The Baseball Project Asks Suspended Giants Outfielder, 'Why Melky Why?'

Indie supergroup laments Cabrera's positive drug test

The Baseball Project
Renata Steiner
August 17, 2012 5:05 PM ET

Like many San Francisco Giants fans clutching their temples in agony this week over the suspension of star outfielder Melky Cabrera for a positive drug test, indie-rocker Scott McCaughey had a simple question: Why, Melky, why? Unlike most Giants fans, McCaughey wrote and recorded a song about it for his band, the Baseball Project. "I was so bummed, not because he's on one of my fantasy teams, but I'm a big Giants fans and a super-big Melky fan this year because he's been so fucking awesome," McCaughey, who also fronts the Minus 5, the Young Fresh Fellows and played with R.E.M., tells Rolling Stone.

Although the Baseball Project usually consists of McCaughey, Steve Wynn, Linda Pitmon and Peter Buck (or sometimes Mike Mills, when Buck's not available), McCaughey recorded "Why Melky Why" himself in his basement studio. "It's just me, because it had to be done really quick," he says. 

Cabrera was traded to the Giants this year after stints with the New York Yankees, Atlanta Braves and, most recently, the Kansas City Royals. He was named most valuable player of this year's All Star Game, but testing positive for high levels of testosterone means he'll serve a 50-game suspension that, perversely, could help Cabrera win the National League batting title, according to the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review.

The Young Fresh Fellows release a new album, Tiempo De Lujo, on August 21st, and McCaughey played on a solo album Buck is releasing in September. He's also writing songs for a new Minus 5 album.

To read the new issue of Rolling Stone online, plus the entire RS archive: Click Here

Music Main Next

blog comments powered by Disqus
Daily Newsletter

Get the latest RS news in your inbox.

Sign up to receive the Rolling Stone newsletter and special offers from RS and its
marketing partners.


We may use your e-mail address to send you the newsletter and offers that may interest you, on behalf of Rolling Stone and its partners. For more information please read our Privacy Policy.

Song Stories

“Santa Monica”

Everclear | 1996

After his brother and girlfriend both died of drug overdoses, Art Alexakis -- depressed and hooked on drugs himself -- jumped off the Santa Monica Pier in California, determined to die. "It was really stupid," said the Everclear frontman, who would further explore his personal emotional journey in the song "Father of Mine." "I went under the water. Then I said, 'I don't wanna die.'" The song, declaring "Let's swim out past the breakers/and watch the world die," was intended as a manifesto for change, Alexakis said. "Let the world do what it's gonna do and just live on our own."

More Song Stories entries »