Lady Gaga hit the American Idol stage in a black fishnet body stocking to perform her latest Fame Monster single "Alejandro." If the performance, which was filmed after last week's elimination show in L.A. and aired last night, seemed a bit choppy, Gaga hints that editing is to blame: "Idol cut down my performance--see the full-length performance here little monsters!" she tweeted shortly after the broadcast with a link to a longer version of the song, which featured an extended piano introduction of "Bad Romance." But "Alejandro" never really locked in step, starting with a missed cue during the intro that led to the synths and violin clashing for a few awkward bars. In classic Gaga style, though, the singer never stumbled, capping the track with a strong, fiery finish as her dancers surrounded her with their hands contorted into her signature monster claw.
Before Ryan Seacrest revealed which final four contestants survived to next week's show, when Jamie Foxx will guide the singers through "Songs of the Cinema" (check out the Bryan Adams-heavy song list on MJ's Big Blog), mentor Harry Connick Jr. regaled the audience with a lengthy anecdote about nervously singing for Frank Sinatra and having Ol' Blue Eyes kiss his future wife, Jill Goodacre, right in front of him. Connick Jr., who brought a much-needed dose of charm and humor to the performance show this week, also broke out his cover of the Beatles' "And I Love Her," joked that Casey James "thought I was Chris Isaak" and brought up an excellent point: "The word 'pitchy' does not exist, judges … it's singing out of tune."
At the end of the hour, Seacrest revealed that James — who the judges had harshly critiqued the night before for an off-base cover of "Blue Skies" — had survived the Sinatra week elimination, leaving Michael Lynche and Aaron Kelly on the block. Kelly, the earnest 17-year-old hopeful, was cut as RS predicted, but went out with a smile on his face as he reprised "Fly Me to the Moon."