Previous Next Latest

Complaints Over Christina, Gwen: When Did Pop Fans Turn Into Prudes?

8/3/07, 12:16 pm EST

Photo: prudes

Last summer Beyoncé’s fans petitioned the star’s label to shoot a less-risqué version of the video for “Déjà Vu.” And now comes news that attendees of Christina Aguilera’s recent show in Sydney were horrified by the raunch factor in the singer’s act when she donned dominatrix garb, invited a male fan onstage, tied him to a circus wheel and playfully whipped him and joined her dancers in a simulated lap dance. A tad wild? Sure. But far from her chaps-wearing, ass-cheek-shaking “Dirrty” phase. Even the mostly PG, day-glo pop vibe projected by Gwen Stefani has drawn negative attention for being too provocative, though to be fair, the complaints came from religious groups with different standards of propriety than American pop stars. Stefani has agreed to stay covered from her shoulders to her knees and refrain from jumping, shouting or throwing objects when she performs later this month in Kuala Lumpur, after Muslim students protested what they consider an obscene performance style. “She will abide by the Malaysian authorities’ guidelines to ensure that her show will not be offensive to local sensitivities,” reads a statement from her reps.

Meanwhile, we don’t hear any uproar about former Mickey Mouse Club poster-boy Justin Timberlake collaborating with 50 Cent in a soft-core porn music video. The clip for “Ayo Technology” features Mr. Dick in a Box spying on scantily clad vixens with night goggles and panting, “I’m tired of using technology / Why don’t you sit down on top of me?” We’re waiting for the outrage …

Photo: Vega/Getty


Previous Next Latest

Comments

Lizzy Lizz | 8/7/2007, 11:41 am EST

Why is Gwen Stefani being lumped into this category? They are probably more afraid of her cursing, shouting and “jumping” because that’s what she does at her shows. Besides, she is simply being alittle sexy sometimes (nowhere near risque), and it’s simply a matter of clashing cultures.

Cravens | 8/7/2007, 11:12 am EST

Makes you wonder if anyone would raise an eyebrow had Madonna (been 30 now and..) released her “Erotica” album today and her “Sex” book as well?

Maybe in some 50 years from now, the line between pornstar and popstar will be completely gone?

*** Now available! The Dirrty Dildo™ available everywhere, endorsed and used (as seen in her very own porn movie: “F*ck! I’m an Arrtist”) by Christina Aguilera. Or buy the Deluxe Dirrty Dildo™ and get a free copy of her 2056 hit single “I Sit on Things, Boo-doo” ***

16 clumsy+shy | 8/6/2007, 4:15 pm EST

Janis can stop frowning, because Christina can SING.

Mark | 8/6/2007, 2:10 pm EST

Where are Wendy & The Plasmatics when the world needs them?

Jason | 8/6/2007, 1:54 pm EST

I have seen the Christina concert and it is far from risque, the performance with the male fan has a burlesque feel, but is not raunchy or dirty in any way. There is way too much censorship anyways, if people are not interested in seeing this type of display, then just don’t pay to go to the concerts or buy the cds.

jungleland | 8/6/2007, 7:41 am EST

These are performers for KIDS, that’s why these groups are upset. Who over 20 would go to these shows???

The Ghost of Janis is frowning | 8/6/2007, 1:01 am EST

If you like female eye candy pretending to sing under the cover of risque entertainment, Christina, Britney, Gwen and all the other scantily-clad mouseketeer wannabes are right up your alley. Personally, i could go to a strip club and be more satisfied with less of a drain on my wallet. If you want female music with some depth, listen to Joss Stone, who is as close in spirit to Janis Joplin and Grace Slick without all the drug abuse. I’m sure there are other talented female singers out there, her name came to mind first.

YYYYESSS | 8/5/2007, 8:35 pm EST

Christina in spite of her fantastic voice jumpstarted as a puppet. Gwen, kept it real then the dollar took over, and Justin can hold his penis.. oh he’s so Michael Jackson!

tinman | 8/5/2007, 4:01 pm EST

brian, you’re a clown. What’s wrong with “the male heterosexual fantasy” - you say it like it’s something evil and perverted.

And re: how male singers dress - nobody wants to see them in s&m gear or whatever. It’s not a double standard, it’s the difference between the sexes. Gender is not a social construct, even if your women’s studies class says so.

anonyms | 8/5/2007, 8:37 am EST

religious differences thats all!
and gwen stefani’s respecting it

brian | 8/5/2007, 8:22 am EST

I just think Gwen and Christina have been too heavily influenced by the sleaze factor. The sleaze factor, rather than being sexy, is essentially a surrender to the male heterosexual fantasy. It comes across as grubby rather than empowering to women.
Also, note how Justin Timberlake and all the other male performers don’t walk around on stage with short shorts or bondage and discipliine costumes. Unless it’s part of an overall theatrical presentation (as in the case of Marilyn Manson), the men basically stick to conservative shirt and ties or T-shirts.
There’s definitely a double standard in how female performers are presenting themselves in comparison to male performers.

daNisha | 8/4/2007, 7:31 pm EST

muslims are allowed to go to concerts? concerts where a female is singing?

Dardo | 8/4/2007, 10:17 am EST

Oh my god, it’s been more than 10 years since Marilyn Manson started to claim that he was the antichrist, and now Xtina Aguilera (puaj) is acting like a s&m fan and you’re like WOWWWWWW WHAT A SHOCK!
Come on, grow up.

No No No | 8/4/2007, 4:28 am EST

Gwen’s not tasteless at all, this is only a matter of religional differences.

Rock and Roll Whoredom | 8/3/2007, 10:13 pm EST

RICHARD: ALL PERFORMERS are WHORES! Whether they be actors,comedians, monkeys,male,female,whites,bla cks,gangsta rappers, or Christian musicians, all of them are whores. That’s show business. It’s practically impossible to be a performer with being one. And the one’s who you think aren’t…Yep, they’re whores too! Phantom

friend | 8/3/2007, 8:13 pm EST

gwen stefani isnt even as bad as compared to christina or britney

slayer rulezzzzzz | 8/3/2007, 6:09 pm EST

Why is this even a fucking discussion!

alberto | 8/3/2007, 5:52 pm EST

Christina, Gwen etc, etc are tame to what Madonna did back in the 90’s. You don’t see either of them masturbating on a bed or hitchiking naked. Why all these young pop tarts want to be like Madonna baffles me. All they’re doing is emulating a rich slut.

Richard Legner | 8/3/2007, 5:41 pm EST

that’s what happens when your fan base is 11 year olds who aren’t old enought to understand…

plus it does serve them right for being whores. And even if they aren’t actually whores…they ARE selling themselves as whores.

I have no idea why people are surprised about his (except, I guess they are Aussies)

Dean | 8/3/2007, 4:53 pm EST

Sex sells.

Johnny Kickass | 8/3/2007, 4:39 pm EST

MMmmm…I love it when girls “jump, shout and throw objects”. What sluts!

Post A Comment

Caution: Off-topic comments will be deleted

Name:

Comments:



Advertisement

Advertisement