R.I.P Rob Sheffield

Yeah, it’s pretentious to like stuff that’s good. Idiot,

This is a great example of why the rest of the world hates Americans.

hahaha a big f u c k you to all of you pretentious film goers. i thought it was rather funny

This just shows tha RS is no longer for people over 20 or with an IQ score higher then Rob Sheffield.

Bad taste Sheffield. This might be funny a few months from now. Too soon.

Pure crap!

Yeah, this sucked.

Cheap, especially for a “cultural” magazine. It would be okay had Rolling Stones Magazine had an actual intelligent entry on Ingmar Bergman and his massive, massive influence on modern cinema and not just the European one.

Oh well, I guess Rolling Stones Magaine might be trying to recast it self as THE magazine for the American Idol crowd.

I wish this would stop. It’s giving me a stomachache. Bad taste all over. This man’s bestowed upon us a piece of knowledge and understanding that nobody else has. He’s not the butt of your fucking joke!

RIP,one the greatest filmmaker ever lived and he deserves a better tribute absolutely.

FUCK SPIELBERG……….

Who wrote this Jenny McCarthy? This thing reads like a description of Cancun on E!S Wild On! Bullet Points with NO BULLETS! You need to HIME ME and send this shlub to work in the mairoom. I KNOW how to WRITE, I do RESARCH abd as you well know, I’M CONTROVERSIAL…The Phantom

Where’s the wacky Antonioni obit?

For once I actually want to read something by Peter Travers!

BERGMAN
El director mas grande del cine moderno. The Queen is Dead.

Wow, dead less than 24 hours and he gets this brilliant tribute. I can’t wait to see what you have to say the morning after Scorcese dies.

This is supposed to be funny? Christ.

Rob Sheffield, must you speak ill of the dead?

Fucking insipid, uninspired and awkardly flip.

This is completely unnecessary. Maybe you could have said something about Bergman’s influence in rock& Roll? It’s downright offensive.

Wow, this was desperately unfunny in a tongue-through-cheek sort of way.

Peter Travers please write something brilliant about Ingmar Bergman and Michelangelo Antonioni for this magazine’s next issue, and smack this twat Sheffield; it probably what any film fan who read this would want to see.

What the hell is the matter with you, Sheffield? Ingmar Bergamn was probably one of the greatest directors of all time, and this is how you sum him up? Absolutley disgusting.

“This just falls flats. Bergman deserves a real tribute, not a sample of half-smart irony.”

Um, yeah…what he said. Really though, I think Ingmar and the readers of RS deserved a little more. We are not all Lohan worshipping, Ipod listening, pinkberry drinkin’ tweeners.

Hopefully Peter T. will write something remarkable and eloquent about Bergman and Antonioni as he did the late Bob Altman last year.

Goddammit Rob Sheffield! Show a little fucking respect.

Bergman’s REAL rock and roll moment was the time he was directing a play and a critic who’d been unkind to him entered the theatre. Bergman stopped rehearsal, walked up the aisle, and CLOCKED the motherfucker. Then he went back to work. THAT’s rock and roll.

This is completely idiotic. Nice going. When did RS start aiming for the lowest common denominator? This would have been alright if it was at least funny, but it barely rates as satire. Even Bergman himself would have gotten a kick out of a lighthearted look at his career, but this is just plain bad writing, which is the biggest insult.

scott walker actually sings a song called the seventh seal that summarizes the movie. download it you bastards

This is completely idiotic. Nice going, you’ve cemented RS’s stature as being totally irrelevant to anything.

This just falls flats. Bergman deserves a real tribute, not a sample of half-smart irony.

Hmm, this one was a miss, in my opinion. Mr. Bergman deserved better than some sub-par, tired Sheffield shtick.