Previous Next Latest

You Win Some, You Lose Some: The American Idol Sweet Spot

3/29/07, 6:38 pm EST

Who says winning is everything? When it comes to American Idol, ending up on top doesn’t necessarily mean you can cash in your life savings and start rolling around in a bed of thousand-dollar bills. In fact, for some former Idol contestants, the exposure they received just from being on the show has been enough to catapult them past the actual winners — and into the careers they always wished they had — long after the Idol curtain call.

There is, of course, Kelly Clarkson, who has managed to live up to the title, but what about Ruben Studdard, who won Season Two? Studdard has released three albums and sold 2.25 million copies overall. Compare that to Season Two’s runner-up (and inexplicable sex symbol) Clay Aiken, who went on to sell a combined 4.6 million over the course of three albums.

Perhaps the best example of a winner not performing as expected is Fifth Season Idol Taylor Hicks. Since nabbing the crown last year, Hicks has proven that just because he’s the kind of guy you’d dance with at your cousin’s wedding doesn’t mean you want him to be the one singing the song. He’s on his way to becoming the first Idol winner to sell under a million copies of his major label debut, with only 650,000 copies of Taylor Hicks sold since its release last December. His Season Five compatriots Kellie Pickler, Katharine McPhee and Chris Daughtry, on the other hand, have been enjoying near-constant attention. In fact, Daughtry, who finished fourth, released Daughtry just a month before Hicks and the album has already gone double platinum. McPhee’s record sales haven’t exactly been been phenomenal, but she has managed to stay in the spotlight through product endorsement and public appearances. Pickler’s 2006 release, Small Town Girl, sold 600,000 copies, just a shade under Hicks’. Not bad for a girl who finished in sixth place.

While some runners-up such as Justin Guarini (Season One) and Diana DeGarmo (Season Three) have watched their middling post-Idol careers dwindle, others are flat-out happy things turned out the way they did. For some, losing Idol is a relief. Back in June of 2005, Season Four runner-up Bo Bice told our Jenny Eliscu, “(I thought)’Please God don’t let me win this thing.’ I never told anybody that. The label ‘American Idol’ was not for me. It would have been even harder for me to play my kind of music if I had won.”
So how short-term is America’s memory? Who was your favorite Idol loser?

Amy Novak

More American Idol

Previous Next Latest

Comments

american idol | 5/23/2008, 5:50 pm EST

pop singer debra winer
is the best american idol
pop singer
pop singer debra winer
is the best selling recording
artists in america
new debra winer the greatest
gift of all cds single’s
new debra winer world tour 2008
debra winer performs 26 number1
hits songs in concerts

american idol | 5/23/2008, 5:50 pm EST

AMERICAN IDOL | 10/9/2007, 8:17 pm EST

DEBRA WINER IS THE BEST
SELLING RECORDING ARTISTS
IN AMERICA WINER HAS THE
BEST CARS IN AMERICA
DEBRA WINER NEW ALBUMS
DEBRA WINER WISH UPON A STAR
DEBRA WINER GIFT OF LOVE
THE BEST OF DEBRA WINERGREATEST HITS SONGS DEBRA WINER CONCERTS

AMERICAN IDOL | 10/9/2007, 8:17 pm EST

AMERICAN IDOL | 10/1/2007, 8:13 pm EST

WINNER DEBRA WINER IS
THE BEST SELLING RECORDING
ARTISTS IN AMERICA
DEBRA WINER NEW ALBUMS CDS
DEBRA WINER GREATEST HITS
DEBRA WINER NUMBER 1
DEBRA WINER THE BESTOF
DEBRA WINER GIFT OF LOVE
DEBRA WINER WISH UPON A STAR
DEBRA WINER THE GREATEST GIFT

AMERICAN IDOL | 10/1/2007, 8:13 pm EST

blue view records cds | 10/1/2007, 7:54 pm EST

new DEBRA WINER NEW CHRISTMAS CDS
DEBRA WINER WISH UPON A STAR
DEBRA WINER GIFT OF LOVE
CELEBRATE DEBRA WINER
BIRTHDAY SEPT 26,2007
DEBRA WINER TOUR 2007AND 08
DEBRA WINER CHRISTMAS CONCERTSNYCD
DEBRA WINER 26SONGSON NEW CDSAND DVDS MUSIC 2007BLUEVIEW RECORDSNYC

blue view records cds | 10/1/2007, 7:54 pm EST

AMERICAN IDOL | 8/30/2007, 8:48 pm EST

DEBRA WINER IS THE BEST
SELLING RECORDING ARTIST IN
AMERICA WINER CHEVROLET
HAS THE BESTCARS BEST SALES
INCARS DEBRA WINER IS THE
OUEEN OF POP MUSIC AND NUMBER 1
DEBRA WINER COUNTRY POPSINGER
BEST SELLING RECODING ARTISTS DEBRA WINER DEBRA WINER CONCERTS TOUE2007NEW MOVIE DEBRA WINERPOPSINGER INAMERICA

AMERICAN IDOL | 8/30/2007, 8:48 pm EST

DianaDeGarmoObsessiveCompulsiv | 5/27/2007, 12:32 am EST

Diana has ton A TON since her Idol days. Whoever wrote this artile is showing poor journalism. No research was done here, because it is obviously apparent that, while she hasn’t been “mainstreamed,” Diana has been involved in many other impressive activites. Among them include a Braodway Production (”Hairspray”), a debut CD (”Blue Skies”), an independent tour that traveled across the U.S., numerous charity events, and currently, a second album that is finishing up recording.

Diana has done so much in the past 3 years. It is not only unfair to label her fame as “dwindled,” but it is poor showing on part of the columnist.
If anyone is truly interested in Diana, visit:
www.dianadegarmomusic. com
www.dianad.com

katie | 4/23/2007, 2:40 pm EST

whoever wrote this needs to get their facts straight. Diana hasnt dwindled. Check up on her and see her accomplishments since Idol

S Ray | 4/15/2007, 7:01 pm EST

Who has sung with Andrea Bocelli? Who missed the Christmas release dates when people buy, buy, and buy? Wait a year–you all will see who is talented!

Actually season 5 — all 10 deserve recording contracts!!!

idolfan | 4/13/2007, 12:58 pm EST

I have just a few comments. 1) Why do people that obviously don’t like Idol even bother posting their comments? If you don’t like Idol, don’t watch and let the people that do like it enjoy it and go do your own thing. 2)Everyone has their own favorite but why bash the others that someone must enjoy. Sure, I think Chris is the best but for those that like Taylor, more power to you and enjoy him or whoever your favorite might be. I think every Idol, winner or loser, has the right to try to entertain anyway they want. If they only sell 100 CD’s, there must be 100 people that like them. I applaud Idol for giving wannabe musicians the chance to showcase their talents or so called talents, as the case may be. Even Sanjaya, who isn’t deserving of being around still, IMO, should be given some credit for the maturity he has handled the ribbing and jokes and still gets up and has a good time in front of millions of people. That’s pretty good for a 17 year old.
So all you Idol haters, just go about your own business and let the fans enjoy the show, and everyone else, enjoy your favorite Idol but don’t be hating the others. That’s all I’ve got to say about that.

