to attract more people. Kiss, influenced hundreds of bands… Where are they?

Dirk Taylor | 3/11/2008, 1:06 pm EST

Sounds like the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame just became the Hall of Shame. Madonna is not Rock and Roll. If she is then somebody is smoking some serious crack

Spook78 | 3/11/2008, 1:06 pm EST

Oh for chrissakes! Can we get away from all the Madonna crap now ? Please ? I don’t “blog” much, and this is a good reason why—people continuing to focus on one mundane thing without regards to the rest of big picture. Aren’t there any Dave Clark 5 fans out there ?

bignickel | 3/11/2008, 1:07 pm EST

The Rock and Roll Hall of Fame is meaningless. With the exclusion of the rockers listed in the other posts alone is enough to prove that. I wrote it off personally years ago when Johnny Rivers was excluded. Madonna and Justin Timberlake, what an insult to all the true Hall of Famers that have been unrecognized as well as to us fans.

Ha! What? | 3/11/2008, 1:08 pm EST

hmmmm. stop, go. me, you. duh

HedHuntr | 3/11/2008, 1:08 pm EST

Wow!

jd | 3/11/2008, 1:09 pm EST

People…think outside the small world you live in. RRHOF is not just all about Rock n’ Roll. It’s about your contributions to music, Madonna has been around for 25 years and has been an amazing force in the music industry. Madonna was a pioneer in the 80’s with her music, still is. It’s not all about head banging and rock bands.

krautht | 3/11/2008, 1:11 pm EST

there are a lot of “pop groups” like the Supremes that are in the hall of fame. Madonna is not the first.

kcv | 3/11/2008, 1:11 pm EST

boy is it funny how upset people get about these things. it was a very entertaining show last night, no one will ever be satisfied w/ who is in…someone pointed out led zeppelin, black sabbath and ac/dc, well all 3 of them are in there! yes rush should be in, i think cheap trick should be also, but some of these things take time unfortunately, rush was never big w/ rock critics.

kcv | 3/11/2008, 1:11 pm EST

boy is it funny how upset people get about these things. it was a very entertaining show last night, no one will ever be satisfied w/ who is in…someone pointed out led zeppelin, black sabbath and ac/dc, well all 3 of them are in there! yes rush should be in, i think cheap trick should be also, but some of these things take time unfortunately, rush was never big w/ rock critics.

Ohio Sucks | 3/11/2008, 1:11 pm EST

Once again R&R Hall of Shame has done it again. Yep. Rock and Roll is TRULY DEAD.

DHW55 | 3/11/2008, 1:12 pm EST

High selling pop artists should not be considered for induction into the RockNRoll hall of fame, there are too many “real” rockers missing from these hallowed halls.

Karen | 3/11/2008, 1:14 pm EST

Rock On-Who exactly is Earth Water and Fire? Whoever they are did not sing “It’s raining men”. That would have been the Weather Girls and although I am not positive, I am pretty sure that they are not and never will be inducted.

Truth | 3/11/2008, 1:14 pm EST

“Madonna changed generations of women”

Yeah, her legacy is Britney Spears and all those other pop tarts.

Steve Wells | 3/11/2008, 1:14 pm EST

Way to go Ventures! It’s about time. I have learned guitar because of you guys and I will always love your music.

blah | 3/11/2008, 1:15 pm EST

Hey JD…if it’s not all about rock n roll , then why oh why do they call it the Rock n Roll Hall of Fame? What you are talking about is the General Music Hall of Fame, which it seems just opened up in Ohio somehwere.

purtyGF | 3/11/2008, 1:16 pm EST

I ask the same questions — Where’s Alice Cooper? Heart?
I enjoyed some of Madonna’s songs being an 80s young adult but man, her music has always been pop. JT is the same and what was he doing there? We all have to realize that when we include those who are not supposed to be there, we bump off those who should be. Sad. So commercial…

kcv | 3/11/2008, 1:16 pm EST

whether one likes it or not, madonna has had 47 top 40 hits, which is a lot…and i totally agree that cheap trick and kiss and rush should be in, and thin lizzy, j. geils band…maybe they should reveal how many votes each artist got, that might tell us more.

jk | 3/11/2008, 1:16 pm EST

I dream of a world without Madonna

fistofate | 3/11/2008, 1:16 pm EST

I never liked Madonna… too much “look and listen to me” and nothing worthwhile to look at or listen to, in my humble opinion. Geekess of the 1980s… I guess she’s found her niche writing children’s books… people she can really shock.

Proof | 3/11/2008, 1:17 pm EST

Why is everyone all over Madonna? Is she any less rock n roll than Mellancamp? It think is because she is a women and most of you are misogynists.

Proof | 3/11/2008, 1:17 pm EST

Why is everyone all over Madonna? Is she any less rock n roll than Mellancamp? It think is because she is a women and most of you are misogynists.

HedHuntr | 3/11/2008, 1:20 pm EST

Let me know when they induct Tool. This opens the flood gates for these other pop tart wannabes

sweetlarryk@yahoo.com | 3/11/2008, 1:20 pm EST

As a former bass player in the 60’s for an opening act,now being 58 myself,i feel the 3 performers long overdue for induction,no questions asked,or excuses made are: chicago,linda ronstadt,moody blues.Nobody can sing any type of song,any genre,cross over to standards,she was the first to do to that with amazing falsettos. What’s wrong with the RRHOF to by pass such legends of rock music. I infact backed Ronstadt up 3 times,pure joy,what a great rock voice,everybody got up and danced,sheer delight!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Anonymous | 3/11/2008, 1:21 pm EST

OMG! Madonna! How horrible! Come to think of it, let’s take back our inductions of Prince, Michael Jackson, The Bee Gee’s, Parliment, Simon and Garfunkel, Billy Joel, The Jackson Five, Joni Mitchell and James Taylor. Simply because they aren’t “rock” enough. Look, I’ll give you that Alice Cooper is an amazing artist and performer, BUT, you prove to me that he has made a tenth of the impact on the music industry that Madonna has made, and I’ll each my shoe.

First, learn the definition of “Rock N’ Roll”, then get back to me.

Proof- you are right. | 3/11/2008, 1:21 pm EST

not about all women, just Madonna. Ummm and now you. how about a little BJ baaaabbbbyyyyyy?

rock hall revolution | 3/11/2008, 1:21 pm EST

People get upset about this sort of thing because they take it very seriously. Much more so than the actual board who inducts these people it seems.

How many more deserving people like Mike Smith will die before they get their day… meanwhile the board is busy inducting Madonna.

Turn the votes over to the people! Make your process transparent!

Rock fans deserve better than this!

And the rock hall in cleveland has nothing to do with this.

It’s the board… of which… this very magazine has some influence.

Com'on Truth.... | 3/11/2008, 1:23 pm EST

just hit enter, colon…..#, #, #!!!!

Me | 3/11/2008, 1:23 pm EST

If there was a Pop Hall of Fame then Yes… Maddona Should be in it. If there was a Music Hall Of Fame the Yes… Maddona Should be in it. But putting her in the Rock and Roll Hall Of Fame is like putting Babe Ruth in the Basket Ball Hall Of Fame because he played proffessional sports.

Anonymous | 3/11/2008, 1:24 pm EST

ummm, its not somewhere in Ohio it’s in friggin Cleveland where it should be THE ROCK n ROLL capital!!!

Anonymous | 3/11/2008, 1:24 pm EST

As far as I’m concerned, the HOF will have no credibility until RUSH gets in.

yoda | 3/11/2008, 1:25 pm EST

madonna give me a break!!! i have a friend who work for her concert tour a while back.she doesnt sing she lipsynch. this is embarrasing to the rock and roll hall of fame!!!!!!!!!

A NOT SO MADONNA FAN | 3/11/2008, 1:25 pm EST

WAS THAT ONE OF HER PUBLICITY STUNT? WHATS HAPPENIN TO THIS CRAZY WORLD I BET SHE CANT EVEN SPELL DA WORD “ROCK N ROLL”. FOLKS SHE SLEPT HER WAY THRU DIS ONE!

Duff | 3/11/2008, 1:26 pm EST

Gotta agree, what a joke the Hall has become.

Sad.

IMHO

Truth....be told | 3/11/2008, 1:26 pm EST

wow, get your fingers working there bbbbbaaaabbbbyyyy! I want some!!!

Sad! | 3/11/2008, 1:27 pm EST

Sad, Very Sad!

