Previous Next Latest

How to Be Both Controversial AND Comprehensible

4/10/07, 5:12 pm EST

Kanye West

In one of her recent rants (this one came onstage in San Diego) Lily Allen spewed out a series of incendiary, attention-grabbing political statements. She called President Bush an “asshole and a cunt,” and described British Prime Minister Tony Blair as “a cunt’s bitch.” (Allen went on to say that she was tired of men with “little dicks” and is “probably bisexual,” which is, of course, good to know). We love it when stars make controversial statements, but, especially when it comes to politics, we appreciate it when they manage to express themselves in complete sentences (subject-verb-object will do just fine, no complex clauses required). Here, from five major artists, are five incendiary and (almost) grammatical quotes.

  • Politically outspoken sonic visionary Thom Yorke allegedly wrote the following statement on Radiohead’s Web site last summer, while Israel was bombing Lebanon: “Our government sitting on the fence with the US while world war 3 appears to be breaking out in Lebanon and Northern Israel. we must throw Tony Blair our of office NOW. he does not represent the views of the british people. he does not represent the views of his foreign office and officials. he does not even represent the views of those in his cabinet. he cares far too much about his relationship with Bush, and Murdoch. this man is not fit to be our prime minister. its a nice sunny day. come on lets do it. you know it makes sense.”
  • Britney Spears was mocked relentlessly for her September, 2003 comment, which many felt perfectly reflected the general state of blind, irresponsible, political ignorance of the average young person in America. “Honestly, I think we should just trust our president in every decision he makes and just support that, you know, and be faithful in what happens.”
  • Relentless troop supporter and American Flag wearer Kid Rock has always been affiliated with the kind of conservative political views that are unusual among rock musicians. In February, 2003, at a pre-Grammy party, Rock explained his philosophy on the proper relationship between music and politics. “Why is everybody trying to stop the war?” Rock asked. “George Bush ain’t been saying, ‘You all make shitty records.’ Politicians and music don’t mix. It’s like whiskey and wine. We ought to stay out of it.”
  • A casual statement made by Dixie Chick Natalie Maines to an audience at London at Shepherd’s Bush Empire in March, 2003, resulted in an outpouring of Dixie Chicks-hating that threatened to derail the band’s career and divided America’s music listening population into Red and Blue. So what was it that she actually said? “Just so you know, we’re ashamed the President of the United States is from Texas.”
  • On the list of statements that manage to be both politically incendiary and hysterically funny, we’re hard pressed to think of an example more perfect than Kanye West’s outrageous comment during NBC’s live concert fundraiser for victims of Hurricane Katrina. “George Bush doesn’t care about black people,” West said. Almost as amusing? Mike Myers attempt to go on nodding while West rants, and then tries to read the boilerplate teleprompted copy afterwards. Revisit the moment here.

Previous Next Latest

Comments

txasbranco | 4/10/2007, 5:38 pm EST

Nobody gave a shit about what Chuck Berry’s political beliefs, and he didn’t give a shit about yours. That’s what made him great, and that’s why these guys are chumps.

I hate Mike Anthony | 4/10/2007, 6:07 pm EST

zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz

Stuporfly | 4/10/2007, 6:07 pm EST

I’m tired of Lily Allen going on and on about my little dick! I don’t rant and rave about her wildly hairy vagina, do I?

Dr. Ralph | 4/10/2007, 6:14 pm EST

Kid Rock is my new motherfucking hero! Go to a concert and if you’re lucky you’ll hear him do “If I Were President”.Not on any CD but he played it here in Music City USA and it rules.

mmd | 4/10/2007, 6:23 pm EST

Lilly Allen needs to chill. Her ego is starting to rear its ugly head. Kanye West sounded like an incoherent douch, but he had the balls (stupidity?) to say Bush doesn’t care about black people. Myer’s face after he said that? Priceless.

Marc | 4/10/2007, 6:41 pm EST

Lily Allens ego is getting big! I agree with Rock..music and politics dont mix. Stick to your music or just run for office but dont do both!

ljs with love... | 4/10/2007, 6:51 pm EST

i’m with md on that one.

