Exclusive: David Gilmour Looks Darkly at the Future of Pink Floyd

9/24/07, 4:56 pm EST


Earlier this month, Pink Floyd guitarist David Gilmour released Remember That Night - Live from the Royal Albert Hall, a DVD taken from the London stand of his 2006 world tour featuring guest spots by David Bowie, Graham Nash and David Crosby. Last week he chatted with Rolling Stone’s Brian Hiatt about the DVD, his solo career and the possibility of a Pink Floyd reunion: We hate to break it to you, Floyd fans, but the prognosis sounds pretty grim.

How did you get David Bowie to guest at your show? He hasn’t been performing live much lately.
We were thinking it would be interesting and amusing to get different people up to guest in places. We wanted to get someone to take Roger’s part on “Comfortably Numb” since it’s such a two-person sort of conversation. Our tour manager guy had been working a lot with David Bowie, said he had lunch with him, and I said, “Ask him if he wants to come and do ‘Comfortably Numb,’” he said he’d love to, and could he do another song as well, and I said, “What would you like to do?” So he did “Arnold Layne,” as well.

Do you have a sense of what you’re doing after this DVD?
No. the DVD has been an extraordinary amount of work — I never thought quite how much work it was going to be, getting that all together and working on it, and that’s taken right up until now, basically. I’m not obsessed with a massive ambition to conquer the world anymore. I just would like it if people took the DVD, as the tour I did around the States was fairly limited, a few cities, and I hope people who’ve got a great home system, big screen, great speakers, and will invite a few friends over for a couple of beers and sit down and dig it. I watched it last week, and it was just fantastic. It was a great experience.

What are your hobbies outside of music? What will you do if you’re not working for the next few months?
I’m raising a young family, that sort of stuff takes up an awful lot of time. First time around, when you raise a family when you’re young and ambitious, the family sort of takes second place to your ambition. When you get a second shot at it, I think your attitude may change — certainly, mine has, and I want to put them first. I’ve done an awful lot of stuff, so while I’m definitely going to get back to it one of these days, do another record and some more gigs, there’s not that sense of urgency.

You mentioned something about going out with a lighter burden — is some of that not carrying the Pink Floyd name with you?
Yes. There’s a load of expectations that you can ignore, but it’s difficult to ignore when you go out as Pink Floyd. When you just give yourself your own name and go out, people are going to want you to do whatever you want to do, that’s kind of implicit in the title, isn’t it? I felt much more at ease and much more able to maybe rehearse something for half an hour at a soundcheck and then do it in the evening, and take a much more relaxed approach to some of it.

The inevitable question: The last I heard, you were speaking of Live 8 as perhaps the end of the story of Pink Floyd. What’s your current thoughts on the subject?
What I’ve been doing for the last couple of years — what I was in the middle of when Live 8 came along — was my album, and that’s what I’m thinking about. It’s been a joy and very satisfying, and the album did very well, even though Rolling Stone only gave it two stars. Everything went so well, I can’t see why I would want to be going back to that old thing. It’s very retrogressive. I want to look forward, and looking back isn’t my joy. Roger hasn’t written a lyric lately that has really been something where I’ve gone, “Wow, I wish that was part of my oeuvre.” I don’t know how one puts it, but going back into all that just wouldn’t bring me joy. It’s my time of life to be selfish — please myself.

You could do it without Roger again.
Yeah, yeah. One could do that. But again, I can’t really see why I would want to, unless I wanted a big boost for my ego or a big boost for my bank account, neither of which I need that badly.

They offer you outrageous sums of money to do this.
They did, yeah.

It must be strange to say, “No, I’m not taking that enormous sum of money.”
I can’t — it’s a very hard thing to discuss, really. To you and to virtually everyone in the public, they would find that a difficult thing to understand, because believe me, when I was impoverished, I wouldn’t have turned it down so easily. Life has dealt me a pretty fair hand, I’ve done very well, I’ve been very, very lucky, and now I can say, “This isn’t what I want to do.” As they say, every man has his price, and maybe that’s true, but whatever we’ve been offered isn’t mine.

Have you spoken to Roger since Live 8?
Yeah. Yes, I have. He called me up about something a little while ago. It’s nice. Of course, he was rehearsing. In the documentary that goes with the DVD, there’s a moment of me saying hi to Roger, where we were rehearsing, at Bray Studios near London at the same time last year.

So there’s been a little bit of a thaw?
Yeah. We’re not calling each other every week and going out for dinner every week, but the week of Live 8, we went out for dinner a couple of times. It’s a bit more reasonable. I think there are fundamental differences of opinion and view. As Roger likes to say, we are musically, philosophically, and politically different.

As a Beatles fan, there was something Lennon and McCartney could do together that they couldn’t do apart. Are you willing to accept that that’s true of you and Roger — and yet still not do it?
Yeah, I am willing to accept that. I know that art should be about everything, and therefore, one should get over all one’s differences to create art. But I suspect that our conjunction of people and musicality and taste and intelligence has run out of steam. Roger thought it had in 1975. Certainly, I don’t have any particular desire for it. What one is willing to sacrifice for one’s art is another whole point, and that’s beyond that I’m willing to do right at the moment.

So if you’re going to do another solo record, we have a few years to wait?
Well, not too long — not as long as the last time, and that’s twelve years, which is a little excessive.