Sad! | 3/11/2008, 1:27 pm EST

Sad, Very Sad!

THE TRUTH | 3/11/2008, 1:27 pm EST

Ike Turner is highly credit as the first person to record a Rock n’ Roll song with Rocket 88 and he was inducted until 1991 as part of the Ike and Tina Turner Revue. Now Tina herself probably the most notable female rock performer has never been inducted as a solo artist, yet Madonna goes before her. Interesting.

question | 3/11/2008, 1:28 pm EST

why is madonna included in a rock category?

Give Me a Break | 3/11/2008, 1:30 pm EST

What a bunch of whiners. Just because your “band” isn’t in you want to bash everyone else. You all should look up the definition of “rock -n- Roll” before you spew more nonsense on the world. BTW getting into the hall is all about the “influence” one had on the industry as a whole and not about how good or bad they were.

Whoa Madonna | 3/11/2008, 1:31 pm EST

Is she starting to look like Zsa Zsa Gabor?

Joan Jett is fabulous as is Iggy.

Truth.....I am sorry! | 3/11/2008, 1:33 pm EST

with your last comment…..Rocket! boy do I have a red rocket for you. ummmm so does my dog! lets make it a play date!

Cindy | 3/11/2008, 1:34 pm EST

I can’t play an instrument. I’m not much of a singer. I know nothing about music theory. But I look good and I can dance. What are my chances of some day being in the Rock-and-Rock Hall of Fame?

Mike | 3/11/2008, 1:35 pm EST

How is it possible that Leonard Cohen, The Mamas & Papas, and The Lovin’ Spoonful are in the Hall of Fame and Donovan isn’t? Other than Dylan, was there a more influential folk artist in the 60s? “Season of the Witch” alone is enough to justify his inclusion.

Truth.....are you THE TRUTH | 3/11/2008, 1:36 pm EST

I am sorry but I don’t know if truth is The Truth. Are you one and the same? if not, I am sorry to The Truth….but not truth. Truth is I am sorry, no I am not. wait, yes I am. sigh

Brian Davis | 3/11/2008, 1:38 pm EST

Who votes on this stuff??!!
Madonna in the “Rock” hall of fame?
I personally think you selfimportant, selfindulgent, selfcentered, music exe. types should come back to reality! Leave the politics out of it! Madonna??
I think I’m gonna be sick! The Egles, Stevie Ray, Tesla, Boston, that’s Rock! And you wonder why these stinkin awards shows get crappy ratings, they’re a joke! Get a clue!!!!

Amanda | 3/11/2008, 1:39 pm EST

When did they change the name to Pop and Roll Hall of Fame???

Arthur | 3/11/2008, 1:40 pm EST

I didn’t know Madonna had enough talent to get into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. Oh wait I forgot. Like the untalented J.Low, she has a great publicity agent. Now that’s the person who should be in the hall of fame, not Madonna. Another legend in her own mind!!

the hell with truth! CINDY!!! | 3/11/2008, 1:43 pm EST

she is a tease. Cindy…..hmmmm, lovely. You can play my instrument if you would like. no talent needed just a nice pair of strong lips and not raking please

YOO_HOO | 3/11/2008, 1:44 pm EST

Here is what the HOF has to say about their inductees:The Rock and Roll Hall of Fame honors the legendary performers, producers, songwriters, disc jockeys and others who have made rock and roll the force that it is in our culture. For over two decades, the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame Foundation has been nominating and electing those figures, and honoring them at an annual ceremony that has become one of the most celebrated events of the year, and certainly one of the hottest tickets in rock.
So…..to sum it all up, regardless of what you may think fits the “rock n roll” definition, it is more about the impact that said artist has had on “pop” culture and trends……I’m not a Madonna fan….but impact she has made.

Rick Vannoy | 3/11/2008, 1:44 pm EST

Madonna has had ZERO influence on Rock AND Roll. The Hall of Fame in discussion is The Rock and Roll Hall of Fame NOT the INDUSTRY Hall of Fame. Your lumping ANYONE in this category doesn’t change that!! By your definition we should put Millie Small in there for singing “My boy lollipop”.

Steve | 3/11/2008, 1:45 pm EST

Elvis and Madonna are tied for the most # 1 singles. All she needs is one more to surpass The King. She is the QUEEN of Rock and Roll…like it or not folks.

This cant be happening!!!! | 3/11/2008, 1:47 pm EST

I am sorry but I agree with the statement Madonna can not sing she is famous becasue she is a slut did everyone see that movie she did where she could put the bottle all the way down her throat? I mean who does that? not someone with self respect!!!!!! I am not one for bassing people but she really is a joke people just honor her because they feel they have to since she has been around so long. They feel its cool to buy her records since she made such a sexual statement when it was a tabu and it made her cool! If you think about it her music is not as popular now that she has gotten older and she is not as sexy as she use to be. She is really a has been just like Micheal Jackson but irs their reputations for what they stand for that keeps them in the lime light

Rick Vannoy | 3/11/2008, 1:47 pm EST

Give Me a Break – Madonna has had ZERO influence on Rock AND Roll. The Hall of Fame in discussion is The Rock and Roll Hall of Fame NOT the INDUSTRY Hall of Fame. Your lumping ANYONE in this category doesn’t change that!! By your definition we should put Millie Small in there for singing “My boy lollipop”.

napoleon | 3/11/2008, 1:47 pm EST

Vote for Pedro. I bet he did Madonna

Hector | 3/11/2008, 1:48 pm EST

Hello? Madonna helped changed the face of music in the 21st century. Like a Virgin, Justify my Love, Human Nature. Come on people. Wake up and smell the VAG!!!

shavittablkely | 3/11/2008, 1:48 pm EST

i think this is bullshit!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

maria | 3/11/2008, 1:50 pm EST

I love Madonna … I don’t know anything about music.. but .. I love it that everysong takes me some place and moment in my life.

“Like a vergin”

maria | 3/11/2008, 1:50 pm EST

I love Madonna … I don’t know anything about music.. but .. I love it that everysong takes me some place and moment in my life.

“Like a vergin”

actorguy | 3/11/2008, 1:51 pm EST

Yea, where are the Zombies, because madonna,”She’s not there”

actorguy | 3/11/2008, 1:51 pm EST

Yea, where are the Zombies, because madonna,”She’s not there”

actorguy | 3/11/2008, 1:51 pm EST

Yea, where are the Zombies, because madonna,”She’s not there”.

JP | 3/11/2008, 1:52 pm EST

I’m not a fan of Justin Timberlake. Damn! This guy gave a really funny, insightful induction speech for Madonna. Madonna has always been a hit and miss artist for me for every “Ray Of Light” there is “American Life”. Rock and Roll Hall of Fame has always inducted everybody from rock to soul to rap. So, why not pop music? If there is anyone from pop music that deserves to be in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, it has to be Madonna.

Dolly | 3/11/2008, 1:53 pm EST

Madonna in the R&R Hall of Fame? Speaking ONLY for myself…I wouldn’t bother to walk across the street to see Madonna if someone gave me a free ticket! I’m glad Jimi, Janice, John Bonham, Jim Morrison, etc., weren’t alive to see it—they probably all would have died a second death.

Joey | 3/11/2008, 1:53 pm EST

Dont you people realize that “rock” is an attitude-an aura-and few have it as distinctively as Madonna, commerical as she is. She is in a sense the “alpha” and “omega” of entertainers. Every artist deserving has their year for induction, and this is her year. It has ben her yeat for the past 25. Peace.

Mary | 3/11/2008, 1:54 pm EST

i like madonna and she still looks good to be her age don’t try to diss her because she has been doing music since the eighties and she still getting paid so if u feel u have to to diss her then don’t write comments because she was out before alot of u were born and don’t compare her to brittney spears because brittney don’t have nothing on her i doubt if she’ll have a long career like madonna has had

JOEY!!!! | 3/11/2008, 1:59 pm EST

alpha? omega? listen man, Hector may need a hug and I think you have what it takes to make him happy. Two apples in a bucket….or pickles in a jar. yawn…get a life.

no one | 3/11/2008, 2:02 pm EST

who cares………..

alan | 3/11/2008, 2:02 pm EST

I’m I wrong about something .Did I miss something .Where’s Paul Rodgers , Andy fraiser , Simon Kirke ,, Paul Kossoff .
Madonna in the Hall Of Fame .
Maybe next year Lawrence Welk .
If it wasn’t for Madonna show and dance .She wouldn’t even be a good back up singer .
Shame on the Hall of Fame .

alan | 3/11/2008, 2:02 pm EST

I’m I wrong about something .Did I miss something .Where’s Paul Rodgers , Andy fraiser , Simon Kirke ,, Paul Kossoff .
Madonna in the Hall Of Fame .
Maybe next year Lawrence Welk .
If it wasn’t for Madonna show and dance .She wouldn’t even be a good back up singer .
Shame on the Hall of Fame .

londoner | 3/11/2008, 2:02 pm EST

I think the Hall defines Rock & Roll loosely, more like “contemporary music” or “popular music”. The people complaining here obviously have a slightly more purist view on what R&R is, i.e. guitar-driven music.

