Body of Lies
Starring: Leonardo DiCaprio, Russell Crowe, Mark Strong, Golshifteh Farahani, Oscar Isaac
Directed by: Ridley Scott
2008 Warner Bros. Pictures Thriller
Deception. Disinformation. Deploying truth as a bridge to nowhere. Whoppers have become the lingua franca of our culture, useful in presidential campaigns, Wall Street bailouts, even diet books. And if you believe Body of Lies, U.S. intelligence wouldn't work without them. Here's a combustible spy thriller that wires Syriana to Three Days of the Condor, heats it with Patriot Act politics, and then lets Ridley Scott light the fuse. Snobs have dissed the British director of Alien, Blade Runner and Gladiator as a decorator tarred by his start in lowly commercials. Scott gets regularly gonged for letting style ride herd over substance, despite Thelma and Louise, Black Hawk Down, American Gangster and other potent proof to the contrary. In Body of Lies, Scott laces the action with simmering drama heightened by his killer sense of mischief. Who else would cast Russell Crowe as Uncle Sam and Leonardo DiCaprio as a pawn in his game?
Let me explain. Body of Lies, based on a 2007 novel by Washington Post foreign-affairs columnist David Ignatius, has the gritty feel of something observed firsthand. And the crafty script by Departed Oscar winner William Monahan stays coiled and ready to spring. DiCaprio, in top form, plays Roger Ferris, the CIA's man on the ground in the Middle East, trying to stop a series of bombings in Europe orchestrated by Al-Saleem, an Al Qaeda operative based in Jordan. Roger, wounded in Iraq, can speak Arabic and wear disguises to penetrate a cell whose next attack may be on home turf. But unlike James Bond or Jason Bourne, Roger is fallibly human, an idealist stuck with the painstaking work of negotiating a path through shifting alliances, none more tangled than America's own.
Enter Crowe as good ol' boy Ed Hoffman, the CIA's reigning spymaster. Crowe added 50 pounds to his gladiator frame to play the shambling suburban husband and father who uses a cellphone, a laptop and sometimes a personal visit to issue Roger his orders to kill. Factor in an Arkansas accent and you might judge the Aussie guilty of actorly excess. Hardly. Creative daring is more like it. Crowe plays Ed as flabby, fiftyish and friendly to a fault. "Hi, there, little buddy" is his standard greeting to Roger, whom he manipulates without conscience. In short, Ed is the avuncular image America shows to the world, swilling cereal in his pj's, telling his wife he'll come to bed just as soon as he's through "saving civilization." What Crowe reveals, in tandem with Scott and Monahan, is the moral rot behind the facade of Uncle Sam waving the flag of homeland security. Crowe's implosive performance is lethally funny and dangerously scary, the kind of juicy experiment Marlon Brando often tried to shake up a tired genre (remember him as a killer cowboy in a dress in The Missouri Breaks?). Crowe is the live wire this movie needs. "All you need to do is trust me, little buddy," he tells Roger, and you want to prod Roger to run for his life.
Roger suspects he'd be better off putting his fate in the hands of the nonextremist Muslims, personified by the head of Jordan's secret service, Hani Salaam (Mark Strong is nothing short of brilliant in the role). Hani professes to hate lies, which makes him the film's leading fish out of water. Roger has his doubts and refuses to trust Hani with his plan to catch the terrorists by making them believe that the CIA has infiltrated their cell. As Scott tightens the vise of the plot, Roger endures a graphic torture session. There's no doubt karmic payback is part of the equation — just before going in for the kill, one torturer quips, "Welcome to Guantánamo."
All the elements are in place to keep the excitement level high, including location shooting in Morocco, which adds to the film's visceral hold. Scott is provoking the audience to consider the sins committed in the name of God and country, now disguised as due diligence. The respect Scott showed for Islam in his failed Crusades epic, Kingdom of Heaven, also written by Monahan, carries over here. But no one's wearing blinders. It would be hard to find a timelier theme than power shifts in the spy world since September 11th.