Comments

living with the past | 8/22/2008, 5:08 pm EST

” Pink Floyd Is God Blessed By The Creator To Show Love Peace & Life All Over The World From Their Birth, For We Followers They Are Still Together In The Music NO Matter What Happened In Their Personnel Life ”
Pink Floyd will live forever and ever

living with the past | 8/22/2008, 5:08 pm EST

” Pink Floyd Is God Blessed By The Creator To Show Love Peace & Life All Over The World From Their Birth, For We Followers They Are Still Together In The Music NO Matter What Happened In Their Personnel Life ”
Pink Floyd will live forever and ever

The Son of Nothing | 8/6/2008, 1:46 pm EST

You, both David Gilmour and Roger Waters, are totally kids. Please REMEMBER WHO YOU REALLY ARE. DON’T FORGET FROM WHERE YOU HAD STARTED.

P.S. I believe that Richard Wright and Nicholas Mason will agree to reunite with kids like you.

suzyQ | 7/30/2008, 5:51 pm EST

David –please tour in the USA!

Floyd 71 | 7/15/2008, 8:56 pm EST

just came across this site,ive got to say do most these assholes even know what they are talking about,pink floyd was the creation of syd barret (r.i.p) not rw or dg,without barret there would never have been a pf, with barret pf would never have been anywhere as near as big as were/are ive always said that dave gilmour & rick wright are the musical genius of post barret floyd & yes mr waters has wrote some fkn amazing lyrics but they would have been shit without the talents of d.g, rk.w & n.m. personally i & most other pf fans dont give a fuck who wrote the songs ive been a big floyd/gilmour/wright fan for 25+ years & find it very hard to get into waters solo stuff,i just feel that gilmour/wright have always been the voice and sound of pf well since 68 anyway.another way to look at it is that gilmour can do floyd without waters but waters cant do it without gilmour as proven with the pulse album (1 of my favourites)(gilmour & wright are like a fine wine while waters is a like stale beer)and yes i have them all including the waters,gilmour & wright solo albums & on a final note yes it would be great to see the four get back together again & do one last farewell tour but without gilmour willing to do this its never going to happen just be thankfull for the music that they wrote together because no other band out there past or present will ever touch pink floyd the greatest band to grace planet earth music before its time!!!

TomHopes68 | 6/22/2008, 11:46 pm EST

It would be nice for the band to reunite. The albulm would probably be something of a breathe of fresh air. just to here the four of them playing together again on something new. If they did come out with a final albulm, I doubt it would have Pink Floyd written anywhere on it and you can bet your ass there won’t be a tour.

Whatever happens, Thanks guys for the music, and for holding it together as long as you did.

PS Kurt Loder is an ass.

Dave | 6/20/2008, 5:45 am EST

I can only describe the “Remember that Night” dvd as fantastic, I’ve played it again and again and I just don’t get sick of it. Nice to see Nick Mason (PF drummer) in the tour background.

How about a tour to New Zealand David???

eri | 4/12/2008, 3:10 pm EST

Gilmour é simplesmente o melhor solista de todos os tempos.

Rob | 3/12/2008, 5:28 pm EST

Those of us commenting are as divided as David and Roger. As for the one who commented that DG has been living off the PF name and that Syd and Roger had put so much time into building that name. Floyd formed in 1967*, Gilmour officially joined in 1968. * (I know Syd, Roger, Nick & Rick were together before that under a different name) nevertheless, David Gilmour has been the musical stability of Floyd since 1968. Roger’s strength was lyrics, David’s strength was music. Both working together with a common goal of fluid music. I don’t see the difference in David drawing from others lyrical creativity and Roger having to draw from others musical creativity in their solo work. I think DG’s latest solo album was both lyrically and musically tremendous. DG does not owe the fans anything. I look forward to his next solo project.

Billy Bobs | 12/16/2007, 12:38 am EST

ROGER WATERS,
PLEASE release the original Live Wall Concert onto DVD.
Thanks !

Billy Bobs | 12/16/2007, 12:34 am EST

DAVID GILMOUR,
PLEASE put Delicate Sound of Thunder on DVD.
Just get the original master and press it to DVD.
No extraordinary amount of work will be needed.
Just release it already.
Thanks !

Peter B | 12/12/2007, 11:36 am EST

For the last few days, I’ve been searching the Internet on Pink Floyd articles, getting background, trying to understand what David and Roger said about each other, and drove thema apart. One interesting article in particular was “Why the Waters-led Pink Floyd Self-Destructed”, at www.actwin.com/toaph/floyd/ind ulgence.html. They are a magical group, so it is a big shame that they don’t perform together again. There are songs like “Biding my Time”, “One of these Days”, “Shine on you Crazy Diamond”, “Run”, “Another Brick In The Wall, Part 3″, another song off Relics that starts with a cool drum beat that truly psych me up, along with many others that are musically beautiful to hear. But more than creating/recreating the music, reuniting would be giving people a connection to the past, the 60s and 70s when there was vibrant energy in the cultural air and God seemed to bless the musical world with groups like Pink Floyd, the Doors, Led Zeppelin, Blind Faith & Cream, James Brown, (sorry, Jimi Hendrix really doesn’t do it for me) and of course others. As a side-note, I’ve listened to Radio KAOS, and grew to like it.

veovis | 12/9/2007, 4:15 pm EST

Nothing interesting since ATD?
The man wrote an opera! Just because you may not appreciate it doesn’t mean it’s not an admirable accomplishment.

