Previous Next Latest

Pet Shop Boys: Still Our Favorite Synth Rock Bum-outs

10/16/06, 4:38 pm EST

Question: Does the world really need another comeback tour from the Pet Shop Boys? Answer: Yes, obviously. Twenty years after “West End Girls,” the great Eurotrash synth-pop duo rocked Radio City Music Hall on Saturday night, packing the house with Chelsea boys and girls. Neil Tennant wore a top hat and black tails, his dance moves so bad they were good. Chris Lowe wore a day-glo yellow hoodie and hid behind his keyboard, likely texting his mates, “omg its west end grlz agn brb.” They did Eighties hits like “Left to My Own Devices,” “Rent” and “Heartbeat,” featuring one of our all-time fave lyrics: “If I didn’t love you/I would look around for someone else.” When they did “Shopping,” it was disco heaven circa ‘87, with the whole crowd chanting the chorus: “We’re s-h-o-p-p-i-n-g/We’re shopping.” It was a stripped-down show, with hardly any stage props or glitz, no doubt inspired by last year’s amazing Erasure shows. The Boys did way too many songs from their recent disc, Fundamental, though “Integral” was a highlight. They did the worst song from their best album (“Can You Forgive Her,” from Very) and the best song from their worst (“Home and Dry,” from Release). They didn’t do “What Have I Done To Deserve This” or “New York City Boy,” but when Tennant said, “New York, you are fabulous,” the guy next to me screamed, “As are YOU, my man!” That was cool.

In their heyday, the Pet Shop Boys were the Interpol of the Eighties, dressing up to sing really weird pop songs about lust and loneliness in the big city. They’re low-pro now, not retro-worshipped in the manner of Depeche Mode, New Order, or The Cure, but you can hear the reason why–these guys are too sad. Not sad as in “my soul is a void unto the blankness,” or “my teachers don’t understand me,” but sad as in “I’m lonely and tired and old and my blind date didn’t show up and here I am drinking miso soup alone and I don’t even like miso soup and I keep checking my phone but nobody’s going to call.” Real sad. So the moments of release were oceanic, as in the climactic “Go West.” The best moment was the gorgeous “Home and Dry,” which Tennant played on acoustic guitar, a surrender of his disco principles. As soon as the song was done, a guitar roadie came and took Neil’s axe away–a hilariously rock-cliché gesture from a proudly non-rock-cliché band.


Previous Next Latest

Comments

genie | 10/17/2006, 4:16 am EST

I cant help noting that the song mentioned as “heartbeat” is actually “heart”. Sorry lol

Askari | 10/17/2006, 5:54 am EST

I remember reading Rolling Stone back in ‘86, when the magazine panned the PSB as a one-hit wonder, and, commenting on the release of their second single, “Opportunities”, the mag said that the PSB might already have had theirs. Indeed!

Irony | 10/17/2006, 11:28 am EST

“It was a stripped-down show, with hardly any stage props or glitz, no doubt inspired by last year’s amazing Erasure shows” It has, according to the New York Times, a “brilliant” stage design etc and there’s a glIronyitzy photo illustrating this blog. Erasure’s last tour was acoustic… Maybe he’s being ironic?

andrew | 10/17/2006, 12:17 pm EST

rob sheffield. i have lost all respect from you. “eurotrash” “can you forgive her the worst” etc etc lots of crap bull here…and what is that sadness crap about? they are a bit dark and insideous, but come now…what a dickhead

DJMasterK | 10/17/2006, 12:56 pm EST

Yeah, he’s saying a lot of crap about Pet Shop Boys here. I just saw them here in D.C. on Sunday the 15th and I’ve been a long time fan. You could see a lot of “Sheffields” sitting down and refusing to get up and dance. Ignorant americans! That’s why you get fat! If you’re straight, you can still dance, you know! It doesn’t mean that you’re gay.

Marlene | 10/17/2006, 2:22 pm EST

I saw the Pet Shops Boys on Sunday in DC as well. Great show. I was dancing the whole time. The crowd was really into it. The stage set up was very clever. I liked the “sperm men” (as my friend Z called them) who moved the set around after each song. As for sadness…not sure about that…felt a lot of happiness in that room. I’ve been a huge fan for a long time and this was the first I saw the PSB. I’m so glad as Neil Tennant put it, “We are still the Pet Shop Boys!”

