Imagine Whitney Houston and Brittany on the same panel with Simon. It’d be classic.

Find out wher Mark Hollis has been hiding and drag him out.

Rita MacNeil and Yoko ONo

Whitney Houston definitely needs to do this. I can see her asking all the contestants to sit on her lap every time Simon tells them they suck and saying “It’s ok baby, mama says it’s gonna be all right!”

Robert Pollard

How about ODB and say….Cher?

how about ape and Phil?

Courtney Love and Gene Simmons.

George W. Bush and Hillary Clinton, both of whom will need a new gig in a year.

What does Britney know about talent, other than she doesn’t have any?

she could be a good judge of hair.

how about a rocker like say maybe ozzy or steven tyler and then some country chick like maybe martina mcbride so theyll have pop country and rock on the judge panel and not just talentless pop stars

listen to barak

listen to barak

Josh Homme and Lauryn Hill

how about bam and the guy from HIM

listen to barak

how about somebody with some damn talent…let’s go with Ronnie James Dio & Wyclef Jean

how about somebody with some damn talent…let’s go with Ronnie James Dio & Wyclef Jean

I wanna see Axl Rose and Christina Aguilera

Replace Paula with Ozzy. You can’t understand a thing either one says. Ozzy next to Simon? Priceless!

Replace Paula with Ozzy. You can’t understand a thing either one says. Ozzy next to Simon? Priceless!

How about Janet Jackson (now that her ex-choreographer is leaving) and Carlos Santana? Or….Dr. Dre and Natalie Imbruglia? Point being…diverse, ability to recognize ‘talent’, universal appeal and balance. AND PLEASE don’t have ‘guest judges’. No vested interest there!

Phil Spector & Cyndi Lauper

marilyn manson and Sanjaya

Borat and Michael Jackson

Wyclef & cyndi Lauper
would be hot

Why can’t we just not replace them ad take this crap off the air?

tom waits and jonathan richman

Real professionals would be
nice…..some who would add
class and real successful
experience to the “bench”.
Some who would have the res-
pect of most of the listening
audience. These three are
really not good….Mary Newlon

Tunde Adebimpe, Tom Waits, and Debbie Harry.

Robert Pollard is actually a GREAT suggestion. Realistically, Whitney Houston might not be too bad. I also think Mike Love – just to throw ‘em a curveball.

Rob Zombie and Snoop Dogg (Snoop has to be high at all times)
or
DJ Paul and Juicy J from Three 6 Mafia
or
Dean and Gene Ween
or
Bjork and Josh Homme
or
Ape and Phil

to reply to a comment below, ODB is dead.
How about the judges be Marilyn Manson and Alanis…hmm?

rick astley and sheila e.

well like any show when you start changing characters you loose ratings american idol will not be the same without paula and randy.. futher more…. i dont even respect anything brittany has to say let alone critise someone else

OZZY OSBOURNE,CAUSE HE’S THE GREATEST ROCK SINGER OF ALL TIME AND MIRANDA LAMBERT CAUSE SHE IS SO HOT AND HAS A SEXY VOICE.THAT WAY YOU HAVE HUMOR FROM OZZY AND GREAT EYECANDY FROM MIRANDA !!!

Boy George and Right Said Fred

Paul McCartney and Olivia Newton John

Simon Cowell, Britney Spears and Scott Stapp.

C’mon, tell me you wouldn’t tune in to watch those three tell contestants they suck.

I thought LuLu was a great guest judge this season! If Paula was replaced I think she’d be perfect! However crazy Paula gets, I’d still like her to stay around for the sake of keeping this winning formula the same.

REGIS AND KELLY!

REGIS AND KELLY!

I want to see Cher and Rosie O’Donnel with Simon. That would be fun.

The Donald and Paris

Dienda Disdick &
Annita Bonghit

Dienda Disdick &
Annita Bonghit

Dienda Disdick &
Annita Bonghit

Whoever it is, they’d better be deaf and blind to sit through all those third-rate lounge acts (and I’m talking about the finalists)…

VICTOR WOOTEN!

Lauryn Hill & Don Imus

these shows are only at their best when they show the funny parts. otherwise it’s a waste of time

Now what I´d like to see is Paula Abdul, Ozzy and Keith Richards together; then we could have an audience contest each week, guessing what the hell they actually said…

I think Paula Abdul was never a good fit for American Idol in the first place! She’s had only 6 #1’s and she can’t sing at all. She just knew how to dance, so that’s how she became famous. So, at least Britney Spears has the same level of expertise as her. As for an alternate for Paula, I think Mariah Carey or Whitney Houston should be the lady judges. They both have set the standard for pop and R & B. Mariah Carey has had 17 #1’s. That means she’s had the same number as Elvis! If she isn’t a candidate for the job who is? If Whitney got the spot it could be her comeback. As for a replacement for Randy, I think Bono would be the perfect candidate. Another great contender would be Michael Jackson.

u guys dont know crap