…does that even make it a box set, if its just selling loads of junk, and not even good music? their feeding the emo-crazed fire loads.

God, please kill me now.

PANIC AT THEIR BANK ACCOUNT!

ANother PATD blog? You guys are retarded,

I long for the grasp of the English language that would permit me to properly convey to you folks how much I loathe this band. Seriously, they no good.

I’d give them, like, 35 bucks to never play another song again…ever…for the remainder of life on Earth

Nicely put, Wayne. I agree.

After reading this I have concluded that Panic is the most pretentious band out there.

patd sucks.

hahaha. This is too much. Why release this when they’ve only had a short run as of far? Anyways, I’ve said it before and I will say it again – the demos were the only good out of them.

- Ian
http://mesalove.net

oh, please, one record only, and a collector’s box, what are these guys thinking?

I’m going to personally send P!ATD a box set with anthrax.

does it also come with a subscription to ‘the advocate’?

Wow, and I though Panic! at the Disco (who are neither disco nor deserving of that horrendously misused exclamation point) were talentless, unartistic, money-grubbing hangers-on of equally sucky Fall Out Boy, seeing as their singers are clones based on vocal talent (or lack thereof) and they are both sucking rock-n’-roll into an emo-filled “I’m artsy becuase I can say big words but don’t know what I’m really saying” void of nothingness! Now I see that I’m wrong!

omg…..how can yall b so cruel? i mean common spending yr time criticizing a band you dont even like? when ya talk about someone…[or something] and say negative comments about them [*cough* *cough* patd] that usually means that your jealous…maybe cus patd is incredibly talented? the reason they released the box set was so their fans..their many fans…could go buy it…and enjoy it…they have hundreds of webs dedicated to them and their band….and personaly im goin to buy the box set…=] i

mary mother of god…will some one shoot me now?

They should inclue a handkerchief, with dried tears from all the emo shtick they whine… let’s not forget the pacifiers– all the crybabies who can’t bone up and face the reality that life isn’t fair will shut their Jello pudding eaters for a spell.

i like the band, but i think this is absolutely ridic. i definitely would not buy this. are they desperate, like say – kevin federline (who has cancelled shows due to no ticket sales and has had this huuuuuuge pre-sale contest with his album) that they have to have this ‘boxed set’ to make money. that’s a load of malarky.

The art of phrasing in popular music is all but dead, and Panic at the Disco (I refuse to acknowledge the exclamation point) are perhaps the best current example of this. Just because you try to cram as many words into the space of your lousy songs (and their titles) does not give them a deeper meaning or higher artistic merit. Dylan these guys are definitely not. They’re making songs about little girls for little girls and I imagine they’re making decent money at it, so why don’t they just admit it, drop the cabaret theatrics and get in line with Simple Plan, Good Charlotte, Fall Out Boy etc. ad nauseum

Said it before and I’ll say it again, worst headlining band I’ve ever seen. they opened for Fall Out Boy and Motion City Soundtrack (whom I was there to see) and they were okay. they had a cool bass player, whom they’ve since ditched. and become vastly inferior as a result.

I saw them a second time, when The Dresden Dolls were opening for them DD were incredible, but Panic! sucked so horribly. i mentioned to my friends that the 2 good members in the band where the ones playing nontraditional rock instruments.

turns out those 2 where actually session musicians though. luckily, Panic! realized they have zero talent or stage precence and so they hired a mime troupe. the mimes were funny and extremely attractive. only thing that made me not go wait in the car.

this band is absolutely horrible. But they are good businessmen, I give them credit for trying to make more money. Granted, the only people who are going to buy this are 13 year old girls, but hey its still money.

A box set? Good god this band is terrible.

wow.. I can see in your comments that you probably never even listent to their album or watcht an interview. These guys sing about real things. Why do you even reed stuff about them when your not interested in them? Get a life, please!!

i think there good the music i like.what i dont like that,that stupiid pete dude signed them & thhat they were on mtv and trl.other than that they r great and i like them b4 they were on tv

Whether you like it or not this band is the first GREAT band of the new millenium. Their promotion is straight outta the Brian Epstein playbook (the next Beatles?). “And you can’t stand it”

panic at the disco blow. this is a joke, right? who the fuck do these kids think they are? they dont even deserve to be signed to a label, let alone release a box set for their one shitty album full of useless crap for pathetic 11 to 18 year-old-girls to obsess over. a mask and diary?? come on. and rs, you spelled “merchandise” wrong.