SOBECHICK | 10/17/2006, 3:54 pm EST

DJMASTERK obviously another jealous person from europe….by the way do they have dentists in london?

wietie | 10/17/2006, 3:59 pm EST

I saw the band here in Belgium at Marktrock Leuven and i must say that it was a great sow. It was the first time that i saw the pet shop boys live and i enjoyed every second of it

Great great great

Hein | 10/17/2006, 4:15 pm EST

I saw the show in Germany, but this review doesn’t make sense. The stage design was actually great with all changing lighting and video projections. What the last part of the review about being sad is about, is not clear at all.

genie | 10/17/2006, 4:38 pm EST

R Sheffield should confess that he knows or cares little about PSB. After all they are an 80s UK synth pop band who will probably never be a smash in the US again , even if they are the best group of all time.

Kurt in NYC | 10/17/2006, 4:59 pm EST

Sad??? What is this idiot thinking? Radio City was on a f-cking upper, and so were the PSB. My god, there’s nothing “sad” about them at all. This guy should be kicked like the retarded dog he is. BTW, a cool Voice of America radio interview with Neil Tennant is posted on PSB official web site. Check it out.

cwhite | 10/17/2006, 5:59 pm EST

I was pleasantly surprised how good the DC show was…the transforming “cube” is very cool–its effects cannot be conveyed easily in writing but works tremendously well live. Everyone seemed to have a blast and danced for most of the show, despite what I have read in most reviews. Please remember that They’re the PSBs, Actually, not anyone else. I think nothing has been proved in a review of the show by comparing them to supposedly “non-sad” bands like N.O. and Depeche Mode…except that the reviewer may be in denial.

Chinese Democracy starts NOW!! | 10/18/2006, 1:30 am EST

The new Guns N’ Roses album, “Chinese Democracy” is set to hit stores before the end of the year…you can visit gunsnroses.com for all the latest news, performances, and all of your ticket purchasing needs…..

Emily | 10/18/2006, 6:30 am EST

PSB are like a lot of artists they tour and write because that is what they do, a ‘Comeback’ is very difficult is you’ve never gone away. I think the Rolling Stone Journo is trying to be a little too clever and therefor not very genuine.

genie | 10/18/2006, 2:59 pm EST

The PSB dont inspire retro worship like DM or New Order because unlike them PSB dont pretend to be “rock” bands. They are synth pop and feign no interest in reaching out to stadium crowds.
Therefore it seems a little “rockist” to dismiss them thus.
its absurd since the same critics hail obscure underground bands as legendary all the time.
Lastly, PSB fans are somewhat ironic and too smart to be fanatical.

James | 10/18/2006, 4:38 pm EST

Poor Rob …. what a terrible review. Made little sense, especially the ’sad’ thing. As for claiming PSB were inspired by Erasure … now that’s funny.

Joseph | 10/18/2006, 11:22 pm EST

I saw PSB perform in Las Vegas a few years ago during their nightlife tour and have followed them ever since the world premier of West End Girls on MTV back in 1986. Although glitz and glamour claims to be lacking for this tour, the talent and musical creativity is what makes it all worth while! PSB fans know the music and that is why they go to see this awesome duo in concert…. the stage production is simply a compliment of the musical talents of the performers. I am glad to see the “best pop duo of all time” in the USA!!!!! I look forward to seeing their performance in Phoenix, Arizona on November 01, 2006! And yes, it is unfortunate that the composer of this article did not care to provide a fair synopsis as did the other articles that are linked through the PSB website…. perhaps this is the old adage “misery loves company”! Trying to make someone else look as bad as they do…. meaning, the author of this article needs to pull his head out of his a** and get real!

anti-skeptic | 10/19/2006, 3:08 am EST

PSB are not eurotrash Rob S. What the f*** are you talking about ? Idiot!!!

pcboy | 10/19/2006, 10:18 am EST

Calling the reviewer an idiot (tempting) means there is some sort of mental deficiency. Since we don’t know if the reviewer has a mental disease – let’s just say the reviewer is DUMB (as in uneducated). This doesn’t excuse anything since the job of a reviewer is to provide criticism of the (in this case) performance based on knowledge of the genre – of which, apparently, there is none.

