Previous Next Latest

Sometimes a Fire is Just a Fire

10/25/07, 1:34 pm EST

What’s wrong with this country that we can’t just have a natural disaster anymore?

What kind of sick people are we that Fox News has linked the Southland firestorm to Al Qaeda, Glenn Beck suggested that this disaster is some sort of divine retribution for those Malibu-ites who “hate America,” while the Huffington Post has seemed all kinds of eager for this to be The Next Katrina — almost rooting on the Santa Anna winds in the dark hope of adding another failed disaster response to the execrable Bush legacy.

Seriously. Take a breath. How did we become this petty and hysterical? Even the LA Times has gotten caught up in disaster porn, breathlessly touting back-of-the envelope evacuation figures — 800,000.. a million! — that in the cold light of day bear little relationship to reality.

These fires are terrible. But all things considered they’ve been handled admirably. California’s a generally rich and competent state. We’ve mobilized resources both to fight the fires and aid the displaced. The governor’s taking charge. We’ve pulled National Guard resources from the border. The president has loosed federal disaster-recovery monies.

The property damage — at a billion dollars or so to date — is no chump change. But let’s not denigrate the suffering of Katrina survivors by making asymmetrical comparisons. The hurricane, along with its sister Rita, inflicted nearly a quarter of a trillion dollars damage on the Gulf Coast. There have been 1,500 homes destroyed in the recent fires? How about nearly 1,500 dead in the storms?

This fire hasn’t yet approached the toll of the 1991 Oakland conflagration. So why must we raise the ghost of “Brownie” and “Heckuva Job”? Why do we have to pin this on the National Guard troops stationed in Iraq. Why must this be Global Warming’s fault. Or Bush’s — it’s always Bush’s fault!

How far gone are we that we so easily turn a firestorm into a launching pad for our pet political agendas. Let’s put out the flames first before we fight over the ashes.

Meantime, go cleanse yourselves with a donation to the victims.


Previous Next Latest

Comments

Paul Lacques | 10/25/2007, 2:10 pm EST

On the money.

And the bigger picture is that we Southern Californians have known for 200 years that our hills burn with great regularity.

The weeping over our “Katrina” and the fingerpointing at the government cover up a willful and selfish pattern of building in fire zones. The 28,000 square foot McMansions miles deep in the San Diego County hills are the epitome of a society that expects everything, with no consequences.

SUV commuters: get out of the hills. Join us in town, and take responsibility for your urban lifestyles.

It will take decades to assess and learn from the hydra headed disaster of the Bush administration. We don’t need extraneous data to muddy the story.

andy | 10/25/2007, 2:58 pm EST

i agree with just about everything said thus far, in the comments and reaction. i also think any “terrorist” or “global warming” finger-pointing is absolutely ridiculous.

san diego is a chaparral ecosystem and fire is a natural part of that ecosystem, especially in the shrublands where people insist on building gigantic homes.

the only similarity to katrina is the failure of government to intervene appropriately by a) allowing smaller fires in intermediary years (these giant fires are 4 years apart) b) preventing people from building homes in hazardous areas and, in doing so, c) actually preventing catastrophic fires proactively instead of reacting to them when they become behemoths.

scientists need to recommend measures for these natural disasters… not political advisors. that’s the lesson we can learn from katrina and the socal fires.

Merkwurdigliebe | 10/25/2007, 4:10 pm EST

very well said…sometimes the humanitarian cost is lost amid all of the partisan bickering

but i would like to add, that like Katrina, part of this could have been averted with proper management of the land and proper brush clearing techniques. good luck to all of those in the fire zone

the apocalypse | 10/25/2007, 4:11 pm EST

You do realize that the people running this government(as well as some in media) are fundamentalist religious nuts who are trying to bring about the ‘end times’ yea? Plagues, war, floods and catastrophes are kinda their bag. They like to hype it any way they can.

Starked | 10/25/2007, 4:40 pm EST

Oh, and DON’T BLAME THE VICTIMS for Christsake!
There are problems that everyone knows about no matter where they live (fire, hurricanes, earthquakes, tornados, blizzards, WAR…) but they’re always gonna live their. With 6.whatever billion people in the world, would you rather have 300-story apartments in the handfull of “safe” cities?
Please. Be more heartless why don’t you.

C Co... aka I Smell Propaganda | 10/25/2007, 6:14 pm EST

How about a little props for The Governator on this one? Everyone was very well organized and responsive to the needs of the victims. Alas, you can really stop such a juggernaut of a natural distater.

C Co... aka I Smell Propaganda | 10/25/2007, 6:20 pm EST

Tim
Although I highly respect this post, please take a look in the mirror when talking about using non-partisan issues as a launching pad for political agendas.

Capitalist Pig | 10/25/2007, 6:34 pm EST

Damn Tim I actually agree with you for once. I am really suprised.

AnnCoulterneedsamouthfulofcum! | 10/25/2007, 10:12 pm EST

Geez, Tim, whats wrong with you? Can’t you see the fires are God’s just retribution on California for the homos? What’s so ridiculous about that?

Let Them Eat Cake | 10/29/2007, 1:46 pm EST

Yea folks, forget Katrina and the shame and mishandling by Bush, blame the California fire victims, forget the inept handling of any crisis that comes along.

Developers should be Regulated-money trumps safety and wisely planned communities.

But, people do need places to live. Over-development is going on all over the country and, safety and accessability issues for communities seem to be overlooked by real estate developers, hmmm.

Let’s not get lost in whose to blame-are the victims being helped, do federal agencies work in crisis times?

Want more of those tax cuts-than figure on dwindled fire depts., police depts., emergency teams, hospitals, trauma centers, FEMAS and their other Federal Safety Net Agencies. They are becoming more inefficent the more Republican-dominated our Nation becomes.

Post A Comment

Caution: Off-topic comments will be deleted

Name:

Comments:



Advertisement

Advertisement