Leonard Cohen is one of the best lyricist in popular music ever. But based of most of your definition(s), he’s absolutely NOT Rock & Roll! Even less so than Madonna. But he’s honored for his artistic and cultural contribution. In that case, he definitely deserves a place. This guy is a true artist.

Yes, Madonna has sold a gazillion records but she’s also the one that pushes more buttons than most so-called rock bands that have come and gone through the decades. Do some research folks! She’s culturally influential and she’s THE singer that embodies postmodern themes and strategies. People that don’t see the irony of her bimbo image obviously don’t “get” it.

Some folks resort to these lame theories about why Madonna sells records: sex, marketing, controversy. If that’s the case, Pamela Anderson, Jenna Jameson and the late Anna Nicole Smith should have put out some records and sold shit loads. Would they though? I think not. The one Madonna record (”Erotica”) that’s blatantly “sexual” was her poorest selling album. Can it be the simple reason that people actually “like,” and continue to like, Madonna’s music?

Madonna’s music appeals to many people on many different levels. Like the Beatle’s music, can it be that her music happens to possess both mass appeal and artistic/intellectual appeal. She draws from underground sounds, make it her own, and bring it the mainstream.

If you define Rock & Roll as rebellious, no-compromise, boundary-pushing and stereotype-defying, then Madonna is probably more Rock & Roll than many bands that are already in the hall.

Let’s face it, Rock & Roll has historically been comfortably misogynist: some people (male?) are just uncomfortable with a powerful female. I’m sure Joni Mitchell and Chrissie Hynde would agree.

Like Bowie, Prince and Michael Jackson, Madonna as an artist creates musical experiences that combine the music, the visual and the stage performance. She just happens to have outlasted all of them and remains relevant and hugely popular. Can luck, sex, marketing and controversy keep her at the very top of her game for almost 30 years?

Is it possible that perhaps Madonna actually has real talent?

No more tears | 3/11/2008, 2:04 pm EST

Madonna didn’t get choked up. She lost her place on the speech she wrote out because she was nervous and is getting older so she couldn’t see it that well. Her face didn’t MOVE when she talked either!!!

Laura K | 3/11/2008, 2:04 pm EST

Well, it is true the Rock ‘n Roll Hall of Fame is suffering so the intention was to give it a boost and induct Madonna. Like her or not, she has had more sold out concerts, most hits, etc. She is an icon in her own right and changed music in her own way. She was very influential to the younger crowd.

I saw her in concert several years ago and it was a blast! One big party and she danced her a$$ off.

Amberlee | 3/11/2008, 2:08 pm EST

Not a Madonna fan… Never really have been but i do have to agree W/YOO HOO. The bitch does such tho!

Hector and Joey | 3/11/2008, 2:08 pm EST

everyone is invited to the wedding of two pickles. Two boobs who found each other here talking about Madonna. Go figure.

DD | 3/11/2008, 2:10 pm EST

Actually Dolly, its “Janis” not “Janice”. If you are going to refer to her, at least do her the courtesy of spelling her name right.

Brian Davis | 3/11/2008, 2:12 pm EST

Madonna in the “Rock” Hall of Fame…Hmmm. I would call it laughable, but it’s not.

IT’S JUST FRIGGIN STUPID!!!!!

The only impact she’s ever had on rock is to get alot of search buttons on radio’s throughout the world PRESSED!! We all know that talent is only part of what makes a good show. She was promoted well and she was fine, thats all! The hall of fame should be reserved for the “Real Deal” Who’s next??
HANNA MONTANNA!!! Get your own bubblegum pop hall of fame! And leave the “Rock” hall for the real rockers who undestand that music without meaning, is NOISE!!

ROCK!!!!!!! | 3/11/2008, 2:16 pm EST

URDogspot-
Its called ROCK-N-ROLL.Not POP-N-ROLL,OR SOUL-N-ROLL.!!!!!WHY DON’T YOU TRY AND EVOLVE A LITTLE AND GET OUT OF THE SLOW MISERABLE NICHE YOU ARE IN!!!!!!!!!
“YOU ARE” DOG SPOT!!!!

Anonymous | 3/11/2008, 2:17 pm EST

huh

sylvie_is | 3/11/2008, 2:23 pm EST

All I can say about Leanord Cohen being inducted is “It’s about freakin’ time!” (sorry to steal your line spook). But just on a personal level, Leanord Cohen has touched me deeply over the years. He’s influenced my own work. His poetry will live on forever, I believe future generations will see him as a prophet.

Anonymous | 3/11/2008, 2:30 pm EST

Madonna in the 80’s and 90’s was the awesomist. She deserves it. She is creative and entertaines very well. All you haters your fave rock stars will be eligible once they commit to creativity and lead the way to something different and good.

Anonymous | 3/11/2008, 2:30 pm EST

Madonna in the 80’s and 90’s was the awesomist. She deserves it. She is creative and entertaines very well. All you haters your fave rock stars will be eligible once they commit to creativity and lead the way to something different and good.

Zakk Wylde | 3/11/2008, 2:33 pm EST

Attention people who think Madonna is a valid Rock n Roll Hall of Fame inductee…You wouldn’t know rock n roll if Ozzy Osbourne himself bent you over and gave you his Iron Man. \m/ \m/

pumpkin smasher | 3/11/2008, 2:33 pm EST

this is all one big stroke for people who think they are more important than every body else…
rock and roll? hall of fame? ego acts the lot of them.. so tired of hearing about these people.. news media when are they gonna get it we laugh at the freak show in gilded cage..
two bears
one bear says to the other one.. hey did ya hear what happened to joe? the other bear says no what? well they trained him to dance and sing and now he goes from city to city singing for crowds of thousands.. he’s got his own cage.. he performs really good too..
other bear..
starts crying.. how sad for joe..

Roman | 3/11/2008, 2:34 pm EST

Rock-N-Rock Hall of Fame induction checklist. Subject: Madonna:

type of rock music: none
instrument expertise: non-existent
singing voice: poor without digital enhancement
background voice potential: fair
song-writing abilities: poor
dancing ability: excellent
visual qualities: excellent
management: crafty
money made for the industry: superb

decision: She’s in.

Lilly | 3/11/2008, 2:35 pm EST

This can’t be happening, this is addressed to you. The movie that you are referring to with Madonna is like 20 years old, grow up she apparently did..It is time to let it go, and don’t hate that you will never be known for anything. Madonna set a standard for strong women who could be in control of their sexuality, not just lying on a car like a video ho….

LB0T | 3/11/2008, 2:36 pm EST

Bahh She is not rock but I am interested to know if she used her fake British accent.

\m/ (* *) \m/ | 3/11/2008, 2:40 pm EST

Madonna is not, has never been and never will be rock n roll.

Sheila | 3/11/2008, 2:44 pm EST

Madonna is a busy woman! Is she the besy singer..not by a long shot, but she is fun to watch and for the most part has not glorified drugs, or any kind of eating disorder! She’s okay!

Pat | 3/11/2008, 2:45 pm EST

Lilly wrote: “Madonna set a standard for strong women who could be in control of their sexuality.” Great. So Madonna is a wonderful sociologist. But what does this have to do with being a musician worthy of hall of fame recognition?

boogie | 3/11/2008, 2:46 pm EST

I’m not so much upset at Maddona being inducted as reading about that t00l, Justin Timberlake rehashing his lame dating life.

Like i said, grow a pair…

WSJ | 3/11/2008, 2:52 pm EST

Don’t bash people unless you have been there and done that. Madonna and Timberlake, no matter what their talents are, have been enormously successful in a very difficult industry. No one – I mean no one – has an easy road to the top. It doesn’t exist. These two deserve all the respect for that. To those of you who believe that they have had no influence on the music industry: Don’t tell me you don’t know at least one Madonna or JT song by heart. They are the greatest entertainers of their time. Rock on JT!

