Previous Next Latest

Hanson: A Fangirl’s Not-So-Dirty Little Secret

3/9/07, 3:32 pm EST

My unabashed love for late-Nineties band Hanson is an obsession I’ve been defending for a decade. I admit, I was hooked the first time I heard the infectious strains of that 1997 radio hit “MMMBop.”  Nowadays, let’s face it: if the general public thinks of them at all, they still see the Tulsa-born trio as the girly-haired bubblegum moppets they were back then. But as was in evidence at a gig in New York this past week, I am not the only one still loyal to the band of brothers.

After almost ten years as a well-known band, Hanson siblings Isaac, Taylor and Zac have achieved a rather spectacular feat. It’s not marriage (though all three brothers have wed). It’s not kids (though middle brother Taylor has three babies of his own). It’s not new music (though they have a new album — their third original release since their debut, Middle of Nowhere — coming out in May). It’s the fans. Hanson’s mainstream popularity may have peaked along with Lou Pearlman-bred groups *NSYNC and Backstreet Boys in the boy band craze of the late Nineties (thanks largely to the radio success of “MMMBop”). But unlike the prefab pop outfits, they retain a loyal and rabid core group of fans whose devotion has only grown despite flagging presence in the public eye.

As my fellow Hansonites and I hit our late teens and early twenties, going to Hanson concerts has made us into a new version of the Deadheads. We spend long hours in the car traveling to show after show and spend even more time in line to secure a front-row spot. Having learned its lesson from the huge crowds of fans who camped out in the parking lot of New Jersey’s Starland Ballroom before a 2004 Hanson concert, the venue posted a notice on its website before the show last week, firmly reminding fans that no one would be allowed to congregate earlier than 1 P.M. the day of the show. There were other stories of fans camping out for more than two days before last Friday’s Connecticut show, and for almost as long before Tuesday’s New York show — the last in a string of preview dates Hanson played to premiere new music from their forthcoming album The Walk. This borderline-crazy devotion is nothing new to us Hanson acolytes, but it certainly shocks everyone outside our bubble who thought Hanson died out when they hit puberty.

It’s hard to quantify Hanson’s skill and musical prowess empirically — that is, after all, a matter of opinion. But there’s no question these guys have integrity at the very least: After parting ways with their label Island/Def Jam over creative differences upon the release of 2004’s Underneath, the Hanson brothers formed their own indie label, 3CG Records. In 2005, they put out a documentary called Strong Enough to Break about the experience of releasing music independently, and even toured colleges to lecture about the music industry. They later released the whole thing as a series of podcasts on iTunes. In preparation for the upcoming release of The Walk, Hanson has started another podcast series to give the public a behind-the-scenes look at the making of the album.

The band also has support from perhaps the most critical group of music fans around: fellow musicians. Among Hanson’s most vocal supporters are Third Eye Blind’s Stephen Jenkins and the zany “Party Til You Puke” master Andrew W.K., who made a guest appearance on piano at last Tuesday night’s performance at the Supper Club in New York City.

Tuesday’s show was a celebration of many things – it was a reunion for me and the friends I’ve known for ten years and, as Taylor said, pointing to the crowd before the group launched into “MMMBop” (yes, they still play it proudly), “This is a 10th anniversary not for the band, but for us.”


Previous Next Latest

Comments

disbelief | 3/9/2007, 4:04 pm EST

remember that girl who blew everyone in iron butterfly?

Klaatu | 3/9/2007, 4:19 pm EST

I think Erica needs to learn the difference between the words “quantify” and “qualify.” One cannot “empirically qualify” something. Now, as to the substance of her post; nothing is more rock and roll than kids writing, playing, and singing their own simple songs in a garage band. So, we should give the Hanson guys some respect. I hope they keep at it until they hit the right combination of ingredients to put them back on top.

Dan | 3/9/2007, 5:13 pm EST

I don’t particularly care for Hanon’s music, but for some reason I’ve always liked that they’ve stuck at it despite the somewhat popular perception that they are nothing more than a one hit fad band.