Spaceboy | 4/10/2007, 6:54 pm EST

kanye should have said ‘Bush doesn’t care about POOR people’…the Dixie Chicks exile from country radio is ridiculous. I dont get what was so bad about what she said. They’re just ashamed that Bush is from Texas, they didn’t insult the U.S. or nothing…Spears’ idiotic comment makes her recent craziness more clear

Question! | 4/10/2007, 6:55 pm EST

Our own politicians are morons! So what makes anyone think that a high school dropout on drugs should be taken seriously or given more consideration about what he or she feels? There is not one person in our country who believes in what they are saying or writing or yelling or screaming or chanting or protesting, especially when it comes to the anti-war folks and Bush-bashers. I don’t agree with the handling of the Iraq War. I don’t agree with many things the Bush Administration does. But I’m not going to be so delusional or even ignorant to think holding a sign or wasting a weekend gathering with others going to change a thing. It’s a waste. Tell me one thing anyone has accomplished by holding a sign or yelling obscene chants? Nothing! Like I said, THERE IS NOT ONE PERSON ALIVE IN AMERICA WHO TRULY BELIEVES A THING THEY SAY THEY BELIEVE IN! Go ahead and practice your 1st Amendment. If that’s all you do, you won’t accomplish anything.

bill451 | 4/10/2007, 7:11 pm EST

Md – great post

Kelsy Grammar | 4/10/2007, 7:33 pm EST

Hey Thom York,
Why not take a basic English grammar course before you go trying to sound smart?

Boatman | 4/10/2007, 7:36 pm EST

Kid Rock and Britney Spears are idiots

Anonymous | 4/10/2007, 8:46 pm EST

i refuse to understand why music and politics don’t mix. every single person has a right to give us their opinion on the state of the world. It just so happens that msucians have a larger platform than most people. to me that is no reason why they can not voice their opinion. granted if they can not do it logically and understandably than i would prefer they keep the opinion to themselves. but i still think they have the right (and needless to say the freedom) to say it,

Max | 4/10/2007, 8:52 pm EST

I’ve always loved Lily Allen and that makes me love her even more.

lik roper | 4/10/2007, 9:51 pm EST

face it; we all need to care more about the albinos…

nick | 4/10/2007, 9:52 pm EST

Question! I don’t think you understand how politics works in this country. It’s very much about the message. In fact it’s about how many people you can get to say the say damn thing all at once.

Sam | 4/10/2007, 9:56 pm EST

I think musicians commenting on politics is a great thing. If people don’t challenge corruption then things will never get addressed. How was segreation ended? The Vietnam war? It was intense outcry and criticism from the public. Change can be made if enough people ban together.

Question! | 4/10/2007, 11:20 pm EST

Hey Nick,
The message is great, however, review some of the issues you pointed.
Segregation-the fact that this came to an end is great. But the history is actually much more than people of all colors getting organized. It was about money. When many African-Americans decided that equality should be reality, many boycotts ensued. Take public transportation such as city buses for example. When cities started losing money, they decided that segregation as they knew it had to end in order to get back their earnings, especially from African-American who made up the majority of users for buses, especially in the South. So it was the loss of money that ended segregation.
Vietnam War-this came to end because the government decided it was too much money for too long, and the cause was no longer worth it, not because hippies and college students or even disgruntled vets who felt the war was unjustified. My main point about is that when money or life becomes the main loss , that’s when things change. Nothing more or less, including “celebrities. Check just about any issue in history, and you’ll see this is correct. So understand that my good friend, Nick.

yewnorker | 4/10/2007, 11:25 pm EST

When are we going to see the Dixie Chicks on the cover? They won 5 Grammys!

Lennox | 4/10/2007, 11:50 pm EST

most of america doesn’t care about black people. it’s the chinese that we chouls really worry about though.

Chucky | 4/10/2007, 11:50 pm EST

It seems most people that make the statements don’t know what the hell they are talking about anyway…I rarely take political advice from celebs most of which haven’t graduated from any schooling.

Marcus | 4/11/2007, 12:43 am EST

Actually, I recently watched a documentary about the Stones and Mick Jagger seemed very articulate. No British jabbering.

BK | 4/11/2007, 12:45 am EST

Thom Yorke really thought Israel bombing Lebanon would be the start of WWIII? That’s one of the stupidest things I’ve ever heard.

Boraj Ciffarelli | 4/11/2007, 1:12 am EST

George Bush is from Connecticut, not Texas. He went to Andover Prep in Massachusetts. He graduated from Yale in CT, and Harvard in MA. He was also born in CT. Not very southern, huh? Not that he can ever go back to Connecticut. Especially since he has pretty much ignored the half of the nation north of the mason-dixon line .

goatartist | 4/11/2007, 1:38 am EST

the rev al sharpton doesn’t care about black people.

