Previous Next Latest

When Are Defense “Cuts” Actually an Increase?

4/7/09, 4:32 pm EST

Lost amid the hullabaloo over Bob Gates’ proposal to end production of a couple of Cold War weapons systems (the grossly expensive F-22 and the even more strategically absurd DDG-1000 destroyer) is the fact that these “cuts” are more than offset by an increase to the core 2010 defense budget of more than $20 billion. That’s right. Obama’s seeking to spend more than Bush did in the 2009 budget. Yes, Gates is suggesting a slightly saner reallocation of resources. But the Defense budget is still bloated and growing larger.


Previous Next Latest

Comments

Greg_D | 4/9/2009, 2:42 am EST

It’s not the spending on all the big fancy iteams. Some of the big fancy iteams are already decades old (from many naval ships, aircraft and even military tanks). The military is one big welfare state with over a million trooper and tens of thousands of civilians. Everything from pay to basic equipment to housing, to food to medical expenses is paid in that budget.

The second major expense is upkeep of equipment including fuel (in the 1980s a civilian helicopter cost $300 per hour in fuel alone and modern tanks get 8 gallons to the mile) and ammo (During the Vietnam War, it was estimated that 100,000 rounds of ammo were used per enemy killed).

It’s no more bloated than Medicaid which spends twice the amount per person than if the government just bought those people private insurance instead or unemployment/welfare which would pay for 12 million people at $30,000 a year. 75% of households make under $59,000 a year. Right now about 5.7 million people are collecting unemployment according to CNN. In March of 2007 there were 1.16 people on welfare. Note that at least for welfare, the states also pitch in so the amount given per person might be double.

James | 4/9/2009, 2:57 pm EST

Great comparison, Greg especially concerning Medicare. I’m curious… where did you get your stats?

Obameter | 4/9/2009, 4:20 pm EST

Greg_D

Guns over people. Your stance continues to sicken.

Greg_D | 4/9/2009, 4:21 pm EST

From Wikipedia
2009 budget signed by Bush
$408 billion for Medicare
$224 billion for Medicaid/SCHIP
$360 billion for unemployment/welfare

From Wikipedia:
47 million on Medicare in 2007. Cost per person $8,680.
In 2007, 42.9 million were on Medicaid at a total cost of $295 billion. That’s $6,876 per person.

I’d have to advertise to say that one could get health insurance at around $3000 per year (with family plans making it cheaper per person) including deductables and co-pays.

The income per household came from MSN.

The other info came from various news sites.

SoothSayer | 4/10/2009, 1:31 pm EST

Greg, I have to question your insurance numbers. I don’t have a company plan and as a 40 yr old single male good health is almost $4000 per year and going up over 10% per year. I have a friend who has looked into replacing the plan he and his wife have and he been told it would cost over 1500 per month to replace it. they are in perfect health in their late 50’s.

Can’t imagine what is would cost for a 20 yr old married couple in prime child bearing years.

3000 per year might work for a 5K deductible for a single male 25 in Omaha, but otherwise, no.

Tenisci | 4/10/2009, 6:48 pm EST

The Borgen Project has good info on the estimated cost of ending global poverty:

$30 billion: Annual shortfall to end world hunger.

$550 billion: U.S. Defense budget.

Tenisci | 4/10/2009, 6:48 pm EST

The Borgen Project has good info on the estimated cost of ending global poverty:

$30 billion: Annual shortfall to end world hunger.

$550 billion: U.S. Defense budget.

Greg_D | 4/11/2009, 2:13 pm EST

Soothsayer, even $4,000 a year for a family is cheaper than $8,680 per person under Medicare and $6,876 under Medicaid. It would be cheaper for Medicaid (since it’s based on wealth and not age) to use your plan.

Anonymous | 4/30/2009, 10:56 am EST

Earth doesn’t need any justification my friend, she will do what she has to do when she has to do it; she’ll take a quarter million in one Christmas day if she must, or half of humanity in a few months merely to stop a senseless war.
But I can understand you are merely projecting, considering how often this government and your side of the moral and political spectrum have to ‘justify’ your positions. You understand it’s wrong, of course, so your ego has to go into mental gymnastics. Truth is better.