The Grubby 1 | 3/9/2007, 5:22 pm EST

There’s gotta be some law against comparing Hanson to the Greatful Dead in any way…

Bel | 3/9/2007, 5:37 pm EST

Thats a great article and Hanson are some of the best performers and artists of the modern era. Its just sad that most folk wont accept the fact that MMMbop was 10 years ago and the guys are completely credible and amazing musicians and always have been (considering they wrote all the songs on their debut album in 1997 when they were young teens). They arent corporate puppets! I urge everyone to buy their new album when it comes out because you will be completely amazed!

Tiger Beat!!! | 3/9/2007, 5:40 pm EST

Did I just read an article about Hanson?? I feel ill.

Troy | 3/9/2007, 6:15 pm EST

I’m in my 40s and can appreciate the powerpop the guys are making these days. To me, they’re the descendents of Matthew Sweet. Good for them.

Erin | 3/9/2007, 8:00 pm EST

I am also a proud Hanson fan. This is also my 10th year as a fan. And I cannot wait for the next album and will gladly drive several hours to a show this summer.

Gena | 3/9/2007, 10:54 pm EST

If there truly were a law against comparing Hanson to the Grateful Dead (as one poster suggested), Bob Weir would be in jail right now. Hanson have played with his band three different times, and he always has great things to say about them.

your mom | 3/10/2007, 7:36 am EST

look…. they’re were underrated from the other bands obviously, since they actually wrote their own stuff. But the Dead???

If their strongest endorsement comes from Stephan Jenkins, then there’s a problem!

brick | 3/10/2007, 9:45 am EST

Hanson…. its been a while, but they still got it. they write their own songs and they keep up at it. Thats why I believe Stephan Jenkins is endorsing them. 3EB is still around and they are still writing there own stuff.

BabaOreally? | 3/10/2007, 10:03 am EST

This is where it gets to be painful to have a clear view of reality.
Everything in the music business from U2 to Clay Aikens is powered by the money-greased PROMO MACHINE.
Hanson learned their lessons, and their fan-base consists of folks who have actually heard them play.
Several years ago, right after the release of “Underneath”, Hanson played our local historic State Theater.
I got tickets because my then 18-yr-old daughter and her friends were big fans during their “tweens”.
My friend JBoy and I sat in the balconey while KT and Reba went to the floor.
Well, kids, slap my ass and call me HIPPIE, but the show flat-out kicked ass.
We met up with the girls after the show and they were dripping with sweat. They said, “after a few minutes, we just got caught up in the excitement and we were screaming like Beatles fans in the 60’s”.
I don’t think you need to compare Hanson to anyone. They are who they are and for my ancient ass they even cranked out a killer version of “Gimme Some Lovin’”..(I am so glad I made it).
Like George said “Think for Yourself”.
Keep Rockin Hanson… and I’m sure there is some “HIP” band the rest of you know-it-all’s can groove to.

lik roper | 3/10/2007, 11:29 am EST

hanson could really play and sing and write songs for being the kids they were…

you know; i’ve seen languishing garage bands full of members in their 30s doing way worse than hansen ever did…

asongtosing | 3/10/2007, 1:57 pm EST

I am a long time Hanson fan myself and greatly enjoyed this article. They really DO have so much more to offer than many people realize, and I very much hope that they will eventually get some recognition for being who they are now as opposed to who they were back in 1997.

WHY?!? | 3/10/2007, 3:44 pm EST

Ugh. This is going to hurt me more that it will hurt you. It’s Hanson people. Here’s a nickel. Go buy some musical taste.

alyssa | 3/10/2007, 5:24 pm EST

i really admire this article, but a recent photo would’ve been nice..

qbert | 3/10/2007, 6:12 pm EST

And how much is a nickel in real money ?

JonWithnal | 3/10/2007, 6:41 pm EST

I think those fellows in Hanson should have gone to college and gotten an education and done something interesting with their lives rather than travel around the country in a bus playing umbop in 500 seat clubs. Sad, really.