Your Old Man | 4/11/2007, 1:39 am EST

Seriously

Register To Vote | 4/11/2007, 5:42 am EST

Who is making those new brown clouds? Where is FRANK ZAPPA when you need him? Can’t you just picture him launching into a diatribe today? With soooo much ammunition…

Office Bastard | 4/11/2007, 7:24 am EST

West dosent care about black people… where you think those diamonds your so fond of come from nigga?
Hahahaha love it!

whazzup | 4/11/2007, 7:56 am EST

mike myer’s face is effen pricles in that pic! :)

40oz killa | 4/11/2007, 10:27 am EST

I for one think it is nice to hear plain speach when someone is talking about politicts. sure, blurting out G.W. doesn’t care about black people is not the most eloquent form of expression, but have you heard the “experts” talk about a political situation. There is so much doublespeak and jargon that a 5 minute speech full of 50 cent words actually says absolutely nothing. Its not how you spell it or even how you express it, it is the ideal itself that is important. I could write a wonderful essay on the inequality of socio/economic politics, but nobody is going to listen to me, people like Thom Yorke and Kanye do have an audience for their thoughts due to the celebrity factor, so even if they don’t say it well at least they are saying it.

abandonedstation | 4/11/2007, 11:15 am EST

celebrities represent a regular cross section of society. some dumb, some smart, most in between. and like many citizens, many celebrities don’t care about politics in the first place.
those that do care can sound like any other person in society who comment on politics. it’s ridiculous that we expect a higher standard from celebrities because they sound intelligent when saying their pre-scripted lines or sound more emotionally honest when singing a song. they’re just people.

we don’t care about the controversial comments. people make comments like yorke’s and kanye’s every day. we just care about celebrities. if we can get away with it, let them get away with it, too.

Boner | 4/11/2007, 11:26 am EST

Lily and her mom need my sweet bone

Markus | 4/11/2007, 1:38 pm EST

“He not busy being born., is busy dying”

NATAS | 4/11/2007, 1:46 pm EST

Kanye West is a conceded,talentless, racist piece of crap and no one should ever say anything good about him or purchase anything he sells.

ME | 4/11/2007, 2:27 pm EST

Kanye West is an uneducated moron. College drop-out, just like the dumb ass says. I could give a fuck less about his political views. He just jumps on the Bush hating bandwagon like everybody else. Granted, Bush is a dumb ass and so is his whole administration, but Kanye West doesn’t know shit about politics, so he should close his mouth and help in ways that don’t make him look like such a dickhead. I appreciate the views and opinions when they are well-informed and researched, but being a celebrity doesn’t necessarily make you a political analyst.

Spencer V. | 4/11/2007, 5:13 pm EST

Well, I will have to say something good about him. He’s a beast on the mic and the boards and I bought both of his albums and will buy Graduation when it drops. He’s not racist. He’s right about Bush, he doesn’t care about us. He’s not talentless. He is conceded however.

Faith | 4/11/2007, 5:44 pm EST

Learn how to spell conceited, genius.

emily | 4/11/2007, 10:27 pm EST

really, who cares what the celebrities say? we can find millions of idiotic things politicians say and there the ones actually involved. blog them

T-Nasty | 4/12/2007, 3:23 am EST

That Sticky Icky Thump gonna be blazin!

david | 4/12/2007, 4:15 am EST

he cares more about Kanye than he does
Mike Myers. do you really think he cares about Canadians.

Stripes | 4/12/2007, 8:17 pm EST

lol Lily Allen… i thought she was cool and now i think shes AWSUM! im stuck in the Icky Thump and i cant get out until i hear the music. go white stripes!

Evan | 4/14/2007, 12:22 pm EST

Office Bastard | 4/11/2007, 7:24 am EST

West dosent care about black people… where you think those diamonds your so fond of come from nigga?
Hahahaha love i

He does know where they’re from. That’s why he did a song called “Diamonds (From Sierra Leone).

Celebrities are Americans. Thusly, they have a RIGHT and indeed a DUTY to say and to do ANYTHING AND EVERYTHING they want as long as it doesn’t interfere with any one else’s right and obligation to do anything and EVERYTHING they choose to. This does not end once someone gets their Screen Actors Guild card. The fact that they have a larger mouthpiece to do so with is matter of fact. If millions of people worried about everything you said and did, from adopting a child to walking into a bathroom barefoot, and you felt very strongly about something wouldn’t you want to say something about it? Perhaps if we’re so off-putted by celebrities taking stances on politics we should examine our relationship with the very nature of celebrity itself.

In support | 4/17/2007, 3:09 am EST

I think it’s great that the author of this article writes so earnestly about these issues.
America could do with more media coverage such as the above.
Congratulations.

BlindFame | 4/18/2007, 8:23 pm EST

Where is the evidence that Kayne West is racist?

Post A Comment

Caution: Off-topic comments will be deleted

Name:

Comments:



Advertisement

Advertisement