Ms.D | 3/11/2008, 2:54 pm EST

It’s just really sad that no one on here really understands the PURPOSE of the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. It’s to honor the most influential artists, producers and non performers in the music industry particularly Rock and Roll but not limited to Rock and Roll.

Snoovie | 3/11/2008, 2:58 pm EST

For those of you using the Madonna is not “rock” argument, listen up. Go to the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame’s website (www.rockhall.com). Look at the list of inductees. 40% of them are not “rock” artists. The list is comprised of plenty of people whom have contributed to this thing we call “rock and roll”. Country, Blues, Folk, Rock, Pop, R&B, Rap, Funk, etc. make up “Rock and Roll”. Inductess from all these types of music are represented in the hall of fame for their contributions to music in general. That is why Madonna was inducted in her first year of eligibility.

Whether you love her, hate her, or are indifferent, you would have to be in a coma to not realize the impact she has had on music and “rock and roll”. She was instrumental in the emergence of the impact of video imagery on “rock and roll”. She was unafraid to discuss sexuality from a woman’s point-of-view in her music. Male artists had been doing it for years, but female artists were afraid of the stigma which would be attached to them. Madonna changed all of that. She was also the first female artist to have total control of her destiny. Female artists were seen by record executives as a commodity to be used up and discarded. Madonna stayed on the cutting edge to stay relavent and keep her music career viable. She has had a career which has lasted through cultural shifts. When her new album drops in April, it will debut at the top of the charts. After 25 years the public still cares about her music, that is amazing.

Madonna deserves to be in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame for the above reasons.

Pat | 3/11/2008, 3:02 pm EST

WSJ is correct if the Hall of Fame’s intention is to honor the popularity machine of entertainers as opposed to musicians, whether they are “popular” or not. And hell, maybe that is the intention.

Brian Davis | 3/11/2008, 3:02 pm EST

THEN CALL IT THE ALL INCLUSIVE ANYTHING THATS EVER BEEN CALLED “MUSIC” HALL OF FAME YOU DEAD ABOVE THE NECK MORON!!!!!!!!

Rockin' Kevy | 3/11/2008, 3:02 pm EST

Madonna is not a Rocker, she is bad vocals over bad casio inspired dance tracks. Ray Davies was right in his speech when his band , The Kinks, was inducted: ‘Rock and Roll has become a spectacle…what a drag’

p.s.- kudo the the magnificent DK5!

1814 | 3/11/2008, 3:03 pm EST

Who’s justins 2 exes?

Nicki | 3/11/2008, 3:05 pm EST

Madonna Rock? Ummmm, no

Marie | 3/11/2008, 3:06 pm EST

I love Maddonna she has always been around and she deserves this for all her hard work!!!!

Alassin A. | 3/11/2008, 3:06 pm EST

The legacy that Madonna leaves us with is Gwen Stefani…thanks Mads.
And the board wont let The Monkees in on the grounds that they didn’t wrote their own music. Nesmith only invented MTV, but thats not groundbreaking enough. Half of their inductees didn’t write their own music…including Mad Mads!

Bread | 3/11/2008, 3:08 pm EST

Has Bread been inducted yet? “Baby I’m-A Want You” rocks!
(And lets have a little luv for Seals & Crofts, too; We May Never Pass This Way Again.)

MillieVanillie | 3/11/2008, 3:08 pm EST

Come on everyone she is a rocker!! in the same sense that Tiny Tim,Britney Spears,The Archies,Lawrence Welk,The Osmonds,The Young Caucasians,The Way-Outs and Barbara Streisand are.Madonna is the personification of the Spirit of Rock and Roll just as the above mentioned artists are.How anyone could think that she doesn’t belong in a Hall that has accepted much lesser talents such as Jimi Hendrix,Led Zeppelin,The Beatles,The Who,The Rolling Stones and the other wanna be Rockers is beyond me.Rock music came into it’s own when Madam Madonna WROTE the book on ROCK.Rock music was absolute crap before Ms Ciccone blessed us with her slutty genius.Paul McCartney wishes he had as much talent in his whole body as Madonna has in her gap tooth!!Why don’t you people see this obvious fact.She started the whole doing aerobics to a electronic dance beat craze that has REVOLUTIONIZED Rock Music.Which has made Rock the great art form that we know today as exemplified by the Coltrane of Modern Rock-BRITNEY SPEARS.!!!!!!!!

zoeygirl23 | 3/11/2008, 3:10 pm EST

Madonna in the Rock Hall of Fame? Lets start adding basketball players to the foot ball hall of fame! Puhleese!

Keith | 3/11/2008, 3:13 pm EST

Why was Madonna inducted into the Rock-n-Roll hall of fame?

Is the HOF gonna build a Lowest Common Denomination Stupid Pop Crap wing? That’s where all of this top 40 garbage ‘music’ belongs.

Nipples | 3/11/2008, 3:13 pm EST

I love it when some writes a well thought out argument like snoovie (by the way I don’t agree with you), and some one like Brian Davis comes along with a one line response that is the equivalent to a 5-year saying, “You’re a doo doo head.” Good job and nice argument Brian.

Stu Best | 3/11/2008, 3:15 pm EST

The Beatles are over-rated.

Ms.D | 3/11/2008, 3:15 pm EST

Fine. You made me do it…

http://en.wikipedia.o rg/wiki/Rock_n_Roll_hall_of_Fa me

Read it and let it go. Damn!

Spook78 | 3/11/2008, 3:16 pm EST

Madonna, Timberlake….Madonna, Timberlake….Madonna, Timberlake….Madonna…snooze ……….will someone PLEASE change the subject ?? You people are getting realllllly boring here.

John | 3/11/2008, 3:17 pm EST

Great insight, MillieVanillie. Now sing us a tune–oops, sorry. But go ahead and lip sync. The Hall of Fame awaits you.

NASHBR549 | 3/11/2008, 3:21 pm EST

I GOT TWO WORDS FOR YA DOOBIE BROTHERS.
AND WERE THE HECK IS GRAND FUNK.

rocknroller | 3/11/2008, 3:22 pm EST

Madonna is as far from rock as a flute player was from metalica.When will rush get in?

baby jesus is AMAZING! really. | 3/11/2008, 3:23 pm EST

i dont really see why madonna’s in the hall of fame, but whatever.

and jimmy hendrix, led zepplin, the beatles, etc. are AMAZING artists. so if your saying they dont deserve to be there your messed up!! YAY!

Brian Young | 3/11/2008, 3:24 pm EST

Madonna? In the Hall of Fame??? No way! There are so many other great artists… who really dezerve more attention! Who cares about Madonna???

David | 3/11/2008, 3:26 pm EST

dammit I agree with marie Madonna is so coooo ooooo ooooo ooooo ooooo ooooo ooooooooooooooooooooooooooool! !! =) =) =) =) =) i like bread!!!

rollnrocker | 3/11/2008, 3:27 pm EST

Madonna IS a flute player; the skin flute! (What? someone hadda say it!)

Real World | 3/11/2008, 3:29 pm EST

Hmmmm…. Stu Best… Any relation to Peter perhaps? Beatles are as good as it gets…

Sid | 3/11/2008, 3:30 pm EST

Why is Madonna getting the bulk of the headlines over the other more worthy inductees?

And does she really belong in the ROCK hall?

Has Madonna ever recorded a ROCK song?
Has she ever gotten airplay on a ROCK station?
Is her music enjoyed by ROCK fans?
Has she ever even influenced a ROCK artist?

Madonna is not Rock and Roll… She’s ANTI-Rock. She has done more to dilute and undermine rock music than just about anyone. It’s a slippery slope to the Hall of Fame inducting boy bands… When do New Kids on the Block or N-SYNC get inducted?

Madonna shouldn’t even be allowed in the Hall as a visitor, much less as a member.

Oh well… It is the Hall of FAME, not the Hall of Talent.

boogie | 3/11/2008, 3:30 pm EST

Spook=douche

Anonymous | 3/11/2008, 3:31 pm EST

Come on now people, whats the point of being neg and nasty with comments. All the new artists inducted should simply be congradulated for their extreme talents and sucess. Good for them for getting into the Hall of Fame simple as that.