Anonymous | 4/30/2009, 10:57 am EST

First you must defeat the inner demons and be able to stare the devil in the face without wavering, you seem to be flummoxed by mere words on a page and people you’ve never seen and could never possibly understand. Sad state of affairs for you indeed, can’t even recognize it is your nation that needs justification for it’s misdeeds around the world.

Anonymous | 4/30/2009, 10:58 am EST

Can’t you see yourself as a member of an ancient warrior clan, eternal and unwavering in his mission and purpose because he knows it’s just; rather than a mere soldier, beholden to the whims of mortal masters and a philosophy of deception and subterfuge designed by madmen lusting for a power that makes them slaves?

Anonymous | 4/30/2009, 10:59 am EST

mortal masters and a philosophy of deception and subterfuge designed by madmen lusting for a power that makes them slaves?

Anonymous | 4/30/2009, 11:02 am EST

beholden to the whims of

Anonymous | 4/30/2009, 11:04 am EST

intention and purpose because he knows it’s just; rather than a mere soldier,

Anonymous | 4/30/2009, 11:06 am EST

, eternal and unwavering in his

Anonymous | 4/30/2009, 11:07 am EST

member of an ancient warrior clan,

Anonymous | 4/30/2009, 11:14 am EST

Can you not s.ee yourself as a

Anonymous | 4/30/2009, 11:16 am EST

From your postings and the way you treat those you perceive as inferior, I can only surmise youy are a simple soldier that falls for the whispering of ghosts whom would rather drive him to lashing out or self destruction than allow him to recognize his true enemy.

Anonymous | 4/30/2009, 11:18 am EST

You’ve allowed yourself to be pushed over the edge again. You’ve fallen for the goading you like to push on others, yet refuse to understand why it’s not appropriate for anyone to impose such uncivil behavior on others. It leaves you without recourse when it’s visited upon you. You’ve forgotten the value of respect, rectitude, righteousness and all the virtues that help a knight defeat the dragons of our world, yet you consider yourself the member of a ‘warrior class’. Now that’s a hearty laugh I really needed, thanks.

Anonymous | 4/30/2009, 11:19 am EST

dragons of our world, yet you consider yourself the member of a ‘warrior class’. Now that’s a hearty laugh I really needed, thanks.

Anonymous | 4/30/2009, 11:19 am EST

dragons of our world, yet you consider yourself the member of a ‘warrior cla$s’. Now that’s a hearty laugh I really needed, thanks.

Anonymous | 4/30/2009, 11:21 am EST

You’ve forgotten the value of respect, rectitude, righteousness and all the virtues that help a knight defeat the

Anonymous | 4/30/2009, 11:21 am EST

yet refuse to understand why it’s not appropriate for anyone to impose such uncivil behavior on others. It leaves you without recourse when it’s visited upon you.

Anonymous | 4/30/2009, 11:22 am EST

You’ve allowed yourself to be pushed over the edge again. You’ve fallen for the goading you like to push on others,

Anonymous | 4/30/2009, 11:23 am EST

My ilk? what exactly do you mean by ‘my ilk’? :) never mind, doesn’t matter anyway, as usual, it’s just a childish attack.

Anonymous | 4/30/2009, 11:24 am EST

?(not that you ARE any better, only in your own mind). Don’t you find it interesting that you would put yourself in a position to be shown the value of ‘do unto others’ so soon after my mention of it?

Anonymous | 4/30/2009, 11:26 am EST

yet I still assaulted you with your own words when you strayed from that path and directed your venomous tongue at others. Do you not understand that being better doesn’t give you the right to belittle others

Anonymous | 4/30/2009, 11:27 am EST

yet I still a$saulted you with your own words when you strayed from that path and directed your venomous tongue at others. Do you not understand that being better doesn’t give you the right to belittle others

Anonymous | 4/30/2009, 11:28 am EST

I apologize that I hurt your feelings. You were trying hard to be respectful to me in the face of some unwarranted comments and

Anonymous | 4/30/2009, 11:29 am EST

I apologize that I hurt your feelings. You were trying hard to be respectful to me in the face of some unwarranted comments and yet I still a$saulted you with your own words when you strayed from that path and directed your venomous tongue at others. Do you not understand that being better doesn’t give you the right to belittle others?(not that you ARE any better, only in your own mind). Don’t you find it interesting that you would put yourself in a position to be shown the value of ‘do unto others’ so soon after my mention of it?

