P.S. I Love You starring Hilary Swank may be “the chick flick from hell,” but Rolling Stone movie critic Peter Travers has real praise for this week’s two musical releases. Judd Apatow’s Walk Hard: The Dewey Cox Story wonderfully casts John C. Reilly in a rock-biopic parody whose jokes are hit or miss. In Sweeney Todd, Johnny Depp sings — a lot. Tackling a tough vocal score, Depp acts brilliantly as the Demon Barber of Fleet Street who returns to London for cannibalistic revenge. For Travers’ full reviews, click to watch the video above.

Plus: Read Travers’ review of Sweeney Todd here and Walk Hard: The Dewey Cox Story here.

>> Watch every episode of our weekly Peter Travers video podcast by subscribing via iTunes (when prompted, click “Launch application”). Every Friday, a new episode will be delivered to your iTunes. [If you don’t have iTunes, download it here.]