Melanie | 4/8/2007, 6:41 pm EST

Taylor Hicks is on fire and he is selling out venues with great reviews…grassroots style. If you Tay haters would get of the hate wagon long enough to check this man out you would see that this guys is going to be around for a long time in the industry. I’m sure he is well aware of how the industry spits out rock/pop stars all the time and they usually are replaced just as fast they came. Slow and steady will win this race…wait and see where Tay is at next year vs. some of your so-called hot mainstream successes right now.

zoopy2 | 4/8/2007, 5:51 am EST

Hey guys, just go to YouTube and type “Lover All Alone” in the search bar; lots of posters are using the Clay penned song as a soundtrack to their tribute videos for their favorite movies and TV shows, even a Korean one! His new-age sounding version of “Broken Wings” is showing up there too.
Who needs radio?

Chris | 4/7/2007, 8:42 pm EST

People, what about Kerri Underwood?? Amy does not mention her and neither any readers in the blog. She has become a #1 country artist. She isn’t even mentioned anywhere here. She is positive proof that AI works!! What we can’t have a little bit of country with a little bit of rock n roll??

liz | 4/6/2007, 6:03 pm EST

In reality AI is not a talant contest but a contest to see who can get the most votes from their friends and family. Otherwise there would be a limit on votes, say 10 per person per night. That would at least free the lines for others to vote. Back to the Clay/Ruben deal . . I tried to vote nonstop for Clay in the finale because I admired the talent but could never get through ONCE. Then after Ruben wins and the interview with “Mom’ comes on she tells the world that she voted for her boy over 200 times that night. So voting is really a joke and this over 30 or 40 million votes or whatever they claim is just huge numerous votes from the same people over and over . .can’t really say who America chose because alot of us can never get through! As to the best, Clay,Daughtry and Bice are great -and having Sanjaya hang around just proves the moot point of voting. Why bother?

Lynn | 4/6/2007, 4:38 pm EST

Everyone has different tastes in music and some love Daughtry,,some love MacPhee or Fantasia…and that’s okay. Personally the best singer to come out of Idol is Clay Aiken. He is the total package. I love Carrie Underwood and Bo Bice..I like Josh Gracin…but the real talent..is Clay. Bad or little promotion has only increased his fan base and given him a very supportive fan base (whacko’s aside). He interacts and cares about his fans and THAT who is ultimately responsible for ticket sales or record sales. I may not like EVERYTHING he sings or puts out but doesn’t mean I don’t support him. Listen to Lover All Alone and you will see the hidden talent. He is amazing.

Wes | 4/6/2007, 1:20 pm EST

People take American Idol too seriously. Point in case: Sanjaya. It would probably better for all the contestants if he would win. If Sanjaya gets the recording contract, then others will be able negotiate their own. That is a win-win situation.

mack | 4/5/2007, 8:08 pm EST

WHY DO YOU AMERICAN IDIOTS KEEP A TALENTLESS FLAKE LIKE SANGINA ON THE SHOW WHILE SOME REALLY TALENTED PERFORMERS ARE VOTED OFF YOU PEOPLE MAKE ME SICK !!!!!!!!! SANGINA NEEDS TO GO HOME AND WASH HIS MANGINA AND LEAVE THIS COMPETITION TO THE REAL IDOLS!!!!!

mack | 4/5/2007, 7:59 pm EST

WHY DO YOU AMERICAN IDIOTS KEEP A TALENTLESS FLAKE LIKE SANGINA ON THE SHOW WHILE SOME REALLY TALENTED PERFORMERS ARE VOTED OFF YOU PEOPLE MAKE ME SICK !!!!!!!!!

Tyanna | 4/5/2007, 5:41 pm EST

Tom from PGH:

Gold and Platinum certifications are not based solely on record sales. They have more to do with how many records were SHIPPED. Taylor’s label shipped 1mil copies with the assumption that all of them would be purchased, therefore, they went to the RIAA to certify the album platinum.

Tyanna | 4/5/2007, 5:38 pm EST

Wow. CathyEM said it all. Elliott Yamin is the truth! He is practically deaf in one ear, yet he can pretty much out sing any male that has ever been on Idol. He is my favorite of all the “fallen” Idols. Nice guy with tons of talent. He sold 90,000 copies of his album in the first week on an independent label with nearly no promotion. Why isn’t he mentioned in this article? If flop jobs like Kat McPhee can be, so can Elliott.

jp | 4/4/2007, 3:45 am EST

the shows’ entertainment value is astonishing. old folks remember programs like ed sullivan hollywood palace this show is the equal for our generation on our generations terms. people seem to need this kind of diversion away from the parade of corpses on other shows. a fake corpse has never pasted a grin on my face, never.

Tom From Pgh | 4/3/2007, 10:36 am EST

If Taylor’s CD has “only” sold 650,000 copies then why was it certified platinum (1 million units sold) by the RIAA in late January ? There were press releases touting this fact and the album is marked for platinum cerification on the Billboard charts. How old is the information in this article ? Also, Reuben did have a Top 10 album last year and the album’s first single spent 9 weeks at No.1 on the R&B charts, not exactly failure.

dersh | 4/2/2007, 6:33 pm EST

just watch chris slighs band half past forever blow up soon enough

leann | 4/2/2007, 3:59 pm EST

Okay-well first let me say that I love Daughtry! I live about thirty minutes from here he lives but live in the same town where Fantasia is from. Chris has already done two free admission concerts for his fans and Fastasia has done none. He drew in 23 million with his last one in Greensboro on 3/23.I have attended both and he leaves everybody excited. He even filmed his new video Home here. I don’t think he is the greatest but he has a fan in me for the rest of his career.
And as a responses to what King of Cliches posted about Chris’ song but sure what you are listening to ( or hearing ) but go to lyrics.com, saying Like a runaway train You will consume me,
But I can’t walk away;but the ship at sea thing not ringing a bell

Ken | 4/2/2007, 3:21 pm EST

I saw the hilarious movie “Blades Of Glory” this weekend, and was surprised to hear Bo Bice singing the title track at the end! He sounds great and I realized how much talent he has. I htink if he was allowed to put out the type of album he wanted to he would have had a bigger success. Maybe the next time around since it’s rumored he’s not with RCA anymore? Anyway doing a soundtrack song for a # 1 movie is not too shabby!

cin | 4/2/2007, 10:52 am EST

We all have our own tastes and opinions. I am not judging anyone on who they like or don’t like. I do know this. Chris Daughtry has made no secret that the recording band is not the same as his current hand picked band. The reason his tour tix sales are lower then Hicks is because he is only playing small venues at the moment. Even if he sounds like Nickleback, which he said that he considers that a compliment, and even if he does not have the best vocals or is not talented like many say, he is what America likes for his genre and that should speak for itself, just like Taylor is what america likes for his genre. You just cannot compare all of these people to each other. It is not fair.

JMK | 4/1/2007, 9:38 pm EST

I never even thought about the loosers before. But it makes sense that they would be sucessful since the judges are ridiculous. They wouldn’t know talent if it gave them a “goose in the caboose.”

pat | 4/1/2007, 8:08 pm EST

Chris Daughtry is the flavor of the month auntil the next one comes out. I agree that he has more commercial success than Taylor Hicks who is in par with Ruben success wich is not much. They are both eclipsed by the runner ups. You don’t hear much about Ruben excpet for the fact that Clay has outsell hin in all aspects, albums , concerts and more famous.

cindy | 4/1/2007, 7:48 pm EST

the only two succesful AI losers so far are Clay Aiken and Chris Daughtry. The others non winners or runner ups don,t even come close. Katherine Mcphee has not yet been a commercial success in spite of overpromotion. Her debut album has still a way to go before it even reahes gold.

staindpearlygirl | 4/1/2007, 6:19 pm EST

Wow, well before Daughtry, it was mos def Bo Bice, being the little hottie and all. But Chris just blew me away and I absolutely was stunned when he was sent home! So I have to give this one to Chris Daughtry being he caters to the kind of music I’m in to….