Good God. I am beyond speechless at this point. This puts the good name of box sets to shame. One record…..damn.

well i won’t be one of those 16 year olds with a shrine in my closet, go ahead and search nothing related to them will be in there P!ATD is so overrated
ppl just like them cuz they’re “original” but really they aren’t and they’re trying way to hard to be “weird”

hey “i” just cuz they have a large following doesn’t mean their any good…ever heard of “drinking the kool-ade”?

hey um…”;)” well ive actually liked the band bfer they even got signed..so ya….and the reason they have so many “followers” [fans really] is bcus theyr really good…patd deserves none of this worthless critisism, y even bother to say junk about a band wen ya dont even like them, if ya dont like them and yr saying how bad they are…[which teyr not] then youre wasting yr time….b more produtive people…

You know, I’d take these arguments from Panic! fans far more seriously if they learned how to speak the English language first. Oh, and if they weren’t arguing on the side of freaking Panic! At the Disco.

“idioteque” mayb you should bcome jst a little more in touch wth how “other” people type “these days”, an bsides, its saves ya bout 60 sec, so wth tat extra min y dont cha go do something else, if yr jst soooo “smart” huh? i

Wow, no wonder our school systems are “at a low point” or whatever, just take a look at “i”’s spelling, grammer, and lack of ability to use large words. And speaking of jealous… what exactly is there to be jealous about? “dhey have kwel hair!!111111″ -_-

hey finest, i usually don’t waste my time using this instant message board, mostly because people like you are on it, but for fuck sake–the next beatles?
honestly, you are stupid. get it over with already and splatter your emo brains all over that Panic! poster i know you have in your room–that’d be a fitting tribute to the “the first great band of the new millenium.”

If you dont run right out and get one I sure will!!!

I find it amusing that the box set costs more than going to the actual concert.

hey finest,

i don’t usually waste my time posting on these message boards because of stupid people like you, but–the next beatles–are you fucking serious? you are an idiot. why don’t you go and do everyone a favor and splatter your emo brains all over that panic! poster i know you have in your room. that’d be a fitting tribute to the “first great band of the new millenium.”

hey i,

U luved patd b4 they wur kewl? OMG! you’re an idiot too. you are exactly what is wrong with our society, or as you would say, “U R xacly wats bad wit r ppls.” learn how to speak and/or type correctly, or leave it to the grown-ups.

panic at the puke hole BLARF

I do agree that the boxset is a stupid idea, I mean what next, a greatest hits album after only one album. Also, whats with all the short-hand talk, I mean it doesnt cost you any money to post here so why not prove that you actually have the capacity to spell and write in English.

“Wow, no wonder our school systems are ‘at a low point’ or whatever, just take a look at ‘i’’s spelling, grammer. . .”

I agree with everything you’re saying, and panic! is terrible, but it’s “grammar.” Just to enhance your point.

i’s logic: if you don’t like something you shouldn’t talk about it. That’s preteen logic if I ever heard it. i, when you get a little older you may expand your musical pallete beyond Every Band After 2000 A.D., and realize that Emo is as silly as the pet rock, and will probably last as long. Call it whatever you want, I call it bad music, played by bad musicians who don’t know their history. Please do yourself a favor and go out and pick up The Rolling Stones “Exile on Main St”. Or better yet, since you seem to be into the theatrical, Bowie’s “Ziggy Stardust”. Hopefully those will help you fine tune your musical load-o-crap-ometer.

i’m not a fan of panic at the disco, but they’re hardly the first band to repackage their albums with a bunch of useless stuff in the sole pursuit of making money. i think there’a always a risk of alienating your fans with such blatant attempts at taking their money, but i have a feeling that a lot of panic at the disco’s fanbase is made up of the type of people who don’t see this as a rip off, at all. oh, well. if panic at the disco and their fans are happy, who cares?