PATTI | 3/11/2008, 3:31 pm EST

IM FROM THE ROCK N ROLL CAPITAL, CLEVELAND AND WE WHO ARE THE REAL ROCKERS BELIEVE THERE SHOULD BE ONLY REAL ROCK IN THE HALL. NOT POP. THEY CAN GET THEIR OWN HALL. COUNTRY HAS THEIR OWN HALL WHY NOT POP. IT’S NOT THAT I DISLIKE MADONNA OR HER MUSIC I JUST FEEL SHE IS NOT ROCK N ROLL. ALSO WE NEED THE INDUCTEE CEREMONIES HERE IN THE ROCK N ROLL CAPITAL NOT IN NEW YORK. WE IN CLEVELAND HAVE ALWAYS SAID THIS. BUT EVERY YEAR THEY KEEP HAVING THEM IN NY!! NEW YORK COULD HAVE THE POP HOF!! THAT WOULD BE PERFECT FOR THEM OR LA!! NOT IN THE HEARTLAND!!!

Keith | 3/11/2008, 3:36 pm EST

Sid,

Well Said

Willy G | 3/11/2008, 3:37 pm EST

To Yoda, I don’t care who your friend is, or what they claim to have seen, but Madonna absolutely does NOT lip sync at her shows! You people are really sad by thinking that the most influential woman in music history doesn’t deserve her induction. Just because she may not make the kind of music that you prefer doesn’t give you the right to slam her successes. Patheic haters! Get a life!

FV | 3/11/2008, 3:38 pm EST

Pat Benatar rocks! Please induct her.

CLEVELAND, OHIO | 3/11/2008, 3:40 pm EST

TO MILLIEVANILLI, FROM THE ROCK N ROLL CAPITAL OF THE WORLD!!! YOU ARE AN IDIOT!!!!!!!!

FV | 3/11/2008, 3:41 pm EST

Pat Benatar rocks!
Please induct her into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, as well as Heart.

ricky | 3/11/2008, 3:47 pm EST

people r just mad that Madonna does it better and can get in any Halls of Fame she wants, go cry to ur mom about it bitch. MADONNA is the queen of queens in music.

ricky | 3/11/2008, 3:47 pm EST

people r just mad that Madonna does it better and can get in any Halls of Fame she wants, go cry to ur mom about it bitch. MADONNA is the queen of queens in music.

Sid | 3/11/2008, 3:52 pm EST

Joan Jett and Madonna are both at the induction ceremony… and MADONNA is the one being inducted?!?!?

Apparently, Rock and Roll doesn’t love Joan back…

Joan has more ROCK in her toenail clippings than Madonna has in her whole family tree.

Peter S. | 3/11/2008, 3:54 pm EST

I nominate The Replacements

dmunoz | 3/11/2008, 3:54 pm EST

Maddona has been and still is one of the greatest talents in the music industry of the las 25 years. She is very well deserved of her induction into the rock and roll hall of fame. Her music has always been full of positive messages in her lyrics, as opossed to other crap that unfortunately is poisoning our young people in society the way RAP is doing it. Let us embrace real talent people and let us not be jealous of someone as magnificent as the queen of our times in the music world in the name of MADONNA.

Brian | 3/11/2008, 3:55 pm EST

Until KISS is inducted into the R&RHOF it will be a sham.

Spook78 | 3/11/2008, 4:00 pm EST

Hey “boogie”…dazzle all of us some more with your sophisticated, intellectual banter. I have to say, I was impressed (all of this is sarcasm, “boogie”—just thought I would clarify that since you do seem to have some level of difficulty with your thought processes. ‘Nite, nite, now)

Sam Miranda | 3/11/2008, 4:02 pm EST

Madonna is okay, she influenced a lot of people, bought her albaum, but what a heck,I still vote for purely rock & roll dudes!

Fuck this Hall | 3/11/2008, 4:02 pm EST

Madonna’s music isn’t rock, therefore doesn’t belong in the Rock Hall. Create a hall of fame for dance/pop/disco and induct her there. Let rock have its own place. There are quite a few worthy rock artists who are eligible for induction but have not yet been inducted. Yet they induct a music act that has nothing to do with rock. Pathetic.

Sam Miranda | 3/11/2008, 4:02 pm EST

Madonna is okay, she influenced a lot of people, bought her albaum, but what a heck,I still vote for purely rock & roll dudes!

Peter North | 3/11/2008, 4:07 pm EST

Leonard Cohen is no Lynyrd Skynyrd.

ScreenwritingforHollywood | 3/11/2008, 4:12 pm EST

You people are hilarious.

It’s all about the money.

Howee Carr | 3/11/2008, 4:16 pm EST

slightly off-topic, but…

Re. Gov. Spitzer- a shame… Silda Spitzer is a MILF!

revolution | 3/11/2008, 4:19 pm EST

Yes… the rock hall has inducted pop people before. And those people didn’t belong in either!

They also inducted fringe underground groups… some of which may not deserve it either.

Leave it to the fans to say who is in first! Leave it to the fans of rock music and not some secret society of millionaires to decide.

Rock music is for everyone.

It can be like a religion. And for those about to rock, I salute you.

So let’s give the fans a voice in this.

Because it means something REAL to the fans… the true fans of rock.

So before another Madonna… give us the freakin’ Cars! Or the Zombies! Or any number of rock bands that inspired countless other rock artists.

End your secret society TODAY!

a retard from hell | 3/11/2008, 4:20 pm EST

i’m personally just wish esther would go back to england! if jamming your 50 year old tongue down britney spears’ mouth is Rock&Roll then by all means ROCK ON ESTHER! by the way pat benatar DOES ROCK!

Marc | 3/11/2008, 4:44 pm EST

Since its inception, the Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame has recognized legends in all genres of popular music. Not just “rock” or “hard rock” or “blues rock” but also R&B, pop, country, actual blues (rock’s precursor), etc.

For those who argue that Madonna doesn’t deserve to be inducted, are you also suggesting that icons like Aretha Franklin, B.B. King and Ahmet Ertegun don’t deserve recognition either? ‘Rock & Roll’ refers to a spirit, not an actual sound. You don’t have to actually like her music to recognize and respect her tremendous achievements. Anybody who can still sell out arenas and have her albums go platinum 25 years into their career must be doing something right. When all is said and done, it’s her MUSIC that has kept her popular all this time. Name me another artist who’s built a catalogue of instantly recognizable songs as big as hers over these last 25 years.

Nooooooosh | 3/11/2008, 4:50 pm EST

I just wanted to add my voice to those complaining about Madonna’s inclusion to the R&R Hall of Fame. There aren’t enough old white men who play guitars represented in it as is (as if?)

Sid | 3/11/2008, 5:30 pm EST

Iggy Pop and Madonna are photographed together at the R&R Hall of Fame… And Madonna is the one holding the trophy.

How very sad.

revolution | 3/11/2008, 5:55 pm EST

“For those who argue that Madonna doesn’t deserve to be inducted, are you also suggesting that icons like Aretha Franklin, B.B. King and Ahmet Ertegun don’t deserve recognition either? ‘Rock & Roll’ refers to a spirit, not an actual sound.” – Marc

Well… Ahmet Ertegun is in the hall of fame not as a performer of rock music. And frankly BB King was inducted in 1987 at the height of his mainstream success and maybe wouldn’t have been even considered today.

Rock is a sound. It is music isn’t it? That’s why people are being honored.

If it was just about a ‘rock spirit’ as you suggest than why not induct James Dean, Dennis Hopper, Peter Fonda, Howard Stern, Chris Rock, Kevin Smith, etc., etc.?

Because they aren’t musicians. Specifically musicians who play rock music.

Also to say that she “built” her catalog says alot. She didn’t write most of it. She didn’t perform most of it either. She performed current styles but had a big enough mouth to cause pre-meditated controversy at every turn. Is that the rock spirit you are talking about?

Otherwise her music is the anti-rock. But if you can find spirit in her paint-by-numbers drum-machine reliant phoned in pop divaship, good for you I guess.

gettagrip | 3/11/2008, 6:12 pm EST

What the hell does Cleveland know about rock? Why don’t they get back to their “Polka Town” roots and induct Frankie yankovic and His Yanks into their “rock and roll” hall of fame? I think RICK ASTLEY should be inducted. I have heard from a reputable source that Menudo, Vitamin C, Tiffany and Debbie Gibson are front runners for next year. Seriously, does who gets into the hall matter at all? The whole thing is a tourist trap.