MineHead | 12/4/2007, 11:02 pm EST

Dave has clearly won the war over Waters, and Waters has embodied everything that he used to deplore…(eg.he’s come full circle as a sellout “ROCKSTAR”,charging ridiculous package deals for the good seats, presales to Am-Ex users, and lip syncing because his voice is gone)…he’s nearly a laugh, but really a cry…Dave is probably embarrassed by his obnoxious preening behavior at Live 8 , Dave still plays better than ever, and his voice is amazing for his age, …Waters hasn’t done anything interesting since ATD, and he’s turned into a greedy hyper-capitalist to fund his uber-riche lifestyle…

floyd fan | 11/26/2007, 12:26 am EST

both roger and David should swallow there pride and give the fans what they won’t. And no a fence but there solo work will never be as good as what they did together in the pink floyd

wxogepb aldtiru | 11/21/2007, 3:30 am EST

pbcsjvm gijclte sjhnvub yzatxns vcwfgzm xnuby pkey

Mr. Floyd | 11/4/2007, 9:42 pm EST

Kids…

scull&roses | 10/29/2007, 8:28 am EST

LED ZEPPELIN IS BACK,SO NEVER SAY NEVER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

a night int heruts | 10/26/2007, 1:54 pm EST

Like all good things, it eventually must come to an end. Beating a dead horse does not work. So let’s leave well enough alone, and enjoy what Pink Fylod contributed to the musical landscape, the many great rock records that over their career, have given many fond memories and enjoyment to 100’s of thousands.

Kirk Long Pond Pa USA | 10/12/2007, 12:17 am EST

ALL I CAN SAY IS……THANKS DAVID!!I AM ALSO A 30 YEAR FAN. THIS IS YOUR BEST WORK EVER. THANKS FOR SHARING IT WITH US. I KNOW HOW MUCH WORK IT TAKES TO CREATE THE DVD. PLEASE NEXT TIME ADD A FEW MORE SHOWS IN THE USA. I KNOW YOU THINK LOW OF THE USA BUT THERE IS A COUNTRY FULL PEOPLE THAT STAND BY YOUR SIDE SO PLEASE STAND BY US NEXT TIME… PEACE

AJ | 10/6/2007, 10:32 pm EST

All I know is that the last Roger Waters tour was excellent!!!

uduwudu | 10/1/2007, 8:41 pm EST

At the risk of going off topic slightly anyone think all live DVDs should be released with / separately from a matching CD release? Especially now there are SO many officially released concerts, I find having separate releases (format difference) to be something of a rip off - getting the public to buy things twice. I would be interested more in the DG DVD if the CDs were included like Rush did with R30.

marnr67 | 10/1/2007, 11:20 am EST

hey man! don’t be negative! at least Roger Waters and David Gilmour are talking to eachother. There’s something they haven’t done in 20 or so years before Live 8.

EvilMulder666 | 10/1/2007, 11:04 am EST

David frickin’ Bowie on Comfortably Numb?! I am SO there.

uduwudu | 9/30/2007, 6:07 pm EST

music must be judged on merit and DG is better than most new bands

Merit? Of course. The bands I referred to play dark, heavy, spacey instrumental music (of a very high calibre - not derivative clones!). I just meant that there are alternative high standard bands out there as well as DG. I thought on An Island was a wonderful album. But if no there is no PF then see who else is recording and performing challenging music for the mind.
Yes of course DG is better than MOST new bands. He’s have to be, he’s been at it longer. But he’s not the only one out there.

Joe | 9/30/2007, 2:23 pm EST

“It would be so nice to see all this attention directed to the newer bands and musicians that make the sort of compelling, hard, intelligent rock music now that say PF and Crimson did in their attention getting hey day.”

music must be judged on merit and DG is better than most new bands

uduwudu | 9/30/2007, 7:37 am EST

It would be so nice to see all this attention directed to the newer bands and musicians that make the sort of compelling, hard, intelligent rock music now that say PF and Crimson did in their attention getting hey day. Porcupine Tree, Guapo, Indukti, and NeBeLNeST to name a few. Waiting to follow the worms is getting no one anywhere.
Many comments are very valid here, the ones pointing out that DG and PF would be nowhere without the public support particularly so. But no matter how true and painful, your attention should go elsewhere if the real PF type trip is what you want.
Personally I hated seeing the crowd sentimentality during C. Numb at Live 8. I mean it was like some weeping MOR thing. It became a nursery rhyme… Not PF’s fault at all but really it’s time to turn one’s attention to newer happening and non mainstream progressive acts. There is some amazing stuff happening (as Tool fans know) and the media have everyone focussed on
rock music’s money / political issues as that gives them less to think about other than ensuring sales figures for their magazines by going over the same old ground. Some things never change. But looking underground just may turn things around in ways you want yet not expect…
Sorry not much PF content. Love PF and much post Wall releases but there’s more out there than just PF albums, no matter how fantastic they are.

Add to your pile of great albums!

RogerandDave | 9/30/2007, 3:56 am EST

Give it a rest people, our creative period was from 1966-1981. We’re relics from the 60’s and 70’s who are now in our 60’s. We don’t mind playing Pink Floyd songs separately, just not as Pink Floyd the band. Syd’s death was the final nail in the coffin. You want to see Pink Floyd as Roger, Dave, Nick and Rick or before when Syd was lucid, watch YouTube or get the DVD’s, CD’s, or downloads of us in our prime; Like Live at Pompeii, Dark Side of the Moon or the 40th Anniversary edtion of Piper at the Gates of Dawn. Keep the royalties coming in, RogerandDave over and out.

peter chrispp | 9/30/2007, 1:32 am EST

Looking at the history of Pink Floyd, either way they have left us fans with a huge and a magninficent body of work that will
stand the test of “Time”. In the grand scheme of things all the members are 60+ and although it would be great but the legacy they have left and David’s desire not to
re-form Pink Floyd is to me, although millions of fans would love to see it, the writing is on “The Wall” so be it. At least now
we can enjoy David’s new live in concert dvd, if he decides to bow out good luck to him, you reckon he has deserved it!!! I think so!!!! Thanks once again for some stunning music over the years!!!