I am a big fan of PANIC! at the Disco but I still agree that it’s way too early to be releasing a box set. I mean, If they made the box set after a few great albums then it would be worth it. But after one? Pleas…

Just saying I forgot the ‘e’ at the end of ‘Please’

What happened to the days where artists like Led Zeppelin and Neil Young dodged the press. Worried that their music would lose it aunthenticity if they ever pulled publicity shit like this. Panic is part of a new generation, of music that does not matter, and will never. Dont waste you fucking money people.

And by the way. I know half you guys are under age 12, since thats their fan base, but really please quit following “trend music” and pick up the real stuff.

And it’s Panic! at the Disco by a length over the Killers going into the home strecth of the Incredibly Shitty and Untalented Bands Who Think They’re Better Than They Could Ever Possibly Be Derby.

panic at the disco is the worst band in the world. Period.

i know very little about this band aside from that song about brides being whores that’s on the radio every three seconds, but i need to express something that has been really bugging me for months.

perhaps the excuse for their shitty writing is the fact that they wrote most of their lyrics when they were in that “i just heard morrissey for the first time” phase in high school, but they cannot expect to be taken seriously by adults when they have two glaring logical errors in the first verse of their song.

1. there are no pews in church corridors. take 10th grade humanities or ask your school librarian for more info about that one (or grand funk.)

2. there are very few waiters in wedding ceremonies.

also, the only reasons to ask someone if they’ve ever heard of “closing a god damn door” is if they’re:

1. your uncle abe on the john post-thanksgiving

2. your hippie housemates having sex to phish bootlegs.

I’ll admit to also being a Panic fan, but $50 is an absolutely ridiculous price for ONE album and a bunch of other cabaret-themed bullshit. The entire idea is stupid and pretentious, even if the set price was considerably lower, but the more “devoted” fans will eat it up. I suppose they figured to strike while the iron’s hot — a gyp just the same. Guys, get your heads down from the clouds and come join us here on Earth.

this gets Me mad cause my friend dan has written over 600 songs in his life which would be worthy of BOX SET

eck damn technology…anyway dan has written OVER 600 songs which are worth a box set….check out some tunes at http://www.myspace.com/danmalloy

“dear i” hey i actually have that stone record!!!!!!! i love it too! and none of that music is crap!!!! i like it and i could care less if ya dont…everyone has their own taste in music, and obviously, ours are different, very, very different, but thats ok n all. =]

And here you will find many textbook examples of counter-productivity:

A bunch of internet chumps reading an article about a band they don’t like and then proceeding to spout off about why they don’t like said band, and why you(my faithful reader) should like x band x.

Seriously, if you don’t like it turn it off. and while you’re at it stop being such a bitch i highly doubt any of you were even alive been bowie put out ziggy stardust. and if you were…jesus h christ get a fucking life and stop bickering with children.

I was implying that Exile and Bowie ARE great, and that they would help you to realize what the crappy stuff sounds like, as it wouldn’t sound like Exile, Bowie, etc. Try some Dylan or Neil Young as well. I just can’t comprehend popping out my Exile album, or almost any other album, for some PATD. It just doesn’t hold up. As for new music – Kings of Leon, Black Rebel Motorcycle Club – bands that know their history. You’ll thank me in 10 years when you’re 23, like me.

“dear i” i actually have a broken leg rite now….so im like super bored so i googled somea those bands n listened to their music..btw…neil young is so awesomeness…!!! [its now on my mp3....tanx a bunches...!!!! =]

so, are we, like, dating now?

make it _stop

I am reminded of a certain crapy special edition DVD…ahh yess:

Show Girls – VIP Edition

I am reminded of a certain crapy special edition DVD…ahh yess:

Show Girls – VIP Edition

Included:
-”the greatest movie ever made” commentary
-Lap-Dance Tutorials
-a showgirls Diray storyboard
-Triva Track
-Trailer
-Showgirls Shot Glasses
-”Pin The Pasties on the Showgirl” Game with Pasties and Blindfold
-Deck of Showgirls Cards
-Showgirls Party Games
-Elizabeth Berkley (Saved by the Bell) Photo Series

Just go buy some funking porn either way.