Not a Madonna hater, but... | 3/11/2008, 6:51 pm EST

Doesn’t rock music deserve a hall of fame of its own. I think as far as music genres go, it deserves its own hall of fame. Pop/dance music can also have its own hall of fame. I don’t have any problem with that. I think they should change the name of the place to the Popular Music Hall of Fame, if they’re not going to stick to actual Rock. As for Blues artists going in there, I can at least see the connection in that Rock came out of the Blues. But I don’t think anyone can seriously make an argument for Madonna’s music being a subgenre of Rock. It just clearly isn’t Rock. That’s why we have names for the different genres of music out there. Either have a Rock Hall that’s exclusively dedicated to Rock, or don’t call it that. Or don’t have one at all. It’s not a Madonna-hater thing. It’s that the standards for inducting the artists don’t make any sense at all. Some worthy, eligible Rock artists are not getting inducted while some artists who have nothing to do with Rock are in there. So it seems like a sham of an institution. Like I said, I think agreeable solutions would be to have an actual Rock Hall of Fame with only actual rock artists included, plus separate halls of fame for other music genres. Or, call it what it is… a Popular Music Hall of Fame. Even then I don’t think I’d support it because of many worthy acts who get snubbed annually. I wish the idiots in charge of this thing would adopt more objective standards.

jupitergod76 | 3/11/2008, 7:03 pm EST

iam so sick of people crying that madonna got into the RRHOF she made it she rules get over it quit calling her a blonde bimbe skank we all know that is your mother your talking about.so shut the hell up

Darya | 3/11/2008, 7:17 pm EST

URDogSpot: I am sure there aren’t just Americans here posting ignorant comments, but hey, let’s generalize, shall we? :)

I think that Madonna does deserve her spot. She’s done a lot in giving female performers the opportunity to be taken seriously, whether you like it or not.

steelers_eat_brownies | 3/11/2008, 7:32 pm EST

Sure, I can see Rick Astley in the hall of fame. What about Wayne Newton?

jupitergod76 | 3/11/2008, 7:41 pm EST

Frank Stallone should be in the hall.

DAVID LEE ROTH | 3/11/2008, 7:52 pm EST

Modanna couldn’t sellout a highschool gym! She’s a hasbeen

Willy G | 3/11/2008, 9:12 pm EST

I guess “David Lee Roth” isn’t aware that Madonna’s 2006 Confessions Tour was the most successful concert tour by a female artist in history. I would hardly consider that a “has been”. Again, simple minded haters who make comments with no base on fact. Sad, sad, sad.

beaconmike | 3/11/2008, 9:51 pm EST

Billy Joel’s comments about death were incredibly inappropriate.

To watch last night and hear Billy Joel joke so much about death……….as a ‘good career move’………and that ‘at least you aren’t fertilizer’…………when Billy Joel knew that the lead singer from the Dave Clark Five had just passed away a few days earlier and that the Dave Clark had to sit in the kitchen and endure his pathetically insensitive comments about death………..and even when Mike Smith’s family is grieving across the Bay for their loss of him, and Dennis Payton’s 2 sons are sitting in the audience (sax player for the DC5 who also passed a year earlier)………….to have to endure those comments that Billy Joel either knowingly wrote himself, or had to have known what was to be said before he went on…………well, Billy Joel, you ought to be ashamed………..dammed ashamed, and if I don’t mind saying so myself, unless you learn to cut back on your meal portions, you are going to be making a great career move sooner than later.

I have purchased my last Billy Joel piece of music.

Pattutie on Billy.

Melissa | 3/11/2008, 9:52 pm EST

Let them hate Madonna, like she said they “make her work harder, and better!” I”m not a fan of hers but I do agree she belongs in the hall of fame for her huge influence on music (rock n roll).

beaconmike | 3/11/2008, 9:58 pm EST

Just one more thing…………as everyone googles and gaggles over Madonna being in the Hall of Fame and her incredibly heartfelt speech that almost brought her to tears at times………….well her speech almost brought me to tears when she referred to her current manager, in his earlier days as he apprenticed with her then manager………..she referred to him as a “Steppin Fetchit” type of guy.

Now them, for those of you who don’t know the racial kind of slur that the words Steppin Fetchit can create………..just ask one of your local rappers what he thinks of those words……….they get close to similarity if you were to use the N word.

If you were to suggest that Obama is a Steppin Fetchit character, there would be WWIII initiated right then and there, and for Madonno to be so incredibly stupid as to use that characterization………..I just wonder what drugs she was on………..or she should finally fire her publicist who wrote those incredibly stupid words.

It would be like saying he is just an Uncle Tom or a Little Black Sambo.

Of all people………..you would think that Madonna would get it by now.

I bet the show goes back to simply being reported on and no more live shows.

The kind of insensitivities shown by Billy Joel and Madonna are just incredible.

Screw it! Induct Gerardo now! | 3/11/2008, 10:14 pm EST

Rico Suave!

I agree the Madonna-haters can go. I don’t think anyone should bash on Madonna or her music. And yes, DLR, she remains tremendously popular.

But her music isn’t rock, so it doesn’t belong in the only “Rock” hall of fame. She needs to be inducted into the pop music or disco/dance hall of fame, post haste!

Meanwhile, let rock be rock and have its own place to be celebrated. It’s big enough that it doesn’t need non-rock acts filling in. If you’re going to have a Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, let’s limit the inductees to artists who primarily create and perform rock music (and its closely-related derivatives). They have a country music hall of fame, a gospel music hall of fame, so why not a pop/dance music hall of fame. Why should rock be a catch-all term for various genres of popular music? Let rock have a place of its own.

phoneguy | 3/11/2008, 10:42 pm EST

LIKE THEM OR NOT, KISS DESERVES A PLACE IN RRHOF. HAD IT NOT BEEN FOR THEM, SOME OF THE PEOPLE ALREADY INDUCTED WOULD HAVE NEVER MADE IT AS FAR AS THEY DID. KISS HAS DONE MORE FOR ROCK THAN MOST PEOPLE REALIZE. KISS BEING EXCLUDED FROM THE RRHOF IS A SLAPIN THE FACE TO A BAND THAT HAS SPENT OVER THIRTY YEARS PAVING THE WAY FOR OTHER LESS TALENTED BANDS. GIVE KISS THE HONOR THEY DESERVE. INDUCT THEM NOW!!

Don't worry about it | 3/11/2008, 10:56 pm EST

Don’t worry about the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, at least not yet, because it doesn’t exist yet. What we have now is the Record Industry and Critic-Approved Contemporary Popular Music Hall of Fame. It isn’t about Rock music per se, otherwise non-rock acts wouldn’t be there. I’m waiting for someone to establish the real Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, where only artists who have something to do with Rock are inducted. This one isn’t it. It has some well-deserving rock acts in it already, but it’s ignoring some others who are truly deserving and inducting pop/disco acts instead. I, for one, will welcome the real Rock Hall as soon as it exists. Can’t we have a Rock-only hall? Country and Gospel have each have one.

Hall of Shame | 3/11/2008, 11:10 pm EST

We shouldn’t be petitioning for Rush, KISS, or any other true Rock act to be inducted into this turd. It would be an insult to the bands. This current poser hall ignores deserving Rock artists while inducting non-Rock artists. It has no credibility because the voters aren’t consistent in their nomination standards. They should really change the name to the Popular Music Hall of Fame. If someone ever establishes an actual Rock and Roll Hall of Fame – one that sticks to artists that comfortably fit in that genre’s description. let me know. Then we can have bands such as Kiss and Rush along with other rock acts the current hall has, such as Zeppelin and the Beatles, etc. But let’s not dilute the good names of any more worthy Rock artists by inducting them into a phony Rock Hall.

Me | 3/11/2008, 11:13 pm EST

This lip-synchin’, wannabe-somebody, talentless-twat deserves to be in the Hall, just as the lip-synchin’ Milli-Vanilli’s, the Britney’s gone bonkers Spears and others like them need to be in it. And there are others in the hall, who probably should not be as well.
After all, it is supposed to be the rock and roll hall of fame, not the “pop”, or “lip-synch” hall of fame. The only rock with her (that is if she didn’t smoke it) is that she’s dumber and as talented as a rock.