JMc | 9/29/2007, 11:15 pm EST

Wouldn’t it be the ultimate in irony if Roger, Nick & Rick decided to make an album as Pink Floyd, regardless of Dave’s wishes. Would he try to stop them like Roger did in the 80’s? Unlikely scenario but interesting to ponder. Wouldn’t be as good with a different guitarist & Rick would have to sing more!

Mr. Tequila Dude | 9/29/2007, 6:41 pm EST

I am probably one of the few people who does not want to see a Pink Floyd “reunion”. I have been a PF fan for nearly 30 years, and I have all their CDs including the 40 year anniversary Piper that just came out. But I also have the new David Gilmour DVD and have watched the documentary. David Gimour and Richard Wright put on a show that was as amazing as a Pink Floyd show would likely be, and 100 times better than the Rogerless “Pink Floyd” shows, because the stigma of trying to be Pink Floyd was not there. Even if they get Nick Mason to join them for a show or two, I think they play even better MUSIC without being tied to the name Pink Floyd. It’s all about the music and the show. Pink Floyd has already played an elegant, beautiful, and classy farewell performance at Live 8, and David Gilmour’s shows have been excellent. I’m sure Roger Waters has been playing excellent shows as well. The DG video shows a re-forming friendship between these two visionaries, with the understanding that they give each other space. Don’t force them together and shatter that re-budding friendship. If they decide to get together, let them do it on their own terms. Until then, let’s enjoy what they do under their own names.

Tyler | 9/29/2007, 5:15 pm EST

Kruinski said it right !! As John lennon said once !! THE DREAM IS OVER !!Grow up Rolling Stone !!

timbo | 9/29/2007, 4:53 pm EST

Firstly, I was lucky to have been at an Albert Hall Concert last year, maybe the very one that was recorded. Even luckier I was at the DVD premiere at Leicester Square in London where the great man, (and band) jammed for a bit at the end. I must say that although the DVD is claimed to have been recorded in high definition, I thought it was a load of crap! The content was excellent 10 out of 10, (especially Echoes!) but the picture quality is really grainy and pretty third rate. Visually it does not come across anything like really being there. Stop all this digital crap!! good ol’ analogue technology still rules!
Oh, and secondly. Being a mature Pink Floyd fan, (at 44) I think like many a PF fan, it would be really great if there was some farewell tour with Roger, but I can’t really see that happening despite my wishes. DG & RW have now grown apart from each other in nearly every respect except their music. The good thing about Dave and Roger doing solo tours is you get more of a chance to see them live than you ever would seeing them performing as Pink Floyd! I am more than happy with the thawing of their relations and the current state of things between them with Nick Mason and Jon Carin being the bridge between the two parties.

Kruzinski | 9/28/2007, 2:56 pm EST

I realize that my generation is willing to do anything to keep the dinosaur museum open, but lets face reality:These iconic musicians are getting old, as are we.While I contend that some of them,a few anyway,are still creative and vital, its the people in our age demographic that are now running the music industry, signing horrible bands,suing college students for downloading some stupid forgotten song by the Spice Girls,voting for losers like George Bush,having a ton of plastic surgery, and the list goes on.Let the elder statesmen of rock do as they wish,but can we all just move on a little bit?I agree:a lot of it was great music, and I still enjoy quite a bit of it,but let the dice fall where they may.I saw the Who last Dec,and let me tell you:It was pathetic!Daltry’s voice was roached, and the Pretenders handed them their asses.Take a look around people…the last thing we need to do is continue to engage in nostalgia. P.S. Dave is an incredible guitarist, and every bit as talented as the egocentric Mr.Waters.

yava | 9/28/2007, 10:27 am EST

We all know who was really Pink! Dave do great publish hiw own work as him. Pink Floyd works in David’ lead period was rather sad.
I’d like the idea of a re-union, but I think it’s impossible.
By the way, Rog likes the idea, but PF is a cash cow that D. won’t leave it

Chipsy | 9/28/2007, 3:51 am EST

Hey Cody
I like Guy Pratt - he certainly seems to be a genuinely likeable nice guy (excuse the pun), but even he admits in his latest book (My Bass & Other Animals - a really good read in fact for Floyd fans) that the ‘reggae’ section in Money on AMLOR tour was, ahem, ‘misguided’ at best…

poppy | 9/28/2007, 2:16 am EST

Pink Floyd concerts were always kind of trippy. Especially the laser light fx extravaganza during Comfortably Numb.

Cody | 9/28/2007, 1:19 am EST

The Hitchiker couldn’t NOT make anymore sense…what do you mean Guy Pratt was terrible? what constituted that lackluster comment? How is it that he was terrible? because he wasn’t Roger Waters? grow up…please

SYD | 9/28/2007, 1:00 am EST

Let’s Face it:

Dave NEEDS Roger and Roger NEEDS Dave. And Rick and Nick need them both!

Mr. Floyd | 9/27/2007, 11:36 pm EST

Sorry , but it does seem there has been a reversal of egos going on between David and Roger. I have been on your side for 20 years David. What about the communication theme??? Please do one for us true fans! It’s about all some of us live for!!!!
Bury that hatchet for good, and “Be Carefull With That Axe… hahahahahahahhahahahahhaha)

matt craun | 9/27/2007, 10:17 pm EST

Last time David said that a record would come out soon was during the momentary reason tour so do not hold your breath. If a reunion were to happen Roger would have to convice David. And I do not think it would happen not this year anyway. I could see them doing four us and four uk shows as a farewell tour. With each show raising funds for some global event or charity. It is a bit selfish for them to say that its not the fans its their success though. The reason that IAID did so well is because there has not been new material. As for not going back, what is playing floyd tunes during his solo tour? A trip to the future, please.