I hope they all die in a car fire after getting smoked by a semi trailer heading into their hometown. End of horrible band problem.

Remember when rock bands were people you wanted to BE, not BEAT UP! 20-30 years ago most bands put out albums every year! Now they put out 1 album every 3 years and what’s with this band stationery??!! Do us a favour-all take a helicopter ride with a drunk pilot into the middle of a snow storm!

Panic! At the Disco better make their money while they can, the music is not that good that I would pay fifty dollars for all that crap. I will wait a few years when it is on the sidewalk sale table at the local Best Buy or Circuit City selling for five dollars.

its prity ridiclious but i would rather listen to bad music then no music at all. there just trying to make a buck i would do the same thing.

p.s. I was also correct in my assumption that you were certainly not even born when Bowie was in his glam rock hey-day. don’t worry, i’m sure there is another bandwagon you can jump on thirty years too late…

and my god… the rolling stones? are you fucking serious? a coverband that got a break because they got some mcartney an lennon cast-offs…

I’ll buy it for $100

“wow…” ya so who cares how i frikin type…?!?!? y do ya even bother to say junk like tat..? i have an excuse…its calleda broken leg!!! and i would die bfor i typed like tat “example” ya gave…tats jst strange…and a little cycopathic..=/ patd is such a talented and awesome band..this should b a place were FANS come together and say NICE things..and how much they LIKE the music..not lazy bums who have nothing better to do but criticize a great band…please do SOMETHING with yr lifes….!!!

most of bands release box sets when they are over or they have nothing more to offer… well, guess what!

Alright. I’ve seen several Panic! shows over the short period of time they’ve actually been around, and I can honestly say they’ve been some of the most fun concerts I’ve ever been to. Quite a spectacle. I personally find them amazing, but that’s neither here nor there. Everybody’s right about the 12 year olds eating this up, and I say more power to the people at Fueled By Ramen for throwing it together. If the kids are going to be at shows annoying me with their boney elbows and giant “please do me” signs then I say take all their damn money.

Panic! At the Disco is my favorite band and I am not “one of those kids who doesn’t know and good music who is under the age of 12.” It is kind of early for a box set but come on people! Stop dissing P!ATD! Everybody has different opinions about music and different tastes but stop calling them junk and trash, especially when you are talking about their lyrics. They have said that they spent a long time coming up with lyrics for their first album because they didn’t want it just to be junk thrown together. All of the lyrics were well thought out and relate to Ryan’s (guitarist) life and are not supposed to be literal. They are too deep for some of you morons to understand. And they are NOT “emo!”

Ya Sam, so when The Downward Spiral by Nine Inch Nails came out when I was your age I didnt get that album either?! Is that album not deep? Your parents should give you away or sell you to some Seattle family that can teach you something about music, before you grow up and spawn another one of you. Shame on you.

First of all, if you hate them so much, why read there articles in the first place? && if you dont like them, just shrug them off your shoulders, and dont approve a single word that they wrote.

k thanks.

Bands like Pink Floyd put out box sets, not Panic! at the disco. It is a joke. For those of you who have stated you like their live set. Personally, it is one of the worst. You do not see bands like Radiohead (rock gods) doucing their faces in makeup and putting a production together that lacks any intimacy what-so-ever. They have paid people to put on a production for them. Not to mention they cover three songs for their tour. IF YOU DONT HAVE ENOUGH MUSIC TO GO ON A HEADLINING TOUR THEN YOU HAVE NO BUSINESS GOING!! Get real people.

p.s. panic! at the disco blatantly stole the horn part that Murder by Death orchestrated into their song “A Masters In Reverse Psychology.” Not to mention, Ryan Ross ripped Chuck Palahniuk. NICE WORK PANIC! These guys are horrible.