Fran | 3/31/2007, 10:10 pm EST

Bo Bice is a genuine winner in every way and now that he is healthy get ready

Fran | 3/31/2007, 10:07 pm EST

Bo Bice hits me on all levels. His wonderful voice. musical skills, sense of humor and decency. Now that he is healthy he is ready to kick serious butt. Go Bo on Blades of Glory.

bobby | 3/31/2007, 8:43 pm EST

Diana was only 16. it’s only a matter of time before someone invests in her again (label wise). Be that a year from now or a few.

I mean, if record labels can waste their time/money on other groups/preformers that nobody hears or cares about (ex. megan rochelle, tiffany affair, a girl called jane) then im sure someone will eventually take a chance in Diana.

Paula | 3/31/2007, 7:41 pm EST

I think Bo Bice has more vocal range and versatility . I’m looking forward to his upcoming second album which will be comprised of songs he wrote himself, and some co written with Chris Tompkins of Muscle Shoals fame. The REAL Bo Bice will shine!

Julie | 3/31/2007, 5:17 pm EST

Maybe if the myopic media would look beyond the Top 40 charts then the Broadway success of someone like Diana DeGarmo would be appreciated rather than ignored. She’s proven herself to be a multitalented young woman. She doesn’t need to sell a million CDs, especially in this day and age, to have a career worthy of respect.

Jeff | 3/31/2007, 4:13 pm EST

Diana Degarmo is very underated by many. especially by those who only remember the 16 year old from idol who had the big voice and was also the one to steal the thunder from two of the three divas! But anyone who has actually seen /heard this young lady knows she has the talent to go far, Let the idol competition be over and Go listen to her now… The young lady is amazing.

Julie | 3/31/2007, 3:37 pm EST

This blog is a great example of the myopic view the media takes of success. For Amy it appears that if AI alum are not on Top 40 radio ad nauseum or going platinum, well that must mean they have no career at all.

Diana DeGarmo has been in three successful roles in musical theater, two of them lead roles (West Side Story as Maria, and Brooklyn as the title character) and getting rave reviews for playing Penny Pingleton in the Broadway version of Hairspray. She’s going to be peforming at Carnegie Hall April 30th for the New York Pops Birthday Gala. Yes, what a dormant and sucky career she has. Get your head out of Nickelback’s butt for five minutes and you might see there is more to an entertainment career than pop music.

cally4 | 3/31/2007, 12:36 pm EST

Saw Taylor’s first and third concerts. His energy and genuine desire to please a crowd are evident. Ticket sales and positive reviews shold not be a surprise. He’s always said he’s most comfortable in a setting that allows him to make contact and interact directly with the audience. What’s the best is that in addition to promoting his album during his concerts he’s gradually inserting great music that he values and wants to share with his fans. A most recent example is a knock your socks off Taylorized version of “She’s Gone”.
Even if you have to “drag” yourself to a Taylor concert, please do. I’m willing to bet that you’ll come away with a new respect for a talented artist, performer and musician.

sebby | 3/31/2007, 11:42 am EST

Get your facts straight, Amy. Check Pickler’s numbers again.

Check in a year from now with the status on the Idols.

Deborah | 3/31/2007, 10:37 am EST

Lord, give me another Bo Bice! I haven’t seen another season of A1 that could hold a candle to season 4. At least that was a competition.

CathyEM | 3/31/2007, 10:01 am EST

My all-time Idol favorite Elliott Yamin followed his instincts and stayed far, far away from 19 and Clive Davis. His CD, while in some ways in a concession to “popular music” to get radio play, reflects the kind of music Elliott wanted to make — passionate and soulful, whether an introspective ballad or a club-banger. He uses his voice like an instrument and pours his heart and soul into every number. Even without the promotional backing of the AI machine, his CD debuted at #3 on the Billboard charts. Some of the bonus tracks that are being offered through various retailers are even better than the cuts on the CD. If you want to hear a GREAT singer who has not been coerced by a bunch of suits into recording derivative crap, check out Elliott’s CD.

Dominique | 3/31/2007, 8:42 am EST

This article plays up Katharine McPhee as if she has really done something great, when she has not sold very many cds and she is only in the public eye because she is being pushed and promoted and is selling herself based on her sexuality, which has nothing to do with her musical talent, and I’m surprised that Rolling Stone would stoop that low, when it’s supposed to be about respecting music.

Taylor’s cd hasn’t sold well, I’m sorry to say, though most of the songs are, in my opinion, good songs. He’s on tour right now and getting good reviews. I think Taylor’s going to have a long career and not be a flash in the pan. It’s too soon to judge him. And yes Chris’s sales have been phenomenal, it’s true, so good for him, though he does nothing for me. I couldn’t see why Carrie sold so many cds either, though I love both Kelly and Kellie.

Bottom line, they’re all talented and we all have our preferences. No need to pit them against each other. Most of them are having greater success already than many other artists out there.

Maryann | 3/31/2007, 8:11 am EST

Chris D is the AI wanted - giving him constant promotion.

Kellie Pickler’s total sales are
477,882 albums per her website

KellieFan | 3/31/2007, 3:32 am EST

Kellie pickler has a gold album for Small Town Girl,in fact she has sold 600,000 copies.Look it up it is a true fact!!!

Dale | 3/30/2007, 10:44 pm EST

When will stop pitting these singers against each other? All of them have their pluses and minuses. Most of them, esp.Taylor,do not want to be “just another singer.” One person can go for rock=Chris, and another can go for soul=Taylor, and all of us can shut up and be happy. Dale

Kim | 3/30/2007, 10:35 pm EST

Clay and only CLAY!!

Kim | 3/30/2007, 10:34 pm EST

Clay! And only Clay!!

Michelle | 3/30/2007, 10:29 pm EST

I agree with most of what Josh above states. Clive Davis is the deciding factor in promotion of the idols. They decide in advance who they want to be successful and who they don’t. Justin G. got a very raw deal and don’t count him out yet. In watching the Idol Rewind you can see his talent and charisma and he was just pushed aside. Also Taylor is a great performer and is kicking Daughtry’s butt in concert sells.
We saw the idol tour in Portland and Chris looked bored stiff to be there. Yeah he can sing, but he sounds like Nickelback and Live and has no originality. I used to like the guy but he has become so cocky and full of himself that I don’t enjoy him anymore. This year they are pushing Lakisha and I can see a repeat of Fantasia happening.
Hopefully not!
Oh… and what about Constantine?
where is his single? And last but definitely not least.. Why aren’t they plugging Elliotts cd? It is a great cd and no word from Idol.
Is it because Clive baby is threatened? Watch out Kat, Elliotts moving on up………

Carol | 3/30/2007, 10:03 pm EST

I did not watch the first season but just happened on Idol for season two. I have been hooked ever since. . .so far Clay Aiken has earned my respect and I am a devoted follower. His voice is so pure and strong. He is witty, smart, caring, generous and continues to grow into amazing human being. Take a few minutes and just listen to him sing. . .