Melissa30 | 9/27/2007, 6:42 pm EST

David Gilmour doesn’t owe any of us anything. I am a new Pink Floyd Fan, only started liking them in May of this year. And I would love nothing more than to see these guys in concert. But if David feels that being a part of the band is in his past, then he has a right to feel that way. David wants to spend the time with his family, and none of us have a right to judge him for that. We all should just continue to enjoy the music and be thankful that these guys put out the wonderful music that they did.

Factual | 9/27/2007, 5:56 pm EST

DG didn’t criticise RW’s lyrics. “Roger hasn’t written a lyric lately that has really been something where I’ve gone” That, to me means that they aren’t on the same page anymore. Simple as that really.

The Hitchhiker | 9/27/2007, 5:18 pm EST

Have to agree with the previous posts regarding Dave’s roundabout attempt to criticize the lyrics of Roger Waters.
For someone who has turned to his wife, poets and lyricists to write his lyrics for him on MLOR and the Division Bell is somewhat pathetic.
Dave has been living off of the Pink Floyd name for years, a name that was largely built by Syd and Roger.
As for Guy Pratt, the only reason he is part of the band is because he is Rick Wrights son in law, he was awful on a MLOR tour, and isnt any better now.
As for “Island”, at least he is promoting as a solo project as opposed to calling it a Pink Fraud album.

jean-claude thirion | 9/27/2007, 5:00 pm EST

well david what can i say just simply the best my comment why you never play there’s no way out of here!!!!!!! or so far away??? anyway best regard from USA J_C

James | 9/27/2007, 4:38 pm EST

Exclusive? Wow, I got to participate in a phone interview with David Gilmour last week and I write for a college newspaper. What a scoop!

Rkwonsch | 9/27/2007, 4:37 pm EST

Forget Waters - how about David Bowie , Gilmour & Wright do a special aniversary concert of the Wall and Tour. Bowie was fantastic doing Floyd - .

Liam | 9/27/2007, 2:21 pm EST

I’m a mere 17 years old, and have never had the opportunity to see Pink Floyd live. I saw Roger at the MEN Arena in Manchester in May, and it was amazing. All of their creativity and musical output really made a huge impact on me when I first discovered the band, and continues to.

And while one of the things I would do anything for is to see Pink Floyd live, I am reluctantly happy to accept that if David doesn’t really want to do this, then c’est la vie. He owes us nothing, yet I wait patiently for another musical masterpiece to be presented to us!

Liam | 9/27/2007, 2:21 pm EST

I’m a mere 17 years old, and have never had the opportunity to see Pink Floyd live. I saw Roger at the MEN Arena in Manchester in May, and it was amazing. All of their creativity and musical output really made a huge impact on me when I first discovered the band, and continues to.

And while one of the things I would do anything for is to see Pink Floyd live, I am reluctantly happy to accept that if David doesn’t really want to do this, then c’est la vie. He owes us nothing, yet I wait patiently for another musical masterpiece to be presented to us!

Liam Schwartz | 9/27/2007, 2:21 pm EST

I’m a mere 17 years old, and have never had the opportunity to see Pink Floyd live. I saw Roger at the MEN Arena in Manchester in May, and it was amazing. All of their creativity and musical output really made a huge impact on me when I first discovered the band, and continues to.

And while one of the things I would do anything for is to see Pink Floyd live, I am reluctantly happy to accept that if David doesn’t really want to do this, then c’est la vie. He owes us nothing, yet I wait patiently for another musical masterpiece to be presented to us!

Howard | 9/27/2007, 8:13 am EST

Does anyone know if Gilmoure going to have any consert with in next year?

Zak | 9/27/2007, 5:54 am EST

I think we are blessed that these guys are still out there doing their thing. Its great we hear such rarities performed live such as “Wots the Deal”, “Fat Old Sun”, “Echoes” and Davids current superb version of “Shine on”. I actually feel sorry for these guys constantly being asked when Pink Floyd will re-unite, lets be grateful that they are still willing to perform at all. Yes its a shame that Pink Floyd no longer perform as Pink Floyd, but in some respects the music is stronger because of it.

David Richard | 9/27/2007, 3:26 am EST

Floyds over, move on! I love listening to their (Mine) CDs and seeing the DVDs. So I’ve spent a few hundered dollars on them (for Me). They don’t owe me anything. I’ve had the past 40 years of listening enjoyment because of the Floyd. My first serious girlfiend would go nuts everytime she heard The Great Gig In The Sky. Thanks for making my life fuller by recording excellent music. See you in the Rock and Roll pages…DAVE

Wiz | 9/27/2007, 2:50 am EST

On david new dvd, check inside flyer and notice the section were he shows different reviews of the show. One in particular clearly demonstrated that David’s ego is alive and well. The headline reads “Gilmour Wins floyd battle comfortably” was it neccesary to disrestpect Roger by including this particular clip.. Can you say EGO or what?

Wiz | 9/27/2007, 1:50 am EST

Quick note about Dvd ,his ego is alive and well just look on the inside flyer were David shows us some newspaper reviews…one in particular the headline reads “Gilmour wins floyd battle comfortably” Why does he have to disrespect Roger that way! That particular artical is just written by mainstream looser who prob is not even a true fan and yet david decides to even put it in There is no need to have to say one won over the other. I have seen Roger and David in there solo gigs and they were both great..there is no need to choose sides! Anyways Once again really disrsectful of David to have inclued that particular headline….Can you say Ego or what?? Its Ironic but when roger was being an ass back in the day when he tried to stop floyd from existing anymore,who now seems to finally be over it, now it seems its david turn to be the ass!!!!