Sorry, mistake, it was actually the horn part in the song “The Desert is on Fire” by Murder by Death that panic stole. RIDICULOUSLY UNORIGIONAL

I checked out the horn part and it is pretty obvious. I think Murder by Death should take legal action against panic! at the disco. When panic wrote the song that copies it they probably did not keep in mind that they might get HUGE one day.

The simple fact that the majority of you are illiterate, or just…dyslexic is making it intolerable for me to even read your comments. Take some English lessons, kids.

Well, it seems as though panic! at the disco are getting bashed on this rolling stone forum. In my opinon that is exactly what they deserve. Ryan, try not to copy lyrics or even paraphrase for that matter, you do know you can be sued for that right? Also, next time try to name your songs with something a little more original than a line directly out of a movie. HAHA this band makes me laugh!!

What the fuck is wrong with those cop-outs??!??
Words cannot express my utter HATE for this band.
People say theyre so original.B.U.L.L.S.H.I.T. They are simply copying My Chemical Romance, one of the only bands to come out in the past few years with any originality.
Let me rattle off the unoriginality of Panic at the disco.
Their CD, has 13 tracks, as does MCR’s 2nd album. Their eighth track is intermission, as is MCR’s. They are so unoriginal as to not even come up with own layout!!
Their first video is a direct ripoff of Helena, by My Chemical Romance.
Helena is set at a funeral, so PATD has just set their song at a fucking wedding.
They dont have any acknowledgement of the rest of the band, they are solely based around their pathetic, prolonged, hollow lyrics.
Their stage shows are fucking boring. I have seen a few on You Tube, and it is purely the singer, the rest of the band are just fucking statues.
i dont think they really get what theyre saying, or understand their titles.
The Only Difference Between Martyrdom and Suicide is Press Coverage, what the fuck, suicide is a weak, pathetic, selfish act viewed as glorius by many.
Martyrdom is fucking different!
For a start, Martyrdom, your life can be taken by others. TAKE JESUS FOR EXAMPLE!!
They are direct cop-outs of My CHemical Romance, as are the likes of FalloutBoy and Taking Back Sunday etc. Comeup with something original!!
And, i would like to know why the fuck this shit has been dubbed PUNK by some. Whatever ignorant Twat did that should rot.
Punk is primarily about doing it yourself and about being different and just fuck the system, and how can you associate PATD with that. They are a studio enhanced band, simply doing what is the latest and sexiest thing in little girls magazines. Theyre meant for slutty little mainstream bitches, only intersted in things like “oh, theyre so hot” and “they have really deep thoughtful lyrics” get over yourselves!!
All you teeny-bop fucks that worship this band, get a life, and do something with your lives.
look at bands that did it for themselves and/or didnt just do what was hip and mainstream.
Those who hate these bullshit emo rippoff bands are people that still have some self respect and originality, something rather unheard of in todays world.

i have the box set…and it seriously rocks… its so good and different from a lot of other band’s box set’s cause it doesn’t just include a dvd and another random thing… they put things in there that are personal to them….and they only released one cause they wanted to release a dvd, but being extravagant and over the top people they are, they included other things to be different….. and its all good stuff

SO DONT GO DISSING IT IF YOU HAVEN’T SEEN WHAT’S IN IT!!!!

i would pay $100 for it

Okay, everyone has their opinions to bands, but honestly, bashing a band because they made a freaking box set, or because they play “emo” music -_-’ Like COME ON! How stupid can you people get? Maybe you don’t like there idea of their boxset, SO DON’T BUY IT! You don’t have to go around bashing it because its full of “shit”. Maybe you think their music is stupid, and full of shit, and other people might adore their music, either way, whether you hate them or not, you don’t say “I hope they die” or some shit like that, if you had a band would you want people saying that about your band? It kind of ruins peoples self esteem. I know we all hate some bands or singers, but I don’t go around saying I want them to die -_-’ And also, yes I think it is overpriced, but I honestly doubt they have a choice in how much its sold for, so just GET A LIFE AND STOP ACTING LIKE FUCKING IDIOTS.