Frank "Native American" | 10/19/2006, 12:46 pm EST

Rob, Your review, how disappointing. Where do you get your facts from? If you can’t be objective and research your subject than maybe you should write fiction or even better -comics. You are obviously one of these people that think Pet Shop Boys have had only one hit “West End Girls” and pronounce it “Western girls.” They are not on a “Comeback tour” they have had many albums and tours. The set was brilliant and different from Erasure. Pet Shop Boys have an incredible loyal fan base. Of course they are goig to play more songs from Fundamental; thats the album they are promoting right now. They have so much great music that is diverse they can’t play everyone’s favorites. Maybe you should go back to the “Fundamentals” of Journalism.

Zazou | 10/19/2006, 4:37 pm EST

What a crap article! Do you hate them, mr journalist?

By the way… comeback tour?? I saw them back in ‘99, 2000, 2002, 2004 and 2006. Oh, that means they’ve never gone away! You idiot! If they don’t tour the USA as often as Europe that doesn’t mean that they don’t exist anymore!

Sure you loved last U2′S and Coldplay’s album. Bah!

Liv | 10/19/2006, 5:11 pm EST

Clear lack of knowledge, research or any journalistic talent at all.
THAT is sad.

Trevor | 10/20/2006, 9:37 am EST

What ever happened to informed journalism – where the journalist has actually done some proper investigation and research before writing a review which allegedly contains “facts” – the comment about Erasure is a joke? Do Rolling Stone not review articles before they are finalised? Also disagree with his conclusions about the best albums and best songs – “Can you forgive her” is the best song on very…

jbt6 | 10/20/2006, 1:30 pm EST

PSB have more talent in their little toes than every act on Billboard 100 today. What a CRAP review but not at all unexpected from a tired corporate sell out rag like Rolling Stone. Can’t wait for the next cover of Ashlee Simpson — she’s so hot with her new nose job and all ……NOT.

Picuj Hungary | 10/20/2006, 3:44 pm EST

Can you forgive her is the worst song of Very?? What a rubbish oh my God! :D DD

geo | 10/20/2006, 4:28 pm EST

I got no doubt that Rob was on something that night,or maybe he’s the one that’s old,sad and fat.Can’t judge talent by age ,gay or straight.Still Pink Floyd sell albums after 38 years from their first.get sober man

djmjlcst | 10/20/2006, 4:31 pm EST

“How Dare You!” PSB are truly one of a kind! They write brilliant original music (aside from some covers) and lyrics that will stand up next to the rest of the manufactured crap that has been issued lately. It’s so sad that some American Radio stations do not embrace these brilliant musicians! Neil and Chris no exactly what they are doing!

djmjlcst | 10/20/2006, 4:38 pm EST

How Dare You Rob! PSB have consistently put out excellent records and just because they don’t get the proper airplay in America doesn’t mean that they are considered 80’s has beens! They still write original music and some of the best lyrics that will stand up next to the current manufactured crap they play on the radio. They ARE the most successful pop duo in the history of pop/rock!

Graeme | 10/20/2006, 8:24 pm EST

What a pointless review. The PSBs never went away…

Javier | 10/21/2006, 11:35 pm EST

Rob, please don’t write anymore reviews. Also you don’t know anything about music.

Tiggyboot | 10/22/2006, 12:51 pm EST

This review just mimics most of the reviews out there. Fluff and no meat. I saw the second show of the tour in Toronto. It was simply excellent. The only negative was that it wasn’t LOUD enough! I saw their show at the Government in Toronto (Nightlife Tour) and that was a much better venue. It’s a large nightclub so there were no seats, plenty of booze and dancing. That was a magical night. I saw Erasure at the same club..same deal, magical.
I’ll add to the notion they’ve never gone away. They get better and better. Try and think of one act that has lasted this long with absolutely zero controversy whatsoever. Very few and far between.