Kaos | 9/27/2007, 1:33 am EST

No, I don’t think he should stop speak in interviews, they’re so amusing, esp. when he speaks about dinners and cuisine - agree, these are probably things which are much more important to him than any kind of Floydian reunion… To speak of someone’s bad lyrics is, in my view, a roundabout way of saying, “Im pretty satisfied with my nice family enterprise producing great solo albums which make people sleepy”. It took me effort to survive until the end of “On an island”, and it’s too far from Dave’s best things he did in Pink Floyd. I’d say that even if I had a chance, I’d never watch Dave’s show, and I don’t care whether Rog can or cannot sing, these are his songs, so why should anyone else (esp. Mr Pratt) sing them instead?

Wiz | 9/27/2007, 1:27 am EST

David gilmour’s new Dvd is fantastic, However his attitude over last couple years is not so good. Its very nice that he was able to give all that money to charity and all of that, but all of that was only made possible because of the Fans. His attitude of being selfish now completely contradicts his giving attitude. He would not be where he is now if it was not for Roger,nick and richard and especially THE FANS!!!!!!!! I find it really disrespectful to us Fans the comments coming out of his mouth these days!!!! If it was not for us he would have no were near the amount of money to have 8 kids and give all that money away. To be blunt he prob would not had a hot new younger wife either!! I think of all the money that I given to Pink floyd over the years endless records,reissues,concerts, dvd..ect.. Anyways If you want to see Pink floyd in the prime watch live at pompeii, those were magical creative times for the band! The live 8 was so amazing and the fans loved it so much, but according the Gilmour Fu#k the fans! And what the hell he doing going to shrek 2 premiers and crap like that!!! Its so anti-floyd its incredible….whats next there music in commercials!!!

Pat | 9/26/2007, 11:05 pm EST

Dave Gilmour is about the LAST person on the face of this Earth to comment on someone’s lyrical skills. He had his wife write pitiful lyrics for him to sing, and he’s going to comment about Roger??? Now we see who the egomaniac really is.

Dave needs to stick to guitar and not speak in interviews anymore.

Lenny Bruce | 9/26/2007, 9:30 pm EST

Yeah, everything Sammy just said, and a little “Fuck You” thrown in ta boot!

Sammy | 9/26/2007, 7:02 pm EST

Lucifer, it’s vomit…not vomint. Ignore me? I was not talking to you anyway you dirty bummer. God you’re rude. Do you butt into other peoples conversations in real life? You sound like you need a PB&J sandwich, animal crackers, chocolate milk, and a hug!

Lucifer Sham | 9/26/2007, 9:52 am EST

Sammy’s comments about “a bunch of black chicks vominting” is reason enough to ignore this moron. Sod off, wanker!

Amused to Death was fantastic, and the crowd went nuts at his show. Deservedly so.

Sammy | 9/26/2007, 6:53 am EST

This could very well be the best DVD I’ve ever seen! 22 dollars and worth every cent.

adam | 9/26/2007, 1:44 am EST

what ever happened to guy pratt?

Dan | 9/26/2007, 12:51 am EST

The new Gilmour Dvd is excellent. “Echoes” alone would be worth the price of the package. I don’t think a Floyd reunion is very likely to happen. I saw Waters’ DSOTM Tour last year, it was a very good concert. I don’t mind performers voicing their political views and supporting their causes, but not at their concerts.I paid good money to be entertained, not to be preached to, which was also the case on the Radio KAOS tour. I think if Roger could keep his politics off stage it would go a long ways and create a more harmonious atmosphere for touring. As far as solo outings for my money Richard Wright’s 1978 album “Wet Dream” has been the closest to the “Pink Floyd Sound” to date. I wish something could be done to create a DVD of the material that was recorded during The Wall tour, it would be nice to re-experience that concert.

scoop | 9/25/2007, 9:48 pm EST

I HAVE SEEN FLOYD 24 TIMES SINCE 1968, AUSSIE FLOYD 2 AN WILL SEE THEM ON NOV. 9 IN PHILLY, TOWER THEATER, FLOYD DOES OWE ITS FANS AFTER ALL WE PUT THEM THERE A FAREWELL TOUR WOULD BE THE WAY TO GO AN BRING RODGER ALONG TO, EVERY BODY MAKES BOOK AN PINK FLOYD CAN PUT IT TO REST ONCE AN FOR ALL, JUST WISH THIS COULD MAKE IT TO ALL 4 ORIGINAL MEMBERS…..SCOOP

David | 9/25/2007, 7:45 pm EST

Oh yeah, one more thought…the Australian Pink Floyd Show is fantastic. I’m going to see them again next week. Catch their show if you ever get a chance.

David | 9/25/2007, 7:42 pm EST

I saw Roger’s tour in Phoenix last year. I thought it was great. I just watched David’s new dvd, though, and I was highly impressed. I certainly regret not seeing one of the shows from his tour. If I had a chance to see either one of the two, though, I would definitely want to see David. First, he was the principal singing voice of Pink Floyd, so it’s a rather glaring omission when he is not there. His singing on the new DVD is surprisingly good…very impressive. Second, his amazing guitar was the dominant instrument of the band, and he is one of the best guitarists ever. You just don’t hear current bands playing the soaring, lyrical guitar parts that David gave us in Pink Floyd. Third, David is still gettin it done. He definitely breathed new life into the Pink Floyd songs. Shine On You Crazy Diamond was amazing; I was mesmerized. Finally, his most recent songs may not match up to Pink Floyd’s best in music or lyrical concept, but the Island songs are far better than anything Roger has offered lately. The new song he played was just lame and irritating. I’ll take a reunion first, a Gilmour concert second, and then if I can’t have either of those, I’ll take a Roger Water’s concert.

