Photo

Black Book (Zwartboek)

Starring: Carice van Houten, Sebastian Koch, Thom Hoffman, Halina Reijn, Waldemar Kobus

Directed by: Paul Verhoeven

RS: 3.5of 4 Stars Average User Rating: 3.5of 4 Stars

2007 Sony Picture Classics All Movies

Watch the trailer More information from

Just for starters, no movie about the Dutch Resistance during World War II has any right to be this wildly entertaining, not to mention this provocative and potently erotic. In part, it's a love story about a sympathetic Nazi and a Jewish girl who dyes her hair blond, pubes included, to seduce him. Only in a Paul Verhoeven movie, kids. The Amsterdam-born director made his name in Hollywood sending Ah-nuld to Mars in Total Recall, uncrossing Sharon Stone's legs in Basic Instinct, building a better police state in RoboCop and crafting the most watchable flop ever with the deliciously awful Showgirls.

For those with longer memories, Verhoeven first made his mark in the Netherlands with a series of feisty films (Spetters, Turkish Delight, The Fourth Man). The best was 1979's Soldier of Orange, a tale of the heroic Dutch Resistance, a theme that Verhoeven and screenwriter Gerard Soeteman seek to re-examine and even repudiate with Black Book. The title refers to the book containing the names of Jewish families who spend their savings for boat passage out of German-occupied Holland in 1944, only to be betrayed to the Nazis, who rob and murder them.

Carice van Houten, a star in the making, plays Rachel Stein, who sees her family slaughtered while she escapes by diving to safety. Spurred on by revenge, she joins the Resistance. Told to dye her hair and pass for Aryan as singer Ellis de Vries, Rachel smuggles guns on a train with flirtatious Resistance doctor Hans Akkermans (Thom Hoffman). But a chance meeting with Nazi chief Ludwig Müntze (Sebastian Koch) leads to her most dangerous mission: Beguile the widowed Müntze into bed, get a job working at Nazi headquarters and bug the place so the Resistance can listen in.

From that kernel springs a plot that Verhoeven loads with incident and thrilling action, taking time out for Rachel to sing at Nazi dinner parties and fall in love with Müntze, who wants to arrange a truce before the war ends, to avoid more senseless killing. The chemistry between van Houten and Koch is palpable. They are easily the hottest couple in movies right now. Koch, who portrayed the playwright in the Oscar-winning The Lives of Others, proves himself again to be a romantic, riveting screen presence. But the film belongs to van Houten, 29, a sexy, showstopping beauty with the gift possessed by only the best actors to make you feel the emotions roiling beneath the surface. Verhoeven is counting on the fact that we'll follow her anywhere, and we do. Not to give too much away, but Black Book takes us down byzantine corridors concerning the traitors and profiteers in the Dutch Resistance and the abuse of prisoners after the war that rivaled Abu Ghraib. Verhoeven bites off more than he can handily chew. He wouldn't be Verhoeven if he didn't. But his tremendously exciting film can suddenly, unpredictably move you to tears. Black Book, the first film Verhoeven has made in the Netherlands in two decades, is spoken in Dutch, German, Hebrew and English, and it lasts for 145 minutes. There's not a dull second in the bunch. Verhoeven is back, baby, and he's got his mojo working.

PETER TRAVERS

(Posted: Mar 7, 2007)

Review 1 of 2

philh writes:

4of 4 Stars


fantastic - showed that even Germans could show compassion
and humanity (Muntze-head of Gestapo) - and that people could
fall in love despite circumstances that should keep them apart.

May 26, 2007 06:19:56

Off Topic Report Abuse

Review 2 of 2

YankeeSlugger writes:

4of 4 Stars


This is a terrific movie! Peter Travers' review is right on -- I have only minor quibbles. What distinguishes this film is Carice van Houten, who gives the most extraordinary performance by an actress I've seen so far this year.

Carice van Houten is a gifted actress who is always natural and comfortable on screen and modulates an impressive range of subtle expressions that riveted me and transported me through the progression of her darting thoughts during critical scenes -- at times without her saying a word. I recall each of particularly demanding scenes vividly, and she never falters or breaks faith with her character's humanity and indomitable spirit when called on to compromise or risk herself to protect the lives of others.

In her entire performance, never a hollow note, false instinct or easy gimmick. Credit the director, Paul Verhoeven, yes, of course; but heap credit on the actress for pulling it off so skillfully, thoroughly and convincingly. She is a joy to watch and her presence dominates every scene she appears in. You will find it difficult to take your eyes off her -- but unfortunately you must to read the subtitles below. The plain truth is, I continue to believe Carice van Houten is Rachel Stein, and not simply playing her character.

As for the film plot's twists and turns -- some of the events depicted in the film seem so improbable that had I not known it is based on a true story, I would have criticize it for stretching credulity too far for dramatic effect. While the film's violence can hardly garner the description "it is an enjoyable film to watch," it was nonetheless always exciting and at times deeply moving. Nevertheless, the greatest asset of this film is the lovely Carice van Houten's brilliant performance that is sexy, masterful, mesmerizing, and elevates the film.

Apr 6, 2007 21:21:10

Off Topic Report Abuse

Previous Next

Advertisement

More Movie Reviews


News and Reviews

loading...

Click "Copy Me" to add the RS.com Widget to your Facebook page, blog, MySpace page and more.

Advertisement


Advertisement

Advertisement