My ilk? what exactly do you mean by ‘my ilk’? :) never mind, doesn’t matter anyway, as usual, it’s just a childish attack.

You’ve allowed yourself to be pushed over the edge again. You’ve fallen for the goading you like to push on others, yet refuse to understand why it’s not appropriate for anyone to impose such uncivil behavior on others. It leaves you without recourse when it’s visited upon you. You’ve forgotten the value of respect, rectitude, righteousness and all the virtues that help a knight defeat the dragons of our world, yet you consider yourself the member of a ‘warrior class’. Now that’s a hearty laugh I really needed, thanks.
From your postings and the way you treat those you perceive as inferior, I can only surmise you are a simple soldier that falls for the whispering of ghosts whom would rather drive him to lashing out or self destruction than allow him to recognize his true enemy.

Can you not s.ee yourself as a member of an ancient warrior clan, eternal and unwavering in his intention and purpose because he knows it’s just; rather than a mere soldier, beholden to the whims of mortal masters and a philosophy of deception and subterfuge designed by madmen lusting for a power that makes them slaves?
First you must defeat the inner demons and be able to stare the devil in the face without wavering, you seem to be flummoxed by mere words on a page and people you’ve never seen and could never possibly understand. Sad state of affairs for you indeed, can’t even recognize it is your nation that needs justification for it’s misdeeds around the world.

Earth doesn’t need any justification my friend, she will do what she has to do when she has to do it; she’ll take a quarter million in one Christmas day if she must, or half of humanity in a few months merely to stop a senseless war.
But I can understand you are merely projecting, considering how often this government and your side of the moral and political spectrum have to ‘justify’ your positions. You understand it’s wrong, of course, so your ego has to go into mental gymnastics. Truth is better.

Anonymous | 4/30/2009, 11:39 am EST

Can you not s.ee yourself as a member of an ancient warrior clan, eternal and unwavering in his intention and purpose because he knows it’s just; rather than a mere soldier, beholden to the whims of mortal masters and a philosophy of deception and subterfuge designed by madmen lusting for a power that makes them slaves?
First you must defeat the inner demons and be able to stare the devil in the face without wavering, you seem to be flummoxed by mere words on a page and people you’ve never seen and could never possibly understand. Sad state of affairs for you indeed, can’t even recognize it is your nation that needs justification for it’s misdeeds around the world.

Earth doesn’t need any justification my friend, she will do what she has to do when she has to do it; she’ll take a quarter million in one Christmas day if she must, or half of humanity in a few months merely to stop a senseless war.
But I can understand you are merely projecting, considering how often this government and your side of the moral and political spectrum have to ‘justify’ your positions. You understand it’s wrong, of course, so your ego has to go into mental gymnastics. Truth is better.

Anonymous | 4/30/2009, 11:40 am EST

You’ve allowed yourself to be pushed over the edge again. You’ve fallen for the goading you like to push on others, yet refuse to understand why it’s not appropriate for anyone to impose such uncivil behavior on others. It leaves you without recourse when it’s visited upon you. You’ve forgotten the value of respect, rectitude, righteousness and all the virtues that help a knight defeat the dragons of our world, yet you consider yourself the member of a ‘warrior class’. Now that’s a hearty laugh I really needed, thanks.
From your postings and the way you treat those you perceive as inferior, I can only surmise you are a simple soldier that falls for the whispering of ghosts whom would rather drive him to lashing out or self destruction than allow him to recognize his true enemy.

Anonymous | 4/30/2009, 11:41 am EST

From your postings and the way you treat those you perceive as inferior, I can only surmise you are a simple soldier that falls for the whispering of ghosts whom would rather drive him to lashing out or self destruction than allow him to recognize his true enemy.

