Previous Next Latest

High Fidelity Inspires List of Top Five Movies That Should Never Be Musicals

12/12/06, 5:27 pm EST

We were always skeptical about the potential success of a High Fidelity musical. (You can’t expect a good book to turn into a good movie AND into a good Broadway show). And anyway, after what happened with the Bob Dylan/Twyla Tharp thing, we’re really wary of any neon-lit, rock-related projects. In fact, we’ve considered nominating one staff member as the go-to musical attendee. That way we only ever have one corrupted party in the office at a time.

Now that the reviews for High Fidelity have proven to be so discouraging, we’re totally sending him. Then we’re all going to collectively review his notes and create a list of Five Movies Sure to Be Bad Musicals. We’re thinking Jaws goes on that list (”da-dum” need not be accompanied by lyrics) as does The Big Lebowski (imagine the inevitable, falsetto-sung “The Dude Abides” number) and The Silence of the Lambs (though that scene where Bill applies makeup while listening to “Goodbye Horses” by Q Lazzarus could be cool in a depraved way). Which movies do you think would make the worst musicals?


Previous Next Latest

Comments

Horrible Excuse for Human | 12/12/2006, 6:00 pm EST

Any good (key word) Scorcese film:
Goodfellas, Casino, Taxi Driver (”You talkin’ to me?”), Raging Bull, etc.

Dan | 12/12/2006, 6:02 pm EST

Lord of the Rings. Oh wait, they tried that one too…

Topher | 12/12/2006, 6:05 pm EST

Have they tried Pulp Fiction yet? If they did that would be horrible.

Johnny Hardcock | 12/12/2006, 6:15 pm EST

I’m personally crossing my fingers for Die Hard the Musical.

johnny | 12/12/2006, 6:19 pm EST

hmmm…..

the lord of the rings (even though it might be unintentionally hilarious)

Sess | 12/12/2006, 6:34 pm EST

Apocalypse Now. The Horror… the horror.

Cody | 12/12/2006, 7:25 pm EST

I would have to say Platoon…

jill hives | 12/12/2006, 7:35 pm EST

the texas chainsaw massacre – unless they actually chopped the people all up to hell, then i’d go see it.

ekp | 12/12/2006, 7:59 pm EST

Eraserhead
Henry portriat of a serial killer
Requiem for a dream
Sweet smell of success (wait they all ready did that)

The Artist | 12/12/2006, 8:32 pm EST

1. Battlefield Earth
2. Road House
3. Over The Top
4. Stop or My Mom Will Shoot
5. Under Siege 2 Dark Territory

Ryan | 12/12/2006, 8:37 pm EST

Planet of the Apes…although The Simpsons almost pulled it off.

Nonconnor | 12/12/2006, 9:00 pm EST

The Matrix would definetly be even worse as a musical.

Also Pi

Dardo | 12/12/2006, 9:04 pm EST

Terminator (I, II or III).

Rambo (I, II, III or IV… well, dunno how many Rambos are there)

Agree with Lord Of The Rings.

Dogville. That would be very f*cking funny.

And… Titanic.
I think that a musical based on Titanic would cause a massive suicide in the whole world.

Beefy | 12/12/2006, 9:17 pm EST

All ‘Ernest’ movies.

J | 12/12/2006, 9:33 pm EST

Lost in Translation
The Godfather
JFK
Brokeback Mountain
The Deer Hunter

J | 12/12/2006, 9:59 pm EST

I second Requiem for a Dream, that movie was all about the cut scenes with the music and extreme close-ups… it wouldn’t be the same.

teig | 12/12/2006, 11:10 pm EST

i saw the show sunday and found it to be very enjoyable. it’s getting bad reviews because jack black isn’t in it, plain and simple. nick hornby loves what they did.

JT | 12/12/2006, 11:10 pm EST

There already is a musical to Titanic, I’m pretty sure it’s what inspired the movie in the first place.

ROCKGOD | 12/12/2006, 11:25 pm EST

The answer is Rocket Man staring Harland Williams because any movie that is named after an Elton John Theme song is allready 2 legit to quit

Diva | 12/13/2006, 12:14 am EST

Geez! There are so many. Nonetheless, I’ve picked the following movies as the ones most likely to suck as musicals:

1. Pier Paolo Pasolini’s Salò: 120 Days of Sodom
2. William Friedkin’s The Exorcist and Cruising
3. Ingmar Bergman’s Cries and Whispers and Persona
4. David Cronenberg’s Videodrome
5. Woody Allen’s Interiors

Afro Joe | 12/13/2006, 12:17 am EST

I’m only going to post one movie, a movie which tops all other movies as THE movie not to be made into a musical…

Schindler’s List.

