Previous Next Latest

American Idol Winner: Our Expert Predictions, Caught On Tape

5/23/07, 2:12 pm EST

Like most professionals at the top of their field, Rolling Stone’s resident American Idol experts Jenny Eliscu and Rob Sheffield get much of their critical discernment from their mothers. See who they think will win in tonight’s showdown.


Previous Next Latest

Comments

bunjamun | 5/23/2007, 2:40 pm EST

GOD i love Simon hes so hot!

stagefronttickets | 5/23/2007, 2:52 pm EST

I don’t like either of them. But it’s no matter, they will still make tons of money anyway.

http://www.stagefrontticke ts.com

sly | 5/23/2007, 2:54 pm EST

JORDIN

dlt | 5/23/2007, 3:09 pm EST

Death Culture

Ay Simon,
Do you like me new name?

dlt | 5/23/2007, 3:10 pm EST

Death Culture

Ay Simon,
Do you like me new name?

This is rock n roll? | 5/23/2007, 3:11 pm EST

Can’t wait for RS’s inevitable list of The Top 500 Albums By American Idol Participants.

Don Vito | 5/23/2007, 3:28 pm EST

My mom gots da hairy ball syndrome.

Rotten 11 | 5/23/2007, 3:57 pm EST

sux sux sux

woooooooo | 5/23/2007, 6:38 pm EST

jordin is a horrible tone deaf wookie of a singer
and they make such a big deal about her being 17, but honestly, every 17 year old i know who can sing at all is 50 times better than jordin

Oddjob | 5/23/2007, 7:01 pm EST

Let’s be honest: they are both capable singers but far from great and it’s pretty sad that out of the whole country, this is who we’ve whittled it down to. Neither one of them would be able to make a convincing album without a healthy dose of digital enhancement, and that’s the truth.

Now, why is it that no one is talking about how f—ed up Paula Abdul was last night?!?!? Am I the only one who noticed this, I feel like I’m taking crazy pills!

CELLA | 5/23/2007, 10:10 pm EST

I was really disappointed when I found out Melinda was voted off– I didn’t understand it to be quite honest since then I have decided not to watch the show… it’s clearly a popularity contest rather then a true singing competition.

OK | 5/24/2007, 7:38 am EST

Man Rob Sheffield used to look soo much better. What happened to him? He must have aged badly in the last couple of yrs.

OK | 5/24/2007, 7:38 am EST

Man Rob Sheffield used to look soo much better. What happened to him? He must have aged badly in the last couple of yrs.

Driver | 5/24/2007, 7:55 am EST

comon, American Idol is the most ridiculous show on TV..The only winner who has really gotten popular is kelly clarkson and ok..fantasia was ok..but it just produces an artists who sings other peoples lyrics and they just soak in the stardum.. Fox needs to give the show a break for 2 years instead of bringing it back probably this fall

jen | 5/24/2007, 8:30 am EST

I think that the finale was horrible. This season was not as good as past seasons. I have never had a fav to win. Except maybe Kelly Clarkson, but I really didn’t watch it then. Why is it that America is completly dumb until the albums come out? Why can’t they vote the right way before it gets that far? I liked Blake and I couldn’t stand Jordin. She seemed way to fake to me. Maybe if we stopped watching things would work out better.

bunjamun | 5/24/2007, 11:02 am EST

I LOVES DA COCK

Dr. Ralph | 5/24/2007, 3:19 pm EST

Ummm… Driver back up. Billboard Album Charts TODAY…#10 Daughtry. Formerly known as Chris Daughtry on AI. Carrie Underwood #11, Miranda Lambert #29 from “Nashville Star” aka American Idol Country, Josh Grobin #50,Josh Turner #55, Fantasia and Kelly Pickler round out the top 100. Seven percent solution… where have I heard that before? The most ridiculous show on TV is churning out american idols like a Detroit assembly line. Yup, it wil “probably” be back!

Supermarth | 5/24/2007, 3:52 pm EST

Fixed season. Results were a joke. Fake / Ilegitimate winner.
Simon is the only reason for watching the show!!!

iclfujdax qnsogkw | 8/10/2007, 10:14 am EST

qrhz gwrxsu blmtvasek zofygvke casbveyj krpjitnbf bgazwi

davidc | 5/20/2008, 8:59 pm EST

ok… David Archuleta is crazy. The winner should be David Cook. He has so much talent its not even funny. Aswell as looking awesome he rocks. David Archuleta thinks he’s so great.

Anonymous | 8/30/2008, 7:15 pm EST

DAVID COOCK IS FANTASTIC, tHE BEST

Post A Comment

Caution: Off-topic comments will be deleted

Name:

Comments:



Advertisement

Advertisement