David | 9/25/2007, 7:29 pm EST

The hundreds of millions of samoleans offered the band for a reunion is merely a reflection of how much the band means to the audience. If a reunion–a real Pink Floyd tour–means that much to us, it’s hard to understand how it could not mean so much to the band.

We don't need no education.... | 9/25/2007, 6:25 pm EST

Pink Floyd…reunion…yeah right. That’s never gonna happen. So don’t get excited, Floyd fans (which I am one - but I have to admit that the possibility of Pink Floyd having a reunion is like zero). Sorry. It’s true. Too bad.

jungleland | 9/25/2007, 5:50 pm EST

At this point both are better off as solo artists. I’ve heard great things about both solo tours and plan to pick up this DVD soon

Mike R | 9/25/2007, 3:34 pm EST

I would just like to see David and Roger write a couple of songs together. While they are both great on their own, there’s no denying that together they were brilliant. Even if they just collaborated on a couple of songs on one another’s solo albums, and not under the pressure or stigma of the “Pink Floyd” mantle.

Mike R | 9/25/2007, 3:07 pm EST

Never mind the Pink Floyd Reunion, I’d just like to see Roger and David get together and work on a couple of songs together without the mantle of “Pink Floyd.” For there is no doubt that while they’re great seperately, together they’re brilliant. Just doing it themselves as Gilmour and Waters would remove the whole Pink Floyd reunion pressure and stigma.

Bob Geldof | 9/25/2007, 2:05 pm EST

Akh! Pink Floyd, load of crap!

ERIC ROBIN | 9/25/2007, 1:45 pm EST

I’ve beeen attached to Pink Floyd
forever …still remember hitching down to Earls Court from Glasgow for DSOTM -it was life changing. Very few modern bands if any do it better live- so that could bethe viability to have ashort tour or aPronce stle show week -the fans will come .After last Live Aid it was woderful that young fans heard them …who may have never heard them until they ingherited their dad’s LP’s -I’m modern -I’ve got DSOTM on CD but it still sound better on 210grm vinyl -the bass stands out. The fact that new youth hailed them proves PF will be timeless.
Personally ,if they dont reform I dont mind but as a charitable institution they woould be better than the UN or U2 for that matter !
i ahve Daves solo stuff it des not suurpass his work with PF BUT he is underrated as a guitarist- Not quite Pat Metheny but as good as EC
Guys,Do some live shows for the kids and charity .
EricRobin

steven (galway) | 9/25/2007, 1:42 pm EST

I would like to think and not many including the members of pink floyd would wholeheartedly agree that they should do it for syd barrett and of course the fans, i think deep in david’s heart he does want to but its the fear of temptation. *444*

Sammy | 9/25/2007, 1:36 pm EST

Yes! You’ve got me pegged. A neanderthal I am. Sounds like I’ve found yet another person I like to call “MUSICALLY RETARDED”. I suppose you could call any of Roger’s solo works “the best Floyd related material in 20 years” if you think… a bunch of black chicks and other shitty backup singers vomiting all over Roger’s lame ass spoken lyrics, with a guitarist trying hard to sound like Gilmour… is moving at all. Try listening to Rick Wrights solo work, at least the man still sings.

Roger Waters | 9/25/2007, 12:48 pm EST

The above comment stating that Roger’s solo material sucks must have been written by a neanderthal.

Amused to Death is the best Floyd related material that has come out in twenty years. As for the concerts, Dave’s was nice, but the recent DSOTM tour from Roger was a masterpiece!

amendillo | 9/25/2007, 12:13 pm EST

to “the ear”…you might want to get that ear checked out cause Gilmour’s On an island cd is incredible with amazing guitar licks. In a time when “musicians” can barely play their instruments and still sell a million albums, that album was a breath of fresh air. I caught 2 shows on his last tour and they were incredible. Gilmour is the most underrated guitar player, everyone always says how good Page was, but Page stole half his stuff from old blues players and he was very sloppy. Gilmour’s guitar work that has done from pink floyd on up to his solo stuff is incredible.

Jason | 9/25/2007, 12:05 pm EST

I don’t mind them not getting back together. As long as David and Roger continue to tour, we get double the pleasure of having Pink Floyd songs played live by great musicians who all have a history with Pink Floyd. So, while its not the complete package, it’s close enough. I just want my live Floyd.

Lucifer Sham | 9/25/2007, 11:52 am EST

with today’s technology, a new Floyd tour would blow away any of these other reunion shows.

The Prez | 9/25/2007, 11:45 am EST

All of these “rock stars” made their money from fans, and now that they don’t need us anymore, they thumb their noses at us citing “artistic direction” or simply “selfish.” Gilmour should think that his fans made his life easy, and throw us a tour to thank us. Instead he’s a selfish person.

chbk | 9/25/2007, 11:43 am EST

They will never again get together, unless something like Live 8 takes place. The don’t need to, they don’t want to. We all must remember what they really were more than 20 years ago as a real band, enjoy it and find pleasure in a work of art, we as fans and good music lovers will never see o hear again. Ever.