Michael | 3/30/2007, 9:46 pm EST

Clay Aiken is the most incredible LIVE performer - both in vocal artistry and comedic timing… I wish Idol would die a slow death - it’s taking over the country… Yuck… IT’s all about payola on radio who makes it big… It SUCKS…

Patti | 3/30/2007, 9:31 pm EST

Bo Bice is my favorite! He’s dropped the RCA label and is making his second album with Nashville producer Frank Liddell. He’s on tour now and his new songs are fabulous!
check out BoBice.com

Tanja | 3/30/2007, 9:29 pm EST

Bo Bice is the best Idol “runnerup” ever. If he could have put out “his” kind of music he would have done great. I have seen Bo in concert 5 times and every time was better than the last. I can’t wait for his new cd to be released. It will blow others out of the water. I can’t wait to see RCA face when he sells millions. Rock on BO!!!

Rick | 3/30/2007, 7:23 pm EST

I’m not ashamed to say that I’ve watched every season of “Idol” and enjoyed every minute of it. I’ve seen quite a few kids who stand out with stellar vocals and stage presence (Tamyra, Kelly, Jennifer, LaToya, Diana, Bice, Yamin, Melinda, LaKisha). I’ve also seen many kids with good to great voices who needed experience connecting with an audience (Helton, Kimberley, Gracin, Carrie, Katharine, Sligh, Stacey, Jordin). There are some whose vocals are made more interesting by their entertainment skills (Guarini, Trenyce, Barrino, Maroulis, Daughtry, Hicks, Lewis). And then there are those who don’t belong on that stage and are put there by the producers and judges to give the TV show some dramatic flavor and quirky color (no need to embarrass them further by naming them here when we all know who they are). Then the AI bigwigs complain when some segment of the audience “adopts” the underdogs and votes them back week after week. You can’t have it both ways, 19Entertainment!

Through all seasons of the show, there is only one person who knocked me out from Day One with the utter unique sound, pure tone and confident power of a world-class vocalist. That was Clay Aiken. When the competition got into full swing, I was pleased to see that his professional performance style and charisma was as big as his voice. I have never seen anyone before or after him on that show who possessed such one-of-a-kind star quality. If RCA can ever figure out what the heck to do with him in this by-the-numbers and copy-cat radio atmosphere that is today’s sad music industry, his potential will become glaringly obvious to any naysayer. He already has a lot of music legends in his corner. And just in my city, the whole Italian-American veterans club is behind him - lol! Today’s modern equivalent of Frank Sinatra is just waiting for a smart producer and label to snatch him away from the unimaginative RCA/Davis retro covers machine - hopefully Aiken can make the move soon. LOVER ALL ALONE, the Aiken-penned masterpiece buried on iTunes as a bonus track when you purchase his latest album, is an exciting hint of things to come.

MARITIZA | 3/30/2007, 6:10 pm EST

Yep, obviously the public prefers DAUGHTRY music than Taylor’s for he is indeed out selling Taylor 3:1.

It is simply AMAZING how long the DAUGHTRY CD has remained steady on the charts and he has only released one single to radio at this time (”Home” is officially released to radio April 10th.).

I wouldn’t be surprised if Chris Daughtry gets a Grammy Award for best new artist of the year!

Anonymous | 3/30/2007, 5:58 pm EST

My favorite is Bo Bice.

dlt | 3/30/2007, 5:51 pm EST

Willam Butler Yeats said,
“The best lack all conviction,
While the worst burn w/ a passionate intensity,” if my memory serves me correctly

IZZY | 3/30/2007, 5:33 pm EST

HELLO, I’M REALLY TIRED OF HEARING THAT TAYLOR OUTSELLS DAUGHTRY AT HIS LIVE PERFORMANCES BUT DAUGHTRY’S CD HAS OUTSOLD TAYLORS. THE ANSWER IS OUTLANDISHLY SIMPLE!!! TAYLOR HICKS IS NOT THE WORLDS BEST SINGER (BY HIS OWN ADMISSION) AND HIS MUSICAL GENRA IS NOT REALLY RELEVANT TO THE MUSIC THAT IS POPULAR & MOSTLY PURCHASED ($$$$$) TODAY BUT HE IS VERY ENTERTAINING TO WATCH. ERGO, MANY PEOPLE WILL NOT PAY A DIME FOR HIS C/D BUT CERTAINLY WILL PAY & DO ENJOY VIEWING HIM IN CONCERT. DAUGHTRY, ON THE OTHER HAND IS A VERY GOOD SINGER, HIS MUSIC IS,LIKE IT OR NOT, WHAT IS HOT & HAPPENING TODAY ($$$$) AND HE IS TOURING THE COUNTRY PLAYING VERY SMALL ROCK VENUES (200 TO 800). YOU CAN’T COMPARE THE TWO PERFORMERS, WHAT IS REALLY A SHAME IS THAT PEOPLE PIT THEM AGAINST EACH OTHER WHEN IN FACT THEY ARE FRIENDS & QUITE ASHAMED OF THEIR FANS RIPPING THE OTHER APART. FOR WHAT? LISTEN, GO SEE, BUY WHOEVER YOU WANT. IT DOESN’T MATTER. GET A LIFE, WORRY ABOUT THE STATE OF THE WORLD. DO SOMETHING TO MAKE THIS A BETTER PLACE FOR YOURSELF & YOUR CHILDREN.

dlt | 3/30/2007, 5:10 pm EST

I Like Karaoke

Singing Sinatra And Nat King Cole songs,
The Outsiders’ Time Won’t Let Me

Jacob | 3/30/2007, 4:57 pm EST

yeah, chris can pretty much sing his ass off….but man….what a LAME middle of the road, nickelback style album he put out. Hopefully his next album will push the limits and bring something new…..but that’s doubtful. i don’t think he has much vision or talent beyond the great voice.

Connie | 3/30/2007, 4:57 pm EST

Bo Bice was one of the most talented people to ever grace the AI stage. He had stage presence and could work the audience. He had great vocals EVERY time. He is nice to look at. I wish his music could touch the hearts of everyone. He is a special soul.

Swingline Stapler | 3/30/2007, 4:16 pm EST

Not a fan of the show, but here’s a question. How can you promote any of these people beyond maybe one or two lucky singles that might sell some records?
I understand the show as a phenomenon, but the reality is that this isn’t like picking a real musician to build a career around, more like making sure you can move some units of their album before people forget about them.
It’s the same reality with flavor of the month artists who catch a break with a memorable tune, only difference being the American Idol machine seems to speed up the process because there’s always a new season with new faces waiting in the wings.

JB | 3/30/2007, 2:46 pm EST

Diana DeGarmo sucks so much ass.

Susy | 3/30/2007, 2:21 pm EST

Blair when you posted those ticket sales, did you take into account size of venues or prices of tickets?

Hippie Chick | 3/30/2007, 2:01 pm EST

American Idol went down the drain as soon as Season 4 ended. Without Bo Bice the show isn’t worth watching. Boring! Never did anyone on there grab and keep my attention like Bo. I still follow him now and will forever!

ME | 3/30/2007, 1:55 pm EST

FUCK American Idol.