Anonymous | 4/30/2009, 11:45 am EST

It leaves you without recourse when it’s visited upon you. You’ve forgotten the value of respect, rectitude, righteousness and all the virtues that help a knight defeat the dragons of our world, yet you consider yourself the member of a ‘warrior class’. Now that’s a hearty laugh I really needed, thanks.

Anonymous | 4/30/2009, 11:47 am EST

I apologize that I hurt your feelings. You were trying hard to be respectful to me in the face of some unwarranted comments and yet I still a$saulted you with your own words when you strayed from that path and directed your venomous tongue at others. Do you not understand that being better doesn’t give you the right to belittle others?(not that you ARE any better, only in your own mind). Don’t you find it interesting that you would put yourself in a position to be shown the value of ‘do unto others’ so soon after my mention of it?

My ilk? what exactly do you mean by ‘my ilk’? :) never mind, doesn’t matter anyway, as usual, it’s just a childish attack.

Anonymous | 4/30/2009, 11:48 am EST

You’ve allowed yourself to be pushed over the edge again. You’ve fallen for the goading you like to push on others, yet refuse to understand why it’s not appropriate for anyone to impose such uncivil behavior on others. It leaves you without recourse when it’s visited upon you.

Anonymous | 4/30/2009, 11:49 am EST

You’ve forgotten the value of respect, rectitude, righteousness and all the virtues that help a knight

Anonymous | 4/30/2009, 11:51 am EST

defeat the dragons of our world, yet you consider yourself the member of a

Anonymous | 4/30/2009, 11:53 am EST

a ‘warrior cla$s’. Now that’s funny, thanks.

Anonymous | 4/30/2009, 11:54 am EST

Jed Clampett

I apologize that I hurt your feelings. You were trying hard to be respectful to me in the face of some unwarranted comments and yet I still a$saulted you with your own words when you strayed from that path and directed your venomous tongue at others. Do you not understand that being better doesn’t give you the right to belittle others?(not that you ARE any better, only in your own mind). Don’t you find it interesting that you would put yourself in a position to be shown the value of ‘do unto others’ so soon after my mention of it?

My ilk? what exactly do you mean by ‘my ilk’? :) never mind, doesn’t matter anyway, as usual, it’s just a childish attack.

You’ve allowed yourself to be pushed over the edge again. You’ve fallen for the goading you like to push on others, yet refuse to understand why it’s not appropriate for anyone to impose such uncivil behavior on others. It leaves you without recourse when it’s visited upon you. You’ve forgotten the value of respect, rectitude, righteousness and all the virtues that help a knight defeat the dragons of our world, yet you consider yourself the member of a ‘warrior cla$s’. Now that’s funny, thanks.
From your postings and the way you treat those you perceive as inferior, I can only surmise you are a simple soldier that falls for the whispering of ghosts whom would rather drive him to lashing out or self destruction than allow him to recognize his true enemy.

Can you not s.ee yourself as a member of an ancient warrior clan, eternal and unwavering in his intention and purpose because he knows it’s just; rather than a mere soldier, beholden to the whims of mortal masters and a philosophy of deception and subterfuge designed by madmen lusting for a power that makes them slaves?
First you must defeat the inner demons and be able to stare the devil in the face without wavering, you seem to be flummoxed by mere words on a page and people you’ve never seen and could never possibly understand. Sad state of affairs for you indeed, can’t even recognize it is your nation that needs justification for it’s misdeeds around the world.

Earth doesn’t need any justification my friend, she will do what she has to do when she has to do it; she’ll take a quarter million in one Christmas day if she must, or half of humanity in a few months merely to stop a senseless war.
But I can understand you are merely projecting, considering how often this government and your side of the moral and political spectrum have to ‘justify’ your positions. You understand it’s wrong, of course, so your ego has to go into mental gymnastics. Truth is better.

hi | 8/23/2009, 8:11 pm EST

why stop the production of the f22? it can out beat any modern day fighter. but our soldiers need new armour like titanium, and a new assault rifle ammunition like the 6.8mm round

Post A Comment

Caution: Off-topic comments will be deleted

Name:

Comments:



Advertisement

Advertisement