Previous Next Latest

“American Idol,” The Instant EP’s: Rob Sheffield Rates Blake Lewis’ and Jordin Sparks’ AutoTuned Efforts

5/25/07, 11:23 am EST

American Idol, EP, Blake Lewis, Jordin SparksWhat’s this? Blake and Jordin already have music for sale at the iTunes store? Gosh, this really is their now! It’s your now, it’s my now, it’s the whole world’s now! In all candor, neither EP is what you’d call a bargain, not with four bucks for five songs that everybody remotely interested already has in their TiVo. But with America still recovering from the trauma of hearing Ruben Studdard sing about tangerine trees and marmalade skies, not to mention the image of Taylor Hicks blowing his mind out in a car (why wasn’t that the Ford commercial?), I’m happier than the Hotness at a discount spray-tanner to report that Jordin and Blake sound like pros in a real recording studio, where they have the AutoTune angels to wave their magic wands at pitchiness problems. They can both use the help.

Blake’s EP features his cheddar-splendent beatbox version of “You Give Love a Bad Name,” and that nice Ryan Adams song about the stars going blue. But very unfortunately, not Keane’s “Somewhere We Both Know,” the only moment all season that made me vote for him. He also tries to hit the high notes in “Time of the Season,” but he still can’t hack it—on the words “time,” “season,” and “lovin’” he screeches like Paula’s chihuahua with a stiletto in its ear. Down, Tulip!

Jordin inspired Paula’s best line ever on Tuesday night: “You are in great, great vocal voice tonight.” You have to admit, the vocal voice is important, if you want to make sonic sound, and that’s why Jordin won, although having to sing “This Is My Now” every night isn’t much of a prize, now is it? Her EP has “I (Who Have Nothing),” which is the good news… but not Pat Benatar’s “Heartbreaker?” That performance was her star-maker! Her love-taker! She hit us with her best shot! Shameful, really. Oh, well—no harm done, to either career.

Both Jordin and Blake will sell millions of records, earn hundreds of dollars and end up with a lifetime supply of amusingly bitter anecdotes to share backstage on future Xanadu On Ice tours. But most importantly, they will have the honor of appearing on next year’s Idol finale, doing a salute to the fortieth anniversary of the White Album. Jordin can sing “Ob-La-Di, Ob-La-Da,” Blake can do “Revolution #9″ (”Number nine! wikka-wikka-squrrrrp! n-n-n-number nine!”) and Sanjaya will bring down the house with “Wild Honey Pie.” Farewell, Idol. This was the worst season ever. Don’t fire Paula, okay? She was the only thing that kept us awake.


Previous Next Latest

Comments

kyosl mjoc | 9/21/2007, 9:22 am EST

nbikt vpwsuoxr dtla bzetfuwo viyselb hpid btrhj

TRUE BLAKER GIRL | 9/20/2007, 5:40 pm EST

OMG!!!! Blake has inspired me to beat-box and scratch and dance just like him!!!! it is soooooooooooo awsome!!! My friends in class want me to do it all the time!! They don’t care what the teacher is saying, they just want me to do the beat-boxing and scratching and dancing soooooooooooooo cooooooollll!!!

TRUE BLAKER GIRL | 9/20/2007, 5:40 pm EST

OMG!!!! Blake has inspired me to beat-box and scratch and dance just like him!!!! it is soooooooooooo awsome!!! My friends in class want me to do it all the time!! They don’t care what the teacher is saying, they just want me to do the beat-boxing and scratching and dancing soooooooooooooo cooooooollll!!!

brittany | 9/7/2007, 10:10 am EST

Blake so shoudda won he was amazing and so sexy

atxsz oibtf | 8/7/2007, 10:56 pm EST

qdnwpsaeh mjwngc omixh xtgjmornu lkpsr cnxlzedqf otznx

kilka | 7/31/2007, 12:34 pm EST

gmc trucks here www.gmctruck.fora.pl
gmc from america www.gmctruck.fora.pl
real gmc www.gmctruck.fora.pl

and www.emeraldring.fora.pl rings

kilka | 7/31/2007, 12:33 pm EST

gmc trucks here www.gmctruck.fora.pl
gmc from america www.gmctruck.fora.pl
real gmc www.gmctruck.fora.pl

and www.emeraldring.fora.pl rings

Frankenstump | 7/3/2007, 1:10 pm EST

The true winner? Simon Cowell, and perhaps William Hung. He’s the only one I can actually listen to without my gorge rising. At least he’s funny.

Frankenstump | 7/3/2007, 1:10 pm EST

The true winner? Simon Cowell, and perhaps William Hung. He’s the only one I can actually listen to without my gorge rising. At least he’s funny.

nonsense | 6/14/2007, 6:59 pm EST

who cares the show should be illegal its a freak show. Since you obviously have the internet try researching real artists you just might like it.

Mangrobang | 6/9/2007, 9:28 pm EST

Is Keane’s “Somewhere We Both Know” anything like “Somewhere Only We Know”?