Julie | 3/10/2007, 7:18 pm EST

Wow, this is a really great article. I used to be a huge Hanson fan during their teeniebopper days and I am always quick to defend them. Even now, I automatically feel my fandom returning. I will definitely have to check out their new music! Thanks!

bagsrt0t | 3/11/2007, 12:04 am EST

hey WHY???

you wouldn’t know taste if it bit your potato.

go put on “really cool stuff” and quit trying to impress your “self”.

Em | 3/11/2007, 3:59 am EST

Amazing musicians. I’ve been a fan for 10 years now, and I’m proud.

I’ve been reading all the other comments, and geez, why all this hate? I don’t get it. Fine if you don’t like their music, but at least give them some props. It’s not many people that have the courage to do all of the things Hanson has done.

And thank you for this article. It was great!

bag,SR.(tot) | 3/11/2007, 9:28 am EST

“With the entire history of recorded music available at the fingertips of any young musician, often stripped of context in an iTunes playlist, much of the cultural baggage of pop music disappears.” -from an article in the NewYorkTimes
I think this totally applies here. HANSON is bogged down in a lot of people’s perception with a cart-load of “Baggage”.
Ignore tham if you want. It truly is YOUR loss.

Great Musician | 3/12/2007, 12:54 am EST

Truth is… they’ve lasted this long… they must be doing something right! They are truly good-old fashioned music. I always envied my parents for living in the era of great music and listening to Hanson always me to get to that place– a place where real music originated with originality!!! So whether they’re performing for one or millions… the will always be faithful to their image and most important… original, unique, music…

Jess | 3/12/2007, 7:34 am EST

I along with many others have been a fan for the past 10 years. They’re more grown up now and their music has evolved with them, but they’re still the same band that I’ve loved since I was 14 yeard old. We, the fans, have essentially grown up with them, and if it’s possible, love them more now than we did back then. Thirty-eight shows later, I still love seeing them live. I feel most at home at Hanson shows. Rock on guys!!!

Lumpy | 3/12/2007, 7:57 am EST

That’s great that a musician writes his own music… but, I have one word for Hanson: INARTICULATE!!!! And don’t anyone try to tell me that they understand a word from their hit “MmmBop”, other than, umm, the word “mmmbop”.

Of course, one could justly argue with me, and say, sometimes being articulate backfires: for example, I was listening to the No.1 song here on the R.S. chart — to Nickelback’s “If Everyone Cared” — and the lyrics go, “from underneath the trees / we watch the sky / confusing stars / satellites”… umm, “CONFUSING STARS”????????? Nickelback, you got to be kidding me!!! How any fucking more disasterously untintelligent and anti-art and mentally/emotionally crippled and bleak can a band be????????

Nickelback, you make my lumps roll over. 5 million sold of that shitty record??? Well, to 5 million MORONS!

My point, obviously: just because someone writes their own stuff doesn’t make it good.

christina | 3/12/2007, 10:31 am EST

A lot of people who diss Hanson haven’t heard anything they’ve done since “Mmmmbop” and that’s completely unfair. They make great music ON THEIR OWN TERMS. Many other bands would have crumbled by now but after 10 years they’re still going strong. I hated “Mmmmbop” when it first came out and subsequently ignored Hanson for the next few years. But when I heard the solid pop musicianship of “Penny and Me” a few years ago I was forced to pay attention again. They are now one of my favorite bands and I don’t hesitate to tell people that I’m a fan.

Melanie | 3/12/2007, 12:49 pm EST

Well written article…the show in NYC was amazing. Hard to believe it’s been ten years…and I loved that quote from Taylor.

Nikki | 3/12/2007, 11:31 pm EST

If you don’t like Hanson, than don’t listen to them. But for the rest of use who know what type of music we like leave us alone, don’t make fun of something you don’t know. I admit I was an obsessed fan in the beginning. But listening to Hanson I learned to do what I want to. I write my own songs and got into local modeling. I still listen to Hanson, They DO have NEW music. And magazines raved about the music. If Hanson wasn’t so good how were they in the top 100 independent Billboard charts with their last release? And still hit the top 100 on the billboard charts?