JE | 3/30/2007, 1:15 pm EST

After reading all of the commits people have made thus far it has become very obvious that the real problem with the Americn Idol debate is not with the artist or the show. It is with the different taste in MUSIC each and everyone of us on this planet have.
While there has been some good points made about
promotion,expossure and management of the artist it still comes down to talent.Talent is easily critisized by those who have none.But you have to give props to all those artist willing to give it a shot.
How much garbage is being played on the radio everyday by those who never set foot on the American Idol stage?
Whether it be rock,pop,country or whatever,let the artist be the artist,let the critic’s critisize and let the public decide what they like or don’t like.At the end of the day those who find a way to succeed will and those who do not will fail regaurdless of what anyone think’s or say’s.
Even if by some miracle Sanjaya was to win American Idol the kid has gut’s.Give him his props.He’s earned atleast that.

ELY | 3/30/2007, 12:50 pm EST

Probably my favorite loser is Trinece. (sp) I forget which season she was on but I thought that she was very talented and classy.
As for this season my favorite loser so far is Chris Sligh. And if Sanjaya does not go home soon I’m going to scream. America, be careful who you vote for here. A guy like Sanjaya will get chewed up and spit out by the music industry. If you really care about him, stop voting for him!!

Mario Kart | 3/30/2007, 12:07 pm EST

Does it really matter anymore??
Doolittle will already, deservedly so, have the greater career of them all- ever since she started I’ve pictured her singing the national anthem at a SuperBowl… If she came 5th & Sanjaya “won”, would it really make that much a difference??
Not in my eye anyways- nor probably in the eyes of the recording labels & word of mouth.

Lisa | 3/30/2007, 11:58 am EST

What the hell? Are you removing the posts with Youtube links on purpose?

I guess Rolling Stone does not want people to know what Clay Aiken really sounds like, because then it’ll become obvious that they never listened to his album before “reviewing” it.

Morgan | 3/30/2007, 11:32 am EST

I was totally joking

Morgan | 3/30/2007, 11:31 am EST

Bucky Covington Rules!

CLAY RS | 3/30/2007, 11:27 am EST

JENNIFER HUDSON! I loved her the moment i saw her on the show. it sucked she lost, but then again maybe it didnt. Do you see any of the winners (cough)fantasia barrino(cough) holding a golden golbe and an academy award?? think about it people.

buzzard | 3/30/2007, 11:26 am EST

some luv for william hung, the guy keeps putting out the hits one after one…simply classic

pat | 3/30/2007, 11:11 am EST

Clay Aiken definitly. He has personality, charms and can sell a boatloads of c.ds and conerts. Hewill be the one with more longetivity.

smc | 3/30/2007, 10:56 am EST

CLAY AIKEN!!
Game over, idol found!
He is the true measure of a man and so there is no need to watch that show anymore. It is just a joke now.

Carloner | 3/30/2007, 10:33 am EST

Katharine Mcphee is the real deal!

Jennifer | 3/30/2007, 10:22 am EST

I was always consider BO BICE as my idol! And I will always love and support him and his music!

www.bobice.com-OF FICIA L WEBSITE

Check out my fansites

www.myspace.com /bice girl75
www.myspace.com/bobicef anbase

420ishanitit? | 3/30/2007, 9:56 am EST

I like Will Hung, he make me sooo horny! he love me long time!! ok

420ishanitit? | 3/30/2007, 9:50 am EST

geauxrock is a douche

E | 3/30/2007, 9:49 am EST

Diana does NOT have a dwindling career. Please, cut her some slack, for all the opportunity the poor girl was given, she made the most out of it, HERSELF. She made name for herself on Broadway and I highly doubt people like Carrie, Kelly can sing like her and make it on Broadway, I have immense respect for KC and CU, but they’re probably not the material that can sell everywhere.
AI, put Diana in the background when they saw her as a threat to the Diva Trio, then they made it seem like she was just undeservingly in the finale. Then Mr.Clive stepped in with no promotion, cancelling a music video and then releasing a stupid music video to the internet only. What kind of promotion is that? Diana was NOT promoted. All she got was a few spins on Radio Disney which got her a special on the Disney Channel. How many gown-up watch that channel?? And at Sue, it didn’t air after Tina Turner’s special, just to correct you.
Diana has made a name for herself and after all the crap AI and RCA gave her she has made a career for herself to proud of. She’ll probably be around 10 years from now and will make a better artist than anyone on AI because she has potential. Plus this girl is just 19, when Kelly was 19 she was waitress and Carrie went to college and well it goes on…
I think Diana took the best initiative when she left RCA and showed them whose boss, since then she’s taken control over her career and its been helping her. I just hope and pray that a day comes, which I’m sure will come but I hope it comes with a bang and all of Diana’s haters/bashers end up kicking themselves, ‘cuz if you haven’t heard this girl sing, she can blow out notes which most of AI alums can’t even dream about singing. IMHO she’ll be the next Christina Aguilera or Mariah Carey.
That’s all.

420ishanitit? | 3/30/2007, 9:42 am EST

Josh talks too much!

FRAN | 3/30/2007, 9:41 am EST

CLAY,CLAY,CLAY…What more can I say. After seeing him 7 times in concert I can’t wait for more. He
just amazes me with his talent and sincerity.

DJB | 3/30/2007, 9:38 am EST

You all need to take a deep breath. Ms. Novak was simply pointing out the fact that just because you win AI you don’t necessarily have a golden ticket to a long, prosperous career. If you’re really this worked up about a show determined by TEXT MESSAGING you should focus your frustration and use it for something positive instead of nit picking the words of someone who obviously knows more about music in general than you ever will.

420ishanitit? | 3/30/2007, 9:34 am EST

my fav was Ryan Starr…she was in the lingere bowl, looking good! or as Paula would say pretty girl though!

Tytti | 3/30/2007, 9:16 am EST

Well, I’m sure that if either Sanjaya or Haley wins, he/she will never sell like a million copies. They’re so bad and forgettable.

moira | 3/30/2007, 9:01 am EST

Amy ,you should do some research before you print conclusions.Don’t forget a number one album or big seller today is not achieved by quality it is by promotion money.Diana sold only 160,000 cd’s no thanks to RCA for providing absolutely no promotion, providing an album that at least 7 songs were 3rd rate and Simon bashing her at every turn even after Idol.Diana negotiated out of her contract in june 2005.She did not want to be out of the competition to be left on the shelf any longer controlled by people who had no interest in her. Since then she has promoted herself and has toured the country doing concert in 2005. In nov 2005 she starred as Maria in West Side Story at the AMTSJ to great reviews.On Feb 2006 she got to be featured as Penny in Hairspray on Broadway to rave reviews. In May 2006 she starred as Brooklyn in the National tour of Brooklyn the Musical again to rave reviews, she then rejoined Hairspray till Feb 2007. She is now devoting herself fulltime to her sophomore CD. She is also an accomplished talk show co-host and guest. You can see her performing April 29 at Carnegie Hall with the New York Pops Ochestra. Dwindling career huh. Diana is America’s Best Kept Secret.
Why? Because the media doesn’t do their homework.

Amanda | 3/30/2007, 8:59 am EST

Anyone who is voting for Sanjaya is just ruining it for everyone else and it is inconsiderate and rude. Not only are you ruining the show, but you are hurting him. If he wins he will end up selling like one CD…and he will be the one buying it.