HipsterScienceAlgebraEquations | 12/13/2006, 1:02 am EST

Steel Magnolias

Remeber the Titans

High School Musical(keep that stuff on the disney channel)

Power Rangers

Breakin Bugaloo Bongaloo

Nicole | 12/13/2006, 4:49 am EST

Well, on the other hand the Evil Dead musical is supposed to not suck….

Dan | 12/13/2006, 7:42 am EST

The Passion of the Christ
Animal House
Ferris Bueller’s Day Off
Jackass
Bill and Ted’s Excellent Adventure
Miami Vice
…anything with the Brat Pack

dmbu27 | 12/13/2006, 7:54 am EST

any charlie chaplin movie
Silent film by Mel Brooks
any thing by Marcue Marcue

shawna | 12/13/2006, 8:36 am EST

The Color Purple. Oh wait…too late.

Rich | 12/13/2006, 8:48 am EST

Shawshank Redemption, imagine the numbers:

“Take That, You Tub of Lard”
“Same Ol’ S*it, Different Day”
“He Shoulda Died in Here”

HA! | 12/13/2006, 9:28 am EST

2001 A SPACE ODDYSSEY… bad idea.

Matt | 12/13/2006, 9:37 am EST

“And… Titanic.
I think that a musical based on Titanic would cause a massive suicide in the whole world.”

Too late. It came out a while ago. My parents brought me to it when I was a child. Holy jeebus, was it terrible.

Fedoko | 12/13/2006, 9:37 am EST

This is spinal tap

kevy b. man | 12/13/2006, 9:49 am EST

Reservoir Dogs
Saving Private Ryan
The Good The Bad and The Ugly
Blue Velvet

the buynak | 12/13/2006, 10:40 am EST

Only one film would surprise me and piss me off if it was turned into a musical…Back to the Future! The world would probably ened if that happened.

the buynak | 12/13/2006, 10:41 am EST

I take that back…Clerks would make a shitty musical. Can you imagine some gay guy playing Randal, singing about the destruction of the Death Star?

Eileen | 12/13/2006, 10:49 am EST

I believe they’re already going a stage version of “High School Musical” (something I never saw and have no desire to see).

As for “Titanic,” the musical and the movie were totally different stories, but ended up coming out at about the same time. (Personally, I liked the stage production far better than the movie.)

Eileen | 12/13/2006, 10:50 am EST

I meant ‘doing’ a stage version, not ‘going.’

Larry | 12/13/2006, 11:19 am EST

Silence! Silence of the Lambs The Musical has been made (kinda)…go to: http://www.silencethemusical.com

S tar Wars the Musical is pretty amusing too.

david | 12/13/2006, 1:02 pm EST

star trek! all of them!

david | 12/13/2006, 1:03 pm EST

the godfather

Rachel | 12/13/2006, 1:06 pm EST

I would have said “The Ten Commandments” but alas, it already is a musical starring none other than Val Kilmer as Moses.

I’m just glad “Deliverance: The Musical” is only 8 minutes long.

A.J. | 12/13/2006, 1:27 pm EST

The Departed

rustyshackleford | 12/13/2006, 1:44 pm EST

Any David Lynch film

jim | 12/13/2006, 2:21 pm EST

dazed and confused

Evan | 12/13/2006, 2:47 pm EST

Schindler’s List.

fordmaxwell | 12/13/2006, 6:03 pm EST

The Matrix (bullet time with fishing wires, acrobats flying all over the stage – I can see it way too clearly) Friday Night Lights, Eyes Wide Shut, Saw I, II, & III. There’s some appetizers.

fordmaxwell | 12/13/2006, 6:07 pm EST

Let’s not forget “Dawn of the Dead.” Imagine the musical numbers – recycled MJ Thriller dance moves. And the songs? How about “I dared to dream, though the zombies tore out my spleen.”

Bill | 12/13/2006, 6:59 pm EST

i’ll go counter to the discussion and name the movie that would make a GREAT musical…
woody allen’s PURPLE ROSE OF CAIRO

James | 12/13/2006, 7:01 pm EST

The 1969 Jane Fonda vehicle “They Shoot Horses, Don’t They?”. Probably too depressing for a musical.

Nine-Juan-Juan | 12/14/2006, 5:34 pm EST

OVERBOARD….wait that would be amazing. (esp. if they get Goldie Hawn)

Monsieur | 12/18/2006, 8:56 pm EST

Freddy got fingered with Tom Green doing an orchestral DADDY WOULD YOU LIKE SOME SAUSAGE

Foo | 3/29/2007, 9:13 pm EST

feh

Post A Comment

Caution: Off-topic comments will be deleted

Name:

Comments:



Advertisement

Advertisement