Rock Hall? | 3/11/2008, 11:22 pm EST

This hall of fame isn’t just for rock music. The powers that be have made that painfully clear. If was a real Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, Madonna and JT would not be allowed through the doors without buying a ticket – to see the exhibits. Madonna’s very talented and popular, and she deserves recognition for it, but her music just isn’t Rock and Roll. They should just change the name of the hall to something more general, like the Popular Music Hall of Fame. Sorry to say, the Rock-only hall that Rock fans want to see doesn’t exist.

Come to think of it... | 3/11/2008, 11:36 pm EST

Why doesn’t somebody create an actual Rock and Roll Hall of Fame? One with only Rock artists in it? There are quite a few deserving Rock artists if you look back through the last 50 years or so. Certainly they’ve accomplished enough to deserve their own hall of fame. That way, the pop music fans can have their hall and the Rock fans can have theirs as well. Country has its own hall, so why doesn’t Rock have its own hall?

madonna fan | 3/11/2008, 11:56 pm EST

“beaconmike”, you are WAY off base with your ridiculous comment! Only a racist bent on finding racist things in what people say would even REMOTELY consider what Madonna said a racial slur. Oh, and learn how to spell before you post comments!

Iggy hates shirts! | 3/12/2008, 12:24 am EST

Rush definitely belongs in the hall. They have accomplished a lot (over 30 million records sold, big, well-attended concert tours, influenced a lot of other famous bands, have about 18 gold records and about 10 platinum records). Not to mention all the charity work they have done. But, many people are concerned about the hall’s induction standards, and it’s name. Some less-deserving artists have already been inducted, and some who have been inducted aren’t Rock artists. So maybe it should be the “Popular Music Hall of Fame”, not the “Rock and Roll Hall of Fame”. Even then, Rush and at least a dozen other Rock acts (Yes, Genesis, Kiss, to name just a few) would still deserve the recognition. However, I’m still concerned that their standards for induction are a bit illogical, flimsy and unfair, given some pretty bad snubs. Maybe we need an actual Rock and Roll Hall of Fame with more logical induction standards, and to get past the thing about non-Rock acts being inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame as they have now. In a better world, we’d have an actual Rock hall, to avoid all this controversy. And then maybe the deserving Rock artists (such as those I mentioned above) wouldn’t get snubbed for so long. These bands aren’t critics’ and RS favorites, so when they’re letting artists from all other genres in there, it makes you wonder if these actual Rock bands will ever get inducted into the place that calls itself the “Rock and Roll” Hall of Fame. Because of the goofy, illogical induction standards they have, plus the non-Rock artists in there, this place lacks sorely in credibility. It’s a joke of an institution, but it sure isn’t funny, it’s just insulting.

Sid | 3/12/2008, 12:43 am EST

Hmmm… Madonna is in the Hall of Fame, but not Deep Purple.

Can anyone really make the argument that “Papa Don’t Preach” is a greater contribution to Rock Music than “Smoke on the Water?”

eicain | 3/12/2008, 2:35 am EST

I thinj Madonna is the best female artist in history. She has launched new musical trends and she’s a big inspiration for a lot of artists. Madonna has to stay in the Hall of fame.

cristi | 3/12/2008, 2:50 am EST

It isn’t the first time an artist who hasn’t made rock n roll is inducted in the Hall of fame, so… why are you criticizing Madonna in this way? We all know how she influenced music and culture. She’s a legend. (Excuse my english but I’m italian)

RRHOF | 3/12/2008, 7:01 am EST

Damn….ok…I agree with madonna being in there. I am not a fan whatsoever but she had a big impact. Enough said. John Mellancamp…not a fan, but had a big impact. Enough said. The Dave Clark 5? The Venturers? What about Rush? What about KISS? Are they not in the hall because they are the ugliest guys to pick up instruments? Its a damn shame thats all I am going to say.

Anonymous | 3/12/2008, 8:09 am EST

Whoever said rush should be in there are wrong they should die, Stooges should be in there

joey | 3/12/2008, 10:01 am EST

to the user (((ME))) calling Madonna a talent less twat is not only false and rude it is just plain stupid it shows how smart your inbred hick 3rd grade educated mind is.i mean come on she has lasted how long?and how many albums does she have she sells out all her concerts looks and moves amazing does not I repeat does not lipsync her songs play a mean ass guitar and if you or anyone else cant see that well your not only blind but stupid hypocrites ,her songs,movies,books,are all amazing my kids love her she is tough and does what she wants,your jealous and envious that someone like you didn’t make it big so you need to criticize those who made it,so shut up go back to your banjos and check out your family members for dates and the world will be a much better place without you

Sid | 3/12/2008, 10:23 am EST

Shouldn’t the HoF exhaust the supply real ROCK acts before extending membership to dance-pop singers and rappers? Why in particular does the HoF ignore metal and progressive rock bands? Shouldn’t musicianship count for something?

Why start inducting people like Madonna when there are still glaring omissions among eligible acts such as Rush, Alice Cooper, Deep Purple, Judas Priest, MC5, King Crimson, Yes, the Stooges, Ted Nugent, Iron Maiden, the Runaways, Blue Cheer, ELP, ELO, the Damned, Foghat, Free, Bad Company, Mott the Hoople, Motorhead, et. al.

Oh, and inducting Madonna and not Joan Jett is like inducting Pat Boone instead of Little Richard…

Noooooosh | 3/12/2008, 1:58 pm EST

Ohmygod, you all need to switch to decaf. The outrage here is compelling me to roll my eyes until they seize.

Mrs.Christ Superstar | 3/12/2008, 2:05 pm EST

She sells records and other peoples art. She began ripping off Malcolm Mclaren(”Hey DJ”)in the onset of her career.”Vogue” also is a knock off of Malcolm McLaren’s “Deep In Vogue” which was written years prior to her new product release.
McLaren began the Sex Pistols,Bow Wow Wow-etc.). Look, she’s lying-delusional and definitley going to spend a big budget to cover up her past-the only way she can escape the truth is by removing everything from the public.Good Luck Madge- Crucifying yourself could have been a mistake.

Sid | 3/12/2008, 2:29 pm EST

So Madonna started out “playing drums along with Elvis Costello records, and strumming four chords on a guitar.”

Big deal… I played little league baseball when I was nine, but that doesn’t mean I belong in the baseball Hall of Fame.

CEO in florida | 3/12/2008, 3:08 pm EST

all of you Madonna haters need to go she does not rip off other peoples music if you know anything she writes her own,and to that vogue remark well vogue was written by her for the dance style called vogue based in newyork clubs,get your facts right quit crying that she made it damn you all cry more than a newborn baby so she made it in the RRHOF,good for her so have many other people but do you bitch about them hmmm no you don’t just about her your just a bunch of jealous hicks so stick to your beer and loser life and your petty little sad remarks get a life

Sid | 3/12/2008, 3:56 pm EST

Apparently, “CEO in florida” is trying to get into the Run-on Sentence Hall of Fame…

And please stop referring to anyone who objects to Madonna’s induction as “haters…”
You sound like a bunch of illiterate 13-year-olds. There is a big difference between legitimately recognizing someone’s lack of talent or appropriateness and “hating” that person.

The fact remains... | 3/12/2008, 4:01 pm EST

Madonna’s music isn’t rock. It’s not even close. Induct her into the dance/pop music hall of fame instead. Let rock artists have their place. They’ve earned it.

Sid | 3/12/2008, 4:31 pm EST

A lot of people here have tried to justify Madonna’s inclusion simply by citing her commercial success and record sales.

Fine… then induct Celine Dion, Julio Iglesias, Garth Brooks, Abba, Frank Sinatra and Bing Crosby… all of whom have sold as many or more records than Madonna (and are no less Rock & Roll).

2all the dimwits | 3/12/2008, 4:34 pm EST

oh SID your so funny ha ha ha ha ha and get with it when someone says hater it means you dislike something duh what are ya 80!and she has no lack of talent do you even know who Madonna is?seems like you don’t so like stop whining damn grow up and shut up while your at it……oh and run on sentence hall of fame?———good one yeh bravo i think CEO would agree with that very smart intelligent remark.and have any of you been to the RRHOF if you have you would see many many others in the that is not ”’rock”’

Bitter Gay Mark | 3/12/2008, 4:40 pm EST

Uh, BEACONMIKE. . . Madonna’s alleged racial slur was talking about her white/jewish manager. How is that a slur?

