Previous Next Latest

The Idol Countdown: Five Essential Moments From Last Night’s “American Idol”

2/20/08, 1:25 pm EST

Brace yourself: the next twenty-one days will bring three episodes of American Idol per week, with four eliminations each Thursday until we’re down to the twelve finalists. Last night the top twelve guys performed songs of the Sixties, and the show became infatuated with the idea that they have three “rockers” in its midst. Let’s assume you won’t hear from Chikezie, Jason Yeager, Luke Menard or Garrett Haley again (Ellen Degeneres lookalike Colton Berry, dreadlocked guitarist Jason Castro and smooth David Hernandez will likely make the cut) — here are last night’s best (and most rockin’, according to the judges) clips:

5. David Cook’s “Happy Together” makes Randy Jackson imagine Cook fronting Alice in Chains. Seriously, he says this, watch:

4. Former boy bander Robbie Carrico looks like Justin Timberlake but refuses to take off his bandanna like Bret Michaels. This means he rocks about as hard as Three Doors Down.

3. David Archuleta is rocking a Melinda Doolittle “Who, me? I can sing? You like me!?” attitude that would be grating if he wasn’t so damn likeable.

2. Randy likens Aussie Michael Johns to Michael Hutchence. We were too distracted by the fire flaming away in the background to remember anything else.

1. And now for a moment we’d like to call “Oh, Snap! Danny Noriega!”


Previous Next Latest

Comments

rhiannon | 3/9/2008, 7:34 pm EST

greg, i wish you could hear david cook sing “man in a box.” he’s not layne stayley, but he’s the closest you’ll ever get anymore.

GREG | 3/6/2008, 11:19 am EST

TO SHAWNUEL LAYNE HAS BEEN DEAD SINCE 2002 SO UNLESS U ARE BEING SARCASTIC DAVID COOK VOICE WILL NEVER TOUCH THAT OF THE LATE GREAT LAYNE STALEY AND TO BONERJAM AGREED LAYNE IS ROLLING OVER IN HIS GRAVE RIGHT NOW

engamenga | 3/5/2008, 10:12 pm EST

yahoo for jason castro,not clumsy, charismatic. Hallelujah!

JULES | 2/24/2008, 11:31 pm EST

I think that there are 4 dudes that had really good performances this week. Robbie, David, Jason,and Michael. If they continue down this path, we are in for some great entertainment. As far as Danny goes, he probably going to get votes because of his personality and his bitchy attitude. He is funny though. I just wish that he would quit pouting and put his tongue back in his mouth. Geez.

Shawnuel | 2/23/2008, 12:37 pm EST

Actually, Staley’s voice has been a little off lately.

Roger Tubalado | 2/23/2008, 5:08 am EST

Malibay just shot me to the moon. All 3 judges swooned over her unanimously;

She’ll be singing her way to the top 3 finalists!

BEE | 2/22/2008, 6:24 pm EST

David Cook’s performance was hands-down the best. The weird, permasmile, deer-in-the-headlights look on Jason Castro just made me laugh hysterically.

Junhow | 2/22/2008, 3:50 pm EST

I’m sick of people comparing Danny to Sanjaya… newsflash: Sanjaya couldn’t sing and Danny can blow!

Allison | 2/21/2008, 11:10 am EST

Michael Johns is my favorite. Definitely the best in my opinion. Funny, I never even noticed the flames until everyone started blogging about it the next day. Guess, I was too busy enjoying his performance.

And, yeah, Jason Castro was great. He really should have been on that list.

Oodb | 2/21/2008, 3:00 am EST

Checking the internet, the buzz and the pics, and the oohs and ahhs are going to Jason Castro….

AB | 2/20/2008, 6:29 pm EST

Jason Castro was AMAZING! I can’t believe he wasn’t on this list..Simon , the hardest judge to please, even said he was top 2 next to David Archuleta…He really was Incredible.. If he had a CD out right now i would literally go and buy it today!

emilylovee | 2/20/2008, 6:11 pm EST

David Archuleta definitely has my vote. Hes the best singer I’ve ever seen. Not to mention very cute

Dan | 2/20/2008, 5:47 pm EST

Um dude, the guy who had “One of the top 2 performances tonight” was Jason Castro, so how can he be out of the top 5? His guitar moment was historical because it was the first time anyone has ever had an instrument on Idol. Plus, how many guys with dreds have they had? And he was fantastic on top of that…VOTE JASON CASTRO

JS | 2/20/2008, 5:29 pm EST

Past Idol seasons I have flipped over Carrie Underwood, Fantasia, Paris, Taylor Hicks, Clay Aiken, Ruben Studdard, Jennifer Hudson immediately. The moment I heard Chris Daughtry sing I was telling everyone I could find to listen to this guy. This year no one has come close so far. Really, last season was just lukewarm to me. I hope one of the women tonight blows it away.

Miko | 2/20/2008, 5:12 pm EST

Danny is Sanjaya Part II..

Blair | 2/20/2008, 4:07 pm EST

David Cook is a great singer and the only one last night that even came close to being doing a modern/current performance!

BONERJAM | 2/20/2008, 3:24 pm EST

Daivd Cook is a horrible singer and he looks like he is trying to look like rocker. Fronting Alice in Chains, what a joke, Layne Staley’s voice is a thousand times better.

Post A Comment

Caution: Off-topic comments will be deleted

Name:

Comments:



Advertisement

Advertisement