i don’t think oasis wrote the greatest songs of all time. that would be more like crazy frogs to me.

wonderwall its a great tune…

oasis are bollocks!

oasis don t joke with me the best band who wrote the best songs is the one and only gods of rock pearl jam

Not the greatest of all time, but good stuff. Oh well.

That is a pretty dumb list all together. all the obvious songs from all the obvious artists. a list of the day should be “Worst Lists of All Time.”

Oasis Owns

Oasis were the best band in the world for quite a while there. And they were fuckin’ hilarious as well.

Oasis have written some pretty solid classics but to call them the best songs of all time is a bit extreme and based on…presumably nothing. Honestly, in terms of being able to cover a wide range of themes, sounds, moods and depth I’d give best songwriting credit to REM.

bullshit oasis no no no gg allin wrote the best song”i want to fuck myself”

Al Gore says Oasis did indeed write two of the finest songs of all time.

rock on duds

They sure kicked our arse, didn’t they.

I think “Wonderwall” and “Don’t Look Back in Anger” are some of the greatest songs of all time but not that high of ranking i would understand them being played in the 500-200 range but defianltly not that high ranked

What? This is crazy!!

the beatles wrote the greatest songs…oasis sucks.

unreal…simply unreal…Q is a joke…oasis sucks…AND they left off Bruce…Robbie Williams?!?

I love “Live Forever”, really do. But the greatest song of all-time? Jesus christ, I knew Brits loved Oasis but having the 2 greatest songs of all time is extreme. I guess “Sympathy for the Devil”, “Won’t Get Fooled Again” and “My Girl” aren’t worth dick. Yea I heard some guy named Bruce was left off too. That magazine deserves zero credibility.

In 10 years we will be speaking of Oasis much like we are talking about the Beatles and The Stone. The funny thing is in 10 years they will still be performing and writing some of their most impressive material.

either that or Saturday Night by Whigfield….

http://w ww.youtube.com/watch?v=ohNLvzn ugYE

Oasis wrote the greatest rip-offs of the greatest Beatles tunes.

I think that’s a little more accurate.

“Some guy named Bruce”? You do realise that Q is an English magazine, don’t you? People in England have never been brainwashed into sucking up all that hokey “Jes’ Folks” Springsteen, Tom Petty, John Cougar dog shit. Good for them!

Oasis does not have the best songs of all time and neither do the Beatles. The Beatles are the most overrated artists in history. Blah. Gimme Bowie, Zeppelin, Cash, Bob Dylan and forget that garbage.

greatest songs of all time? no. some of the best? yeah, sure. so what if at the end of the day oasis is still just a bunch of drunken beatles wannabes :p

Those 2 are probably the best Oasis songs. Best songs ever though? Hardly, and I love Oasis. Also, why is Robbie Wiliams ahead of Like a Rolling Stone?

ummmm, are they like hall and oates?

“Oasis does not have the best songs of all time and neither do the Beatles. The Beatles are the most overrated artists in history. Blah. Gimme Bowie, Zeppelin, Cash, Bob Dylan and forget that garbage.”

Wow. I don’t even know how to approach that. I love Bowie, but..he’s just a musical chameleon. He changes with the seasons. As for Zeppelin..NO THANKS. Cash and Dylan are great, though. But the Beatles…overrated? That’s just ridiculous. You obviously haven’t heard enough of their amazing catalogue.

am i the only one that hasnt lost his mind. this list is a fucking joke. robbie williams, the verve, joy division? give me a break, dylan and maybe the beatles should be the only ones to stay on the list. everything else must go. radiohead gets a pass. q sucks ass!

Fuck the guy who dooesnt like the beatles

I love Oasis very very much, but a Beatles song should be number 1…Live Forever should be up there, but maybe not number 1. It’s just an odd list all together. What’s Robbie Williams doing on there? Come on people! Greatest songs of all time! He’s talented as are all of those artists but some of the songs just don’t belong.

And to those who are saying that the Beatles are over rated, you can not like their music, I mean I understand it may not be your taste. But to casually dismiss them as over rated and stuff…is totally uncalled for. Do you know anything about music? They were a groundbreaking band who had (and still has) an immense influence. You should atleast appreciate them for that. Besides that, they made great music! Simple as that! From a technical standpoint it really is some of the best music ever recorded. And so even if you don’t really like their music, you should atleast be able to understand why they are so highly rated (not OVER-rated) and appreciate them for what they are.

i am an oasis fan!!! but i dont think noel wrote the best song of all times… four words: HEROES BY DAVID BOWIE!

Some things that can be found in a desert are an Oasis and a Mirage. Oasis writes good music, but they’re a mirage when it comes to writing the greatest songs of all time. The Lets face it, the Beatles and Led Zep wrote the greatest songs of all time.

I’m a huge Oasis fan and might even put one of their songs in my top 50…but #1? I think they are so much bigger in England. So many of the 20-30 year olds there grew up on them as THE big band. Now Robbie Williams? I can’t name a single song of his!

I can’t wait for the XTC Box set! The Live Box set they did is amazing. Now XTC Should have songs in the top 50 best for sure.

people need to stop giving so much credit to the beatles. the kinks were a far superior band as were the stones and love at their peak.

Oasis have written about5 of the top 20 tunes of all time – but not necessarily these 2