DamnBoy | 5/29/2007, 8:46 am EST

Annnnnd .i like the song
I WHO HAVE NOTHING

DamnBoy | 5/29/2007, 8:44 am EST

Jordin is great…i like her big mouth and white teeth while shouting.just like WHITNEY HUSTON’s ….

sara | 5/29/2007, 6:57 am EST

Most boring Idols ever. There was no stand out. Melinda for voice, but just lacking. Blake had only his gimmick, and Jordin was good but not consistent. Yawn!

sara | 5/29/2007, 6:57 am EST

Most boring Idols ever. There was no stand out. Melinda for voice, but just lacking. Blake had only his gimmick, and Jordin was good but not consistent. Yawn!

sara | 5/29/2007, 6:57 am EST

Most boring Idols ever. There was no stand out. Melinda for voice, but just lacking. Blake had only his gimmick, and Jordin was good but not constant. Yawn

David Layne | 5/28/2007, 5:36 pm EST

I absolutely agree that this was by far the worst AI season ever,and that’s really saying something since there have been several that were HORRIBLE. (Fantasia comes to mind).Melinda was the only GREAT singer this year,although Gina was cute and spunky.Jordin is fourth or 5th rate at best (I will ask again: Did no one notice her annoying BREATHING between nearly every line of most songs????) And Blake is one of the most talentless idiots ever on AI.I thought it was bad enough that the country moron Tim McGraw butchered “When the Stars go Blue”,but Blake’s off key screeching version was worse than Karaoke.This will definitely be remembered as the season AI jumped the shark for good.

Jordan | 5/28/2007, 4:16 pm EST

the winner is America! LOL lmaooo

simone | 5/28/2007, 9:29 am EST

what the hell the winner must be chris

simone | 5/28/2007, 9:29 am EST

what the hell the winner must be chris

sdsdsdd | 5/28/2007, 2:22 am EST

fgghg gggg

Blaker Girl | 5/27/2007, 9:28 pm EST

I EFFIN LOVE BLAKE!! ;) HES HOTT AND IM MAD HE DID NOT WIN BUT PETER NOON SAID BLAKE WILL SELL MORE RECORDS SO yeah haah!

Blaker Girl | 5/27/2007, 9:28 pm EST

I EFFIN LOVE BLAKE!! ;) HES HOTT AND IM MAD HE DID NOT WIN BUT PETER NOON SAID BLAKE WILL SELL MORE RECORDS SO yeah haah!

z19 | 5/27/2007, 3:43 pm EST

the worst season is season 3! boring.. haha..

MusicalJenius | 5/27/2007, 11:35 am EST

I enjoyed the finale and I’m really happy for Jordin. I loved watching her react to her dreams coming true. It was great! Good for her!

Anon | 5/27/2007, 1:20 am EST

I agree..iTunes should have “Somewhere Only We Know” that was what made me love him in the show! He stood out when he sang that song.

Anonymous | 5/26/2007, 8:24 pm EST

somewhere we both know

cliff | 5/26/2007, 4:59 pm EST

Sheffield is pretending to be a reality-TV snob, but with Kelly Clarkson and Carrie Underwood outselling Britney, Christina, Beyonce, etc, it’s kind of naive to assume Jordin Sparks might be “on ice” anytime soon.

CDP | 5/26/2007, 4:40 pm EST

Dolittle had the BEST VOICE, but AMERICA is not ready for a POP SINGER with NO NECK!

gail | 5/26/2007, 8:34 am EST

whiney little biatch much?

gail | 5/26/2007, 8:32 am EST

whiny little biatch much?

Ralph | 5/25/2007, 6:24 pm EST

You are right but the world is full of idiots that will keep on watching thinking that beatboxing is the COOLEST INNOVATION OF 2007!!!!!

Ralph | 5/25/2007, 6:24 pm EST

You are right but the world is full of idiots that will keep on watching thinking that beatboxing is the COOLEST INOVATION OF 2007!!!!!

shaun | 5/25/2007, 5:16 pm EST

i agree with max buzz. but thats the stupid world we live in today…

Jim | 5/25/2007, 4:46 pm EST

Rob got it right.

A.J cr | 5/25/2007, 4:41 pm EST

What a horrible season of AI. I barely watched it. I believe this is the worst season ever (that and LATIN American Idol season 1 last year). Why dont they just cancel this crap? Geez…

dlt | 5/25/2007, 3:39 pm EST

And

The winner is
Oswald Spengler

Al | 5/25/2007, 2:33 pm EST

Rob Sheffield is a hack, talentless writer who made dead wrong predictions all year. Rob Sheffield, you’re an idiot.

jungleland | 5/25/2007, 2:26 pm EST

Already over Idol for the year (why did I kinda care up till now??)

Chucky | 5/25/2007, 2:18 pm EST

I LOVE POOP SEX ;)

Sam | 5/25/2007, 1:45 pm EST

I know they hate Taylor Hicks but did they have to go so far as forcing him to blow his mind out on stage? The guy’s really not that bad and he did win last year. There’s a real story in there somewhere that AI isn’t letting out.

killingfloor | 5/25/2007, 1:35 pm EST

Just saw a promo for Larry King Live tonight. It said ‘Sanjaya and other Idol winners..tonight!’. Nuff said.

Max Buzz | 5/25/2007, 12:27 pm EST

Crap. Pure crap.

No truly talented person would find it necessary to subject themselves to this moronic contest.

These idols are not stars - they are pawns.

.

killyridols | 5/25/2007, 12:18 pm EST

The funny thing is that no one will care about any of this next week. I still don’t know why Blake didn’t pick Sugar and Spice by “The Searchers” for British invasion week.

melinda was robbed | 5/25/2007, 12:09 pm EST

I read the news today, oh boy

stagefronttickets | 5/25/2007, 12:05 pm EST

This season has not shown the real talent portrayed in other seasons. Oh well, all ten finalists are going on a U.S. Summer tour that kicks off in July. Maybe they’ll be better in front of bigger LIVE audiences.
www.stagefronttick ets.com

Rotten 11 | 5/25/2007, 11:51 am EST

the show was more boring than church, enough already!

Don VIto | 5/25/2007, 11:50 am EST

Jordin who??
You know that beatbox fruit! thats what they’ll be saying!

? | 5/25/2007, 11:46 am EST

The funny thing is no one will care about any of this come next season.

Post A Comment

Caution: Off-topic comments will be deleted

Name:

Comments:



Advertisement

Advertisement