Daughtry - King of Cliches | 3/30/2007, 8:42 am EST

I like that one song by Daughtry where he says he’s a ship lost at sea.

I like that other one where he’s a runaway train.

The best one, though, is the one where he’s a runaway train headed toward some sort of underwater train depot, on a collision course with a ship that was once lost at sea.

Amazing lyrics, dude. You’re incredibly deep.

SMB | 3/30/2007, 8:40 am EST

Thanks for a great article and for the well-deserved recognition that you gave Chris. Your description of Taylor is very apt as well. He seems like a nice enough guy and certainly has a modicum of talent, but, sadly, he’ll eventually be back to playing clubs for a modest devoted contingency of fans. Chris, on the other hand, is an incredible vocalist, musician, and artist. I’ve had the pleasure of attending one of his concerts, and, being older and having been to numerous rock concerts, it was one of the best I’ve experienced in a long time. He will be embarking on an overseas tour, starting in Australia in June and then later on in Japan. He also will be doing an arena tour later this fall. All in all, your article was very perceptive and well written. Keep up the good work!

Mojo | 3/30/2007, 8:31 am EST

Taylor may have been the winner..due to power voting and VFTW’s help, but the cream always rises to the top and that is Daughtry.

Dave | 3/30/2007, 8:11 am EST

American Idol is to music what professional wrestling is to sports.

rubyc | 3/30/2007, 2:58 am EST

I totally agree that the big story that ALL the media “experts” seem to miss is the woeful mismanagement of the idols after the show. I don’t think that AI or RCA have any clue about how to develop talent. They’re just bean counters. And that’s why BIG MUSIC is sinking like the Titanic and most of the radio stations just play oldies.

Linda | 3/30/2007, 2:37 am EST

I love Bo Bice…he’s my only AI.

Phil | 3/30/2007, 2:00 am EST

Sanjaya will be the idol by which all others are compared!! Vote Sanjaya!!

Blair | 3/30/2007, 1:53 am EST

I find these figures from Billboard via Pulse fascinating:

Taylor Hicks
March 9 sold $67,650 in tickets
March 18 sold $66,137 in tickets

Daughtry!!11!!
March 10 sold $29,200 in tickets
February 6 sold $14,000 in tickets

And yet we hear what a great touring success Daughtry!!11!! is. Go figure.

Jakers | 3/30/2007, 12:43 am EST

Inexplicable sex symbol, yea right. Clay’s a total BABE!!! and I’m seeing him on tour in July!!! WooHoo!!

lik roper | 3/30/2007, 12:20 am EST

it’s a long way to the top if you wanna rock n roll…

Sanjaya Fan | 3/30/2007, 12:05 am EST

I just started watching cause I heard about the Indian sensation, Sanjaya. Everyone here at the call center where I work, in Bangalore, puts the Dell customers on hold for the voting hour just to call in and get Sanjaya to the next round.

Skip | 3/30/2007, 12:03 am EST

Wow! Did Kellie Pickler really sold 600,000 CDs? There must be a typo in the Billboard chart since it reported that her total sales for week ending 3/31/07 was 471,134.

Joni | 3/30/2007, 12:03 am EST

My favorite is Clay Aiken, he is the total packgage. Clay’s concerts leave you wanting more, he has an unbelievable connection with the audience, he is a wonderful performer, he has quick wit and a voice like an angel. Just consider how well he is doing with no radio play, which I will never understand why. “A Thousand Different Ways” which is his latest CD is so beautiful even tho it has alot of covers on it thanks to Clive, but the original songs are wonderful. I also hope that some day everyone gets to hear the song “Lover All Alone” which Clay wrote the words and David Foster wrote the music, its a sin that this song was not on the album. Clive and RCA you should be ashamed of the promotion Clay received for this beautiful Cd.

AIsux | 3/30/2007, 12:01 am EST

I hate the AI machine and RCA and the way they pit all the contestants fan bases against each other. Can you imagine the power if the fan bases would quit fighting and join forces to demand equal promotion.
We know that’s not going to happen but it does seem unfair that some of the talent coming off the show gets a free ride while others are treated like crap by radio and media. Spin, spin and I agree, old fart Clive Davis doesn’t have a clue what to do with real talent.

Sue | 3/29/2007, 11:44 pm EST

“Sue, I was comparing Fantasia the winner to Diana the runner up. Fantasia got radio play right? That to me is promotion. Diana got squat for radio play. I have nothing against Fantasia at all. All I am trying to say is that some of the Idols were left to hang out to dry. Fantasia was not one of them. She got lots of kudos from the AI machine, Clive himself and great reviews.”

Josh now I know you’re not saying that Critics reviews are promotion, as if they are, EVERYONE gets those, however, fantasia’s just were EXCELLENT, diana’s were very poor. Diana did have a single released to radio and it simply didn’t catch on, Fantasia’s did. However, radio play isn’t promotion, it is the BASIC that every artist gets, you still need to push the artists’ material. Diana’s album wasn’t nearly as good as fantasia’s and thus didn’t deserve they same promotion. However, diana received a month long cable special for her album which ran back to back with tina turner, that is the type of A plus promotion that I can only dream that one day fantasia receives for an album.

I just hate how you people who clearly know nothing about the reviews of albums, and quality of them and say that “such and such deserves the same promotion when the material that they put out based on reviews shouldn’t even be on the shelf to begin with.

Josh | 3/29/2007, 11:11 pm EST

Sue, I was comparing Fantasia the winner to Diana the runner up. Fantasia got radio play right? That to me is promotion. Diana got squat for radio play. I have nothing against Fantasia at all. All I am trying to say is that some of the Idols were left to hang out to dry. Fantasia was not one of them. She got lots of kudos from the AI machine, Clive himself and great reviews. She is not my type of song stylist, but music is subjective. I want them all to be successful. I am not a hater whatever that means. If the labels put out an album, I don’t understand why some supposedly deserve radio play and some don’t. Do the labels not know how to market to radio? Do they choose to sell who they want to radio. Can they not afford to support all artists equally? Why not have a level playing field instead of having a handful of artists pushed down our throats every 2 hours. And I’m not just talking about AI folks here. What about Indie artists who are mega talented? Radio is so repetitious with their call out and formats, it isn’t fun anymore.
Believe me, I am an equal opportunity fan and want them all to do well.

Lojak78 | 3/29/2007, 11:10 pm EST

Ill answer that question klaatu…the feeble minded souless bastards in this country…people dont realize that twenty years down the road…or even ten for that matter…no one is gonna care about these bums…

Irishgal | 3/29/2007, 10:58 pm EST

I agree with just about everything said regarding the promotion or lack there of for any of the artists once their first CD has dropped off the charts. It’s really a “short term memory game” for the big boys upstairs playin’ wid’da numbers! That’s all it is to them and you can bet they have absolutely no real long term emotional investment or commitment beyond thier initial contract. The big boys believe they will have enough talent (and I use this term loosely) in their stable to afford losing or writing a few of the past idols. That said, I would just like to say that if Clay Aiken doesn’t do something unique like move on and start his own label or show or something I fear we may lose the BEST THING to ever come out of that show. And what a sad lose that would be!!

Dave | 3/29/2007, 10:45 pm EST

In response to Kat: Unfortunately or fortunately the music industry is quantitative versus qualitative. This pertains to objective judgements on “doing well”. Therefore units sold is the only true measure of “success”. Artistic success is something else and is subjective.

