Jay-Z, Fans React to "We Are the World 25 for Haiti"

February 16, 2010 12:00 AM ET

Since the Winter Olympics debut of "We Are the World 25 for Haiti," featuring Lil Wayne, Pink, Kanye West, Fergie and 80 more singers, over 6.5 million people have watched the Paul Haggis-directed video on its official YouTube page. With its modern take on the original track's production and a new rap interlude, the new version of the iconic 1985 charity single is drawing mixed reaction from all corners of the Internet — 67,000 comments have already been posted on YouTube and Rolling Stone's blog lit up with responses after the song's premiere during Friday night's opening ceremony in Vancouver.

"We Are the World 25 Years for Haiti": photos of the all-star session.

One of the most famous voices in the mix is Jay-Z, who told MTV that the original version was too sacred to him. "I think 'We Are the World' is like [Michael Jackson's] 'Thriller' to me. I don't ever wanna see it touched." He added, "Some things are just untouchable. It was a valiant effort, but for me, it's gonna be untouchable."

Rolling Stone readers' main critique is that the new lineup doesn't boast enough high-profile rockers. "This version does not hold a candle to the original which was composed primarily of A-list performers, many who are now in the Rock Hall of Fame," JD writes. "The original had individuals. That's the key thing, from the moment the original starts you know who everyone is, very distinct voices," adds Chris.

Lionel Richie's response? "What's a classic? To the next generation, it's just an old song," he told USA Today. "Why not bring in Miley Cyrus and the Jonas Brothers and let them address the issues? We can pass the baton and empower the next generation to take up arms and have a legacy with this."

Readers also griped over the track's use of Auto-Tune (Akon, T-Pain and Lil Wayne's vocals all feature the studio hallmark) and the addition of the rap interlude, which the producers referred to as a "Greek chorus." Richie tells USA Today rockers were the voice of opposition in the original, but "Now the radicals and bad boys and messengers are rappers. We had to add that to give it freshness."

Despite the critiques, readers praised Pink, Jennifer Hudson, Mary J. Blige and Celine Dion's solos, the touch of originality Kanye West added to the track and the too-brief, heartwarming moment where Michael and Janet Jackson sing side by side. "OK, Pink killed it. Awesome and somewhat unexpected. Celine Dion, incredible. It was tasteful to leave Michael Jackson in it too," writes T Bone.

Watch the original "We Are the World" below, and let us know what you think about "We Are the World 25 for Haiti" in our comments:

Related Stories:
Preview the New "We Are the World," Plus Meet Nine-Year-Old Singer Ethan Bortnick
"We Are the World 25 Years for Haiti": Inside the All-Star Recording Session

To read the new issue of Rolling Stone online, plus the entire RS archive: Click Here

Music Main Next
Around the Web
Powered By ZergNet
Daily Newsletter

Get the latest RS news in your inbox.

Sign up to receive the Rolling Stone newsletter and special offers from RS and its
marketing partners.


We may use your e-mail address to send you the newsletter and offers that may interest you, on behalf of Rolling Stone and its partners. For more information please read our Privacy Policy.

Song Stories

“Love Is the Answer”

Utopia | 1977

The message of the Beatles' "All You Need Is Love" proved to be a universal and long-lasting one, which Utopia revisited 10 years later on this ballad. "From a lyrical standpoint, it's part of a whole class of songs that I write, which are about filial love," Todd Rundgren explained. "I'm not a Christian, but it's called Christian love, the love that people are supposed to naturally feel because we are all of the same species. That may be mythical, but it's still a subject." Though "Love Is the Answer" wasn't a hit, a cover version two years later by England Dan & John Ford Coley peaked at Number Ten on the Billboard singles chart.

More Song Stories entries »