Does the film have rough spots? You bet. A subplot in the novel about Roger's hot fling with a blondie American volunteer worker has been rejiggered on film to become a passionate connection with a Jordanian nurse (Golshifteh Farahani) who cares for Palestinian refugees. The result is commendably non-West-centric, but no less sentimentally conceived. Ditto the twist ending that drags in a glimmer of hope without laying a believable foundation. Body of Lies will be sold as a serpentine mind-bender, which it partly is. But the part that counts is the hard kick in the teeth the movie delivers to American duplicity. The kick feels deserved. No lie.
(Posted: Oct 16, 2008)
Your Turn
Review 1 of 3
Clif writes:
First I would like to say that Peter did a great job on his review for the Rolling Stone. I just thought it was funny that his first comment slammed him for being liberal and the slammed him for being anti-liberal. When both sides think you are bias, it's a strong indication that you certainly must not be bias.
Of all the reviews I've read on this film, they all seem to miss the big story. No one wants to see yet another dark anti-American movie.
I hate to be the one to point this out, but the 1994 pro-American Gulf War comedy, You're In The Army Now (Hollywood Pictures), starring Pauly Shore, earned $28,881,266 USD at the box office. PAULY SHORE made a better war movie than Leonardo DiCaprio and Russell Crowe. That should tell Hollywood something.
In recent years Hollywood studios have put out a long string of liberal propaganda films that would make Leni Reifenstein proud. No, that's not correct. Leni Reifenstein had no delusions about the films she made. Hollywood needs a Director like John Ford (1894-1973). If Hollywood made a real war movie, real people would want to see it. I never thought I would ever hear myself say this, but if Pauly Shore made a pro-American sequel to his 1994 film You're in the Army Now, I would pay to go see it before I even thought about going to see another dark anti-American film like Body of Lies. That alone should tell you how sick most people are getting of Hollywood liberal elitism.
And before the people that thrive on the hate and self loathing that permeate such films I would just like to say, leave the hate at home people. Life is too short. The 19th. century Euro-centric peasant mentality that drives such hate has no place in the reality of the 21st. century. And my Native American grandmother would appreciate it if you could leave the Native American peoples out of any possible pointless tirades of hate in your reply to my post. Don't forget there is a liberal requirement to call me racist at least once. I guess it really does not matter what color I might actually be. Life's too short. Let go of the hate.
Oct 13, 2008 16:52:40
Review 2 of 3
No Screen Name writes:
Dear tflum, Why would you come to Rolling Stone to complain about "typical left-leaning, liberal diatribe" in the first place? As for the "Islamic extremists who continue to seek our destruction", if you had any education you would know that Islam already saved our civilization by keeping the entire corpus of Greek philosophy safe in their universities while Christians were burning women and books in the rest of Europe. And, if Christopher Columbus sailed to America from Spain, it was certainly because in Islamic Spain he could find books that told him the world was round. That was also the reason that the Inquisition was particularly rigorous there. Now, to complete your education, read-up on the Crusades and don't forget "The Seven Pillars of Wisdom" which will give you an insight on British foreign policy in the Middle East which was taken over by the United States after the WWII. Frankly, I have to laugh when I hear Americans ask, "why do they hate us?" Have you done anything recently to make anyone like you? You don't even have to go to the Middle East. Just start by asking a Native American.
Oct 13, 2008 01:32:35
Review 3 of 3
tflum writes:
PETER TRAVERS, are you kidding with this review? The movie is a typical left-leaning, liberal diatribe of how corrupt "Uncle Sam" is in dealing with Islamic extremists who continue to seek our destruction. Specifically, what "American duplicity" are you referring to and why is a "hard kick delivered to American duplicity...feels deserved?" Why don't you just reserve your political judgements to the editorial pages of the N.Y Times,L.A Times, you cocksucker.
Oct 10, 2008 15:30:21
Previous Next
Advertisement
More Movie Reviews
-
4of 4 Stars
-
2of 4 Stars
-
2.5of 4 Stars
-
2.5of 4 Stars
-
3.5of 4 Stars
Advertisement
Email
Stumble
AIM
Del.icio.us
DiggThis
Fark It!



- Portions of Album Content Provided by All Music Guide © 2008 All Media Guide, LLC.