Kat | 3/29/2007, 10:35 pm EST

I just never understand the point of articles like this. Are Taylor and Katharine fans supposed to read this article, realize that their favorites aren’t selling like hotcakes, come to a realization that their personal preferences are obviously wrong, and go worship at the altar of Daughtry? Daughtry has sold a lot and that’s great, but album sales don’t prove or disprove talent. McPhee is not one of my personal favorites, and I think her albums sales prove that the buying public hasn’t quite connected to her yet, but I can’t deny that she is quite talented. The same goes for Taylor, my personal favorite. Love the guy and his music, and the minute he won, I knew that Arista would have him spit out a poppish, assembly-line CD that I’d quickly forget. So what if he’s only sold under 700K copies, or Katharine’s sold under 300K? That doesn’t eliminate the fact that thousands of their fans enjoyed their weekly Idol performances and are actively following their careers and awaiting their new music. Maybe next time, we can get an article about their actual CDs, instead of an article that treats units sold as a reflection of something more than it really is.

semi wood | 3/29/2007, 10:01 pm EST

Soul Asylum…best ever runner-up, no doubt!

Sue | 3/29/2007, 9:49 pm EST

“They put all of their eggs into Fantasia who has done a fair job, but not phenomenal.”

No they didn’t, Fantasia NEVER has had great promotion for ANY album. After fantasia won all I heard is “What happened to Fantasia”. Now I ask you, if all the eggs were poured into her wouldn’t the world know where she was?

Anonymous | 3/29/2007, 9:49 pm EST

Let’s not forget ELLIOT YAMIM. He signed with an independent label and has done quite well (3rd on Billboard for his first album) Although Elliot doesn’t have the charisma or soaring vocal skills of CLAY AIKEN, he should be taken seriously! That said, I’m impressed with Elliot who is my 2nd favorite “loser.”

Josh | 3/29/2007, 9:43 pm EST

How could I forget Jennifer Hudson, my favorite from Season 3. When she sang EJ’s circle of life, I thought she had it wrapped up. Again, the public is manipulated by Cowell because she didn’t have the look. I saw her in Dream Girls, and the girl is fantastic. I hope to hell Clive doesn’t screw up her album.

kylaa | 3/29/2007, 9:40 pm EST

Daughtry = The Monkees for a whole new generation.

Sue | 3/29/2007, 9:36 pm EST

Whomever said fantasia received major promotion is nothing but a hater. Fantasia received RAVE and I MEAN RAVE reviews for her lates CD fantasia yet they (IDOL) only shipped 400K TOTAL, if that’s a sign of big promotion then you are an idiot.

Furthermore, the only time that bucks have been poured into fantasia being promotion came by the way of Lifetime TV for her movie which that promotion did pay off bringing in 19 MILLION viewers the most viewers that lifetime had seen in on ten years and the second most watch movie in lifetimes 23 year history.

The second time when promotion was great for fantasia came when she landed the leading role in “The color Purple”. Just today an article came out and her new nickname is “The SIX million dollar woman”, in only four weeks, that’s how many tickets she’s sold in advance of her april 10 debut. She now joins Denzel Washington, Julia Roberts and Billy Chrystal as broadway stars who brought in MEGA bucks.

Anonymous | 3/29/2007, 9:20 pm EST

I agree with you on almost all counts, Josh. The three most heavily promoted and most successful AI came from different seasons and they were the closest to carbon copies of what the music scene already had out there. It’s a shame that talented and unique individuals that America liked and voted for cannot get heard or given the right material to show off their talents because AI can only afford to promote 1 person per season. I do think that Clay Aiken has serious talent and potential, but where has he been lately? And I’m pleasantly surprised by Kellie Pickler. I thought she was mediocre on season 6 but her cd is fantastic for those who like ‘real’ country pop music. She even covers Aimee Mann…how about that! I thought Jennifer Hudson had far more talent than Fantasia and couldn’t understand the major lip service Fantasia was given on season 3. She has a unique sound too, but AI poured far too many dollars into her promotion and quite frankly, it hasn’t paid off. Maybe that’s why they are too hesitant to back up any other idols who aren’t a ’sure thing’ like Kelly, Carrie and Chris (fake band and all!). It’s too bad, because if Katharine McPhee, Kellie Pickler or Clay Aiken got anywhere near the promotion (ie, paid to be played on the radio to the tune of ‘make me number 1′) those 3 got they probably could be more successful too. Given the right combo of material and promotion, these three have the charisma and talent to be every bit as successful if not more so than ‘the other three.’

Travis | 3/29/2007, 9:20 pm EST

The Taylor Hicks album is actually pretty good , as stuff like that goes. His live shows have received rave reviews as well. The Daughtry album is more Nickleback-tastic dreck.

GeauxRock | 3/29/2007, 8:58 pm EST

Josh…………
I understand some of what you’re saying…. but before or anyone starts posting about record labels,artist,etc. Please get your facts straight! Chris Daughtry picked his bandmates himself, they weren’t just handed nor chosen by the label or anyone else. Chris interviewed each and everyone of those guys before reaching his decision!! Taylor Hicks wrote and co-wrote a large number of songs on his first Album. The problem with Taylor is that being solo isn’t his “cup of tea”, another problem He has is that His voice range doesn’t go more than 4 notes! He’s a great guy but just doesn’t have that range the majority of artist do! I have known Taylor for 6yrs and have talked with Him many times. Taylor is going back to his “roots” and is gonna sing songs that fit his range and style. He was in a band that sang 3-4 times a week in & around the B-ham area & was pretty successful even though they performed in very small venues! Finally, it’s each & everyone of the Idol contestants choice whether or not to sign with RCA or someone else! Several of the names you’ve mentioned have recieved offers from other labels or bands looking for an Artist or lead singer.
Also, I’m not posting this to discredit you…….. it’s just the facts from someone who knows them.

Rock On & Peace out,
JLS

Ted | 3/29/2007, 8:51 pm EST

Daughtry is such a Douche, especially for acting like Idol held him back when it actually allowed him to connect with millions of other douches.

robert | 3/29/2007, 8:49 pm EST

Daughtry and his bald rock boys will soon be nothing but an irritating bleep in bubblegum rock history. McPhee will sell her soul to Broadway and mid-priced cosmetic companies, and Hicks will perform to sold-out crowds in small to mid sized venues for the next 20 years before retiring to a ranch in Montana where he will design his own line of men’s clothing and salad dressings. Every 10 years he will release a new recording which will never quite make it to the Billboard top 10.

Terry | 3/29/2007, 8:36 pm EST

I can not wait to hear what everyone says when Taylor Hicks is the news…right now the attention is on Daughtry..and that is not by accident….

Sparty | 3/29/2007, 8:19 pm EST

American Idol is dumber than this article.

debbie | 3/29/2007, 8:14 pm EST

I like how Josh (see above) found something nice to say about every single idol except for chris. The jealousy has gotten out of control. I’ve also heard fans of other AI5 idols saying that daughtry’s CD sales are made up. As in favricated out of thin air. Honestly, chill. Chris and Carrie and Kelly C are the best so they are the most successful. That’s it.

Jack | 3/29/2007, 7:58 pm EST

Hey, is this site messing up the links on purpose? Anyway, remove all the spaces to watch Youtube videos I posted.