Rodrigo | 10/22/2006, 8:00 pm EST

Rob Sheffield,

Could you please investigate a littler more before writing.
They have been touring on and off for last 10 years, a comeback tour is when a band hasn´t play for a long period of time, no 2 years..
Eurotrash? Do you what it is?
i guess not, cause you can´t say that about Tennant and Lowe.

I can´t belive somebody at Rolling Stone hire you….

Susan Miller | 10/23/2006, 12:04 am EST

I was at that show…Came all the WAY from Californ-I-A! It was truly one of the best shows I have ever seen in my entire life. As for the playlist: They sang all my favorite PSB songs, and didn’t sing the ones I don’t like! That almost NEVER happens! Neil and Chris looked SO GOOD, the dancers were out of this world, and there wasn’t an empty seat in Radio City. Everyone was SO HAPPY and SO ROCK’IN! Thanks you so much Neil and Chris for a night I’ll never, ever forget!

Boston Man | 10/23/2006, 11:07 am EST

This reviewer is terrible. Fire Him! First off, the song is called “Heart”, not “Heartbeat”. And “Can You Forgive Her” is arguably the greatest song the PSB’s ever wrote, and certainly not the worst on “Very”. Can Rolling Stone hire an intelligent informed reviewer!

jonny | 10/24/2006, 8:51 pm EST

jonny

Larry | 10/25/2006, 2:03 pm EST

DO YOUR HOMEWORK! This review is
sad, not the concert. We flew from Mississippi to see the show and couldn’t have been more satisfied. I even had to go to the book and CD signing at midnight!
These guys are the most consistently intelligent artists around. The stage design was incredible and any moron knows that tours promote new CDs, so we
expected lots of new music. The new CD is as good as anything they have ever done! Great concert-review was lacking.

Nikita in SF | 10/25/2006, 3:45 pm EST

The real example of “sad” is the lonely and venomous Mr Rob Sheffield, whom no one will even remember in 20 years. And he is lucky if he has even a tiny friction of the energy, talent and appeal that the PSB have at 50 years old, which I doubt.

If you go to the PSB concert expecting to see a Justin Timberlake, then you deserve the disappointment. At least there will be one fewer idiot at future shows.

tr | 10/28/2006, 2:02 am EST

I’m a HUGE psb fan from wayback and thought this was one of the worst shows i’ve ever seen. Void of any emotion or style. Way too bright with no moody lighting or fog. Really boring “just like the album” arrangements of the songs. Undeveloped half baked ideas for the cubes. Horrible amatuer dancers that were laughable. Boring song choices. The constant spotlight on neil was annoying and made it unatmoshperic and too bright. So non-club like. The sound was so quiet I could’ve heard a pin drop. Horrible “costumes.” Niel in stupid old man tuxedo all night. I hate projections in a concert and they proved why. All washed out and made it again too bright in there. I think they go tricked in to a so called experimental show by the theatre director they used that failed big time. Some of the WORST lighting i’ve ever seen in a show. Every song was performed lackluster and emotionless. I actually couldn’t wait for the show to end. The Release tour was so emotional, dark, clubby and gorgeous that i can’t beleave how bad this one was. I’m just going to try to forget about this show because all their others have been great. Neil and chris alone on stage with a laptop in the dark would’ve been better than this.

CactusRock | 10/29/2006, 1:01 am EST

Wow. While I’m no big fan of the PSB, I despise Sheffield. As soon as I see his name on RnR Daily, I quit reading. Its good to see that this jackass brings all types of people together.

green | 10/31/2006, 3:08 pm EST

it was quite interesting to see this article from the u.s point of view,which dont really be fond of elegant,genius,melancholy pop music.
its sad that the only thing the u.s remember is ‘west end girls’,but its good to see from the comments that there are some who still appreciate pure good music,not just the same boring tunes on mtv.

RichF | 10/31/2006, 6:15 pm EST

Review highlights poor research and shows a distinct lack of knowledge – must be an American journalist……

simondo | 11/2/2006, 1:51 pm EST

What an ignorant prat. next time you review the PSB’s, be an actual journalist and do some research on them. You’ll find they’re the most successful pop duo ever in Britain, and they’re still releasing top 20 records after 20 years. Can’t imaging some of your American garbage in the charts today pulling something off like that. And what’s this crap about comeback tours?? What a diabolical thing to say about the PSB’s. Sad? Eurotrash? Inspired by Erasure? Get a life for god’s sake. Look at the rest of these comments. You haven’t got a clue mate

blusna01 | 11/2/2006, 3:50 pm EST

The Arizona State Fair PSB concert was awesome last night!!! They sounded great. I was excited about attending the first concert they ever did in AZ. I hope to see more of their concerts in the future.

