Fricke’s Picks: Porcupine Tree, the Future Kings of England and the Raspberries

11/7/07, 1:46 pm EST


The Art of Nightmares

Porcupine Tree – the long-running British progressive-rock band founded and commanded by singer-guitarist-composer Steven Wilson – are rare in their field: obsessed not with fantasy but the death of it, particularly in children. At a recent head-trip gig at New York’s Beacon Theatre, films of sickly-white preteen
zombies – hypnotized by computer screens, gulping medication, brandishing handguns – were projected on a screen behind Wilson during his tangled distortion-bomb riffing in the long title track of the recent album, Fear of a Blank Planet (Atlantic), and the record’s even longer centerpiece nightmare, “Anesthetize.” A schoolgirl ran amok in what looked like a ruined psych ward during the convulsive title instrumental from the group’s new EP, Nil Recurring (Transmission). Wilson started Porcupine Tree in 1987 as a home-studio experiment that has since evolved, live and on an extensive series of records, into an aggressively modern merger of Rush’s arena art rock, U.K. prog classicism – especially Pink Floyd’s eulogies to madness and King Crimson’s angular majesty – and the postgrunge vengeance of Tool. There are no dragons evident on Fear of a Blank Planet or Nil Returning. But there are plenty of demons. And King Crimson guitarist-sage Robert Fripp plays on both records, an impeccable seal of approval.
New Royal Freaks

Witches and fiends run riot through the lyrics and instrumental vapors of the six extended tracks on The Fate of Old Mother Orvis (Backwater), by the Future Kings of England. The audaciously named British band’s mix of art rock and freak folk is also rife with other specters – the pastoral Floyd, ’72 Genesis, the echosoup psychedelia of Amon Düül II – whipped together with an ardor that sounds like yesterday and tomorrow at once.

Seventies Rock Candy

Hard and sweet, the Raspberries were never the second coming of the Beatles. They were, in the early Seventies, and still are – based on a show I just saw by the original lineup – the rockcandy Who, packing the perfect-Sixties choruses of “Ecstasy” and “Go All the Way” with Live at Leeds fireworks. Singer-guitarist Eric Carmen still hits the mod-angel high notes, and no American band wrote better pop songs about being a great pop band (“Play On,” “Overnight Sensation [Hit Record]”). There is no live album from the group’s ’72-’74 hit streak, which is OK. On Live on Sunset Strip (Rykodisc), a CD/DVD set of a 2005 show, they play every hit, and those that should have been, with the power and shine of their first heyday.


Comments

Justin C. | 8/30/2008, 2:05 am EST

Anyone who refers to Tool as post-grunge should not be writing about music. I’m not one of those rabid, obsessive Tool fans, either, but really, that’s just stupid. Also the Nil Recurring/Returning thing. So I have nothing left to do but label this reviewer as a pseudo-intellectual moron, and beg him to stop writing about music this very second. Thank you.

david | 5/7/2008, 12:12 pm EST

Porcupine Tree are a modern day Floyd with the heaviness of Metallica but five times as good as those bands combined.
Steven Wilson is a rock god that surpasses Hendrix, Morrison and Lennon.

Felix Cobbold | 11/30/2007, 10:51 am EST

The Future Kings of England are a great band.

DFactor | 11/24/2007, 10:58 pm EST

Yep, the Raspberries live LP is a good one (and the show at Highline Ballroom was loads of fun too!).

Mike C. | 11/23/2007, 6:13 pm EST

P’Tree is a sensational band. I’ve seen them twice this year and will gladly go again when they return to NYC.

Fear of a Blank Planet is the best new album of thre last decade.

Peter S. | 11/23/2007, 12:32 pm EST

I saw the Raspberries at Disneyland, I believe it was 1975 .. they sounded good.

Francis L | 11/18/2007, 2:22 pm EST

Robert Fripp is on the road with Porcupine Tree as we speak.

Helvis | 11/13/2007, 8:57 am EST

Recurring makes more sense than returning in the context of the music on the disk!

Peter von Karajan | 11/10/2007, 6:08 pm EST

Norman St John-Stevas: “I have two albums by the Future Kings of England and both are excellent. Highly recommended”

lol…

to have two Ptree albums like fishing two trouts from a large river… u can´t tell a thing… well.. u can eat those trouts and enjoy them anyway.

By the way… what about the whole history of Ptree? what about those milestones of Psychedelia?…
there´s BIA and AIF (Before and After in Absentia) if we talk about the “sound” of Mr.Wilson’s band.

Sure u only know AIF period.

Peter von Karajan | 11/10/2007, 6:05 pm EST

Norman St John-Stevas: “I have two albums by the Future Kings of England and both are excellent. Highly recommended”

lol…

two albums for Ptree are like two trouts from a large river… u can´t tell a thing… well.. u can eat those trouts and enjoy them anyway.

By the way… what about the whole history of Ptree? what about those milestones of Psychedelia?…
there´s BIA and AIF (Before and After in Absentia) if we talk about the “sound” of Mr.Wilson’s band.

Sure u only know AIF period.

Sometimes is like a pain in the stomach when u realize that just a few know about real jewels like Up the Downstair and Signify.

and i`m not saying that after In Absentia the band recorded crap… not at all… Foabp is another milestone in the history of Ptree… but it´s not the only one.

Steven Wilson | 11/10/2007, 11:32 am EST

Yes, tell them Steven! ò_ó

Tony O'Rourke | 11/9/2007, 10:30 am EST

I wouldn’t worry. I heard someone last night at the P Tree in Oxford UK ask the merchandise table for a copy of “Nil By Mouth”! Classic film but not a classic EP.

Norman St John-Stevas | 11/9/2007, 9:03 am EST

I have two albums by the Future Kings of England and both are excellent. Highly recommended.

Ian Perge | 11/8/2007, 11:29 pm EST

RS reporting *positively* about Porcupine Tree?!? I’m pretty sure someone’s hacked the site…

Joe | 11/8/2007, 12:56 pm EST

Porcupine Tree’s album Fear of a Blank Planet is incredible.

nana | 11/8/2007, 9:10 am EST

I agree, Tracey! It would be awesome to see PT finally get some big stateside recognition!! A cover story sounds like a great idea and they deserve it. Break out of your teeny-bopping ways, RS, and give the REAL MUSIC fans some adult music to chew on!

Tunefreak | 11/7/2007, 11:39 pm EST

The best band touring right now. THAT’S RIGHT, the best. And you can’t judge them until you SEE them. Rolling Stone FINALLY picks up on Porcupine Tree… Will wonders never cease? Now if Fricke actually listened to the EP that’d be cool. (this band has been making GREAT music for quite some time now. And the best is yet to come….)

Tracey in Nashville | 11/7/2007, 10:26 pm EST

You go, Steven! And Rolling Stone, how about you guys put Porcupine Tree in your damned magazine? I think your readers are ready to read about someone besides Arcade Fire, the White Stripes and Fitty v. Kanye. In fact, PT would look nice on the cover.

ken | 11/7/2007, 8:18 pm EST

the live raspberries lp is killer, i just wish they’d do a long enough tour and actually play in michigan.

Steven Wilson | 11/7/2007, 3:51 pm EST

Er, the name of the EP is Nil Recurring, not Returning.

Post A Comment

Caution: Off-topic comments will be deleted

Name:

Comments:



Advertisement

Advertisement