Christian | 9/25/2007, 10:46 am EST

I have seen both Roger’s and Dave’s solo gigs and seen the Roger-less Floyd. All were great, but with each it always felt there was something missing. But I was also at Live 8 in Hyde Park, and can honestly say that although they only played 4 tracks, that was something truly special - not simply because they were reunited, but because of the unique sound that comes out when it is the four of them together - regardless of who wrote what bits of each song. I would love to see them reunite to write one last album. I think that the big issue here though is the weight of expectation on a Floyd reunion. Everyone would expect, or want it to be a classic album, and if it isn’t then it would mean the Floyd ending on a slightly sour note. It’s easier for them, or anyone, to say they’ve got nothing in common anymore or that they’ve lost their creativity etc. etc. but I don’t buy that…think that’s a bit of a cop out. The Floyd, like the Beatles, and many others, are testament to the notion that out of conflict comes great creativity. It is precisely their differences that enabled them to do what they did - they tempered eachother’s excesses to create a unique sound that neither can recreate in the absence of eachother. That is where the true creativity and quality came from - through a combination of collaboration and conflict. Whilst some of the solo stuff, and post-Waters Floyd stuff hasn’t been classic, there’s still lots of good moments, which always left you wondering, ‘if only they’d recorded that together’. Are they past it? Not at all. Verdi was writing operas up until he was 80 years old! Who imposed a shelf-life on a rock band anyway? There is a real challenge that can be taken up if they want to. There’s no reason they should…they don’t need the money, or the fame, and they haven’t got anything to prove. The motivation should lie in the challenge for challenge’s sake, and for the sake of art. I think they can pull if off if they can approach it in the right way - perhaps as if they are a newly forming band with everyone having an ‘equal’ share of voice; and they could end up enjoying the experience a lot more than they might think. Come on the Floyd…well come on Dave really…I think the others would jump at the chance. Ironic how Dave in seemingly wanting to bury the Floyd, has almost become the mirror image of what Roger was 20 years ago.

mark | 9/25/2007, 9:39 am EST

It would be nice to see them do something together but I really do not see that happening. Roger’s material as of late “leaving beruit” was pretty weak. Though island was a good album it still had some pretty weak moments the blue and when we start I am glad to see that Rolling Stone was able to put to Dave that the relationship of the beatles. I think that something thats never pointed out to him.

The "Ear" | 9/25/2007, 9:24 am EST

Doesn’t really matter if Pink Floyd tours or records again…I really haven’t heard anything outstanding from either camps Gilmore or Waters in nearly 20 years! Now, they only create Pink Floyd noise all creativity is long gone. sorry RIP Pink Floyd

Sammy | 9/25/2007, 7:44 am EST

We don’t need no Pink Floyd reunion, Dave and Rick would do just fine on their own. Let Roger keep making those fucking opera disks. After hearing all of Roger’s solo material, it’s no wonder Dave said he hasn’t heard anything too impressive from Roger lately. It was a very nice way of saying… it fucking SUCKS.

basser | 9/25/2007, 1:42 am EST

Man, I wish Floyd would do one more tour with Waters, and they could donate 1/3 of the money to charity, like The Who did in 1989. And if you have to have extra musicians, put Jon Carin on second keyboard/guitar/backup vocals, and Phil Manzanera on second guitar. Phil is such a team player. Loved watching him smile at David during David’s solos. Phil’s style complimented David’s too, so if Floyd ever tours again, get Phil and Jon to round out the sound (or just do it as a four-piece - The Police did it this year as a three-piece)

kooz | 9/25/2007, 1:33 am EST

DO IT FOR THE FANS!!
Do a week of shows in England at Earls Court. Do only the music you ALL were involved in(PIPER through WALL) Do all 3 nights of COACHELLA 2008 festival. Donate all the proceeds after production costs to charity. This way its not a tour, they dont do it for the money. Everyone wins. COME ON!!

Radio Free Colorado | 9/24/2007, 7:51 pm EST

If you have never seen or heard any of Mr. Gilmour’s DVD’s before, you are missing out on enjoying some great knockout material. Checkout David’s other DVD called “David Gilmour in Concert” (2002) - it’s wonderful!

mr roboto | 9/24/2007, 7:26 pm EST

I thought I recognized John Carin from Roger’s tour!

He did a great version of “Dogs” I think it was…

Sixie | 9/24/2007, 6:48 pm EST

I think Jon Carin is the real glue that makes Dave’s and Rog’s solo outings really hold together with dignity. He’s is the newest member of Pink Floyd.
Absolutely… I totally agree. To be able to play unconditionally and equally with both bands is remarkable. Not able to catch Dave’s latest tour but did see Roger’s in Tampa and of course was a brilliant, energetic show.
Jon is the sixth floyd member,don’t forget Sid…

Danny | 9/24/2007, 5:49 pm EST

I’d love to see David and Mark Knopfler do a double bill..(or get Kate Bush out of hiding) they both like playing the smaller venues and the fanbase for both crosses over. Maybe one “Dark Side of the Moon” for posterity but DG solo is pretty cool.

bowieno | 9/24/2007, 5:48 pm EST

the part in the DVD where Dave and Rog meet up was touching. Rog was even a gentlemen to Polly.(not that I do think he would be impolite-but given their history) Rick seemed great! It’s nice to see Rick Wright involved and looking cofident and healthy and we even get to see Nick too. I think Jon Carin is the real glue that makes Dave’s and Rog’s solo outings really hold together with dignity. He’s is the newest member of Pink Floyd.

Post A Comment

Caution: Off-topic comments will be deleted

Name:

Comments:



Advertisement

Advertisement