CEO in florida | 3/12/2008, 4:50 pm EST

well thank you sid you made my day i have not laughed so hard at someone for a long time.and to those who say madonna is not a rocker well i have been to the RRHOF 5 times and i recall the supremes are there,dusty springfield,the isley brothers and many others who are not “rockers”.so please quit being haters oh excuse me (those who object to madonnas being in the RRHOF)just live with it and cry about something else.and SID i accept being in the SHOF.thank you boohoo thank you

Pardon me | 3/12/2008, 5:18 pm EST

Where are the faces?

Not All Madonna Haters | 3/12/2008, 5:25 pm EST

I don’t think all those who question or denounce Madonna’s induction are all Madonna haters. I don’t hate Madonna or her music. Actually, I like quite a few of her songs. I think a lot of us just question what the Rock Hall should and shouldn’t include, if they’re going to call it the Rock Hall. Add into that the highly questionable selection process and worthy actual rock artists getting snubbed year after year. That’s the big one, worthy artists getting snubbed in a highly suspect nomination process that has iffy standards. It makes one question the integrity of the whole thing. It’s a virtual recipe for controversy. I know it isn’t important, but it would be nice if the hall had some credibility if we’re even going to have one. Otherwise there’s no point to its existence.

Anyway, don’t dismiss such arguments as simply people hating on Madonna. It’s simple-minded, childish and simply not true (for many people, anyway).

CEO has a point | 3/12/2008, 5:35 pm EST

There are a lot of other non-rock inductees already in the hall. So we should throw them all out as well, not just Madonna. Let them get their own hall, and them the RRHOF commit itself to Rock only. Or, change this one over to the Popular Music Hall of Fame and start an actual Rock Hall someplace else.

New nomination process | 3/12/2008, 6:03 pm EST

I have the solution: the potential nominees to a pool of only artists who clearly fall somewhere into the Rock spectrum. A small panel of Rock overlords set the standards (I’m thinking one representative from each sub-genre, with someone like like OZZY presiding over the court. If an artists fits better in Country, Pop, Disco, Classical, or Rap/Hip-hop, etc., leave ‘em out. Blues was the main father of Rock, so we leave it in. OZZY gets veto power. Then punish the junta that currently picks the nominees by banishing them from the process forever, maybe even exiling them to an iceberg or secret prisons. The voters shall consist of actual Rock or Blues artists and the public. Normally I’d be worried about the public taste in anything, but if we limit what they’re allowed to vote on to just Rock artists, then they can’t go that far off track. One more rule: Poison is banned for life from induction and even visiting the hall. No override on that rule, not even for OZZY and the panel of Rock Overlords.

k.drone(michael) | 3/12/2008, 8:28 pm EST

Madonna and her management are aware of the anger vented towards this issue. they will blow it off, until it subsides and publically manuever a special moment to accomodate this situation(it is a joke to them, like most things they want to and need to control). No, No rocker would keep an award if they know it should be elsewhere.Is she an American Pie? I could detail a list of complete disasters in her career from the past 5 years, but those are swept away after success is acheived. Do you think Liz Rosenberg(manager) worked hard to get MDonna’s public image in good graces?
And Madonna if you are reading this why after I declined to submit my early recording to Maverick in 2001 was my close friend/producer flown to San Fran to spin at Nikki H’s birthday bash which you attended(2002)-then after moving to NYC in 2003 who sent Junior Vasquez into my then new studio? And Madonna I showed nothing but distaste not for you personally but the method of tactic to manipulation- that did not matter Felix Housecat took over my former recording studio while in your entourage. YOu have no boundries woman-don’t second guess why people think your not worthy. I was kind to share a few political plans with friends who I assume relayed then in your direction..you have yet to submit-
people don’t trust you..think your a sleaze at 50 still. The dj’s in your oh-so-cool side show are paid to play Madonna songs..-your music would never drop into the disc drive or slam down on a turntable without a fat check. Do not Madonna use a hint of my idea’s until I am paid a nice,sweet sum of cash money.If you want Mcmommy research the Judas Priest trial of subliminal audio hallucinations-its verdict, cause I have a real live documented case involving your Messiah iconography-”Like A Prayer” and your Sigmond Freud religious game self designed by Mrs. Richie to create the “Messiah” only one problem the real life scenario plays out like a Manson case.

Me | 3/12/2008, 10:25 pm EST

To the brainwashed person calling himself Judy or Joey or whatever. The talentless twat Madonna can half-way dance and that and that is as far as her talent can take her. She sounds like a sick cow, cannot play anything but play with herself and gullible people like you. As far as writing, I’m sure that her children’s books would probably sound better in her songs than the crap that’s in her lip-synchin’ junk that is no where near rock and roll, more along the lines of bubblegum or disco.And as far as her music having “mean-ass” guitar….apparently you have never heard the likes of Ritchie Blackmore, Robin Trower and countless other deserving and talented musicians and rock and rollers who deserve to be in the Hall…..not someone who can only dance…..where the heck is Fred Astaire?

PaulyR | 3/13/2008, 9:23 am EST

Whoa… a ton of posts. I’m not going to get into the fray. I would guess the RS writer was _actually there_. The ceremony, as broadcast on television, was just short of a train wreck: JT and Lou’s speeches… Paul Schaffer with Mark Goodman… the wait before the last song, the filthy Waldorf-Astoria, just painful. Dear VH1: go back to taping it & airing it a week later.

Millie Vanillie | 3/13/2008, 10:55 am EST

This post is directed to CLEVELAND,OHIO-Rock Capital of the World.You imbecile did you not detect the Sarcasm in my previuos posting??Do you know what the word means?The Artists listed wrote the book on ROCK(DUH!)This was a fun debate,but useless.Really the point is that rock music contains so many sub genres that Johnny Cash belongs there( his 50’s rockabilly-Country Rock)Muddy Waters belongs(Blues Rock etc..)Madonna is not rock music nor does she really fit in any way as an influence.For those that love her music that’s cool-but there should be a Pop/Dance music Hall of Fame,a Hip Hop Hall of Fame,an R&B Hall of Fame etc.It really doesn’t matter who is in the Hall because they seem to let anyone and everyone in anyhow.Dusty Springfield?? But music is art and musical art is in the ear of the listener and therefore subjective.C’est la Vie

rebebeck | 3/13/2008, 6:33 pm EST

yes spook i agree iggy is so fuuu old

rebebeck | 3/13/2008, 6:38 pm EST

yes i agree iggy is so oldddddddddddddddddddd

the truth is bought- | 3/14/2008, 2:57 pm EST

When journalists write they sell their material, and whether its to the Whitehouse or Madonna’s agent/manager if its a real dirty and true-that story is often sold to its defendant for a large sum.
When people are really celebrities/”stars” they do not need to send propoganda promo releases in their favor to sway public opinion.
Madonna’s camp is guilty.
If Miss thing were not a wanna-be herself then she could never relate to her worshipers-she is better in disguise than them. No person has what she has because no else feels the need or is empty enough in the creative spirit to legally plagurize and imitate orginal artists in order to receive adoration. First example, and the only one used(here)is “Vogue” which is the knock off to Malcolm McLaren’s “Deep In Vogue” written/visualized few years prior.
Rock N Roll is alive; corporate commerical media control freaks in search of themselves and power did not ruin anything. Rock is been on sabatical, its time is come..Live Nation can try to corner every market and venue in America all they want-without music-they have no sales..street fairs in the projects and ghetto rock festivals with real rockers taking over the inner corridors and streets of the U.S. first is where its at. Nothing will shock the Nation of Islam and the Latin Kings more than hard rock and touring musicians rolling neighborhoods with sound and princesses.Not too many white folk have stepped out of the norm-its time to inspire and draw from where soul came from.

k.drone(nemesis)Michael | 3/14/2008, 3:32 pm EST

Was the intro speech Justin Timberlake gave pre-written by a publicist?
And does he realize that he imitated Prince-Elton John and Michael Jackson and claims himself not a wanna-be?He could just claim as McDonna does that he was nveer those people before-which will give him the power to do anything else he wants.
Pure genius, absolutely an inspiration to everyone who loves kareoke and Korean t.v-
His production team doesn’t fish don’t phish round the intranet hooking new idear’s fer rechords AND SUPPERstarz dew they?

Orgo | 3/14/2008, 5:14 pm EST

I can see the Detroit connection as to why The Stooges played those Madonna songs but if I were in The Stooges and had any sense,I wouldn’t've done such a thing since The Stooges are STILL waitin’ to be inducted into the Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame!



Advertisement

Advertisement