FScoundrel | 11/4/2006, 7:51 pm EST

Rob S. is an ignorant motherf@#$# who has no clue of the band’s legacy. Viva Pet Shop Boys – fan since 1984. The DC show was the epitome of sophisticated entertainment and great music.

Rob yourself | 11/5/2006, 8:08 am EST

What a C U N T.

J'ason D'luv | 11/9/2006, 10:27 pm EST

Rob, dude, don’t quit your day job. You’re S-U-C-K-I-N-G… You’re sucking!

Gary in Indy | 11/10/2006, 7:37 am EST

Don’t you have to go away to come back? The PSB have been making brilliant music continuously for over 20 years! What’s sad is this completely clueless review…not the PSB. My friends and I went to see the amazing show in Chicago. Wake up, Rob and Rolling Stone…the PSB have many loyal fans in the US who appreciate the true genius of Neil Tennant and Chris Lowe!

gustavom | 11/17/2006, 1:22 pm EST

los pichichos son lo mas grande del mundo loco!!!

David R Los Angeles | 11/30/2006, 6:39 pm EST

I saw the show Nov 9 in LA. I’ve seen every PSB tour here in Southern California. This last tour came second to their 1991 “Performance” theatrical event! I have a feeling the writer of this “review” has no idea what PSB is all about. If he just took the time to read their official website, he would get an understanding of their genius. The staging and set design of this show fits with their last albums theme of Fundamentilism and minimilism– less is more, especially in their simple, creative and versatile set. As for comeback– when did they leave? Yes, PSB tours are rare but that’s what keeps them fresh and special. It was great to see that they were touring in more cities. As for their costume changes– we did not go to see Cher perform. We went to hear over 20 years of music that has touched our hearts. I saw a 10 and 13 year old singing and dancing to every song (a new generation of PETHEADS)! My favorite song was not performed this tour(LOVE COME QUICKLY) but what a joy it is to hear what they have chosen to share with us. As for their lyrics, they are gay in subject-yet love is love, pain is pain when it comes to the human condition– all people can relate. More over PSB remains to be a favorite here in USA. IT was amazing to see peoples eyes light up when the lights went down in the theater.

joe new orleans | 12/10/2006, 10:58 am EST

wow! sorry about all the rude comments here from my fellow petheads. however, they all do make one common point – you do not seem to have all the info necessary to consider this review accurate or just. i must concur with the other in the fact that this article is quite misleading and you are fairly ill-educated in the talents or history of the pet shop boys.
http://www.petshopboys.co.uk

jonny865 | 12/11/2006, 9:28 pm EST

jonny677

Paddy | 3/29/2008, 7:05 pm EST

Comback tour? They have never gone. just becuase their music isn’t played as much in America doesnt mean they are “dead”…. Their music is always played in Europe… their last album Fundamental reached number 2 in Europe… unlike fucking Erasure… what a awful band erasure are.. Pet shop boys are the kings of electronic music!

insoc | 4/3/2008, 6:06 pm EST

I love to read reviews where you can tell the reviewer knows a lot about the music genre he is talking about and you can actually still learn something from the review. The guy that did this review obviously is no expert and Rolling Stone shouldn’t have published this review as it contains some inaccurate data like saying that there is a PSB song called “Heartbeat”. Obviously the guy doesn’t know a thing (saying Can You Forgive Her? is one of their worst songs) so this review has the same value to me as if anybody outside the theater, not knowing anything about the PSB were asked about the PSB? Almost zero knowledge.

Tim | 4/13/2009, 3:33 pm EST

Pet Shop Boys have a new album coming out soon in 2009, called “Yes”.
-Tim

Post A Comment

Caution: Off-topic comments will be deleted

Name:

Comments:



Advertisement

Advertisement