Matt | 3/29/2007, 7:53 pm EST

how you can write an article like this, and not mention that carrie underwood won the show and is also the biggest hit yet? i wish i could get paid to write bad articles.

Trina | 3/29/2007, 7:50 pm EST

Two words: Idol. Mouthpiece. Did they supply you with the talking points so you could pimp the contestants they like and put down the ones they don’t?

Josh | 3/29/2007, 7:48 pm EST

These contestants on Idol are saddled with “The Idol Machine” and an older than dirt Clive Davis to guide them.
When will America wake up and notice that who they vote for isn’t necessarily who will sell the most albums or be the most successful?
That is determined by Clive Davis and his archaic team at RCA records.
They decide who will be successful and who will not.
1.)Justin got a raw deal. He wasn’t allowed to put his album out until the same day that Clay and Ruben singles came out. Where is the fairness in that? He was not promoted to be successful.
2.) Diana was not promoted either. She has been very successful on Broadway, and if she finds a label that will support her, she will be fine.
They put all of their eggs into Fantasia who has done a fair job, but not phenomenal.
4.) Bo Bice had a lot of health problems, but was also made to put out a CD that castrated him. Where was the southern rock that the people loved about him?
5.) Carrie has been extremely successful with her Nashville arm of RCA. They did it right. The right music, promotion for the right singer.
6.) Kelly had a pop light AI first album. Was going nowhere. But because of the right music and promotion her second album was successful.
7.) Taylor’s album was not Taylor. It was Clive Davis MOR crap because he doesn’t know what to do with anyone who is different and doesn’t fit into the neat little radio friendly gag worthy music of today. The guy is out touring and bringing in great reviews.
8.) Daughtry is the funniest thing I have ever witnessed as far as record label manipulation. Does anyone even realize the band on the album is not HIS band? These guys were pulled into the studio to record with “DAUGHTRY” to give him cred as a band. The band he tours with is not the same. Wake up people. The guy can be reproduced and is a dime a dozen. He is nothing but a rip off of Nickelback. But, the label can pull the wool over the publics eyes, because they know how to polish him up, tell him what to say, produce the flavor of the day album and there you have it.
9.) Ruben Studdard has a phenomenal voice. What has good ole RCA done for him…not much of anything as far as I can tell.
And he was a winner.
10.) Then you have Clay Aiken who also has a phenomenal voice and is the best entertainer to come off of that show. What does RCA do with him? Give him some tired covers, no radio play, no video and poor promotion.
11.)Katherine McPhee was my favorite. She has gotten a ton of promotion, the sales aren’t that great, but I really think she has her eye on movies, modeling etc.
12.) Kellie Pickler is unique, has the IT factor. She may not be the best singer in the world, but is a hell of an entertainer.
I wish these guys wether they win or not could be courted by any label that wants them. It’s pretty much a conflict of interest to have all of the Idol singers at one label. It looks to me like the label only has the funds to promote one a year the way that they need to be promoted to be successful. If the singers are anything outside of the box that they are pushed into, the label has no clue what to do with them. It’s a shame that so much talent goes unheard.

Ann | 3/29/2007, 7:48 pm EST

Clay Aiken is my favorite male singer and male entertainer. I love Clay Aiken! Clay Aiken Rocks!!! Clay Aiken Rules!!!

Teri | 3/29/2007, 7:28 pm EST

Try to imagine Kelly, Carrie & Daughtry releasing their CDs with NO VIDEOS, NO SINGLE PUSHED TO RADIO & practically non-existant pre-promotion of any kind. Would they have faired any better than Taylor, Justin Or Diana’s debuts or the Clive Davis mandated cover album that Clay got stuck with?

It’s all marketing, people. Those whom Sony/BMG deem worthy are given the megabucks push & the others are left to get by without much label support. That said, a Gold album is nothing to sneeze at - most Rolling Stone darlings would kill for a career of Golds. And some of the Idol kids have made a great name for themselves without Top 40 radio & huge sales. Ruben & Fantasia are doing fine in the R&B field. Diana is becoming a Broadway veteran. Taylor is selling far more seats on his tour than Daughtry, just as Clay has made more money touring than even Kelly. Josh Gracin has had 2 Gold country albums & 2 #1 country hits. Kimberley Locke has become a staple of AC radio with 3 #1 hits there. The Top 40 genre is NOT the be-all & end-all of a career in music, thank God.

G | 3/29/2007, 7:28 pm EST

ITS NOT OVVVAAAAA

gotsoul | 3/29/2007, 7:27 pm EST

Small Town Girl has not sold 600,000 copies, in fact, it hasn’t even sold 500,000, which Taylor did in his first two weeks. How long has STG been out for? Nearly half a year. Get your facts straight, Novak, before you piss away the little credibility that you have.

rachel | 3/29/2007, 7:20 pm EST

you didnt even mention carrie underwood,
and look how well shes done.
well carrie and chris are my favorites from the show so far.
thumbs up to them.

Bluesfan | 3/29/2007, 7:17 pm EST

Btw why is rolling stone so Anti Gun for?

Bluesfan | 3/29/2007, 7:17 pm EST

katharines music might have not sold like Chris, or Taylor, but shes far more popular overall than any of the other idols. katharine is beautiful like prettiest girl in the world, is very kind, and very likeable personality that warms anyones heart!

Taylor you dont even hear about anymore.

Bubblicious | 3/29/2007, 7:11 pm EST

GO BE BALD SOMEWHERE ELSE

Cheshcat | 3/29/2007, 7:09 pm EST

“and Diana DeGarmo (Season Three) have watched their middling post-Idol careers dwindle”

Amy, I’m getting pretty sick and tired of media people measuring a successful career on the number of CD’s sold. First of all RCA did nothing to promote Diana’s post AI CD causing less than expected sales. Second of all Diana had a very successful run in “West Side Story” and stared on Broadway in” Hairspray” to rave reviews. Diana also received rave reviews for the title role in “Brooklyn – The Musical” which toured last summer. Please do some research before your post such remarks as “have watched their middling post-Idol careers dwindle”

Deb | 3/29/2007, 7:08 pm EST

My favorite and the most consistent “loser” is definitely Clay. The guy is a phenomenal entertainer, has a wicked sense of comedic timing and, of course, a great voice. He’ll be around for a long time.

JF | 3/29/2007, 6:58 pm EST

None. Never watched a show. The competition is ridiculous, the voting questionable and like Chris Rock pointed: Paula Abdul judging singers? How it manages to keep such high TV ratings is puzzling. And to make things worse, I am from Quebec, Canada, and so we have our own Canadian Idol and Star Académie that is just in Quebec. Damn you Simon Cowell! Damn you!

Klaatu | 3/29/2007, 6:54 pm EST

Who cares about American Idol?

Subscribe to Rolling Stone Rock & Roll Blog feed

See all available RSS feeds / learn more

You Win Some, You Lose Some: The American Idol Sweet Spot

Comments

Post A Comment

Most Popular

Top Posts

Put RS.com On Your Website

Blog Archives

Get Our Headlines

RS Updates

Get Rollingstone.com on your mobile phone

You Win Some, You Lose Some: The American Idol Sweet Spot

Comments

Post A Comment

Most Popular

Top Posts

Put RS.com On Your Website

Blog Archives

Get Our Headlines

RS Updates

Subscribe!

Get Rollingstone.com on your mobile phone