Chelsea | 3/13/2007, 1:21 am EST

Erica,

You’re the best.

Love,
Chelsea

Fansons
1997-2007
NOT HING BUT LOVE

Nicole | 3/13/2007, 10:03 am EST

Erica-

I definitely think you did all of us fans and the band justice in this article. Hearing them recognize everything we’ve done for their career for 10 years really puts things into perspective. I think we should all be proud of Hanson, where they’ve gone, where they’ve taken us and for withstanding the criticism for so long. It takes real musicians to stay true, and I consider myself lucky to be a part of the craziness of the last decade.

P.S – I await my framed copy. Don’t think I forgot! ;)

harvey dudeman | 3/13/2007, 3:56 pm EST

i cant believe that this is on rollingstone.

Dayna | 3/14/2007, 9:39 am EST

Awesome article!

-DAYNA
http://www .hansonfans.net

ashleigh | 3/20/2007, 12:59 am EST

wow this article is great! It is exactly what I have been explaining to my roommates who think that I am crazy!
I try to explain to them the difference between Hanson fans and other fans…no one gets it. However, you nailed it!
nice writing ;o)

Imppu | 3/27/2007, 10:43 am EST

Listen. To all impassionate Hanson fans: will you please stop defending them on the basis of their making their own music(and worse, playing their own instruments). Yes, they do that, and it’s great, but that was remarkable only ten years ago, not anymore. They are grown-up musicians, so those factors don’t make them any better than the rest anymore. Do some Hanson fans have difficulty seeing that the music scene isn’t only about an opposition between Hanson and the manufactured puppets like Nelly Furtado, Avril Lavigne and Westlife? Hanson aren’t the only “real” band there, please keep that in mind. It’s right there along with my other favourites, such as Josh Rouse, Jeff Buckley, the Cure, Echo and the Bunnymen, Everything but the Girl, Idlewild etc. Luckily, though, those musicians are respected for their music, period. They don’t have to defend their ability to write songs. Why can’t we Hanson fans allow Hanson that same unconditional respect? So, it’s true what Lumpy said, the own stuff doesn’t make a band good. Nickelback is an excellent example. Good Charlotte, the Rasmus, Norah Jones and Evanescence are further examples. We don’t want to make them think they’re good music just because they make it themselves, do we? And for anti-Hanson people ridiculing these brothers: please get yourselves a sense of time. It’s been ten years since MMMBop, so what makes you think you know what this band sounds like today? People change, their views on life and their take on music change.Would you have written Cure-style anxiety tunes at twelve? Nah. If you had, you probably wouldn’t be here now to read these messages. So try to accept what Hanson were back then -kids- and try to be open to what they are now. “The Walk” is coming.

kathy | 6/2/2007, 5:52 pm EST

they are a lyrical genuis. they play great music. their song is a reflection of reality. and it’s awesome how these guys weave reality to create many beautiful harmonies. it’s so not fair for other people to bring them down. they are no longer kids and when you grow, you change (a lot!). they’re not kids forever. if you listen closely to their songs, man the lyrics will really tell a story that will make you ponder and realize. respect them not because they had some hits but because they deserve it — in how they let alot people open their eyes to reality. if i were you, support the song “great divide” for you to be able to become a worthwhile individual. in this way, you will help a lot of people in africa. they did that song to become a catalyst of change in africa – change for the better. i doubt those who has been criticizing hanson negatively has not even helped people.

think again…

yes, i am a fan. but it’s not because of being a fan led me to writing this. it is because i feel it’s about time that we really listen to music with sense and emotion as compared to music who talks sex, curse a lot, rhyme nonesense in their songs.

it’s time to have some music that can make a difference.

me | 11/29/2007, 10:46 pm EST

i am only here, cuz i want to know is jason michael the oldest of the hanson brothers? if yes e mail me @tracedarrell6@yahoo.com we think so, but not sure

Post A Comment

Caution: Off-topic comments will be deleted

Name:

Comments:



Advertisement

Advertisement