Justin Timberlake, Elton John to Judge on 'Idol'?

So You Think You Can Dance' panelist Nigel Lythgoe also rumored to return to the show

July 27, 2010 4:03 PM ET

As they gear up for American Idol's tenth season next year, producers are prepping big changes to boost declining ratings and the loss of longtime judge Simon Cowell. The show is reportedly close to a deal to bring back producer Nigel Lythgoe (who left in 2008) in an executive producer role while targeting new candidates including Justin Timberlake and Elton John as potential replacements for Cowell, according to the Hollywood Reporter.

The American Idol rollercoaster: checking in on the show's biggest winners and losers.

Replacing Cowell is the biggest obstacle for the show, but Lythgoe seems up to dealing with this challenge should he return. Lythgoe, one of the show's original producers who left to work on So You Think You Can Dance, has said that should Cowell ever leave, he would uproot the entire Idol panel. Lythgoe has also gone on record as saying that the show's current roster of judges — Randy Jackson, Ellen DeGeneres and Kara DioGuardi — isn't very compelling and that he would be open to bringing back Paula Abdul, although she has since signed on with CBS' upcoming Got to Dance.

Chris Isaak and Harry Connick, Jr. have been approached about replacing Cowell — and personalities as diverse as Howard Stern and Perez Hilton have expressed interest in the position — but Lythgoe is critical of having a fourth judge at all, saying that it distracts from viewers' attention. With Randy Jackson the lone original Idol judge and DeGeneres in the midst of a multi-year contract, DioGuardi appears most likely to get the boot should producers replace Cowell and revert back to a three-judge format — and that's the most likely scenario if Lythgoe doesn't simply replace the entire judges' table, as the Reporter speculates.

So who would take Cowell's spot? Elton John is reportedly on both Lythgoe's and executive producer Simon Fuller's wish list of potential replacements, but the show has been unable to come close to a monetary agreement with the songwriter. Timberlake would be an even harder catch: While the pop star currently tops Fuller's wish list, it's unlikely he would have time due to his busy acting schedule and music career. (Both John and Timberlake's reps have since denied their clients are considering the Idol gig.) One other possibility is Lythgoe himself, who presently serves as a judge on So You Think You Can Dance and who has earned the nickname "Nasty Nigel" from the British press for his harsh Cowell-esque criticisms on the U.K. show Popstars.

To read the new issue of Rolling Stone online, plus the entire RS archive: Click Here

Music Main Next
Around the Web
Powered By ZergNet
Daily Newsletter

Get the latest RS news in your inbox.

Sign up to receive the Rolling Stone newsletter and special offers from RS and its
marketing partners.


We may use your e-mail address to send you the newsletter and offers that may interest you, on behalf of Rolling Stone and its partners. For more information please read our Privacy Policy.

Song Stories

“San Francisco Mabel Joy”

Mickey Newbury | 1969

A country-folk song of epic proportions, "San Francisco Mabel Joy" tells the tale of a poor Georgia farmboy who wound up in prison after a move to the Bay Area found love turning into tragedy. First released by Mickey Newbury in 1969, it might be more familiar through covers by Waylon Jennings, Joan Baez and Kenny Rogers. "It was a five-minute song written in a two-minute world," Newbury said. "I was told it would never be cut by any artist ... I was told you could not use the term 'redneck' in a song and get it recorded."

More Song Stories entries »